Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Transgender person elected as Deputy Mayor in Sydney

169 replies

Catcentral · 24/09/2026 04:53

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1HxkfR1VCB/

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 24/09/2026 15:19

What are their policies and qualifications?

Why is this newsworthy at all?

can we get back to advocating for women please?

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:17

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:10

You might want to check out the OP's other posts across the board, if you want an insight into why they posted it.

I'll give you a tiny hint, they reply 'well said' quite a lot to the resident TRAs. Can you work out what they were trying to do or would you like more help?

Yes theyve likely posted it because they believe this view would be welcome here. It doesmt matter if it is a reverse of sorts, it's because FWR seems like the kind of place that would agree trans people shouldn't have this (or any) job.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:11

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:08

I'm talking about the OP.

Oh dear

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:10

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:07

If this wasn't an environment where these views were thought to be welcome, OP wouldn't have posted it.

@Catcentral are.you.surprised that more members arent agreeing with you on this given the usual tone and content of the posts?

You might want to check out the OP's other posts across the board, if you want an insight into why they posted it.

I'll give you a tiny hint, they reply 'well said' quite a lot to the resident TRAs. Can you work out what they were trying to do or would you like more help?

DialSquare · 24/09/2026 15:08

I would be wary of him because he is likely to be a TRA. If he turns out to be a user of male single sex provision only, agrees that women should retain their own single sex provision and does not promote the ideology to children, then I have no issue with him in the role. I would have the same issue with any TRA in a similar role whether they are trans or not.

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:08

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 15:00

Which arguments?

Can you please be clear exactly what you have issues with other people saying rather than this vague handwaving that tars everyone with some unspecified "says nasty things" brush?

I've explained exactly why I consider trans people to have a fundamentally sexist worldview. It's not a weird prejudice. There is direct and obvious link between the two.

I do not see how basing my assessment of someone's view of women based on their adoption of a transgender identity is somehow less well reasoned than basing my assessment of, oh, someone's view of immigration based on their membership of Reform.

I'm talking about the OP.

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:07

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:01

There are a range of views expressed on this thread, indicative of the wide range of views and values of the 'regular members' (whoever they are).

If this wasn't an environment where these views were thought to be welcome, OP wouldn't have posted it.

@Catcentral are.you.surprised that more members arent agreeing with you on this given the usual tone and content of the posts?

Franxi · 24/09/2026 15:05

Ingenieur · 24/09/2026 06:05

@sanluca humans discriminate on all sorts of things every single day, big and small - it's called decision making.

I'd suggest a candidate being unable to differentiate truth from fiction does make them unsuited to public office.

If that was the case there would be very few people in public office - take the leader of the USA for example!!

Discrimination isn’t decision making. Saying one thing costs less than something else isn’t discrimination. Not employing a woman because she is of childbearing age and could potentially cost the company more money however would be.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:01

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 14:51

The fact that people can post these arguments and expect to get support here is indicative of the wider atmosphere and the shared values of the regular members.

There are a range of views expressed on this thread, indicative of the wide range of views and values of the 'regular members' (whoever they are).

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 15:00

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 14:51

The fact that people can post these arguments and expect to get support here is indicative of the wider atmosphere and the shared values of the regular members.

Which arguments?

Can you please be clear exactly what you have issues with other people saying rather than this vague handwaving that tars everyone with some unspecified "says nasty things" brush?

I've explained exactly why I consider trans people to have a fundamentally sexist worldview. It's not a weird prejudice. There is direct and obvious link between the two.

I do not see how basing my assessment of someone's view of women based on their adoption of a transgender identity is somehow less well reasoned than basing my assessment of, oh, someone's view of immigration based on their membership of Reform.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 14:59

TurkishShepherd · 24/09/2026 14:39

It's legitimate to have a problem with policies which are detremental to women, or the council claiming 50:50 representation.

