Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Transgender person elected as Deputy Mayor in Sydney

169 replies

Catcentral · 24/09/2026 04:53

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1HxkfR1VCB/

OP posts:
BackToLurk · 25/09/2026 09:36

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/09/2026 09:27

Hey that's some projection there!

As the person who posed the question, I was thinking simply hypothetically, if a Genderist did know, what would they do? I think anyone with enough nouse to be interviewing others can do that thought experiment if they want to. And really in their own mind they already know the answer whether they reply or not.

Although you do of course highlight a significant point here. A woman wearing, oh let's say a subtle gender critical feminist earring or even a clear political t-shirt would be seen as needlessly politically provocative because she has the choice not to.

A man turning up as "a woman", which many women find just as deeply offensive and belittling as he would find her earrings, is not seen as politically provocative because the assumption is he does not have "a choice" amd therefore it would be nasty to object.

So contrary to your assumption, the vast majority of women who are gender critical feminists do not make any such statements at work unless pushed into it by clear Genderist favouritism or EA breaches like the recent court cases. We find each other by what we don't say.

In this way, as so often we see in society, women's real feelings about the situation are invisibled because it's not "nice" to let them be known, and society can pretend the man's preference is neutral and widely accepted.

The pairing of GC views with ‘accusatory and discriminatory remarks against trans people’ I s quite the tell.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/09/2026 09:27

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 05:03

Why would it come up in the majority of interviews?

What is more likely to occur is that someone GC commits some sort of wrongdoing against others at work by revealing their GC views through accusatory and discriminatory remarks against trans people. They will then be disciplined or let go due to their actions.

Hey that's some projection there!

As the person who posed the question, I was thinking simply hypothetically, if a Genderist did know, what would they do? I think anyone with enough nouse to be interviewing others can do that thought experiment if they want to. And really in their own mind they already know the answer whether they reply or not.

Although you do of course highlight a significant point here. A woman wearing, oh let's say a subtle gender critical feminist earring or even a clear political t-shirt would be seen as needlessly politically provocative because she has the choice not to.

A man turning up as "a woman", which many women find just as deeply offensive and belittling as he would find her earrings, is not seen as politically provocative because the assumption is he does not have "a choice" amd therefore it would be nasty to object.

So contrary to your assumption, the vast majority of women who are gender critical feminists do not make any such statements at work unless pushed into it by clear Genderist favouritism or EA breaches like the recent court cases. We find each other by what we don't say.

In this way, as so often we see in society, women's real feelings about the situation are invisibled because it's not "nice" to let them be known, and society can pretend the man's preference is neutral and widely accepted.

NotBadConsidering · 25/09/2026 09:21

Manyanamanyana · 24/09/2026 23:57

It might be helpful to provide some Australian context.
The Australian Sex Discrimination Act was amended in 2013 to remove the definition of "man" and "woman" as a biological distinction, and "gender identity" was included in such a way that anyone with female as their gender identity can now be considered, in law, to be female. The impact of this, as it is currently being interpreted by the High, and the Supreme court, is that biological women are no different to men who claim a female gender identity. In short, we have no legal grounds for sex-segregated spaces, and any that remain are open to a legal challenge that will be won. Some people celebrate this as progress, but there are many of us who understand that this has a detrimental impact on wmen and on girls.
City Councils in Australia are responsible for a broad range of local services and facilities, including parks and their public toilets, public swimming pools, libraries, public building hire, and local by-laws such as protest permits and such like. The Deputy Mayor is the 2IC of the elected council. The Mayor and the Deputy Mayor are typically, and in this case NSW is typical, voted in by the council, rather than directly by the public.
In a city the size of Sydney, this gives the Mayor and the Deputy Mayor considerable influence over services and facilities relied on by many women and girls in their day to day lives. Public swimming pool and public toilet facilities, local libraries where mums and babies and toddlers go for weekly story group time etc. Councils also provide grants for local community groups, sports clubs etc. Womens groups must apply to council for the Australian version of the "let women speak" gatherings and such.
It was in this context that my post questioned, well tbh, assumed that considerations of the needs of women and girls to have legal sex-based boundaries in place are under further threat when the Deputy Mayor, a person with considerable power and influence, shares the ideology that men can be women, and therefore should have access to spaces previously for women only.
Watching the legal environment in Australia deteriorate for women in this way has made me angry and outspoken, and I can see by some of the commentary on here that angry and outspoken women with sex-realist views must tone-police themselves, lest thay come across as angry and outspoken, and give those who are stripping away our rights in the face of a largely silent electorate, ammunition to say, well, they are angry.
When a male person claims a female identity, I do make some assumptions. I will assume that they wish to support the trans community in their desire to access female spaces. With no laws to otherwise protect those spaces in Australia, I see this as another step backwards for womens rights.

