Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

My work insisting I refer to a 9 year old as they/them

870 replies

TheMadGardener · 11/09/2026 00:55

I work in a British primary school. Just started new term. Long standing pupil, a girl, is starting Year 5 now so she is 9 years old. No issues until now although parents are quite "alternative/new age."

Headteacher has informed staff that according to the child and her parents this girl has decided to be non-binary. Staff are now to refer to her as they/them and she is now using a gender-neutral shortened version of her name (think Alex instead of Alexandra or Jo instead of Joanna).

I am extremely uncomfortable with this and will definitely not be using they/them - I will be referring to the child by her chosen abbreviation to avoid using pronouns (at least it's a shortening of her real name rather than a made-up name).

Serious question: I thought new legislation discouraged schools from getting on board with this sort of thing? Or is it only they can't let children do it without parents knowing?

I'm finding it very hard to keep my mouth shut on my actual opinions in the presence of headteacher. (Colleagues I've spoken to on the quiet all think it is bullshit too)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
akkakk · 13/09/2026 17:54

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 17:20

@soupycustard OK but if this condition causes you to feel you’re different to your assigned sex , do you live a life of never feeling your identity is right? I’m not preaching, I am nonplused! I just can’t see why people will go through the whole trauma of changing gender for no good reason. I’m assuming you mean people can’t be a different gender to their biological sex, apologies if you’re not meaning to say that.

If your ‘inner feelings’ are different from the physical evidence of your biological sex…

why would you consider that the right approach to aligning them is body mutilation and taking of chemicals?!

why would you not instead consider that working with that person’s mental health and cognitive dissonance might be the right route?

there is only one reason why society would consider butchery of what is scientifically obvious and accurate into a poor facsimile of something false to deal with mental health issues and that is because somewhere there is an agenda driving that approach…

so consider what agenda might drive an approach of:

  • puberty blockers to make those of legal age still look like small pre-pubescent children
  • mutilation to try and make men look like women so that they can access women and girls in their safe spaces…

now let’s re-evaluate the discussion…

JellySaurus · 13/09/2026 17:53

LongDarkTeatime · 11/09/2026 10:01

And that’s because you are an adult, Bot, not a 9 yr old child talking to someone with power over them.
As an adult you have built your self confidence and someone choosing not not respect your choice will have little impact. A 9 year old having an authority figure repeatedly show they do not respect how they feel could have significant consequences. This is not about meeting the teacher’s needs, it’s about the child’s current needs.

What a nine year old needs are consistent boundaries.

Adults can respect a child’s feelings and opinions without trampling on them, and without allowing the child to trample over others.

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 17:49

MarieDeGournay · 13/09/2026 17:42

Thanks for the reply, SYH.
Not everybody has to get worked up about 'hideous things', esp if they feel there's FA they can do about them, so fair enough.

But this particular board, 'Feminism: Sex and gender discussions', is by definition actively non-meh about things that do hurt other people, and society in general, so meh is bound to get some pushback.Smile

I actually do enjoy reading things by clever women. What could be better?

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 17:47

TheKeatingFive · 13/09/2026 17:41

How far are you going to take that though. Would you use ‘your highness’, or ‘your excellency’ if asked?

Ha! Good one, I’d avoid that situation 🤪

MarieDeGournay · 13/09/2026 17:42

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 13:39

@MarieDeGournay I think I’m more “meh, there’s f@ck all I can do about it. Based on my personal values and beliefs, people do hideous things. But if they are not hurting anyone in in doing so, then meh yeah

Thanks for the reply, SYH.
Not everybody has to get worked up about 'hideous things', esp if they feel there's FA they can do about them, so fair enough.

But this particular board, 'Feminism: Sex and gender discussions', is by definition actively non-meh about things that do hurt other people, and society in general, so meh is bound to get some pushback.Smile

TheKeatingFive · 13/09/2026 17:41

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 17:39

I wouldn’t call a child Satan or Lucifer (for instance) but not would I refuse certain pronouns if that’s what I was asked to do.

How far are you going to take that though. Would you use ‘your highness’, or ‘your excellency’ if asked?

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 17:39

TheKeatingFive · 13/09/2026 17:28

With regards to pronouns, because I find this point very interesting.

Do you always just do what people demand? Without thinking about how reasonable the demand is? Or the long term and second order consequences?

I just don’t really understand why this is positioned as a good thing.