But if your claiming someones unfit to stand only because they're trans, IMO it's a bold look which crosses the line from gender critical to anti trans, rather than pro-woman and it absolutely will be snatched up as representative of 'what GCs think'

I recognise that for someone to be 'trans' there is often a denial of a fundamental biological truth (hence some posters saying 'they're liars') - but that's not universal and the question is the same as any other politician - how much will the individuals personal view affect their political conduct.

Again, we are back to how much we can question 'how much will the individuals personal view affect their political conduct'. Olly may well believe that transwomen are a flavour of men. He may think that transwomen shouldn't use female-only facilities, but would we be able to ask? In principle, anyone should be able to present as they like and stand for public office, but we can't pretend that there isn't a challenge in relation to, for example, transwomen and their interaction with female-only spaces.

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 14:51

The fact that people can post these arguments and expect to get support here is indicative of the wider atmosphere and the shared values of the regular members.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 14:46

TurkishShepherd · 24/09/2026 14:39

It's legitimate to have a problem with policies which are detremental to women, or the council claiming 50:50 representation.

But if your claiming someones unfit to stand only because they're trans, IMO it's a bold look which crosses the line from gender critical to anti trans, rather than pro-woman and it absolutely will be snatched up as representative of 'what GCs think'

I recognise that for someone to be 'trans' there is often a denial of a fundamental biological truth (hence some posters saying 'they're liars') - but that's not universal and the question is the same as any other politician - how much will the individuals personal view affect their political conduct.

And the sexism. Don't forget the sexism.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 14:45

PeachyDaisy · 24/09/2026 14:19

Some of the arguments in this thread are starting to sound like "I have to hire someone for this job but I'll never consider a trans person for it because they are by definition delusional/crazy." Those same arguments used to be made by employers in the past when they refused to hire women (as well as by voters when they refused to support female candidates),

As I said before I will vote for Katiyln Jenner over AOC any day of the week as they knows what a woman is, them being transgender is irrelevant, only their policies matter . And I will consider hiring a trans person for the job if they are the best candidate.

Edited

Sexist. Not "crazy", sexist.

That is the issue. If you believe we shouldn't be able to criticise sexism just because it comes wrapped up in a Gender package rather than a "Make me a sammich!" T shirt, that is a great demonstration of the problem.

TurkishShepherd · 24/09/2026 14:39

It's legitimate to have a problem with policies which are detremental to women, or the council claiming 50:50 representation.

But if your claiming someones unfit to stand only because they're trans, IMO it's a bold look which crosses the line from gender critical to anti trans, rather than pro-woman and it absolutely will be snatched up as representative of 'what GCs think'

I recognise that for someone to be 'trans' there is often a denial of a fundamental biological truth (hence some posters saying 'they're liars') - but that's not universal and the question is the same as any other politician - how much will the individuals personal view affect their political conduct.

PeachyDaisy · 24/09/2026 14:19

Some of the arguments in this thread are starting to sound like "I have to hire someone for this job but I'll never consider a trans person for it because they are by definition delusional/crazy." Those same arguments used to be made by employers in the past when they refused to hire women (as well as by voters when they refused to support female candidates),

As I said before I will vote for Katiyln Jenner over AOC any day of the week as they knows what a woman is, them being transgender is irrelevant, only their policies matter . And I will consider hiring a trans person for the job if they are the best candidate.

Manyanamanyana · 24/09/2026 14:07

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 07:42

I'm sorry but it's this kind of reaction that will give ammunition to trans claims that "terfs" want them eradicated. It damages women's arguments for safe spaces and fair sport.

He's perfectly entitled to dress and present however he wants, just as we are as women.

He has huge experience for the role and was elected unanimously.

Judge the man on his policies and achievements.

Except you will need to address this man as she and her, and agree that "women like her" belong in women's spaces and sports, and should recieve prizes, scholarships and positions reserved for actual women.
A man who asks that people believe he is a woman is dishonest by definition and will do nothing to support women's sex based rights. That means he is working against the best interests of 50% of the population the 50% most in need of sex segregated spaces and facilities.
I will not give him a chance because when we are "asked" to give up our spaces, sports services and facilities to men who wish they were us, we lose.
It is the "reasonable" imposters that soften our boundaries because people use the exception as the rule. It is coercion and it stinks.

