Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Transgender person elected as Deputy Mayor in Sydney

169 replies

Catcentral · 24/09/2026 04:53

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1HxkfR1VCB/

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FanOfGailDines · 27/09/2026 14:36

FanOfGailDines · 27/09/2026 13:17

Have a look at the link below: advice from Australian clothing company about trans rights in public spaces. In that context and with Australian law as it is I think it is a legitimate concern to worry about a man identifying as a woman being in a position to make decisions that are going to have a significant impact on women's and children's safety in public spaces in Sydney. It is a very narrow perspective that I think it is fair to presume the Deputy Mayor would be sympathetic with the advice from this company. This way of thinking about trans rights will I think, in the long run, also do a great disservice to trans identified people.
https://www.transformtranswear.com.au/blogs/articles-resources/your-rights-as-a-trans-woman-in-change-rooms-and-pools-australia?srsltid=AU7gw4VHjKY0ahatmOUr4fXXwzCrf2dvPsSPCfgLrkTQ84HlAldLHHD0

Correction of a clunky and nonsensical sentence of mine. Should read: I think it is fair to presume the Deputy Mayor would be sympathetic with the advice from this company. The advice displays a narrow perspective, namely, Trans Rights trump all other rights.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/09/2026 14:27

DrBlackbird · 27/09/2026 13:10

Yes, I can see that it would be completely different for our small organisation vs a global enterprise where the focus is on the work and just by sheer size, it is much more difficult if not impossible to influence a global firm’s policies.

Of course, there are also many trans people for whom identifying as or presenting as the opposite sex doesn’t necessarily translate into proselytising activist. However, I am now more cautious or at least more thoughtful about hiring. Btw, this applies beyond the gender debate.

Oh definitely.

The worst I've seen it get was actually around the Brexit vote. I sometimes wonder if the people who are very political at work started work after that time so haven't developed the skills to work well with people you don't see eye to eye with on everything.

The colleague I have most had to bite my tongue around politically was the one running for UKIP. TBF that was mainly because of his personality though 😂Any sniff of disagreement and he would be off on one and not let go. I'm sure other people could have been just as UKIPpy without being as difficult to work with.

FanOfGailDines · 27/09/2026 13:17

Have a look at the link below: advice from Australian clothing company about trans rights in public spaces. In that context and with Australian law as it is I think it is a legitimate concern to worry about a man identifying as a woman being in a position to make decisions that are going to have a significant impact on women's and children's safety in public spaces in Sydney. It is a very narrow perspective that I think it is fair to presume the Deputy Mayor would be sympathetic with the advice from this company. This way of thinking about trans rights will I think, in the long run, also do a great disservice to trans identified people.
https://www.transformtranswear.com.au/blogs/articles-resources/your-rights-as-a-trans-woman-in-change-rooms-and-pools-australia?srsltid=AU7gw4VHjKY0ahatmOUr4fXXwzCrf2dvPsSPCfgLrkTQ84HlAldLHHD0

Your Rights as a Trans Woman or Trans Femme in Change Rooms and Pools (Australia)

A plain-language guide to your rights as a trans woman or trans feminine person using change rooms and swimming pools in Australia, including what the law says and what to do if you face discrimination

https://www.transformtranswear.com.au/blogs/articles-resources/your-rights-as-a-trans-woman-in-change-rooms-and-pools-australia?srsltid=AU7gw4VHjKY0ahatmOUr4fXXwzCrf2dvPsSPCfgLrkTQ84HlAldLHHD0

DrBlackbird · 27/09/2026 13:10

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/09/2026 12:38

I take your point, but I work in a very global industry so there's always been potential for sensitivities between cultures. Generally however we all want to stay in our jobs and work well with colleagues so are all pretty adept at treading carefully around each other and focusing on getting the job done together.

Yes, I can see that it would be completely different for our small organisation vs a global enterprise where the focus is on the work and just by sheer size, it is much more difficult if not impossible to influence a global firm’s policies.