With no laws to otherwise protect those spaces in Australia, I see this as another step backwards for womens rights.

This is exactly right. Public toilets, changing rooms, etc are under the remit of local councils. Which is more likely: that this man will help protect women’s spaces, or embed policies into local council that allows males into women’s spaces?

BunnyBunbunbun · 25/09/2026 09:14

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 05:03

Why would it come up in the majority of interviews?

What is more likely to occur is that someone GC commits some sort of wrongdoing against others at work by revealing their GC views through accusatory and discriminatory remarks against trans people. They will then be disciplined or let go due to their actions.

This bloke parades the fact that he identifies as "trans" and is obviously a cross-dressing man.

What's more likely to occur is that it's quite easy to tell when a bloke is trying to pass as a woman.

roseyposey · 25/09/2026 06:52

Smokeywater · 25/09/2026 06:40

Looks like she is the first 'female' person to win - a quick look at the previous mayors shows the rest going back to 1842 are men - wonderful

Another first for women! (🧐)

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 06:51

BackToLurk · 25/09/2026 06:50

Ah, so you’re a bigot. Good to know.

Ok

BackToLurk · 25/09/2026 06:50

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 06:47

It doesn't have to, either.

Ah, so you’re a bigot. Good to know.

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 06:47

BackToLurk · 25/09/2026 06:43

Why would it come up that someone is trans?

It doesn't have to, either.

BackToLurk · 25/09/2026 06:43

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 05:03

Why would it come up in the majority of interviews?

What is more likely to occur is that someone GC commits some sort of wrongdoing against others at work by revealing their GC views through accusatory and discriminatory remarks against trans people. They will then be disciplined or let go due to their actions.

Why would it come up that someone is trans?

Smokeywater · 25/09/2026 06:40

Looks like she is the first 'female' person to win - a quick look at the previous mayors shows the rest going back to 1842 are men - wonderful

PeachyDaisy · 25/09/2026 06:12

I don't think assumptions are always bad but I think we just have to be careful if it means excluding a whole group. For example I would be pretty sad if an employer decided not to hire me because I'm a woman of childbearing age and am statistically likely to have children/go on maternity leave (I'm infertile but they wouldn't know that). Sometimes assumptions can be wrong.

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 05:52

Manyanamanyana · 25/09/2026 05:48

It doesn't sound like it @FlirtsWithRhinos - womens thought crimes are very very serious because they hurt men's feelings.

I think it's probably more likely one will offend someone who is female but trans or NB and not for a "thought crime" because people cannot read thoughts. It will be due to something they said or did in the workplace.

Manyanamanyana · 25/09/2026 05:48

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 05:03

Why would it come up in the majority of interviews?

What is more likely to occur is that someone GC commits some sort of wrongdoing against others at work by revealing their GC views through accusatory and discriminatory remarks against trans people. They will then be disciplined or let go due to their actions.

It doesn't sound like it @FlirtsWithRhinos - womens thought crimes are very very serious because they hurt men's feelings.

Rollingpinofdoom · 25/09/2026 05:44

BunnyBunbunbun · 24/09/2026 20:28

Isn't you calling someone who identifies as a woman "he" discrimination and phobia?

No. It’s using the correct pronouns for that persons sex. To use she/her would be to insinuate that person is a woman. That person is male. Not a woman. If he wants to wear dresses etc, good on him. He can have a blast. As long as he uses male spaces whilst doing so theres no problem is there.

