Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Stella O'Malley on the cowardice of the Irish media

67 replies

ItsCoolForCats · 04/09/2026 09:22

Really blistering article from Stella O'Malley on the failure of the Irish media (particularly the Irish Times and RTE) to report on the trans issue. It's in the Irish Catholic (one of the few publications in Ireland that will run these type of articles).

It's a familiar and depressing tale of capitulation by organisations following bullying by trans activists. The Irish Times is now in a reflective mood about Woke 1.0, and Stella isn't having it.

Not sure if those on X will be able to read this. Are there any alternatives to Nitter?

https://x.com/stellaomalley3/status/2095532646839271615

Stella O'Malley (@stellaomalley3) on X

I often wonder what’s going on in the offices of @IrishTimes and @rte when scandals such as the latest “chest-feeding males” breaks. I’ve no doubt they want to slide back into credibility and pretend “we all partied” during Woke 1.0. But we didn’t....

https://x.com/stellaomalley3/status/2095532646839271615

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
moto748e · 27/10/2026 15:02

1950s: Only 3% of births were via C-section.
1980s: The rate rose to 10%.
2015: About 27% of babies were born by C-section.
2020: The figure climbed to 33%.
2025/2026: The rate hit 45%, officially overtaking natural vaginal births for the first time in NHS history.

That's pretty amazing, really.

turkeyboots · 27/10/2026 14:32

The Catholic Church have secured carve outs in Gender Certificates round the world to ensure that women cant sneak into priesthood by self id as a man. They definitely know who a woman is, and are keen to enforce it. It definitely doesn't make them gender critical though, just self interested.
And Ireland is a deeply conservative and two faced country. We're all very modern and liberal when it suits us, and not at all when it doesn't.

ItsCoolForCats · 26/10/2026 20:10

Genesis1v27 · 26/10/2026 19:10

I found the full interview on pressreader.com:

https://www.pressreader.com/search/all?aid=281956024778112
https://archive.ph/Z57FU

And Estelle Birdy just published a piece about the episodes and the background to them:

https://estellebirdy.substack.com/p/once-upon-a-time-on-rte

That was an interesting read, thank you. I'm Irish but living in Terf island. I vaguely know what goes on in the Irish media, but I didn't know the extent of the madness in the backstory to this. No wonder people are scared into silence. Things do seem particularly batshit in Ireland, but things were the same here a few years ago, so there is hope. Things are slowly being turned around here, albeit with a lot of pushback. Even t BBC is attempting some balance now.

OP posts:
ItsCoolForCats · 26/10/2026 20:05

Gmhopkins · 25/10/2026 18:26

Joe Duffy is a coward. He hosted 3 days of reasonable conversation and then allowed RTE to censor the show. He could have done the right thing.

Perhaps he was cowardly not to ever revisit the topic, but he's not the first journalist to back off from the unhinged vitriol of TRAs. Hopefully his book will open a few people's eyes.

OP posts:
Genesis1v27 · 26/10/2026 19:10

ItsCoolForCats · 25/10/2026 11:35

Joe Duffy perfectly illustrating the stranglehold TRASs have on the Irish media

https://www.independent.ie/videos/joe-duffy-on-the-fallout-from-2022s-programmes-on-the-transgender-issue-accusations-from-tds-and-the-reaction-from-his-rte-bosses/a/163508826.html?utm_campaign=share&utm_medium=referral&utm_source=x

Discussed about 3 and a half minutes in on the embedded video. After discussing it on his show in 2022, he thought his career was over.

I found the full interview on pressreader.com:

https://www.pressreader.com/search/all?aid=281956024778112
https://archive.ph/Z57FU

And Estelle Birdy just published a piece about the episodes and the background to them:

https://estellebirdy.substack.com/p/once-upon-a-time-on-rte

Gmhopkins · 25/10/2026 18:26

Joe Duffy is a coward. He hosted 3 days of reasonable conversation and then allowed RTE to censor the show. He could have done the right thing.

MarieDeGournay · 25/10/2026 15:35

Gmhopkins · 21/10/2026 19:30

It’sa great article and I think it’s interesting that the Irish Catholic is choosing to publish Stella and other sex realists. As far as I know, the Catholic Church hasn’t been great in general on these issues, but this particular publication has been ?

By 'these issues' do you mean transgenderism/gender ideology?

Unlike many Christian churches, the Catholic church is resolutely against the concept of transgenderism - with the usual 'but not trans people, of course' rider.

