Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

My work insisting I refer to a 9 year old as they/them

870 replies

TheMadGardener · 11/09/2026 00:55

I work in a British primary school. Just started new term. Long standing pupil, a girl, is starting Year 5 now so she is 9 years old. No issues until now although parents are quite "alternative/new age."

Headteacher has informed staff that according to the child and her parents this girl has decided to be non-binary. Staff are now to refer to her as they/them and she is now using a gender-neutral shortened version of her name (think Alex instead of Alexandra or Jo instead of Joanna).

I am extremely uncomfortable with this and will definitely not be using they/them - I will be referring to the child by her chosen abbreviation to avoid using pronouns (at least it's a shortening of her real name rather than a made-up name).

Serious question: I thought new legislation discouraged schools from getting on board with this sort of thing? Or is it only they can't let children do it without parents knowing?

I'm finding it very hard to keep my mouth shut on my actual opinions in the presence of headteacher. (Colleagues I've spoken to on the quiet all think it is bullshit too)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:34

hastenotwaste · 11/09/2026 09:31

Again, it is different to a nickname. If anything it it the child (or rather the parents) who are forcing their beliefs onto the OP. It is the OP who is being asked to change how they naturally speak, not the child!

They aren't forcing their beliefs on to the OP. They are telling the OP something they are asking them to respect. It's no different to a child of a particular religion. A teacher doesn't say to all the Christian children there's no scientific or legal basis for God existing therefore your beliefs are rubbish. They just accept that is their belief even if it's not their own. This isn't difficult to grasp.

TheKeatingFive · 11/09/2026 09:34

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:31

And you could be absolutely right, but this child has asked for this very minor request. It's not for us to decide whether it's true or not. Sometimes you just have to let things play out.

It’s absolutely not a ‘minor request’ if it has the potential to unleash all of that.

Its very important to think through the second level, third level consequences of our actions.

LongDarkTeatime · 11/09/2026 09:33

I am extremely uncomfortable with having to identify women by their marital status eg Mrs and Miss. Their marital status is irrelevant to me and I’d prefer to call them Ms. But as I hope for respect in my role (NHS) I obviously have to show respect and use the person’s preferred prefix.
If you choose not to respect their choice, don’t expect respect for yours.

DizzyWhoreEighteenHundredAndFour · 11/09/2026 09:32

AgnesMcDoo · 11/09/2026 09:20

I’m gender critical but I also have no objections to people identifying with whatever they want.

Me too.

I just don't think that anyone should be coerced into saying they believe in something they don't, or using language they are not comfortable with, or tacitly colluding in an ideology they believe it be harmful by being made to use 'preferred pronouns'.

How anyone else identifies is up to them. What I believe is up to me.

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:31

TheKeatingFive · 11/09/2026 09:26

In that case you open a can of worms for everyone else.

Is sex a feeling, rather than a physical reality?

What does it mean to feel like a boy or a girl or neither? How do I know what ‘feels’ like a girl?

If I like things that are more associated with boys, does that mean I’m not a girl? Them were right back to enforcing gender stereotypes.

The whole thing is crazy and deeply regressive

And you could be absolutely right, but this child has asked for this very minor request. It's not for us to decide whether it's true or not. Sometimes you just have to let things play out.

hastenotwaste · 11/09/2026 09:31

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:27

But they're not acting as though they've forgotten. They would be using the pronouns the child is asking for. No different to a nickname.
Kids don't care about gender politics.
There's no reason for the OP to force their beliefs on a child. Part of being a teacher is respecting each child's background.

Nine isn't that young. If it's all rubbish then so what?! Nobody is talking about surgery.
Adults should be capable of being flexible and a teacher should be respectful of a child's request.

Again, it is different to a nickname. If anything it it the child (or rather the parents) who are forcing their beliefs onto the OP. It is the OP who is being asked to change how they naturally speak, not the child!

TheKeatingFive · 11/09/2026 09:31

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:29

I assume if you're on here that you can read. Perhaps you could look into it if it's an area you're curious about. I don't think I could completely deny something exists unless I actually looked into it. If you aren't willing to accept it then at least see if there's any evidence or if your opinion is just bigotry.

I’m very curious about and I’ve read lots.

