Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Transgender person elected as Deputy Mayor in Sydney

169 replies

Catcentral · 24/09/2026 04:53

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1HxkfR1VCB/

OP posts:
Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 12:19

FinchiePink · 24/09/2026 09:49

None of that has any bearing on what I said. Trans people ARE no different to anyone else, I agree.

They can be elected to public office, they can be your boss, your colleague, your tenant, your bus driver, whoever.

None of that means anyone has to "buy into" their belief.

We can respect them as people without having to share their belief.

Good! And that means there should be no expectation of others using false pronouns - and all that tends to accompany that. If people want to imagine themselves in certain ways then that is up to them; we all do it. That is entirely a private matter - and not a matter for public celebration which seems to be the case here...with people making a big thing out of the fact that he has a trans identity; as if it is some sort of progressive act or symbol.

It will be interesting to see if he chooses not to centre his trans identity in his actions whilst in office.

sanluca · 24/09/2026 11:57

Most politicians are liars sorry to say, so this person is no exception. Many politicians are also sexist, see them prioritising mens beliefs over womens rights.

However, if the reason he was elected is now being used to say something is 50:50 men and women and he is being counted as a woman, yes, then I do have a problem with the election. That is not fair representation. Is that what happened?

ButWhoAmI · 24/09/2026 11:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 11:28

Funnywonder · 24/09/2026 11:08

Do you believe that a man who DOESN’T think he is a woman would necessarily be ‘clear eyed and fair’ with regard to the needs of his female constituents? Or, for that matter, a woman? Not all females put the rights of women front and centre of their thinking. I have been utterly shocked at the attitudes of some women in public office. I guess a person’s track record is the only guarantee. That’s how I usually try to make my decision on who to vote for. But they have to start somewhere in order to prove themselves.

As a Feminist I recognise sexism runs throughout society, often in ways that are so deeply embedded in our everyday norms and expectations that it is hard to recognise the sexism underneath. Fish have no word water and all that.

So no, sexism is absolutely not limited just to those people who express their sexism through a transgender identity.

However after thinking about this very deeply for a long time, I have come to the conclusion it is impossible to conceptualise a transgender identity without sexist ideas about how men and women think, feel and act, and it is impossible to require social accommodation of trans women as "women" without the sexist assumption that the trans identity matters more than female realities and needs. So to that end, I do consider a transgender identity to be clear evidence of sexism.

Of course I also acknowledge it's possible there are exceptions I'm missing and I'm open to listening and assessing individuals. However a trans person would have to express a very unusual and nuanced understanding of the intersection of sex and gender identity to be able to claim a transgender identity without some level of sexist belief, and as yet I have never cone across it.

Odd question really. As I said, I wouldn't vote for anyone I believe to be sexist or racist. Why would anything I said suggest I'd make an exception if the sexist person wasn't transgender?

Funnywonder · 24/09/2026 11:08

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 10:43

It's the sexism.

I can't see how a person who believes some ways of thinking, feeling or behaving are only right for one sex, so if you have the "wrong" ones for your actual body you must be the wrong sex somehow,

and who believes that the female half of humanity don't need their own name, history or cultural existence but can be rolled into a single social group within who believe they are/feel whatever it is they assume all women must be or feel and this doesn't impact women at all, or at least the impact on them isn't an important enough reason not to do it,

is going to be capable of being clear-eyed and fair when it comes to the actual needs and challenges of his female population.

Do you believe that a man who DOESN’T think he is a woman would necessarily be ‘clear eyed and fair’ with regard to the needs of his female constituents? Or, for that matter, a woman? Not all females put the rights of women front and centre of their thinking. I have been utterly shocked at the attitudes of some women in public office. I guess a person’s track record is the only guarantee. That’s how I usually try to make my decision on who to vote for. But they have to start somewhere in order to prove themselves.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 10:52

Funnywonder · 24/09/2026 10:01

Should transgender people then be excluded from public office? I reserve my right to look at a trans woman and see a man, whether he is representing the community or emptying the bins. But my thoughts are my thoughts. It doesn’t change how that person does their job. I object to him using women’s toilets (if he does.) I don’t feel compelled to use the so-called ‘appropriate’ pronouns. But those are separate issues from whether or not he makes a good Deputy Lord Mayor. As a human being. And all the cheerleaders saying how great it is to be so progressive and inclusive - well that’s irrelevant too in respect of how he actually performs his duties.

Of course sexist people can, and often do, run for public office. Same as racist people. Depressingly, they also get elected sometimes.

I wouldn't vote for them though, because I don't think sexism or racism are qualities that make for good policy-making.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 10:48

alcovecupboards · 24/09/2026 10:45

There isn't an issue here. Threads like this just demonstrate that a large element here aren't just GC - but are openly transphobic. (Obviously this will be denied despite being blindingly obvious to anyone who can read).