Of course, there are also many trans people for whom identifying as or presenting as the opposite sex doesn’t necessarily translate into proselytising activist. However, I am now more cautious or at least more thoughtful about hiring. Btw, this applies beyond the gender debate.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/09/2026 12:38

DrBlackbird · 27/09/2026 12:07

Yes, we all suffer from patriarchy (except perhaps the 1% making their billions), but nevertheless I would be cautious in deciding whether to hire someone I felt might hold strident views. On any issue.

I think that would include people who were zealous about politics, left or right, or about religion etc but that would also include potential candidates zealous about gender ideology.

This is based on past experience when I was involved with a small community based organisation and responsible for hiring. For example, I did hire someone who was a proponent of GI, completely inexperienced in the industry but came across well in the interview.

Then once hired, this person set about trying to force changes in the organisation including making the toilets gender neutral, wanting changes to the organisational communications, policy wording etc to also reflect GI views. Changes that were either illegal or would’ve cost a lot of time and money all to suit their particular worldview. They were breathtakingly self centred and seemingly incapable of understanding how the changes they tried to insist on could negatively impact others.

It was tiresome and annoying to have numerous conversations with someone who had not invested any time, knowledge, money or resources into the organisation and yet was detracting from the crucial matter of financial survival. So, yes, I would be cautious in terms of future hires. Once burnt…

I take your point, but I work in a very global industry so there's always been potential for sensitivities between cultures. Generally however we all want to stay in our jobs and work well with colleagues so are all pretty adept at treading carefully around each other and focusing on getting the job done together.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/09/2026 12:30

FinchiePink · 27/09/2026 11:28

Point of order: other posters can't just have posts deleted.

Only the mods can make the decision to delete, and they only do that when a post breaks TGs. It's not about the personal opinions of monitors, it's about MNHQs house rules.

That's only half the story.

MN modding is reactive. Mods only look at posts that are reported, and while the MN guidelines set the rules, judgement as to what exactly crosses the line is often subjective.

Gender Critical Feminists on FWR tend to leave nasty Genderist posts to speak for themselves. We think the transparency is valuable.

Genderists tend to report anything they think they can make a case for. I've certainly been deleted for saying things far far far less offensive than have neen said to or about me.

The Genderist tactic is to quash as much as they can then point to deleted posts which no one can now judge for themselves as "proof" of how awful this board is.

I now screenshot a lot of posts just in case.

FinchiePink · 27/09/2026 12:23

GreyskySexRealistsky · 27/09/2026 11:44

Yes, I know.

You've missed the point.

I believe your point was that posts that break TGs should be left to stand and debated rather than deleted.

That's not how MNHQ run their site.

DrBlackbird · 27/09/2026 12:22

@AstonCanKissMyArse summed it up as they'll inevitably expect me to participate in those beliefs / inflict them upon me to a degree and correct or not, I would assume the likelihood of the Deputy Mayor to campaign and take action on an issue that is so clearly central to their identity.

DrBlackbird · 27/09/2026 12:07

FlirtsWithRhinos · 24/09/2026 17:07

Great question! I have had exactly that situation. He was the best candidate for the job, I spoke in his favour and we hired him.

I still however consider his beliefs sexist, and should he turn round tomorrow and run for public office, I wouldn't vote for him because there's too much scope in public office for sexist beliefs to be concretised into sexist policies.

FWIW I consider many trans people to be much the victims of Patriarchy as they are its enforcers. But that's very usual for marginalised people, they take on the values of the system that oppresses them. Trans and Female both.

Edited

Yes, we all suffer from patriarchy (except perhaps the 1% making their billions), but nevertheless I would be cautious in deciding whether to hire someone I felt might hold strident views. On any issue.

I think that would include people who were zealous about politics, left or right, or about religion etc but that would also include potential candidates zealous about gender ideology.