It sees a person's biological sex as something inherent to how god created them, and to be respected not messed about with.
I'm paraphrasing obvs, here's are some proper quotes:
Constituting the person’s being, the soul and the body both participate in the dignity that characterizes every human. Moreover, the body participates in that dignity as it is endowed with personal meanings, particularly in its sexed condition.
..
in recent decades, attempts have been made to introduce new rights that are neither fully consistent with those originally defined nor always acceptable. They have led to instances of ideological colonization, in which gender theory plays a central role; the latter is extremely dangerous since it cancels differences in its claim to make everyone equal...
Declaration “Dignitas Infinita” on Human Dignity (2 April 2024)

I like 'new rights that are neither fully consistent with those originally defined nor always acceptable.'
Very succinct. I also like 'ideological colonization.

ItsCoolForCats · 25/10/2026 11:35

Joe Duffy perfectly illustrating the stranglehold TRASs have on the Irish media

https://www.independent.ie/videos/joe-duffy-on-the-fallout-from-2022s-programmes-on-the-transgender-issue-accusations-from-tds-and-the-reaction-from-his-rte-bosses/a/163508826.html?utm_campaign=share&utm_medium=referral&utm_source=x

Discussed about 3 and a half minutes in on the embedded video. After discussing it on his show in 2022, he thought his career was over.

OP posts:
Gmhopkins · 21/10/2026 19:30

It’sa great article and I think it’s interesting that the Irish Catholic is choosing to publish Stella and other sex realists. As far as I know, the Catholic Church hasn’t been great in general on these issues, but this particular publication has been ?

UtopiaPlanitia · 21/10/2026 17:42

Okl · 21/10/2026 17:36

I was responding to a question someone asked me, not attempting to derail the thread. Which I am perfectly entitled to do.🙂It is rather amusing to me that you think you get to police what strangers on the internet discuss. People can make their own judgement about whether a contribution is relevant without you appointing yourself the thread moderator.

Okay, suit yourself. I'll just ignore the extraneous info.

Okl · 21/10/2026 17:36

I was responding to a question someone asked me, not attempting to derail the thread. Which I am perfectly entitled to do.🙂It is rather amusing to me that you think you get to police what strangers on the internet discuss. People can make their own judgement about whether a contribution is relevant without you appointing yourself the thread moderator.

UtopiaPlanitia · 21/10/2026 17:10

Okl · 21/10/2026 16:49

In the latest MBRRACE-UK Perinatal Mortality Surveillance Report (covering births in 2024) published in June 2026, the overall stillbirth rate dropped to 3.2 per 1000 births. Intrapartum stillbirth historically accounts for a small fraction of that number. Google the report for the exact number but I think it is around 5 percent.

The UK doesn't publish a standalone statistic for just the intrapartum period. Instead, they report the maternal mortality rate, which includes deaths occurring anytime during pregnancy, delivery, or up to 42 days postpartum. The overall UK maternal death rate stands at 12.80 per 100,000 maternities for 2022-2024; with 252 women dying from direct or indirect causes during pregnancy or within 42 days following birth. This figure is 20 percent higher than levels reported in the 2009 - 2011 period. The MBRRACE-UK report details more information if you are interested.

This is interesting information but the thread was not started to discuss maternal mortality rates, it's to discuss Stella O'Malley's article. If you're keen on continuing the discussion of maternal mortality/safety in childbirth, perhaps a separate thread would make more sense to prevent derailing/confusion on this thread.

Okl · 21/10/2026 16:49

AlonsoMosley · 21/10/2026 13:10

Add to that, fewer births.

But I wonder if there are any statists regarding death rates durning delivery for baby and/or mother?

In the latest MBRRACE-UK Perinatal Mortality Surveillance Report (covering births in 2024) published in June 2026, the overall stillbirth rate dropped to 3.2 per 1000 births. Intrapartum stillbirth historically accounts for a small fraction of that number. Google the report for the exact number but I think it is around 5 percent.

The UK doesn't publish a standalone statistic for just the intrapartum period. Instead, they report the maternal mortality rate, which includes deaths occurring anytime during pregnancy, delivery, or up to 42 days postpartum. The overall UK maternal death rate stands at 12.80 per 100,000 maternities for 2022-2024; with 252 women dying from direct or indirect causes during pregnancy or within 42 days following birth. This figure is 20 percent higher than levels reported in the 2009 - 2011 period. The MBRRACE-UK report details more information if you are interested.

