Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Transgender person elected as Deputy Mayor in Sydney

169 replies

Catcentral · 24/09/2026 04:53

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1HxkfR1VCB/

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 16:26

Rollingpinofdoom · 24/09/2026 16:16

But then how fine olly wasn’t a TIM 2 years ago? If he was always a woman, why was he a man 2 years ago? You realise how batshit you sound claiming that 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Do you have an equal problem with people who declare their homosexuality later in life?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 16:26

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 24/09/2026 15:46

Trans women lose their societal privilege when they transition, and were always women before they came out. They have the truth of the importance of feminism spelled out to them every day.

Cis women often have ingrained sexist views, do you think they shouldn't hold office?

If I know a person to be sexist, of course as a Feminist I wouldn't vote for her. Weird that you felt you needed to ask really.

Feminism isn't some free floating concept that follows the word "Woman" whoever it happens to point at, it follows the reality of the female sex, the inequalities we face because of our sex, and the social consequences that come with it.

There's deep Feminist insights associated with the experiences of and social constructs around feminised men, both those who chose to feminise and those who society forces into that role. It really illuminates the mechanisms of Patriarchy.

But these insights are only available if you recognise trans women are men.

If you try to frame the world around Gender and insist feminised men are actually, truly women, you lose these insights. You have become part of the same Patriarchal framework that Feminists are fighting to get rid of.

PeachyDaisy · 24/09/2026 16:23

Yes the transphobia from some people on here saddens me. Although I think we have to be careful to not tar the whole movement with one brush (I happen to think most gender critical people don't have a transphobic bone in their body).

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 16:21

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:44

Well the only people who thought this would 'fly', as you put it, were the TRA OP and your good self. Who expressed surprise that it hadn't and then suggested the only reason it didn't is because people knew who the OP was. So that tells us quite a lot, just not what you think it does.

For the record, I didn't have any idea what they had posted previously when I posted initially.

People don't seem able to see what's happening on this forum.

I didn't know or care who the OP was, I read the article pointed to and he seemed like a really good fit for that particular role in that particular city. I actually thought the OP was a trans phone against the appointment.

Some of the later reactions were either outright trans phobic or can very easily be read as transphobic.

The trans community appear to be feeding these threads into MN, and sitting back and waiting for the plumbs to drop from the tree that can later be used to argue how transphobic gender critical women are and how gender critical women want them erased from society and how justifiably threatened they feel by gender critical women.

This forum is being played, and many of the GC women on it aren't helping their own side with their comments.

Rollingpinofdoom · 24/09/2026 16:16

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 24/09/2026 15:46

Trans women lose their societal privilege when they transition, and were always women before they came out. They have the truth of the importance of feminism spelled out to them every day.

Cis women often have ingrained sexist views, do you think they shouldn't hold office?

But then how fine olly wasn’t a TIM 2 years ago? If he was always a woman, why was he a man 2 years ago? You realise how batshit you sound claiming that 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Rollingpinofdoom · 24/09/2026 16:14

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 14:51

The fact that people can post these arguments and expect to get support here is indicative of the wider atmosphere and the shared values of the regular members.

But that would include you…. So by posting here you are asserting that you also align with those values I mean I’ve seen you a lot in here do is assume you were a regular member……

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 24/09/2026 15:51

p.s. I get the impression someone pro-trans posted this, and if so then well done proving the points I made. The posts desperately trying to justify their objection to a trans person's election are quite something, and depressingly unsurprising.

Just say you hate trans people and have invented a raft of justifications, it's quicker.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:49

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 24/09/2026 15:46

Trans women lose their societal privilege when they transition, and were always women before they came out. They have the truth of the importance of feminism spelled out to them every day.

Cis women often have ingrained sexist views, do you think they shouldn't hold office?

Well maybe you could tell me this then. Was Olly Arkins a woman 3 years ago when he used 'he/him' pronouns and the name Mitch Wilson? Or 2 years ago when, still as Mitch, he was elected. presenting as male although then using they/them pronouns? What made Olly/Mitch a woman then?

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:48

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 15:32

No, i don't. I take my words seriously. I hate name calling. I'm interested in reasoned debate and in challenging others to do the same. I'm responsible for myself and my own behaviour, not that of other people.

