Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Stella O'Malley on the cowardice of the Irish media

67 replies

ItsCoolForCats · 04/09/2026 09:22

Really blistering article from Stella O'Malley on the failure of the Irish media (particularly the Irish Times and RTE) to report on the trans issue. It's in the Irish Catholic (one of the few publications in Ireland that will run these type of articles).

It's a familiar and depressing tale of capitulation by organisations following bullying by trans activists. The Irish Times is now in a reflective mood about Woke 1.0, and Stella isn't having it.

Not sure if those on X will be able to read this. Are there any alternatives to Nitter?

https://x.com/stellaomalley3/status/2095532646839271615

Stella O'Malley (@stellaomalley3) on X

I often wonder what’s going on in the offices of @IrishTimes and @rte when scandals such as the latest “chest-feeding males” breaks. I’ve no doubt they want to slide back into credibility and pretend “we all partied” during Woke 1.0. But we didn’t....

https://x.com/stellaomalley3/status/2095532646839271615

OP posts:
Blueberrywild · 21/10/2026 10:21

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 10:03

Do you not recall that there was a whole stable of feminist books in the late 1970's and 1980's dedicated to women's bodies and women's health and to the birth experience? ( 'Our Bodies, Ourselves'; 'Active Birth' ( Janet Balaskas); 'Spiritual Mid-wifery' etc). This was certainly a very formative time in my young life as a developing woman and very much shaped my experience of the women's movement. We didn't want to be subject to the routine episiotomies given to our mothers, or to being forced into a reclining position whilst giving birth; or to having our babies whisked away by medical staff and immediately swaddled etc

Taking control of your birthing experience is good as long as women don’t forget that childbirth has inherent risks.
I’d never have taken the risk to have my children at home, personally, but then we’re some distance from a hospital.
I know one woman who free-birthed, so had no midwife attending. I thought she was off her head tbh.

Cailleach1 · 21/10/2026 10:12

Chicaontour · 21/10/2026 10:03

"This specific board was set up to discuss the clash and conflict created by transgender ideology and its negative impact upon women and children. Maybe you are unaware of that"

Now that is making more sense. From the name it was focusing on feminism. Why not just rename it Transbashing . As an Irish women I remember how much the LGBTQ community stood with women to safeguard our rights. Hilarious that a group proporting to be a feminist group is allying with the least Feminist group i know. Talking about whitewashing .

What a load of nonsense. I think anyone who supports the rights of women (and their children) would most certainly be interested in anything that had a negative impact on their rights.

I wouldn’t be blindly following any new, faith based religious movement that wanted women to believe in the fantastical claims of men, to their own detriment.

Qui bono? Clue, it’s certainly not women.

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 10:11

totino · 21/10/2026 10:07

Improving the pregnancy and childbirth experience is great and I support that. I'm also sure it can be amazing and empowering. But it's still a medical event. I understand your framing, but to me being called "a patient" would mean they take me seriously. Especially if the mother's or birthing parents' well-being should be centered, which I agree with.

You asked when this approach ( not referring to women as patients) had ever been considered a feminist one.

To me, the moment you are admitted to a hospital and become a patient you lose your individuality and become processed into the sytem. You become institutionalised very quickly.

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 10:08

Chicaontour · 21/10/2026 10:03

"This specific board was set up to discuss the clash and conflict created by transgender ideology and its negative impact upon women and children. Maybe you are unaware of that"

Now that is making more sense. From the name it was focusing on feminism. Why not just rename it Transbashing . As an Irish women I remember how much the LGBTQ community stood with women to safeguard our rights. Hilarious that a group proporting to be a feminist group is allying with the least Feminist group i know. Talking about whitewashing .

The 'General feminist chat' was hived off at request of people who didn't want to talk about the damaging impact of transgender Ideology. You are talking down in an ignorant and insulting way to women who have been involved in women's rights in one form or other for a long time.

I'd suggest it was the other way around. It was women ( lesbians) that stood with gay men during the 1980's - only to be abandoned by many of those same gay men once trans ideology had taken over and became the main Stonewall campaign - after gay marriage equality had been won in 2014.

totino · 21/10/2026 10:07

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 09:53

Because one of the evolutions in the women's movement was a move towards taking back childbirth from the hands of the male obstectrians - in a bid to improve the birthing experience and recognise it as a major life changing transtional event; and to re- empower women.

