Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Transgender person elected as Deputy Mayor in Sydney

169 replies

Catcentral · 24/09/2026 04:53

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1HxkfR1VCB/

OP posts:
BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 18:00

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:50

Let me make this clear that I am not saying that anyone on this forum should not have expressed their personal views. What I am saying is that personal views like these below are unnecessarily handing ammunition directly to trans activists, and this forum is being played by trans activists in order to generate that ammunition

Referring to people as lying when they are expressing a genuinely held, if delusional, view, particularly when that view is supported by the law in the country that person lives in.

"How low can Australia go" when all that has been said at that point is that a trans person has been appointed deputy mayor, as if nobody trans should ever be appointed to a political position.

"Not chosen on merit" when is clear that he has huge experience for the role and he was elected unanimously.

Multiple assumptions that he has been chosen only because he is trans and not on the basis of his extensive experience.

Ridiculing and questioning his not coming out as female identified earlier in his life.

Assumptions with no evidence that he will prioritise trans rights over women's rights. Not discussing whether he might, but simply assuming that he will.

Are those unhelpful? Yes

Do they fairly represent the majority of posts on this thread? I don’t think they do.

ETA when one of the critics of the thread believed the OP to be GC, they suggested that the OP would be disappointed with the responses. Implying the thread is not the ‘hate fest’ that some would like to think.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 17:57

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:50

Let me make this clear that I am not saying that anyone on this forum should not have expressed their personal views. What I am saying is that personal views like these below are unnecessarily handing ammunition directly to trans activists, and this forum is being played by trans activists in order to generate that ammunition

Referring to people as lying when they are expressing a genuinely held, if delusional, view, particularly when that view is supported by the law in the country that person lives in.

"How low can Australia go" when all that has been said at that point is that a trans person has been appointed deputy mayor, as if nobody trans should ever be appointed to a political position.

"Not chosen on merit" when is clear that he has huge experience for the role and he was elected unanimously.

Multiple assumptions that he has been chosen only because he is trans and not on the basis of his extensive experience.

Ridiculing and questioning his not coming out as female identified earlier in his life.

Assumptions with no evidence that he will prioritise trans rights over women's rights. Not discussing whether he might, but simply assuming that he will.

Thank you. It is so much more helpful and frankly a much stronger post when it's clear to what someone is (and is not!) referring.

I don't disagree with the assessment that those are weak and unhelpful comments by the way. Though from experience I warn you "delusional not a liar" doesn't land well with the TRA-inclined either!

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:54

This thread is now, in a familiar pattern, turning to attack the messenger, so I will leave you all to it.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 17:52

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:11

Isn't it up to him to decide when he's ready to take the last step in living in keeping with how he feels?

Sure, but I still think it’s a stretch to compare that, in Olly’s specific circumstances, to somebody coming out as gay later in life. That aside, the post you made that comparison as a reply to was talking specifically about the claim that Olly was always a woman. Even when he was a male presenting nb person called Mitch - as he was when elected. You seem to be suggesting that it is ‘transphobic’ or at the very least ‘giving ammunition’ to trans activists to even discuss that claim that Olly was always a woman.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 17:52

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 17:07

Great question! I have had exactly that situation. He was the best candidate for the job, I spoke in his favour and we hired him.

I still however consider his beliefs sexist, and should he turn round tomorrow and run for public office, I wouldn't vote for him because there's too much scope in public office for sexist beliefs to be concretised into sexist policies.

FWIW I consider many trans people to be much the victims of Patriarchy as they are its enforcers. But that's very usual for marginalised people, they take on the values of the system that oppresses them. Trans and Female both.

Edited

Of course the really interesting question is whether the Genderists on this thread would hire a gender critical Feminist if she were the best qualified candidate, and if not, why not.

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:50

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 17:29

I am not stupid. I've thought through this a lot. Wargamed both sides.

Ultimately if the choices are to say nothing and be silently right in my own head but change nothing, or say something, know I will and indeed should have to justify it, and thereby work towards change, of course I will say something.

Again, please be specific about this "plenty that has been said seeded right through responses on this thread that hands ammunition directly to trans activists."

What exactly do you think should not be said?

Let me make this clear that I am not saying that anyone on this forum should not have expressed their personal views. What I am saying is that personal views like these below are unnecessarily handing ammunition directly to trans activists, and this forum is being played by trans activists in order to generate that ammunition

Referring to people as lying when they are expressing a genuinely held, if delusional, view, particularly when that view is supported by the law in the country that person lives in.

"How low can Australia go" when all that has been said at that point is that a trans person has been appointed deputy mayor, as if nobody trans should ever be appointed to a political position.

"Not chosen on merit" when is clear that he has huge experience for the role and he was elected unanimously.

Multiple assumptions that he has been chosen only because he is trans and not on the basis of his extensive experience.

Ridiculing and questioning his not coming out as female identified earlier in his life.