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 05:03

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 17:52

Of course the really interesting question is whether the Genderists on this thread would hire a gender critical Feminist if she were the best qualified candidate, and if not, why not.

Why would it come up in the majority of interviews?

What is more likely to occur is that someone GC commits some sort of wrongdoing against others at work by revealing their GC views through accusatory and discriminatory remarks against trans people. They will then be disciplined or let go due to their actions.

Manyanamanyana · 24/09/2026 23:57

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:19

I was getting there in understanding that with previous threads but this one has been really shocking. There's outright transphobia on this thread.

It might be helpful to provide some Australian context.
The Australian Sex Discrimination Act was amended in 2013 to remove the definition of "man" and "woman" as a biological distinction, and "gender identity" was included in such a way that anyone with female as their gender identity can now be considered, in law, to be female. The impact of this, as it is currently being interpreted by the High, and the Supreme court, is that biological women are no different to men who claim a female gender identity. In short, we have no legal grounds for sex-segregated spaces, and any that remain are open to a legal challenge that will be won. Some people celebrate this as progress, but there are many of us who understand that this has a detrimental impact on wmen and on girls.
City Councils in Australia are responsible for a broad range of local services and facilities, including parks and their public toilets, public swimming pools, libraries, public building hire, and local by-laws such as protest permits and such like. The Deputy Mayor is the 2IC of the elected council. The Mayor and the Deputy Mayor are typically, and in this case NSW is typical, voted in by the council, rather than directly by the public.
In a city the size of Sydney, this gives the Mayor and the Deputy Mayor considerable influence over services and facilities relied on by many women and girls in their day to day lives. Public swimming pool and public toilet facilities, local libraries where mums and babies and toddlers go for weekly story group time etc. Councils also provide grants for local community groups, sports clubs etc. Womens groups must apply to council for the Australian version of the "let women speak" gatherings and such.
It was in this context that my post questioned, well tbh, assumed that considerations of the needs of women and girls to have legal sex-based boundaries in place are under further threat when the Deputy Mayor, a person with considerable power and influence, shares the ideology that men can be women, and therefore should have access to spaces previously for women only.
Watching the legal environment in Australia deteriorate for women in this way has made me angry and outspoken, and I can see by some of the commentary on here that angry and outspoken women with sex-realist views must tone-police themselves, lest thay come across as angry and outspoken, and give those who are stripping away our rights in the face of a largely silent electorate, ammunition to say, well, they are angry.
When a male person claims a female identity, I do make some assumptions. I will assume that they wish to support the trans community in their desire to access female spaces. With no laws to otherwise protect those spaces in Australia, I see this as another step backwards for womens rights.

Wishesandhorses · 24/09/2026 20:40

BunnyBunbunbun · 24/09/2026 20:35

As a lesbian, I'd always be very wary of a trans-identified male who says - as this Olly does - that he wants to help promote LGBQTIA+ issues, because I know that he believes that biological men can be "lesbians" and it's those types of "lesbians" that he wants to help, while us lesbians who are exclusively attracted to our own sex are the people he's against.

Yes. The acronymn sounds lovely, but it is actually anti- homosexuality.

Which is not so lovely at all.

BunnyBunbunbun · 24/09/2026 20:38

It should be noted that while Olly won an election to be a Sydney councillor, it's his fellow councillors on Sydney Council who appointed him to be deputy lord mayor, not the citizens.

BunnyBunbunbun · 24/09/2026 20:35

As a lesbian, I'd always be very wary of a trans-identified male who says - as this Olly does - that he wants to help promote LGBQTIA+ issues, because I know that he believes that biological men can be "lesbians" and it's those types of "lesbians" that he wants to help, while us lesbians who are exclusively attracted to our own sex are the people he's against.

BunnyBunbunbun · 24/09/2026 20:28

sanluca · 24/09/2026 05:55

Is it the person being transgender that makes you think he is unsuited to office? Because that is discrimination. There are nice transgender people out there too, you know?

What are his policies? Is he going to actively work against women? If that is the case yes, he would be the wrong person for the job. Otherwise, give him a chance. It is not like being deputy mayor is a role reserved for women.

Isn't you calling someone who identifies as a woman "he" discrimination and phobia?