Blueberrywild · 21/10/2026 14:14

Yes, thankfully. From what she’s said though (not much) I don’t think she’d make the same choice again. She was unprepared for the reality of it, I think. She was very young (though an adult) and idealistic.

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 14:08

Blueberrywild · 21/10/2026 13:15

I think, unfortunately, some women don’t fully inform themselves of the risks involved when it comes to free-birthing.

Edited

Maybe, but you'd have to assume someone who has chosen what amounts to quite a radical path ( without even a midwife) has done a lot research. Staff being excessively risk averse is what has led to so many disastrous consequences for so many women giving birth in hospitals.

Every time we leave the house there are risks. There are risks involved in most actions or decisions. I assume that the free birthing, in this instance, went well - and without undue complication?

Blueberrywild · 21/10/2026 13:15

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 13:02

I also think most women are capable of weighing up the conditions of their pregnancy and making an informed choice as to how and where they'd like to give birth.

I think, unfortunately, some women don’t fully inform themselves of the risks involved when it comes to free-birthing.

AlonsoMosley · 21/10/2026 13:10

Okl · 21/10/2026 11:13

I recall very very strong insistence that giving birth was not a medical event, even if it happened in a hospital, that childbirth is a natural event and that mothers are not patients. (barring problems requiring medical intervention of course).

Yes, absolutely! Pregnancy and childbirth are normal physiological processes. However, in England, the caesarean section rate is currently 45% and rising. It has spiked heavily over the last decade, accelerating most rapidly after 2020.
To put the timeline into perspective:

  • 1950s: Only 3% of births were via C-section.
  • 1980s: The rate rose to 10%.
  • 2015: About 27% of babies were born by C-section.
  • 2020: The figure climbed to 33%.
  • 2025/2026: The rate hit 45%, officially overtaking natural vaginal births for the first time in NHS history.

So when you take the section rate and add this to the instrumental delivery rate most women in England are not birthing naturally.

I don't know the figures for the rest of the UK and Ireland but I am aware the section rates are high and rapidly rising too.

Add to that, fewer births.

But I wonder if there are any statists regarding death rates durning delivery for baby and/or mother?

AlonsoMosley · 21/10/2026 13:06

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 10:08

The 'General feminist chat' was hived off at request of people who didn't want to talk about the damaging impact of transgender Ideology. You are talking down in an ignorant and insulting way to women who have been involved in women's rights in one form or other for a long time.

I'd suggest it was the other way around. It was women ( lesbians) that stood with gay men during the 1980's - only to be abandoned by many of those same gay men once trans ideology had taken over and became the main Stonewall campaign - after gay marriage equality had been won in 2014.

Edited

Indeed - but not only lesbians, heterosexual women too.

Without women, the gays rights movement would have stalled at the gate.

And yes, you are also right that the majority looked the other way when they were needed.

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 13:05

totino · 21/10/2026 10:28

Thanks for telling me. I associate the idea of birth being "natural" for women because we are "built for it" strongly with a paternal way of downplaying the dangers, but I understand the idea of wanting to reclaim it.

I always saw it as 'paternalism' that men wanted to move in and take-over control of the birth process ( dis-empowering midwives in the process) - without any real understanding of what it means to women, nor how women experience pregnancy, birth and motherhood.

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 13:02

Blueberrywild · 21/10/2026 10:21

Taking control of your birthing experience is good as long as women don’t forget that childbirth has inherent risks.
I’d never have taken the risk to have my children at home, personally, but then we’re some distance from a hospital.
I know one woman who free-birthed, so had no midwife attending. I thought she was off her head tbh.

I also think most women are capable of weighing up the conditions of their pregnancy and making an informed choice as to how and where they'd like to give birth.

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 12:56

Blueberrywild · 21/10/2026 10:21

Taking control of your birthing experience is good as long as women don’t forget that childbirth has inherent risks.
I’d never have taken the risk to have my children at home, personally, but then we’re some distance from a hospital.
I know one woman who free-birthed, so had no midwife attending. I thought she was off her head tbh.

Yes, but my point was that the natural/home birth movement was a feminist one and one that was very powerful in the women's movement for some of the reasons I've given.

It is also the case that in more recent times there seems to have beome a censure on women talking about home births or natural births lest it upset women who have had more traumatic experiences. We are all supposed to accept that it is selfish and irresponsible to want more than just a healthy baby at the end of one's pregnancy. That birthing doesn't have to be traumatic, can, in fact, be celebratory and empowering is forbidden from being spoken.