Assumptions with no evidence that he will prioritise trans rights over women's rights. Not discussing whether he might, but simply assuming that he will.

BettyBooper · 24/09/2026 17:44

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:19

I was getting there in understanding that with previous threads but this one has been really shocking. There's outright transphobia on this thread.

If you believe that a man who maintains that he is actually a woman is fundamentally sexist, then it follows (if you are against sexism) that you would not want that man in a politically influential post.

If you don't think that a man who maintains that he is a woman is sexist / don't care about sexism, then you might want that man in a politically influential post. Whatever.

It isn't 'transphobic' to believe the former and to be concerned about a man who thinks womanhood is a special feeling he has being in a position of power.

Do you think that women have the right to believe that men who maintain that they are women are sexist? Because, whether you agree or not, what you seem to be implying is that they shouldn't be able to say that without being accused of 'transphobia'.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 17:33

alcovecupboards · 24/09/2026 17:17

You're wasting your time. There's a bizarre GC purity test on here and unless you openly hate trans people for existing - or deny they exist - you're branded a TRA. It's sad and working against us but they refuse to acknowledge that.

Please don't lie about other people. It undermines your position.

The only person saying anything about "hating" trans people or wanting them "not to exist" here is you when you make dishonest claims about what some handwavy "others" say.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 17:29

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:09

There is nothing that shouldn't be said for fear of making men angry.

There is plenty that has been said seeded right through responses on this thread that hands ammunition directly to trans activists.

You're being played.

Edited

I am not stupid. I've thought through this a lot. Wargamed both sides.

Ultimately if the choices are to say nothing and be silently right in my own head but change nothing, or say something, know I will and indeed should have to justify it, and thereby work towards change, of course I will say something.

Again, please be specific about this "plenty that has been said seeded right through responses on this thread that hands ammunition directly to trans activists."

What exactly do you think should not be said?

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:28

Wowthatwasabigstep · 24/09/2026 17:24

You can call it transphobia and I will call it reality. It is biologically and legally impossible to change sex, reality is winning.

That isn't something I have ever disagreed with and it's not what I'm talking about.

I have referred to this person throughout this thread as he.

Wowthatwasabigstep · 24/09/2026 17:24

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:19

I was getting there in understanding that with previous threads but this one has been really shocking. There's outright transphobia on this thread.

You can call it transphobia and I will call it reality. It is biologically and legally impossible to change sex, reality is winning.

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:19

alcovecupboards · 24/09/2026 17:17

You're wasting your time. There's a bizarre GC purity test on here and unless you openly hate trans people for existing - or deny they exist - you're branded a TRA. It's sad and working against us but they refuse to acknowledge that.

I was getting there in understanding that with previous threads but this one has been really shocking. There's outright transphobia on this thread.

alcovecupboards · 24/09/2026 17:17

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:09

There is nothing that shouldn't be said for fear of making men angry.

There is plenty that has been said seeded right through responses on this thread that hands ammunition directly to trans activists.

You're being played.

Edited

You're wasting your time. There's a bizarre GC purity test on here and unless you openly hate trans people for existing - or deny they exist - you're branded a TRA. It's sad and working against us but they refuse to acknowledge that.

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:11

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 16:35

I think that is a stretch TBH. Olly wasn't living in some redneck backwater, supressing his sexuality for fear of ostracism, or unexposed to ideas around gender identity. He was politically active, in progressive circles. He was openly 'queer'. He wasn't a woman then because he isn't a woman now. It's perfectly legitimate to examine claims that he was 'always a woman', and posters who believe he was can outline why they believe that.

On your other points, there is a world of difference between saying 'transpeople should not be in public life' and saying 'we can discuss the conflicts and challenges that arise when we try and accommodate groups with vastly differing world views'. I'd have the same outlook if we were talking about extremely religious people refusing, for example, to shake hands with members of the opposite sex (if that was required of their role) or demanding they don't sit next to members of the opposite sex.

Isn't it up to him to decide when he's ready to take the last step in living in keeping with how he feels?

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:09

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 16:29

Please be specific.

Say explicitly what you think should not be said even if true in case it gives angry men excuses to be angry and we can talk aboit that.

Handwaving vaguely at "Some People" saying "some things" isn't helping.

There is nothing that shouldn't be said for fear of making men angry.

There is plenty that has been said seeded right through responses on this thread that hands ammunition directly to trans activists.

You're being played.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 17:07

PeachyDaisy · 24/09/2026 16:33

If you were an employer and you were looking to hire someone for a job, would you refuse to to hire a transwomen (even if they happen to be the most qualified candidate)? It's not a gotcha, I'm genuinely curious.

Great question! I have had exactly that situation. He was the best candidate for the job, I spoke in his favour and we hired him.

I still however consider his beliefs sexist, and should he turn round tomorrow and run for public office, I wouldn't vote for him because there's too much scope in public office for sexist beliefs to be concretised into sexist policies.