Tell me you haven't read the thread without telling me you haven't read the thread.

alcovecupboards · 24/09/2026 10:45

There isn't an issue here. Threads like this just demonstrate that a large element here aren't just GC - but are openly transphobic. (Obviously this will be denied despite being blindingly obvious to anyone who can read).

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 10:43

sanluca · 24/09/2026 05:55

Is it the person being transgender that makes you think he is unsuited to office? Because that is discrimination. There are nice transgender people out there too, you know?

What are his policies? Is he going to actively work against women? If that is the case yes, he would be the wrong person for the job. Otherwise, give him a chance. It is not like being deputy mayor is a role reserved for women.

It's the sexism.

I can't see how a person who believes some ways of thinking, feeling or behaving are only right for one sex, so if you have the "wrong" ones for your actual body you must be the wrong sex somehow,

and who believes that the female half of humanity don't need their own name, history or cultural existence but can be rolled into a single social group within who believe they are/feel whatever it is they assume all women must be or feel and this doesn't impact women at all, or at least the impact on them isn't an important enough reason not to do it,

is going to be capable of being clear-eyed and fair when it comes to the actual needs and challenges of his female population.

Savvysix1984 · 24/09/2026 10:21

No issue with a transgender person doing any role, as long as they’re upfront about it and it doesn’t impinge of other groups rights (ie women). I wonder is he lauded as a ‘female deputy mayor’ and will he be recorded in history as one?

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 10:21

FinchiePink · 24/09/2026 10:14

But you could say that about nearly anything a person believes.

Whether it's benefits, taxes, going carbon neutral, healthcare - there will always be winners and losers in all policies.

I suppose a difference is that we could freely interrogate all of those differences in policies without being accused of 'hate speech'. Questioning the right of some men to use female-only spaces is in a different category.

This individual raises some interesting questions for the 'TWAW' brigade though. 3 years ago he was 'Mitch Wilson', very much male. 2 years ago, when elected, he was still Mitch although now 'they/them', but very much presenting as male. I don't think anyone just looking at a picture of him would think he was anything other than a man. He is now a 'woman' with a new name. He may not believe TWAW. He may be happy to just be considered a 'transwoman', but if he starts to espouse policy 'as a woman', there are issues. I still would like to understand in what sense the TWAW people believe Olly is a woman.

DialSquare · 24/09/2026 10:19

FinchiePink · 24/09/2026 10:14

But you could say that about nearly anything a person believes.

Whether it's benefits, taxes, going carbon neutral, healthcare - there will always be winners and losers in all policies.

If anyone were as blatant about their priorities on those things, I would have the same issue with them.

FinchiePink · 24/09/2026 10:14

DialSquare · 24/09/2026 10:09

If someone believes that some men should be able to use female single sex provision, they do not have the best interests of all the people they represent, at heart.

But you could say that about nearly anything a person believes.

Whether it's benefits, taxes, going carbon neutral, healthcare - there will always be winners and losers in all policies.

DialSquare · 24/09/2026 10:09

If someone believes that some men should be able to use female single sex provision, they do not have the best interests of all the people they represent, at heart.

Funnywonder · 24/09/2026 10:01

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 09:47

Obviously it is not unreasonable to assume that since he uses 'she' pronouns he is going to have some expectation that others go along with this make believe too? That his 'trans identity' is going to be the most significant thing about him. If it is not such a big deal, then why is everyone lauding him as a sign of how 'progressive' Australia is imagined to be?

We know Australia has fatally undermined women's rights and protections in pursuit of what it sees as some sort of anti-colonial act of "liberation for marginalised identities", blah, blah, blah. It is still quite galling to see it in action though.

Edited

Should transgender people then be excluded from public office? I reserve my right to look at a trans woman and see a man, whether he is representing the community or emptying the bins. But my thoughts are my thoughts. It doesn’t change how that person does their job. I object to him using women’s toilets (if he does.) I don’t feel compelled to use the so-called ‘appropriate’ pronouns. But those are separate issues from whether or not he makes a good Deputy Lord Mayor. As a human being. And all the cheerleaders saying how great it is to be so progressive and inclusive - well that’s irrelevant too in respect of how he actually performs his duties.

Rightsraptor · 24/09/2026 09:49

And being 'nice' doesn't mean you are suited to public office either.

FinchiePink · 24/09/2026 09:49

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 09:42

People who adopt trans identities are no different to anyone else. They are not a unique category of human being.They are either male or female., and nobody should be expected to pretend otherwise. Crack on if you want to cross dress or even change your first name but the expectation that people must buy into this whole 'trans' thing is way off the mark.

Edited

None of that has any bearing on what I said. Trans people ARE no different to anyone else, I agree.