UndecidedOtter · 24/09/2026 13:58

Why post this link? A transgender person has been elected to public office. That's it.

Justme56 · 24/09/2026 13:50

He’s a woman like any other woman in Australia, as is quite obvious from the Giggle/Tickle case. I can’t imagine there will be any situation where you could state otherwise without landing up with accusations of transphobia or even ending up in court. I think the problem lies less with the job role and more with freedom of speech and being able to speak about reality.

Funnywonder · 24/09/2026 13:29

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 12:26

You see, i take question with the very concept of a 'trans person'. Nobody is the opposite sex to that which they are. We are all male or female. I prefer to use the more accurate phrase of 'man/woman/person who has adopted a trans identity.

Using this correct definition in no way trying to position that person as something they are not, or suggest that people can somehow be the other sex to that which they are. It places the emphasis on the assumption of a certain type of social identity (which has become formulated and 'on trend' in the last couple of decades) but which not everyone must pay lip service to.

Identity politics tends to place the emphasis on the social identity of, rather than on the actual character of the person.

Edited

That is a fair and interesting point. Terminology certainly matters. I have seen TIM, as in Trans Identified Male, used. I think that’s a whole separate debate though, in terms of whether a person who identifies in this way should be permitted to hold a public position. There would have to be a societal shift away from the current terminology (a good thing, I reckon.)

With regard to a point made by other posters, I agree that recording this man as a woman in the council would have the serious consequence of misrepresenting the male/female balance, which I definitely don’t agree with. But the OP plopped on here with a title and a link, with absolutely no context. No explanation as to why they had posted. Had they given a reason, that could have been debated. Otherwise it’s just someone who is pissed off with a trans person in Australia for reasons unknown. Or perhaps they don’t give a toss either way and just wanted to start a bun fight, which is what usually happens on these threads.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 12:45

AstonCanKissMyArse · 24/09/2026 12:35

There was no mandate for a 50:50 sex split, AFAIK.

But a PP noted it is being reported that Sydney now has a 'gender balanced' council. This 'fact' will be taken up by search engines and AI and repeated when its not true.

These 'false facts' based on incorrect sex reporting mask the progress still needed on women's equality by making it look as though it's already been achieved . it hasn't.

I'd have much less of a problem with a trans identified woman (trans man) being elected for this reason, although the question of sexist beliefs remain.

It's vaguely interesting to see how much Sydney City Council is confusing Google's AI. The Mitch/Olly change alone has got it thinking they are two different people.

AstonCanKissMyArse · 24/09/2026 12:35

sanluca · 24/09/2026 11:57

Most politicians are liars sorry to say, so this person is no exception. Many politicians are also sexist, see them prioritising mens beliefs over womens rights.

However, if the reason he was elected is now being used to say something is 50:50 men and women and he is being counted as a woman, yes, then I do have a problem with the election. That is not fair representation. Is that what happened?

There was no mandate for a 50:50 sex split, AFAIK.

But a PP noted it is being reported that Sydney now has a 'gender balanced' council. This 'fact' will be taken up by search engines and AI and repeated when its not true.

These 'false facts' based on incorrect sex reporting mask the progress still needed on women's equality by making it look as though it's already been achieved . it hasn't.

I'd have much less of a problem with a trans identified woman (trans man) being elected for this reason, although the question of sexist beliefs remain.

ButWhoAmI · 24/09/2026 12:29

sanluca · 24/09/2026 11:57

Most politicians are liars sorry to say, so this person is no exception. Many politicians are also sexist, see them prioritising mens beliefs over womens rights.

However, if the reason he was elected is now being used to say something is 50:50 men and women and he is being counted as a woman, yes, then I do have a problem with the election. That is not fair representation. Is that what happened?

They don't generally pretend to be the opposite sex though.