FWIW I consider many trans people to be much the victims of Patriarchy as they are its enforcers. But that's very usual for marginalised people, they take on the values of the system that oppresses them. Trans and Female both.

Rollingpinofdoom · 24/09/2026 16:56

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 16:26

Do you have an equal problem with people who declare their homosexuality later in life?

No. I was questioning @TransParentlyAnnoyed who claimed TIM “were always women”. In that case what were they transitioning from?

Wowthatwasabigstep · 24/09/2026 16:44

Oh dear what a sad state of affairs. I would be worried that his grip on reality is tenuous if he is unable to realise he is a man.

sjays · 24/09/2026 16:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 16:36

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 24/09/2026 15:51

p.s. I get the impression someone pro-trans posted this, and if so then well done proving the points I made. The posts desperately trying to justify their objection to a trans person's election are quite something, and depressingly unsurprising.

Just say you hate trans people and have invented a raft of justifications, it's quicker.

So very bored of bad faith comments like this.

I hate Sexism. Whether it's being expressed as a trans identity or a conservative exhorting the trad-wife lifestyle doesn't change that view.

No one has yet been able to explain how it's not sexist to believe that some ways of thinking, feeling or being are only right for one sex, nor why the female half of the species is less significant, less deserving of legal, social and cultural recognition, than a male's sense of self.

Until that happens, I will continue to conclude that adopting a trans identity is an intrinsically sexist act.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 16:35

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 16:26

Do you have an equal problem with people who declare their homosexuality later in life?

I think that is a stretch TBH. Olly wasn't living in some redneck backwater, supressing his sexuality for fear of ostracism, or unexposed to ideas around gender identity. He was politically active, in progressive circles. He was openly 'queer'. He wasn't a woman then because he isn't a woman now. It's perfectly legitimate to examine claims that he was 'always a woman', and posters who believe he was can outline why they believe that.

On your other points, there is a world of difference between saying 'transpeople should not be in public life' and saying 'we can discuss the conflicts and challenges that arise when we try and accommodate groups with vastly differing world views'. I'd have the same outlook if we were talking about extremely religious people refusing, for example, to shake hands with members of the opposite sex (if that was required of their role) or demanding they don't sit next to members of the opposite sex.

sanluca · 24/09/2026 16:34

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 24/09/2026 15:46

Trans women lose their societal privilege when they transition, and were always women before they came out. They have the truth of the importance of feminism spelled out to them every day.

Cis women often have ingrained sexist views, do you think they shouldn't hold office?

Transwomen might lose some societal standing compared when they thought of themselves as men, but they are still put above women. Every time you post, you clearly demonstrate that.

PeachyDaisy · 24/09/2026 16:33

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 16:26

If I know a person to be sexist, of course as a Feminist I wouldn't vote for her. Weird that you felt you needed to ask really.

Feminism isn't some free floating concept that follows the word "Woman" whoever it happens to point at, it follows the reality of the female sex, the inequalities we face because of our sex, and the social consequences that come with it.

There's deep Feminist insights associated with the experiences of and social constructs around feminised men, both those who chose to feminise and those who society forces into that role. It really illuminates the mechanisms of Patriarchy.

But these insights are only available if you recognise trans women are men.

If you try to frame the world around Gender and insist feminised men are actually, truly women, you lose these insights. You have become part of the same Patriarchal framework that Feminists are fighting to get rid of.

If you were an employer and you were looking to hire someone for a job, would you refuse to to hire a transwomen (even if they happen to be the most qualified candidate)? It's not a gotcha, I'm genuinely curious.

sanluca · 24/09/2026 16:31

Lexibletheflexible · 24/09/2026 15:07

If this wasn't an environment where these views were thought to be welcome, OP wouldn't have posted it.

@Catcentral are.you.surprised that more members arent agreeing with you on this given the usual tone and content of the posts?

You are mistaking 'views are welcome' with 'you can post views but you will be debated on them'. Posts like these are interesting, as they show how people come at it at differen angles. It is interesting and actually very nuanced, if you bother to read the answers and think about it.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 16:29

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 16:21

People don't seem able to see what's happening on this forum.

I didn't know or care who the OP was, I read the article pointed to and he seemed like a really good fit for that particular role in that particular city. I actually thought the OP was a trans phone against the appointment.

Some of the later reactions were either outright trans phobic or can very easily be read as transphobic.

The trans community appear to be feeding these threads into MN, and sitting back and waiting for the plumbs to drop from the tree that can later be used to argue how transphobic gender critical women are and how gender critical women want them erased from society and how justifiably threatened they feel by gender critical women.

This forum is being played, and many of the GC women on it aren't helping their own side with their comments.

Edited

Please be specific.

Say explicitly what you think should not be said even if true in case it gives angry men excuses to be angry and we can talk aboit that.

Handwaving vaguely at "Some People" saying "some things" isn't helping.

Swipe left for the next trending thread