This comes at a time when we are told that Cesaerian rates are rising dramatically and many women are having terrible and traumatic experiences in hospital maternity wards - with staff that don't seem to care and in a system which prioritises excessive surgical and interventional precaution, such as routine inductions, over nursing and midwifery skill.

Okl · 21/10/2026 11:13

I recall very very strong insistence that giving birth was not a medical event, even if it happened in a hospital, that childbirth is a natural event and that mothers are not patients. (barring problems requiring medical intervention of course).

Yes, absolutely! Pregnancy and childbirth are normal physiological processes. However, in England, the caesarean section rate is currently 45% and rising. It has spiked heavily over the last decade, accelerating most rapidly after 2020.
To put the timeline into perspective:

  • 1950s: Only 3% of births were via C-section.
  • 1980s: The rate rose to 10%.
  • 2015: About 27% of babies were born by C-section.
  • 2020: The figure climbed to 33%.
  • 2025/2026: The rate hit 45%, officially overtaking natural vaginal births for the first time in NHS history.

So when you take the section rate and add this to the instrumental delivery rate most women in England are not birthing naturally.

I don't know the figures for the rest of the UK and Ireland but I am aware the section rates are high and rapidly rising too.

borntobequiet · 21/10/2026 11:04

totino · 21/10/2026 09:42

How would it be feminist to play down pregnancy as a medical event? It's challenging, dangerous, potentially life-threatening, and alters your body permanently. It is definitionally a medical event, which is why someone who's pregnant should get the utmost support and care. I remember at least one pregnant friend of mine saying how she wished people were more open about the freaky stuff your body does when pregnant.

It's challenging, dangerous, potentially life-threatening, and alters your body permanently.

None of these make it inherently “medical”. It becomes medical when things go wrong.

That said, it’s important to realise that advances in medicine (often instigated by male doctors) have helped make childbirth safer for women and their babies.

MarieDeGournay · 21/10/2026 10:49

Chicaontour · 21/10/2026 10:03

"This specific board was set up to discuss the clash and conflict created by transgender ideology and its negative impact upon women and children. Maybe you are unaware of that"

Now that is making more sense. From the name it was focusing on feminism. Why not just rename it Transbashing . As an Irish women I remember how much the LGBTQ community stood with women to safeguard our rights. Hilarious that a group proporting to be a feminist group is allying with the least Feminist group i know. Talking about whitewashing .

The notion of a 'LGBTQ community' is a recent invention created by sticking a T for transgender onto an existing LGB community. It is useful because it enables trans rights activists to appropriate the struggle of lesbian and gay people, and creates an illusion of a long history e.g. pushing the GRA15 through on the coattails of the Marriage Equality reference, the ahistorical claim that the Stonewall Riots in 1969 were started by transwomen, etc.

Transgender people and lesbian and gay people are two different social groups with different identities, different histories, different issues.
There is no logical reason to include a group of people who believe that transwomen are women/transmen are men with people who are sexually attracted to members of their own sex.

'LGBTQ' doesn't make sense.

How is asserting that some men are women 'safeguarding' women's rights?
By removing the social categories 'women as in biological women', specific women's rights as such disappear.

The GRA2015 created the legal fiction that some men are women, and that all they have to do to become women is to say so. The law is sometimes an ass, but that beats Banaher.

Hard-won Sex Equality legislation which protected the specific rights of women - and men, of course - were retrospectively re-interpreted, so 'sex' is replaced by 'gender', and gender means.... the kind of vague abstract stuff that the law doesn't usually get mixed up with, but it certainly no longer means biological sex.
Sex is no longer a protected category in Irish equality legislation.
In other words, women - and men - in Ireland have recently lost the specific rights that used to be guaranteed by law.

I don't see that as progress, and I don't see LGBTQ activists rallying to ensure that women's rights are restored in law.

totino · 21/10/2026 10:28

Shortshriftandlethal · 21/10/2026 10:11

You asked when this approach ( not referring to women as patients) had ever been considered a feminist one.

To me, the moment you are admitted to a hospital and become a patient you lose your individuality and become processed into the sytem. You become institutionalised very quickly.

Edited

Thanks for telling me. I associate the idea of birth being "natural" for women because we are "built for it" strongly with a paternal way of downplaying the dangers, but I understand the idea of wanting to reclaim it.