I wouldn’t call a child Satan or Lucifer (for instance) but not would I refuse certain pronouns if that’s what I was asked to do.

TheKeatingFive · 13/09/2026 17:28

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 16:54

@MarieDeGournay thank you for sharing your views, which you expressed eloquently and persuasively. I can’t imagine a time when I would not follow someone ‘s wishes about their pronouns and name . But I do appreciate your views which have provided food for thought.

With regards to pronouns, because I find this point very interesting.

Do you always just do what people demand? Without thinking about how reasonable the demand is? Or the long term and second order consequences?

I just don’t really understand why this is positioned as a good thing.

TheKeatingFive · 13/09/2026 17:26

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 17:20

@soupycustard OK but if this condition causes you to feel you’re different to your assigned sex , do you live a life of never feeling your identity is right? I’m not preaching, I am nonplused! I just can’t see why people will go through the whole trauma of changing gender for no good reason. I’m assuming you mean people can’t be a different gender to their biological sex, apologies if you’re not meaning to say that.

You could only conclude that your ‘identity is not right’ if you’ve internalised there’s a right way to be male or female.

Acceptance of regressive stereotypes are the problem, not people’s identities.

TheKeatingFive · 13/09/2026 17:24

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 16:51

@TheKeatingFive I may have given it too much thought and ended up with no conclusion. I can’t imagine a situation when I wouldn’t respect someone’s naming/pronoun preference. Nevertheless, thanks for sharing your views, which are very interesting.

No offence but I don’t think you can claim you have given it ’too much thought’ when you stopped at ‘I don’t intend to end up in prison, so not my problem’.

And don’t you think, having had had some discussions that upholding women’s sex based rights might be more important than just doing what a man demands re pronouns, without thinking through the consequences?

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 17:20

@soupycustard OK but if this condition causes you to feel you’re different to your assigned sex , do you live a life of never feeling your identity is right? I’m not preaching, I am nonplused! I just can’t see why people will go through the whole trauma of changing gender for no good reason. I’m assuming you mean people can’t be a different gender to their biological sex, apologies if you’re not meaning to say that.

soupycustard · 13/09/2026 17:12

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 16:57

@ExpectMore I do believe there are more people than Caster who have this condition.

Yes there are. And other types of dsd too. There are nevertheless only two sexes in humans. That is the very basis of our continued existence as a species.

ExpectMore · 13/09/2026 17:09

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 16:57

@ExpectMore I do believe there are more people than Caster who have this condition.

And even those, as noted by many posters above, don’t prove anything.

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 16:57

@ExpectMore I do believe there are more people than Caster who have this condition.

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 16:54

@MarieDeGournay thank you for sharing your views, which you expressed eloquently and persuasively. I can’t imagine a time when I would not follow someone ‘s wishes about their pronouns and name . But I do appreciate your views which have provided food for thought.

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 16:51

@TheKeatingFive I may have given it too much thought and ended up with no conclusion. I can’t imagine a situation when I wouldn’t respect someone’s naming/pronoun preference. Nevertheless, thanks for sharing your views, which are very interesting.

ExpectMore · 13/09/2026 16:49

SevenYellowHammers · 12/09/2026 22:22

Athlete Caister Semaya assigned female at birth but had undecended testes. Had to take testosterone suppressing drugs to complete in women’s sport. Honestly I’m not trying to be tricksy or smart arsed here . It’s probably not even relevant to thread but I don’t think people are as binary as we might think. Only my opinion!

So 1 (possible) example of our 7Bn+ suggests we’re not binary….?

Come one. The other 7Bn - 1 might be proof we are….

TheKeatingFive · 13/09/2026 15:08

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 13:39

@MarieDeGournay I think I’m more “meh, there’s f@ck all I can do about it. Based on my personal values and beliefs, people do hideous things. But if they are not hurting anyone in in doing so, then meh yeah

People are being hurt though.

You seem happy to dismiss the point about women being incarcerated with men because it won’t happen to you, but there are women in this very position across the world right now. It’s not a theoretical concept to them.

That’s not to mention women who can’t now have access to single sex domestic violence shelters, rape counselling, intimate care if they need it.

Then there’s the wider implications of dismantling our scientific understanding, language and safeguarding structures as we pretend men can become women.

It strikes me that you haven’t given this any thought at all.