Somehow it has now become verboten to discuss how positive and empowering a natural birth can be and how it can shape a women's confidence in herself as a mother, and as a woman. We are all supposed to be satisfied that "the most important thing is a live baby", and that the traumatised and brutalised women is the price to pay.

Improving the pregnancy and childbirth experience is great and I support that. I'm also sure it can be amazing and empowering. But it's still a medical event. I understand your framing, but to me being called "a patient" would mean they take me seriously. Especially if the mother's or birthing parents' well-being should be centered, which I agree with.

Chicaontour · 21/10/2026 10:03

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 09:46

And entry level sociological analysis obscured by emotional group think mantras.

I don't think you can have been much involved with the women's movement and certainly not exposed to its history - outside of a predicatbly small, carefully curated circle - no doubt formed in a social media age in which people don't really bother to engage fully or independently with issues anymore.

What we are most interested in is women; their rights and protections; their strength; their dignity. This specific board was set up to discuss the clash and conflict created by transgender ideology and its negative impact upon women and children. Maybe you are unaware of that.

Edited

"This specific board was set up to discuss the clash and conflict created by transgender ideology and its negative impact upon women and children. Maybe you are unaware of that"

Now that is making more sense. From the name it was focusing on feminism. Why not just rename it Transbashing . As an Irish women I remember how much the LGBTQ community stood with women to safeguard our rights. Hilarious that a group proporting to be a feminist group is allying with the least Feminist group i know. Talking about whitewashing .

Cailleach1 · 21/10/2026 10:03

How wonderful to have Sall Grover on the Pat Kenny Show! Not impeded by illogical, quasi religious nonsense about gender souls being on an equal level (if indeed not overriding) biological sex.

Interestingly, in the transcript, where Sall refers to her support to the LGB community, they have written LGBT.

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 10:03

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 09:53

Because one of the evolutions in the women's movement was a move towards taking back childbirth from the hands of the male obstectrians - in a bid to improve the birthing experience and recognise it as a major life changing transtional event; and to re- empower women.

Somehow it has now become verboten to discuss how positive and empowering a natural birth can be and how it can shape a women's confidence in herself as a mother, and as a woman. We are all supposed to be satisfied that "the most important thing is a live baby", and that the traumatised and brutalised women is the price to pay.

Do you not recall that there was a whole stable of feminist books in the late 1970's and 1980's dedicated to women's bodies and women's health and to the birth experience? ( 'Our Bodies, Ourselves'; 'Active Birth' ( Janet Balaskas); 'Spiritual Mid-wifery' etc). This was certainly a very formative time in my young life as a developing woman and very much shaped my experience of the women's movement. We didn't want to be subject to the routine episiotomies given to our mothers, or to being forced into a reclining position whilst giving birth; or to having our babies whisked away by medical staff and immediately swaddled etc

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 09:53

totino · 21/10/2026 09:42

How would it be feminist to play down pregnancy as a medical event? It's challenging, dangerous, potentially life-threatening, and alters your body permanently. It is definitionally a medical event, which is why someone who's pregnant should get the utmost support and care. I remember at least one pregnant friend of mine saying how she wished people were more open about the freaky stuff your body does when pregnant.

Because one of the evolutions in the women's movement was a move towards taking back childbirth from the hands of the male obstectrians - in a bid to improve the birthing experience and recognise it as a major life changing transtional event; and to re- empower women.

Somehow it has now become verboten to discuss how positive and empowering a natural birth can be and how it can shape a women's confidence in herself as a mother, and as a woman. We are all supposed to be satisfied that "the most important thing is a live baby", and that the traumatised and brutalised women is the price to pay.

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 09:46

Chicaontour · 21/10/2026 06:52

This page is so blinded by their hatred of trans peoole that they are lauding the Irish Catholic Church as a great beacon of feminism. Are ye in a twilight world?

I am Irish feminist living in Ireland and this is risable. I cant get over how right wing this page is. Everyones religion is their own choice but the Catholic church and its guideance in Ireland is the opposite of feminism. A synod voted last week NOT to set up a womams department never mind admit female clergy. They are STILL avoiding paying "sweetheart reparatitions" to the victims of industrial schools and mother and baby homes. A referendum 3 years back kept " womens special.place in the home ( mere platitudes as opposed to actually supporting carers). This is all current.