This is based on past experience when I was involved with a small community based organisation and responsible for hiring. For example, I did hire someone who was a proponent of GI, completely inexperienced in the industry but came across well in the interview.

Then once hired, this person set about trying to force changes in the organisation including making the toilets gender neutral, wanting changes to the organisational communications, policy wording etc to also reflect GI views. Changes that were either illegal or would’ve cost a lot of time and money all to suit their particular worldview. They were breathtakingly self centred and seemingly incapable of understanding how the changes they tried to insist on could negatively impact others.

It was tiresome and annoying to have numerous conversations with someone who had not invested any time, knowledge, money or resources into the organisation and yet was detracting from the crucial matter of financial survival. So, yes, I would be cautious in terms of future hires. Once burnt…

NotBadConsidering · 27/09/2026 11:51

and they only do that when a post breaks TGs

🤣 sure.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 27/09/2026 11:44

FinchiePink · 27/09/2026 11:28

Point of order: other posters can't just have posts deleted.

Only the mods can make the decision to delete, and they only do that when a post breaks TGs. It's not about the personal opinions of monitors, it's about MNHQs house rules.

Yes, I know.

You've missed the point.

FinchiePink · 27/09/2026 11:28

GreyskySexRealistsky · 27/09/2026 10:40

If one has no arguments then it's so much easier to run and tell teacher hit the report button and delete delete delete.

To the monitors on here: why not counter what you don't like with robust evidence and fact?

Point of order: other posters can't just have posts deleted.

Only the mods can make the decision to delete, and they only do that when a post breaks TGs. It's not about the personal opinions of monitors, it's about MNHQs house rules.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 27/09/2026 10:40

ElenOfTheWays · 27/09/2026 00:28

I see there's a transmaiden/TRA on the MN mod team again.

quite a few arbitrary deletions today I've noticed - of posts that when I read them were not violations of the guidelines at all. Unless it's just a lazy newbie who gets a report and just hits delete without reading the actual post.
I can't be arsed to ask why my post went - remember when you used to get an email explaining?
I expect it was that I upset TPA by telling the truth about trans privilege.
I daresay it's "not in the spirit" to upset TRA ploppers by disagreeing with their sexist bullshit.
Or maybe it's because I used the popular trans trope "girl dick" while being female.

Who knows. I didn't break any guidelines. (I wasn't insulting to TPA.) But neither did the other posters I saw deleted today.

Getting sick of this bullshit now.

If one has no arguments then it's so much easier to run and tell teacher hit the report button and delete delete delete.

To the monitors on here: why not counter what you don't like with robust evidence and fact?

Helleofabore · 27/09/2026 09:58

Smokeywater · 25/09/2026 06:40

Looks like she is the first 'female' person to win - a quick look at the previous mayors shows the rest going back to 1842 are men - wonderful

Clover Moore is a female Lord Mayor of Sydney and has been in the role for decades.

ElenOfTheWays · 27/09/2026 00:28

I see there's a transmaiden/TRA on the MN mod team again.

quite a few arbitrary deletions today I've noticed - of posts that when I read them were not violations of the guidelines at all. Unless it's just a lazy newbie who gets a report and just hits delete without reading the actual post.
I can't be arsed to ask why my post went - remember when you used to get an email explaining?
I expect it was that I upset TPA by telling the truth about trans privilege.
I daresay it's "not in the spirit" to upset TRA ploppers by disagreeing with their sexist bullshit.
Or maybe it's because I used the popular trans trope "girl dick" while being female.

Who knows. I didn't break any guidelines. (I wasn't insulting to TPA.) But neither did the other posters I saw deleted today.

Getting sick of this bullshit now.