BonfireLady · 13/09/2026 13:57

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 13:39

@MarieDeGournay I think I’m more “meh, there’s f@ck all I can do about it. Based on my personal values and beliefs, people do hideous things. But if they are not hurting anyone in in doing so, then meh yeah

In less than a decade, we'll be looking back on a huge medical scandal where young adults have removed body parts, altered their endocrine systems irreversibly with cross-sex hormones and potentially suffered brain damage from puberty blockers that were given in childhood before these were restricted.

Many people will be scratching their heads, wondering how we got there without professionals seeing it and stopping it from happening.

Eyes will be on the medical profession for providing the surgery and medication but also on schools for not protecting children from entering this affirmation pathway.

But if they are not hurting anyone in in doing so

They are doing. This is harming thousands of children and young adults in the UK. Even more worldwide.

Is it still meh?

JamesKirkupReviewWritersFund · 13/09/2026 13:56

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 13:39

@MarieDeGournay I think I’m more “meh, there’s f@ck all I can do about it. Based on my personal values and beliefs, people do hideous things. But if they are not hurting anyone in in doing so, then meh yeah

But people are being hurt though - that is the point.

ETA - meant to add, we don't have to demonstrate or quantify hurt at every turn. The potential for hurt (whether to dignity, privacy or safety) is enough for the application of SSS and for effective safeguarding and for just saying no.

SevenYellowHammers · 13/09/2026 13:39

@MarieDeGournay I think I’m more “meh, there’s f@ck all I can do about it. Based on my personal values and beliefs, people do hideous things. But if they are not hurting anyone in in doing so, then meh yeah

AstonCanKissMyArse · 13/09/2026 13:31

LongDarkTeatime · 11/09/2026 10:01

And that’s because you are an adult, Bot, not a 9 yr old child talking to someone with power over them.
As an adult you have built your self confidence and someone choosing not not respect your choice will have little impact. A 9 year old having an authority figure repeatedly show they do not respect how they feel could have significant consequences. This is not about meeting the teacher’s needs, it’s about the child’s current needs.

But what about all the other children in the class? What about their needs, to be able to trust the adults around them to tell the truth?

Why should they be indoctrinated into this belief system that tells them if they don't feel like a boy/ girl (whatever the hell that means) then they must be NB?

Why don't you care about them?

This is exactly as aPP said, its analogous to the teacher saying prayers every morning because one religious kid demands it. Actually its more than that. Its saying the prayers AND telling the class that that religion is definitely true and it would be unkind to question it.

Even religious schools don't teach religion as fact, its 'some people believe...'

This girl will be using the girls toilets.

She's in y5 which is when they learn about reproduction and puberty.

Do we really think all the other children will just accept that she's a special anomaly and that they shouldn't question it (if they know what's good for them)?

Won't they be asking 'why does she use the girl's toilets if she's not a girl' Am i not a girl? How would I tell? etc etc? There's no good answer to these questions except to go further down the rabbit hole of lies.

I would be furious if my child was in that class being taught that its a fact that some people don't have a sex, because they don't feel like a stereotype.

Edit for typos.

ILikeDungs · 13/09/2026 12:41

soupycustard · 13/09/2026 12:39

Yes this conflation of trans and gay is nonsensical. Being same-sex attracted self-evidently requires and understanding of what sex means!

But it is a TRA tactic. Fancy that.

soupycustard · 13/09/2026 12:39

iwishitwouldstartraining · 13/09/2026 12:02

Also, Section 28 did not cover 'trans kids'.

Back in 2000 Jan Morris was who people thought of when they thought of a transexual and there was no conflation with being gay.

Edited

Yes this conflation of trans and gay is nonsensical. Being same-sex attracted self-evidently requires and understanding of what sex means!

soupycustard · 13/09/2026 12:36

This thread is a really interesting example of why this topic is so difficult. The concept of 'non-binary' is fundamentally meaningless, but it's being used/accepted/encouraged by people - motives varied/unknown - on bases that lack scientific understanding and logic. So the arguments we've had are that everyone should just agree with whatever a child (or her parents) say, without any objective concern whatsoever. This attitude clearly doesnt apply to all sorts of situations, so why does it apply here and where is the line? That there are more than 2 sexes in human beings, and 'hermaphrodites'; which shows no understanding of sexual reproduction or Darwinism; and that some people just don't care about women's rights; which isn't even an argument is it really; though is very indicative I think of the link between so-called trans rights and the neo-liberal individualism that many proponents of these rights would claim to shun.

Swipe left for the next trending thread