I have come to the conclusion that this page had been taken over by bad actors as i have never met any feminist in real life who are so obsessed with trans people. Its a broad church but I hear a hell of a lot more talk about medical mysogny, violence against women, barriers in the work place but nope here its all about trans people who make up 1% of the population.

And entry level sociological analysis obscured by emotional group think mantras.

I don't think you can have been much involved with the women's movement and certainly not exposed to its history - outside of a predicatbly small, carefully curated circle - no doubt formed in a social media age in which people don't really bother to engage fully or independently with issues anymore.

What we are most interested in is women; their rights and protections; their strength; their dignity. This specific board was set up to discuss the clash and conflict created by transgender ideology and its negative impact upon women and children. Maybe you are unaware of that.

totino · 21/10/2026 09:42

MarieDeGournay · 20/10/2026 21:45

Thanks for all those points, Oki, especially for providing me with the word 'obstetrician' which had evaded me when I was writing my postSmile

Maybe I'm showing my age by being surprised that women giving birth [he was talking about 'matrescence' in general not problem births] are referred to as 'patients'.

I recall very very strong insistence that giving birth was not a medical event, even if it happened in a hospital, that childbirth is a natural event and that mothers are not patients. (barring problems requiring medical intervention of course).

It must be one of those old feminist-y things from the past that have gone out of style. 'Patient' definitely grated on my ears, which must be old feminist-y earsSmile

How would it be feminist to play down pregnancy as a medical event? It's challenging, dangerous, potentially life-threatening, and alters your body permanently. It is definitionally a medical event, which is why someone who's pregnant should get the utmost support and care. I remember at least one pregnant friend of mine saying how she wished people were more open about the freaky stuff your body does when pregnant.

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 09:37

MarieDeGournay · 20/10/2026 21:45

Thanks for all those points, Oki, especially for providing me with the word 'obstetrician' which had evaded me when I was writing my postSmile

Maybe I'm showing my age by being surprised that women giving birth [he was talking about 'matrescence' in general not problem births] are referred to as 'patients'.

I recall very very strong insistence that giving birth was not a medical event, even if it happened in a hospital, that childbirth is a natural event and that mothers are not patients. (barring problems requiring medical intervention of course).

It must be one of those old feminist-y things from the past that have gone out of style. 'Patient' definitely grated on my ears, which must be old feminist-y earsSmile

Your're right, I'm of that generation of women for whom birth was a natural process and not a medical event - and who fought for the right to a home birth and for the woman remaining in control of her own birthing process. I always think of this as 'goddess feminism'. A feminism rooted in the facts and experience ( and power and strength) of the female body.

I'm really taken by what the doctor said about 'matrescence' being equivalent to adolosecence. I'd never thought of it like that before - but I think there is a profound truth in it. The surge of hormones and all of the changes they induce, at both physical and emotional level, does represent a step change in a woman's life; one in which her sense of herself and her priorities in life under-go significant revolution.

ItsCoolForCats · 21/10/2026 08:55

Right wing and blinded by hatred? Because we have a different opinion to you on this issue? 🙄

I think you've got yourself so worked up that it's affected your comprehension skills and you've missed all the nuance where the Catholic Church has been discussed. It is ironic that the Irish Catholic is one of the few publications that will print stories on how women's rights have been impacted by gender Self ID. Could you point me to where on the thread we have said the Catholic Church is a great beacon of feminism?

I am not "obsessed" with trans people. I know quite a few trans people. Some I like, some not so much, just like anyone else. What I am "obsessed" with is women not losing the protections we have in law based on our sex. For women and girls to have fair and safe sport. For women and girls to have access to single sex spaces in situations where sex matters. And I have seen first hand in my workplace what happens when you elevate the rights of one group over another and how it negatively impacts women.

And, shocker, but I also care about the things you listed at the end of your post, such as VAWG, because it is possible to care about more than one issue, especially when they're linked. Do you think women who have been traumatised by male violence should have access to single sex spaces?