Edited

See, if it appears that I'm on the same side of people doing something clearly wrong, I make sure I loudly call them out to separate them from people like me who share their particular view on a topic. I especially make sure I am not seen to support them.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 24/09/2026 15:46

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 15:00

Which arguments?

Can you please be clear exactly what you have issues with other people saying rather than this vague handwaving that tars everyone with some unspecified "says nasty things" brush?

I've explained exactly why I consider trans people to have a fundamentally sexist worldview. It's not a weird prejudice. There is direct and obvious link between the two.

I do not see how basing my assessment of someone's view of women based on their adoption of a transgender identity is somehow less well reasoned than basing my assessment of, oh, someone's view of immigration based on their membership of Reform.

Trans women lose their societal privilege when they transition, and were always women before they came out. They have the truth of the importance of feminism spelled out to them every day.

Cis women often have ingrained sexist views, do you think they shouldn't hold office?

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:46

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 24/09/2026 15:42

And?

So what?!

Well, I guess it proves once again that all the complaints about trans people on this forum boil down to one thing: some people can't cope with the fact that trans people exist.

And do normal things. Have jobs, contribute to society, get happily accepted by a large section of society.

I apologise for the disappointment some of you are feeling. Because trans people are meant to be permanently angry and sex-obsessed, right? And nothing else. Just a cartoon of a human being, a temporary abberation.

Maybe confront the idea that you have a problem with difference, if something so utterly normal is newsworthy to you.

You might want to catch up with the whole thread.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:44

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:28

I'd be more.embarrassed that people thought this would fly somewhere I am.known to frequent. We dont all share the same sense of shame though

Well the only people who thought this would 'fly', as you put it, were the TRA OP and your good self. Who expressed surprise that it hadn't and then suggested the only reason it didn't is because people knew who the OP was. So that tells us quite a lot, just not what you think it does.

For the record, I didn't have any idea what they had posted previously when I posted initially.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 24/09/2026 15:42

Catcentral · 24/09/2026 04:53

And?

So what?!

Well, I guess it proves once again that all the complaints about trans people on this forum boil down to one thing: some people can't cope with the fact that trans people exist.

And do normal things. Have jobs, contribute to society, get happily accepted by a large section of society.

I apologise for the disappointment some of you are feeling. Because trans people are meant to be permanently angry and sex-obsessed, right? And nothing else. Just a cartoon of a human being, a temporary abberation.

Maybe confront the idea that you have a problem with difference, if something so utterly normal is newsworthy to you.

Ingenieur · 24/09/2026 15:41

@Franxi

Discrimination isn’t decision making.

Discrimination is the ability to make distinctions or discern differences. It is essential to decisionmaking.

DialSquare · 24/09/2026 15:39

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:28

I'd be more.embarrassed that people thought this would fly somewhere I am.known to frequent. We dont all share the same sense of shame though

Oh we definitely don’t all share the same sense of shame. Some of us find it extremely shameful to promote an ideology that harms children, wants to turn single sex provision into mixed sex (which in turn will mean some women will self exclude from their own previously single sex provision) and believes that men can be lesbians.
Others don’t find that shameful at all.

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 15:36

Manyanamanyana · 24/09/2026 14:07

Except you will need to address this man as she and her, and agree that "women like her" belong in women's spaces and sports, and should recieve prizes, scholarships and positions reserved for actual women.
A man who asks that people believe he is a woman is dishonest by definition and will do nothing to support women's sex based rights. That means he is working against the best interests of 50% of the population the 50% most in need of sex segregated spaces and facilities.
I will not give him a chance because when we are "asked" to give up our spaces, sports services and facilities to men who wish they were us, we lose.
It is the "reasonable" imposters that soften our boundaries because people use the exception as the rule. It is coercion and it stinks.

Your APU {Assumption Production Unit} is working overtime there as to how I and he would behave.

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 15:32

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:26

Do.you name call ever though? Or suggest women who disagree with you are stupid or "handmaidens" or must be men anything like that?
Do you call out others that do those things in the name of "the movement"?

