Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"I don't need you to believe I'm a woman"...but I still get whatever I want

85 replies

WeeBisom · 11/08/2026 15:04

https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/i-dont-need-you-to-believe-im-a-woman

I've just read this article which was gushingly endorsed by Jesse Singal. The author is a non-passing TIM who admits that he isn't really a woman and hasn't really changed sex. And it's ok, he doesn't need us to believe he's a woman! Despite that, even though he's not a woman, and knows he's not a woman, he still claims that he has 'rights' to have access to women's spaces and services. We don't have to believe he's a woman, but we have to be fine with letting him do whatever he wants and taking all our stuff anyway.

His argument for being allowed to use women's toilets boils down to 'freedom': it's more free to not police spaces and let people do what they want, than to have boundaries in place. There is no analysis whatsoever of why toilets and spaces are segregated by sex. No analysis of safety or dignity risks to women. The thought that women might just not want to hang out in spaces with males doesn't cross his mind.

I think he's right to say that the mantra of 'trans women are women' doesn't work, and people don't believe it. But where the argument falls flat is his insistence that even though he's not really a woman, and no one has to believe it, he STILL is entitled to women's rights.

I don’t need you to believe I’m a woman

The important thing is that you believe in my rights

https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/i-dont-need-you-to-believe-im-a-woman

OP posts:
ProtectTransKids · 12/08/2026 23:09

I'm living proof you can identify and even be a woman, but still be the man of the house.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/08/2026 23:18

Yes dear, of course you are. I'm sure it's a lovely house,.

moto748e · 12/08/2026 23:31

Damn your CSN earworm! 😀

BezMark · 13/08/2026 07:56

The 'as long as they pass' thing doesn't stand up to a minute's scrutiny and it's strange to see someone who is smart enough to type on the internet use it.

What about all the males with strong cross sex gender feelings who don't pass (arguably the vast majority of them). Are we just throwing them all under the bus because their bone structure, hairline, massive hands, adam's apple, deep voice, posture, irrepressible air of male entitlement, or whatever it is prevents them from entering the holy gates of Passhalla? What if someone can pass in dim lighting on a good day with full slap, but they woke up today and didn't have the spoons to get all womansuited up because their chronic fatigue or dysphoria was really bad? Are they off the team?

We cannot make laws that operate on the basis of some kind of subjective beauty contest. That's not fair on anyone.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 13/08/2026 13:36

ProtectTransKids · 12/08/2026 23:09

I'm living proof you can identify and even be a woman, but still be the man of the house.

I'm living proof that one can identify a woman. Most women can, with no trouble at all.

JellySaurus · 13/08/2026 14:22

ProtectTransKids · 12/08/2026 23:09

I'm living proof you can identify and even be a woman, but still be the man of the house.

Rather a sexist, misogynistic view.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 13/08/2026 14:29

Rather a grammatically challenged view, too.

viques · 13/08/2026 19:45

ProtectTransKids · 12/08/2026 13:41

Some men are pregnant right now, many have even given birth. Look it up, do your own research.

Oh, you mean TIW! Who have retained working wombs that like the working wombs of women all over the world for many thousands of years have grown babies? This is why language is so important, if we use the terms woman and man to describe TIM and TIW then that leads to all sorts of ridiculous statements and situations like Freddie McConnell trying to get registered as the father of children that they have given birth to.

viques · 13/08/2026 19:53

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 13/08/2026 13:36

I'm living proof that one can identify a woman. Most women can, with no trouble at all.

Me too! Honestly, it just sort of comes naturally to me. I don't have to think about it or anything.

moto748e · 13/08/2026 23:02

Some men are pregnant right now

Nope. Why do we have to listen to this rubbish? No man has ever been pregnant in the history of humanity.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page