AstonCanKissMyArse · 24/09/2026 12:27

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 11:28

As a Feminist I recognise sexism runs throughout society, often in ways that are so deeply embedded in our everyday norms and expectations that it is hard to recognise the sexism underneath. Fish have no word water and all that.

So no, sexism is absolutely not limited just to those people who express their sexism through a transgender identity.

However after thinking about this very deeply for a long time, I have come to the conclusion it is impossible to conceptualise a transgender identity without sexist ideas about how men and women think, feel and act, and it is impossible to require social accommodation of trans women as "women" without the sexist assumption that the trans identity matters more than female realities and needs. So to that end, I do consider a transgender identity to be clear evidence of sexism.

Of course I also acknowledge it's possible there are exceptions I'm missing and I'm open to listening and assessing individuals. However a trans person would have to express a very unusual and nuanced understanding of the intersection of sex and gender identity to be able to claim a transgender identity without some level of sexist belief, and as yet I have never cone across it.

Odd question really. As I said, I wouldn't vote for anyone I believe to be sexist or racist. Why would anything I said suggest I'd make an exception if the sexist person wasn't transgender?

Edited

I agree. I think for me, this is the issue with a person in authority being trans - the sexism is baked in to their personal belief system. Its a feature, not a bug. Their entire belief system is predicated on there being a right way (and therefore a wrong way) to be male and to be female. How can that not affect their policy decisions?

In theory, it should make no difference whether or not the candidate is trans. But its not the same as any other belief and I can't 'respect the person while not sharing their beliefs' - because they'll inevitably expect me to participate in those beliefs / inflict them upon me to a degree. I would feel the same if a public official was a fundamentalist religious person, or a militant animal rights activist - I'd be concerned that their overt beliefs would impact on their policy making in a way that I don't agree with.

That's not to say the other candidates don't have beliefs but if they keep them to themselves, we can't comment on them - we can only comment on what we know. A man might have sexist beliefs. A TW definitely does.

As a pp said upthread, we would be permitted to freely discuss these other aspects of a public official and their potential affect on their policy stance without being accused of hate speech.

Regarding 'discrimination' , it has rather become a dirty word but it just means 'to notice a difference'. I have just ordered a flat white, and in doing so have discriminated against tea! Some forms of discrimination, mainly to do with how people are treated with regards to employment and services are illegal and rightly so. But its not illegal discrimination (yet!) to notice and discuss the difference between elected candidates. Voting is like dating - the ultimate non equal opportunity activity. Anyone should have the right to stand, nobody else has to vote for them.

I don't agree that we should police discussion on this forum in case some hard of thinking people think badly of gender critical people because they can't tell the difference between hate speech and discussion. That's heading towards purity spiral thinking. This is one of the only corners of the Internet where discussions around gender and sex are permitted, more specifically, their impact on women. Long may it continue.

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 12:26

Funnywonder · 24/09/2026 10:01

Should transgender people then be excluded from public office? I reserve my right to look at a trans woman and see a man, whether he is representing the community or emptying the bins. But my thoughts are my thoughts. It doesn’t change how that person does their job. I object to him using women’s toilets (if he does.) I don’t feel compelled to use the so-called ‘appropriate’ pronouns. But those are separate issues from whether or not he makes a good Deputy Lord Mayor. As a human being. And all the cheerleaders saying how great it is to be so progressive and inclusive - well that’s irrelevant too in respect of how he actually performs his duties.

You see, i take question with the very concept of a 'trans person'. Nobody is the opposite sex to that which they are. We are all male or female. I prefer to use the more accurate phrase of 'man/woman/person who has adopted a trans identity.

Using this correct definition in no way trying to position that person as something they are not, or suggest that people can somehow be the other sex to that which they are. It places the emphasis on the assumption of a certain type of social identity (which has become formulated and 'on trend' in the last couple of decades) but which not everyone must pay lip service to.

Identity politics tends to place the emphasis on the social identity of, rather than on the actual character of the person.