Wishesandhorses · 26/09/2026 14:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ElenOfTheWays · 26/09/2026 14:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FanOfGailDines · 25/09/2026 20:13

Smokeywater · 25/09/2026 06:40

Looks like she is the first 'female' person to win - a quick look at the previous mayors shows the rest going back to 1842 are men - wonderful

I think there have been female deputy mayors in Sydney in the past.

fatsausages · 25/09/2026 17:08

If a man can't accept himself, how does he expect others to accept him whilst pretending to be a she.
The world has gone mad, this nonsense needs to stop.
A biological man can never be a woman, a 5 year old knows that, yet many grown adults believe they can.

Stop the world I wanna get off.

BunnyBunbunbun · 25/09/2026 14:27

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 14:00

What would that have to do with your working day?

Why would me noticing that someone identifies as trans mean I'd lose my job, to refer to your original comment?

Having a co-worker who identifies as trans wouldn't particularly affect my working day. Being forced to lie and pretend he/she is the opposite sex might, however, which is an issue in Australia but thankfully not so much in the UK.

We're talking about someone who is a city councillor, however, not regular jobs.

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 14:00

BunnyBunbunbun · 25/09/2026 09:14

This bloke parades the fact that he identifies as "trans" and is obviously a cross-dressing man.

What's more likely to occur is that it's quite easy to tell when a bloke is trying to pass as a woman.

What would that have to do with your working day?

NotBadConsidering · 25/09/2026 12:32

PeachyDaisy · 25/09/2026 11:46

Unfortunately I do still believe that the only hope we have left is with legislative change at the federal level (and I say this as sadly a woman who is stuck living in australia). Taking a similar case to the high court (one like giggle v tickle) is probably not going to be successful, even if we had a gender critical council willing to take it that far.

Edited

I agree. But apart from a One Nation majority government, the only hope of legislative change is a case so egregiously offensive in the public eye once again that politicians just won’t be able to ignore it.

PeachyDaisy · 25/09/2026 11:46

Unfortunately I do still believe that the only hope we have left is with legislative change at the federal level (and I say this as sadly a woman who is stuck living in australia). Taking a similar case to the high court (one like giggle v tickle) is probably not going to be successful, even if we had a gender critical council willing to take it that far.

NotBadConsidering · 25/09/2026 11:30

PeachyDaisy · 25/09/2026 09:39

I'm not sure that a deputy mayor can make laws around who can enter single sex spaces. The law that allowed this was introduced in 2013 by the federal government. It is already in affect. Worrying that he is going to embed this policy is silly when it is already embedded in law throughout the country.

The only way to fix it is to change the law through parliament. Hiring a gender critical mayor is not going to fix it as they legally can't stop transwomen from going into women's spaces.

Edited

No, he can’t make a law. But he can impact how councils respond to complaints. It’s not silly. The only time the law has ever been challenged is with Tickle vs Giggle. No one even knew the law is how it’s written until the final outcome of this case a month ago. And would the same be applied to a better argued case involving a council swimming pool changing room, for example?

A “gender critical” council could decide its facilities are going to remain single sex and it would require the next Tickle to challenge that in court, forcing the reality of the SDA into the public eye once again.

But if a woman’s boundaries are transgressed in this man’s council, would her complaint even be heard?

His appointment just reduces the number of people on the side of women in positions of influence.

PeachyDaisy · 25/09/2026 09:39

NotBadConsidering · 25/09/2026 09:21

With no laws to otherwise protect those spaces in Australia, I see this as another step backwards for womens rights.

This is exactly right. Public toilets, changing rooms, etc are under the remit of local councils. Which is more likely: that this man will help protect women’s spaces, or embed policies into local council that allows males into women’s spaces?

I'm not sure that a deputy mayor can make laws around who can enter single sex spaces. The law that allowed this was introduced in 2013 by the federal government. It is already in affect. Worrying that he is going to embed this policy is silly when it is already embedded in law throughout the country.

The only way to fix it is to change the law through parliament. Hiring a gender critical mayor is not going to fix it as they legally can't stop transwomen from going into women's spaces.

Swipe left for the next trending thread