OP posts:
borntobequiet · 21/10/2026 08:29

MarieDeGournay · 20/10/2026 21:45

Thanks for all those points, Oki, especially for providing me with the word 'obstetrician' which had evaded me when I was writing my postSmile

Maybe I'm showing my age by being surprised that women giving birth [he was talking about 'matrescence' in general not problem births] are referred to as 'patients'.

I recall very very strong insistence that giving birth was not a medical event, even if it happened in a hospital, that childbirth is a natural event and that mothers are not patients. (barring problems requiring medical intervention of course).

It must be one of those old feminist-y things from the past that have gone out of style. 'Patient' definitely grated on my ears, which must be old feminist-y earsSmile

Grates on my ears too, for the same reasons.

borntobequiet · 21/10/2026 08:27

Uh?

Chicaontour · 21/10/2026 06:52

This page is so blinded by their hatred of trans peoole that they are lauding the Irish Catholic Church as a great beacon of feminism. Are ye in a twilight world?

I am Irish feminist living in Ireland and this is risable. I cant get over how right wing this page is. Everyones religion is their own choice but the Catholic church and its guideance in Ireland is the opposite of feminism. A synod voted last week NOT to set up a womams department never mind admit female clergy. They are STILL avoiding paying "sweetheart reparatitions" to the victims of industrial schools and mother and baby homes. A referendum 3 years back kept " womens special.place in the home ( mere platitudes as opposed to actually supporting carers). This is all current.

I have come to the conclusion that this page had been taken over by bad actors as i have never met any feminist in real life who are so obsessed with trans people. Its a broad church but I hear a hell of a lot more talk about medical mysogny, violence against women, barriers in the work place but nope here its all about trans people who make up 1% of the population.

MarieDeGournay · 20/10/2026 21:45

Okl · 20/10/2026 20:30

Sorry one last point @MarieDeGournay The man you mentioned on the radio was an obstetrician. An obstetrician is a doctor whose role is to provide medical and surgical care in pregnancy, childbirth and the postpartum period. So it was entirely natural and appropriate for him to use the word 'patient' In these circumstances. It reflects the professional relationship and the care being provided; it is not an attempt to erase or avoid acknowledging that she is a woman.

In sum, 'patient' is an established term in healthcare, and there is nothing inherently dehumanising or ideologically motivated about its use in maternity care.

Thanks for all those points, Oki, especially for providing me with the word 'obstetrician' which had evaded me when I was writing my postSmile

Maybe I'm showing my age by being surprised that women giving birth [he was talking about 'matrescence' in general not problem births] are referred to as 'patients'.

I recall very very strong insistence that giving birth was not a medical event, even if it happened in a hospital, that childbirth is a natural event and that mothers are not patients. (barring problems requiring medical intervention of course).

It must be one of those old feminist-y things from the past that have gone out of style. 'Patient' definitely grated on my ears, which must be old feminist-y earsSmile

Genesis1v27 · 20/10/2026 21:18

Gizzasec · 20/10/2026 20:48

I don't have X & I can't read it! Anyone got those images?

Full-size images:

https://ugc-assets.mumsnet.com/images/202610/HBbYkNXuHvVyZ4TKcEJZfxpV5hhSyZmFrN992Lrn.jpeg

https://ugc-assets.mumsnet.com/images/202610/t67vtsQRuToFxM7tdKPF3j69kjkc9TG4H36AexC4.jpeg

Stella O'Malley on the cowardice of the Irish media
Stella O'Malley on the cowardice of the Irish media
Gizzasec · 20/10/2026 20:48

ItsCoolForCats · 04/09/2026 09:30

Thanks, I just wasn't sure if anyone without an X account would be able to read it.

I don't have X & I can't read it! Anyone got those images?

Okl · 20/10/2026 20:30

Sorry one last point @MarieDeGournay The man you mentioned on the radio was an obstetrician. An obstetrician is a doctor whose role is to provide medical and surgical care in pregnancy, childbirth and the postpartum period. So it was entirely natural and appropriate for him to use the word 'patient' In these circumstances. It reflects the professional relationship and the care being provided; it is not an attempt to erase or avoid acknowledging that she is a woman.

In sum, 'patient' is an established term in healthcare, and there is nothing inherently dehumanising or ideologically motivated about its use in maternity care.