It doesn’t stand up to any scrutiny.

As I said earlier, if it’s referencing sex, no one is non binary.

If it’s referencing gender, everyone is non binary.

So what does this child actually mean do you think?

Myalternate · 11/09/2026 09:31

Are the other children ‘instructed’ to pretend ‘Alex’ is neither a boy nor a girl?

Mistachio · 11/09/2026 09:31

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:16

How can you say it's a delusion?
What proof do you have?
Throughout history there have been countless examples of people who are non-binary

Where? I can’t wait to hear about all these people who claimed to be both sexes at once/no sex at all.

Gengha · 11/09/2026 09:31

BackToLurk · 11/09/2026 09:26

Or everyone is.

Well true

MaggieMop · 11/09/2026 09:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Gengha · 11/09/2026 09:30

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:05

Why? This is so unnecessarily cruel. It would be like asking your kids to deliberately use the wrong name. Imagine if a parent in their class told their child to call your child a random name and your kid really didn't like it. Would you be happy with that?

That analogy doesn’t work. A person’s name is their name. Pronouns are ordinary sex-based words in the English language, not individual names allocated to particular people.

My children have been told that they are not required to state something they do not believe to be true in order to validate somebody else’s identity. To force them to do so is cruel to them. I don’t care about the delusional child and alleged “kindness” to them.

Disagreement is not cruelty, and children should not be taught that it is.

Wowthatwasabigstep · 11/09/2026 09:30

That poor child, to have the misfortune of such addled parents. They or them refers to a group of two or more and so unless the child is a conjoined twin I would use the name he or she is known by.

TheKeatingFive · 11/09/2026 09:29

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:27

But they're not acting as though they've forgotten. They would be using the pronouns the child is asking for. No different to a nickname.
Kids don't care about gender politics.
There's no reason for the OP to force their beliefs on a child. Part of being a teacher is respecting each child's background.

Nine isn't that young. If it's all rubbish then so what?! Nobody is talking about surgery.
Adults should be capable of being flexible and a teacher should be respectful of a child's request.

Of course pronouns are different to a nick name.

Pronouns are part of shared language conventions which help us all make sense of the world.

What are we suggesting to the other children by avoiding sex based pronouns? That this child is somehow not the sex they are?

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:29

TheKeatingFive · 11/09/2026 09:27

If it ‘runs deeper’ what is it exactly?

I assume if you're on here that you can read. Perhaps you could look into it if it's an area you're curious about. I don't think I could completely deny something exists unless I actually looked into it. If you aren't willing to accept it then at least see if there's any evidence or if your opinion is just bigotry.

akkakk · 11/09/2026 09:28

Either no one is non-binary if it is based on sex as sex is binary and immutable

or if based on gender then arguably everyone in the world is non-binary

either way it is meaningless

and pronouns are based on sex - the child was born a girl will still be a girl, will always be a girl - so her pronouns are she and her

not difficult to teach the truth!

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:27

thirdfiddle · 11/09/2026 09:23

I went to school with a boy who insisted on being called a colour. From Reception up to year 6 every single child and teacher called him by this colour. Nobody batted an eyelid. The kids certainly didn't care. As an adult it seems absolutely wild but we were not bothered as kids.

Child has nickname, shocker.
The shortening of the kid's name was never the problem.

The request to refer to the child as if you've forgotten what sex she is, and find a way all the adults agree on to explain this to classmates, and to make sure safeguarding rules are still complied with where these are sex based, and other kids' and teachers' boundaries are respected. That is the tricky bit.

But they're not acting as though they've forgotten. They would be using the pronouns the child is asking for. No different to a nickname.
Kids don't care about gender politics.
There's no reason for the OP to force their beliefs on a child. Part of being a teacher is respecting each child's background.

Nine isn't that young. If it's all rubbish then so what?! Nobody is talking about surgery.
Adults should be capable of being flexible and a teacher should be respectful of a child's request.

TheKeatingFive · 11/09/2026 09:27

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:23

Can they not teach them that anyway?
If it's all a conspiracy, and kids don't understand the spectrum of what is a girl, then surely teachers have done a crap job.
Teach them that, respect what's being asked. If the child then has a revelation that actually they just didn't feel girly, then great, if not, then at least you've educated them enough that they can make an informed decision.