No, i don't. I take my words seriously. I hate name calling. I'm interested in reasoned debate and in challenging others to do the same. I'm responsible for myself and my own behaviour, not that of other people.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 15:32

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:22

No, which is somewhat warming. However, is that because certain folks knew the OP was "a TRA"? Would it have gone down differently if the OP was known to be GC?

I doubt it. Certainly I have no idea who the OP is, didn't notice the username. Didn't even click on the link. So that didn't influence my posts one bit.

More generally, my GC Feminist arguments are based in facts and logic and don't change based on what I think I know about the person I'm replying to.

What might change if I recognise a username or posting style as one of the groundhog day posters is how much presumption of good faith I'm prepared to extend or how much time I'm prepared to invest, but that's just a rational decision based on knowing full well I've said exactly the same things to the same poster many many times before, meaning their pretence they've never come across certain ideas or arguments or indeed data is simply exactly that, a pretence.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:30

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 15:24

I suggest most people who are long standing posters here are not looking for a " bun fight" but instead are committed to pushing back against trans ideology in all its many guises. I don't come here for a scrap or to name call, I come here because i want to be a part of the movement that challenges it. I come here because this board is a great source of information, and a place of support.

Edited

The TRA OP has very effectively demonstrated that the members of the board aren't interested in, as you say, a bun fight and in the main hold a variety of nuanced views. (Despite the efforts of the 'I'm as GC as they come, but' contingent to claim otherwise)

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:28

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:26

Stop, you're embarrassing yourself now.

I'd be more.embarrassed that people thought this would fly somewhere I am.known to frequent. We dont all share the same sense of shame though

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:26

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:22

No, which is somewhat warming. However, is that because certain folks knew the OP was "a TRA"? Would it have gone down differently if the OP was known to be GC?

Stop, you're embarrassing yourself now.

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:26

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 15:24

I suggest most people who are long standing posters here are not looking for a " bun fight" but instead are committed to pushing back against trans ideology in all its many guises. I don't come here for a scrap or to name call, I come here because i want to be a part of the movement that challenges it. I come here because this board is a great source of information, and a place of support.

Edited

Do.you name call ever though? Or suggest women who disagree with you are stupid or "handmaidens" or must be men anything like that?
Do you call out others that do those things in the name of "the movement"?

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/09/2026 15:24

Funnywonder · 24/09/2026 13:29

That is a fair and interesting point. Terminology certainly matters. I have seen TIM, as in Trans Identified Male, used. I think that’s a whole separate debate though, in terms of whether a person who identifies in this way should be permitted to hold a public position. There would have to be a societal shift away from the current terminology (a good thing, I reckon.)

With regard to a point made by other posters, I agree that recording this man as a woman in the council would have the serious consequence of misrepresenting the male/female balance, which I definitely don’t agree with. But the OP plopped on here with a title and a link, with absolutely no context. No explanation as to why they had posted. Had they given a reason, that could have been debated. Otherwise it’s just someone who is pissed off with a trans person in Australia for reasons unknown. Or perhaps they don’t give a toss either way and just wanted to start a bun fight, which is what usually happens on these threads.

I suggest most people who are long standing posters here are not looking for a " bun fight" but instead are committed to pushing back against trans ideology in all its many guises. I don't come here for a scrap or to name call, I come here because i want to be a part of the movement that challenges it. I come here because this board is a great source of information, and a place of support.

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:22

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:21

Oh I don't doubt that the hard of thinking some contributors might believe this was welcome, but as you noticed ("are you surprised that more members arent [sic] agreeing with you") it really didn't get that type of reception.

No, which is somewhat warming. However, is that because certain folks knew the OP was "a TRA"? Would it have gone down differently if the OP was known to be GC?

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 15:21

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:17

Yes theyve likely posted it because they believe this view would be welcome here. It doesmt matter if it is a reverse of sorts, it's because FWR seems like the kind of place that would agree trans people shouldn't have this (or any) job.

Oh I don't doubt that the hard of thinking some contributors might believe this was welcome, but as you noticed ("are you surprised that more members arent [sic] agreeing with you") it really didn't get that type of reception.

Swipe left for the next trending thread