They can be elected to public office, they can be your boss, your colleague, your tenant, your bus driver, whoever.

None of that means anyone has to "buy into" their belief.

We can respect them as people without having to share their belief.

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 09:47

Funnywonder · 24/09/2026 09:39

OK, I’m very much gender critical, but I seriously don’t see a problem with a HUMAN BEING assuming this role. A human being working as a public figure for other human beings. Where exactly is the problem here? It just seems that some posters come on here with ANY news about a transgender person and hope to get everyone worked up into a frenzy.

Obviously it is not unreasonable to assume that since he uses 'she' pronouns he is going to have some expectation that others go along with this make believe too? That his 'trans identity' is going to be the most significant thing about him. If it is not such a big deal, then why is everyone lauding him as a sign of how 'progressive' Australia is imagined to be?

We know Australia has fatally undermined women's rights and protections in pursuit of what it sees as some sort of anti-colonial act of "liberation for marginalised identities", blah, blah, blah. It is still quite galling to see it in action though.

Rightsraptor · 24/09/2026 09:47

sanluca · 24/09/2026 05:55

Is it the person being transgender that makes you think he is unsuited to office? Because that is discrimination. There are nice transgender people out there too, you know?

What are his policies? Is he going to actively work against women? If that is the case yes, he would be the wrong person for the job. Otherwise, give him a chance. It is not like being deputy mayor is a role reserved for women.

For it to be discrimination, at least in the UK, someone has to have suffered a detriment. Saying a deluded person is not suited to public office is not a detriment and is accurate. Ni way would I ever vote for someone who denied their reality.

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 09:42

FinchiePink · 24/09/2026 09:30

Agreed.

This thread is the kind of thing which lends weight to the argument that FWR is actually transphobic.

A trans person is deputy mayor. So what? I'm sure we'd all agree that trans people do exist and that they have the right to participate in public life like the rest of us.

They may be a shit deputy mayor or they may be a great one.

Reacting with horror solely because the person elected is trans is, I'm afraid to say, definite transphobia.

People who adopt trans identities are no different to anyone else. They are not a unique category of human being.They are either male or female., and nobody should be expected to pretend otherwise. Crack on if you want to cross dress or even change your first name but the expectation that people must buy into this whole 'trans' thing is way off the mark.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 09:40

FinchiePink · 24/09/2026 09:30

Agreed.

This thread is the kind of thing which lends weight to the argument that FWR is actually transphobic.

A trans person is deputy mayor. So what? I'm sure we'd all agree that trans people do exist and that they have the right to participate in public life like the rest of us.

They may be a shit deputy mayor or they may be a great one.

Reacting with horror solely because the person elected is trans is, I'm afraid to say, definite transphobia.

I agree up to a point. As I've said I think there are issues around this - discussed above. I think that the thread itself can be used for those discussions. I also feel that the thread would only 'lend weight' to the argument that FWR is transphobic if it was page upon page of transphobia. It isn't. I suspect it will be largely ignored (she said, not ignoring it).

More broadly, it's evident that in general when someone starts a thread in a similar vein there isn't much appetite for it. I'm thinking of the 'Dolly' thread, where the consensus is pretty much a rejection of purity tests. In some ways these threads demonstrate the diversity of thought on FWR and the general rejection of 'transphobia'.

Funnywonder · 24/09/2026 09:39

OK, I’m very much gender critical, but I seriously don’t see a problem with a HUMAN BEING assuming this role. A human being working as a public figure for other human beings. Where exactly is the problem here? It just seems that some posters come on here with ANY news about a transgender person and hope to get everyone worked up into a frenzy.

FinchiePink · 24/09/2026 09:30

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 08:25

Yes I see that wider implication and would have supported a thread that led with that and not that Australia is going to the dogs because Sydney has appointed a trans person as deputy mayor. That reaction, imo, gives fuel to trans arguments against gender critical women.

Agreed.

This thread is the kind of thing which lends weight to the argument that FWR is actually transphobic.

A trans person is deputy mayor. So what? I'm sure we'd all agree that trans people do exist and that they have the right to participate in public life like the rest of us.

They may be a shit deputy mayor or they may be a great one.

Reacting with horror solely because the person elected is trans is, I'm afraid to say, definite transphobia.

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 09:15

At some point we'll look back and be increduloius that such nonsense was seen as credible. An example of what people will do, say and believe when they prioritise group belonging and moral righteousness as their supreme value.

He might be perfectly capable and a fantastic communicator, but he's not a woman, and the use of she/her pronouns is a joke.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 08:36

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 08:25

Yes I see that wider implication and would have supported a thread that led with that and not that Australia is going to the dogs because Sydney has appointed a trans person as deputy mayor. That reaction, imo, gives fuel to trans arguments against gender critical women.

Fair point.

Swipe left for the next trending thread