My understanding is non-binary is more than just not feeling girly. I think it runs much deeper.

If it ‘runs deeper’ what is it exactly?

TheKeatingFive · 11/09/2026 09:26

Strzyga · 11/09/2026 09:22

Alex doesn't feel like a girl / boy at the moment - so they are they.

The bigger deal this is made also makes it harder for the child (or adult) to reverse their decisions.

"I'm non binary" - OK, did you want a cup of tea?
"I'm no longer non binary" - OK, did you want sugar in your tea?

"I'm non binary" - no you're not, that's stupid and against biology
"I'm no longer non binary" - told you it was stupid and against biology

In that case you open a can of worms for everyone else.

Is sex a feeling, rather than a physical reality?

What does it mean to feel like a boy or a girl or neither? How do I know what ‘feels’ like a girl?

If I like things that are more associated with boys, does that mean I’m not a girl? Them were right back to enforcing gender stereotypes.

The whole thing is crazy and deeply regressive

BackToLurk · 11/09/2026 09:26

Gengha · 11/09/2026 09:21

No one is non binary, it’s not a thing.

Or everyone is.

ErrolTheDragon · 11/09/2026 09:25

hastenotwaste · 11/09/2026 09:17

Maybe it is a phase, maybe it is because they don't feel girly and what is female is too narrow, who knows?
This is exactly the problem. You are also teaching the other girls that they are not actually girls if they don't feel girly. How about teaching children that they can be whoever they want to and they do not need to conform to stereotypes? This would be a much better message.

Quite. ‘Gender critical’ is precisely about wanting to ‘expand the bandwidth’ for both sexes, of breaking down the culturally enforced constraints of gender but without denying the inescapable reality of sex.
The child is a girl, she will grow up to be a woman. She absolutely doesn’t have to be ‘girly’.

Mistachio · 11/09/2026 09:25

FoxAndSquirrel · 11/09/2026 08:56

Does it really affect your life so much to just try?
My eldest is non-binary, a recent announcement and I don’t always say the right thing but I acknowledge and correct myself (or stand corrected!!)
They don’t feel feminine or like a she
They dont feel masculine or like a he
They are just being THEMselves

I don’t always “feel” feminine when I’m mucking out a stable or mending my wall.

I just feel like myself.

I still AM a woman though. No getting away from it.

You know full well whether you gave birth to a baby boy or a baby girl.

IsItSnowing · 11/09/2026 09:24

I would use her name and try to avoid pronouns completely. It will sound a bit strange I expect but at least if other children ask, 'why do you always say Alex', you can truthfully reply, Because it is Alex's name. On the other hand, they/them is a perfectly correct English usage for either sex so it's not a massive deal to use it. If children ask you can tell them exactly that, sometimes we use they/them when speaking about people/things. Some people like it. No need to provide some kind of ideological based reply.
I think binary is the new attention seeking phase unfortunately. There is always something with young people. What's unfortunate these days is that parents seem to be too involved in it. Let young people have their rebellion moments without parents making a political/ideological thing out of it and elevating it to something it's not. For most children they will grow out of it.
But in this case is it really Alex who wants the attention or Alex's parents. This for me is the core of the issue.

Justme56 · 11/09/2026 09:24

One of the biggest issues with the whole thing is that we see sex or at the very least what we perceive as the sex of the person. So what happens with this girl out of the school environment? A stranger refers to her as a girl - will she constantly be upset because she cannot control what others see and say. It’s just not that simple especially when we are talking about a nine year old.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 11/09/2026 09:24

GoldenSandy · 11/09/2026 09:16

How can you say it's a delusion?
What proof do you have?
Throughout history there have been countless examples of people who are non-binary

Every body has a sex (even people with DSDs - Disorders of Sexual Development).

Pretending your neither a man or a woman is fine for adults if that's what floats their boat - as long as they respect the sex based conventions of changing rooms etc. However children should never be deliberately misled about their sex. That's abusive and this child is only 9 - her body will grow and develop into a woman and it's critical that she's encouraged to be comfortable with that.
Plenty of time for her to make these choices when she's an adult.