Okl · 20/10/2026 20:14

Patient is a perfectly appropriate term in many maternity contexts, particularly given how much obstetric involvement many women have throughout pregnancy, birth and the postnatal period. A woman undergoing a caesarean section, receiving obstetric interventions, requiring specialist antenatal monitoring, or needing significant medical care following birth is undoubtedly a patient within that clinical context. Her status as a woman or mother does not somehow negate her status as a patient.

I would make a distinction when referring to a woman who has had an entirely straightforward, low-risk pregnancy, a normal vaginal birth and an uncomplicated postnatal recovery, with no obstetric intervention or medical input. In that context, I would refer to the woman as woman/mother/her name. My point is that these terms are not mutually exclusive, and context matters. Calling a woman a patient does not erase her identity as a woman or mother, nor does it necessarily imply anything about gender identity. It is a longstanding clinical term that has a legitimate place in maternity care.

Okl · 20/10/2026 20:00

MarieDeGournay · 20/10/2026 17:56

There were two items on Irish radio the other day, one was about women's health and was all about health issues that are specific to women as in biological women. By a woman. No hesitation prevarication apologies or circumlocution: women's health, full stop.

Then a while later there was an interview with a man who is a specialist in the obstetrics kind of area. [sorry if I'd realised it would be so quotable, I'd have paid more attention to names!].
It was very interesting about 'matrescence' which is the range of changes, hormonal, psychological, physical etc which occur when a woman gives birth.
He said it was as significant as adolescence, and needs to be recognised, support given, etc etc.

However, although he was talking about a most essentially female experience. he kept referring to the changes in the new mother 'and father' and the importance of supporting the couple through matrescence.
He also consistently referred to new mothers as 'the patient'.

Two things struck me, apart from the obvious one that no man goes through matrescence:🙄

Given the high number of single mothers, constantly referring to the parents plural. and automatically referring to the father/ the couple used to be frowned upon, as so many mothers do not have partners. It looks like that has been overturned. There is always a man involved now.

It was also frowned upon in the recent past to over-medicalise pregnancy and childbirth, so calling new mothers 'patients' seems to have been brought back into use to avoid having to say 'mother'..

I think these two items on Irish radio, only a few hours apart, are indicative of two tiers - lots of people, probably most people, not buying into TWAW at all; and on the other hand, professionals going out of their way to avoid speaking the words 'woman' or 'mother' - even if that overturns previous 'sensitivities' around single mothers and the over-medicalisation of childbirth.

As a midwife with over 20 years of service, my experience is that “patient” is simply a traditional, old-school medical term used in healthcare. It certainly wasn’t coined or adopted to avoid specifying the sex or gender of a pregnant or postpartum woman.

OP posts:
MarieDeGournay · 20/10/2026 17:56

There were two items on Irish radio the other day, one was about women's health and was all about health issues that are specific to women as in biological women. By a woman. No hesitation prevarication apologies or circumlocution: women's health, full stop.

Then a while later there was an interview with a man who is a specialist in the obstetrics kind of area. [sorry if I'd realised it would be so quotable, I'd have paid more attention to names!].
It was very interesting about 'matrescence' which is the range of changes, hormonal, psychological, physical etc which occur when a woman gives birth.
He said it was as significant as adolescence, and needs to be recognised, support given, etc etc.

However, although he was talking about a most essentially female experience. he kept referring to the changes in the new mother 'and father' and the importance of supporting the couple through matrescence.
He also consistently referred to new mothers as 'the patient'.

Two things struck me, apart from the obvious one that no man goes through matrescence:🙄

Given the high number of single mothers, constantly referring to the parents plural. and automatically referring to the father/ the couple used to be frowned upon, as so many mothers do not have partners. It looks like that has been overturned. There is always a man involved now.

It was also frowned upon in the recent past to over-medicalise pregnancy and childbirth, so calling new mothers 'patients' seems to have been brought back into use to avoid having to say 'mother'..

I think these two items on Irish radio, only a few hours apart, are indicative of two tiers - lots of people, probably most people, not buying into TWAW at all; and on the other hand, professionals going out of their way to avoid speaking the words 'woman' or 'mother' - even if that overturns previous 'sensitivities' around single mothers and the over-medicalisation of childbirth.