Ingenieur · 24/09/2026 20:17

Franxi · 24/09/2026 20:05

Ok, sorry, I was talking about discrimination in the widely accepted meaning of the unfair or prejudicial treatment of a person or group based on specific personal characteristics. What you are defining as discrimination to me means noticing differences. I haven’t heard of this definition of discrimination. I don’t think anyone has a problem with noticing differences.

@Franxi

You haven't heard of the originaln definition of the word that forms the basis for your definition of it?

Just because some discrimination is unlawful, doesn't mean all discrimination is. Nor should it be the case that some currently-unlawful discrimination continues to be.

Franxi · 24/09/2026 20:05

Ingenieur · 24/09/2026 15:41

@Franxi

Discrimination isn’t decision making.

Discrimination is the ability to make distinctions or discern differences. It is essential to decisionmaking.

Edited

Ok, sorry, I was talking about discrimination in the widely accepted meaning of the unfair or prejudicial treatment of a person or group based on specific personal characteristics. What you are defining as discrimination to me means noticing differences. I haven’t heard of this definition of discrimination. I don’t think anyone has a problem with noticing differences.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/09/2026 18:18

Wishesandhorses · 24/09/2026 18:06

Mmn.

I remember when Madigan was made 'women's officer', and at that point I was still dewy eyed and trusting, and was happy to embrace this and see if he turned out to be a good women's officer.

Sadly pattern recognition is a thing. At this point I can't think of a man with a gender identity who has taken a women's post or role, or any political seat, without their sole focus and representation being for themselves as a trans person focused very much on trans alone as an issue to the exclusion of all else, and on their interests and the interests of other men with gender identities. And to attempt to use their responsibility and power to do harm to women, children and gay rights in the name of their activism. I don't agree with activists for any subject in positions of responsibility for this reason, when the seat merely becomes something to use in their activism rather than for its public function, but when the job requires impartiality and the capacity for equal treatment and consideration regardless of personal feelings, transactivism continually demonstrates an utter incapacity for this.

He may be the first to do this differently. But the pattern is now very, very, very established.

To keep trying to ignore that elephant in the room, plus that it's a little odd to overlook a person in a political role having an obvious massive issue with reality and living an entire lifestyle based on selective personal reality to avoid it - and expect them to be able to cope and be rational about all other parts of reality - is a bit 'apart from that Mrs Lincoln, how did you enjoy the play?'. Is it really safe or sensible to have someone in that position taking a role like this?

And yes. I agree that it is fundamentally sexist for a man to identify as a woman.

Edited

Very well said.

Wishesandhorses · 24/09/2026 18:06

Mmn.

I remember when Madigan was made 'women's officer', and at that point I was still dewy eyed and trusting, and was happy to embrace this and see if he turned out to be a good women's officer.

Sadly pattern recognition is a thing. At this point I can't think of a man with a gender identity who has taken a women's post or role, or any political seat, without their sole focus and representation being for themselves as a trans person focused very much on trans alone as an issue to the exclusion of all else, and on their interests and the interests of other men with gender identities. And to attempt to use their responsibility and power to do harm to women, children and gay rights in the name of their activism. I don't agree with activists for any subject in positions of responsibility for this reason, when the seat merely becomes something to use in their activism rather than for its public function, but when the job requires impartiality and the capacity for equal treatment and consideration regardless of personal feelings, transactivism continually demonstrates an utter incapacity for this.

He may be the first to do this differently. But the pattern is now very, very, very established.

To keep trying to ignore that elephant in the room, plus that it's a little odd to overlook a person in a political role having an obvious massive issue with reality and living an entire lifestyle based on selective personal reality to avoid it - and expect them to be able to cope and be rational about all other parts of reality - is a bit 'apart from that Mrs Lincoln, how did you enjoy the play?'. Is it really safe or sensible to have someone in that position taking a role like this?

And yes. I agree that it is fundamentally sexist for a man to identify as a woman.

Rollingpinofdoom · 24/09/2026 18:00

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 17:19

I was getting there in understanding that with previous threads but this one has been really shocking. There's outright transphobia on this thread.

Oooh you’d better report it then hadn’t you!