Most 'trans' people are non binary - EU survey

This is Glenna Goldis reminding us of the disconnect when medical experts define ‘gender’ . She was the Assistant NY attorney general.

https://x.com/womenarereals/status/2081788633980506473?s=46

here is an interview

https://x.com/stellaomalley3/status/1967613627902607594?s=46

Yes, same guy.

Isn’t he the one that equates womanhood with blank eyes & an expectant arse, or some such shit? Sounds like internalised homophobia.

Not just "respect", but respect it by specifically treating like it can be swapped into the place of physical sex in law and society.

Which is to me far more significant than the unfalsifyablity of inner feelings.

After all, religious conviction is equally unfalsifyable and we can still create laws and protections around it.

It is specifically the overreach of requiring trans identities to be accomodated in specific ways and with specific language that downplays or ignores the risks, challenges, history, lived experiences and needs that pertain to sex that cannot IMO be justified by any of the claims trans people and TRAs make for gender.

The issue to me is not what "gender" supposdly is, but what it is not.

But... I can't help but wonder if it could be real for a handful of them? Could there be a "hardware", heritable element that makes both parent and child feel trans?

Equally, we could say its virus-like and contagious, and thats why lots of school children in the same class have it.

If a parent is on board with supporting their child or husband transition, they are more likely to see non conformity or feelings in themselves as been trans. If they are against it they won't.

"If I could be desirable, I could be loved."

Wow, talk about having very sad and very heavy psychological issues 😨! That's literally the kind of people who should not be made to transition, because their problem has nothing to do with being trans in the first place! They just latched onto it as a solution to an entirely different problem.

Yes but I bet they see it as some sort of awakening, rather than the grubby and creepy way it comes across to anyone else.

Well quite.

That would make it cross dressing/a lifestyle choice. I doubt he sees it like that either.

Exactly, it comes from:

“everyone has a gender identity, most people are “cis”, some are “trans” and I don’t identify with being a woman or a man fully in the sexist way I conceptualise those “genders” so I in my specialness am non binary, unlike all those mundane stereotype people”.

Didn’t Andrea Long Chu admit that sissy porn made him trans. Not convinced he believed it was innate.

Occam's Razor suggests that in the vast majority of those parent-child cases, it's simply that the parent has bought into transgenderism, and is applying it to themselves as well as their child.

But... I can't help but wonder if it could be real for a handful of them? Could there be a "hardware", heritable element that makes both parent and child feel trans? It's not unknown, for example, for parents of autistic kids to end up being officially diagnosed as autistic themselves, and several genes involved in autism have been found already. So if studies were done on trans people, would they unveil some similar phenomenon? It would be much rarer than the current "trans kid" wave would suggest, but who knows, maybe there's something to it?

I wouldn't bet much on it, though.

There is very little consistency so a declaration that someone is “non binary” is meaningless and can’t be pinned down to anything specific. It’s not a bug, it’s a feature.

A lot of people use non binary as simply the umbrella term for “agender”, “genderqueer”, “gender fluid” “multi gender” etc etc.

Me too. I think it’s a type of pipeline among parents of “trans kids”.

There is a hint of it Empress, but I also suspect we have seen other cases as well. Where after a child has announced they are trans, a mother has followed with their own announcement.

And how many times have we seen siblings within the same family, or a father and a child.

Considering I have watched as one by one a group of 5 out of 7 friends declare they are transgender, I still find it very concerning that this dynamic is dismissed by those who desperately need to maintain the 'being trans is innate' line.

NB means anything the NB person wants it to. If you don’t agree you’re a monster.

This poster reminds me strongly of Amanda Jette Knox. Her partner & child both identified as trans so she went from nonbinary to identifying as male.

This poster has many fantasies not least that they have a trans identifying daughter.

I think that poster may not know as much about gender nonsense as many of us do. She's been talking about NB as though it's something she's only just discovered, so it's all very new to her.

That's what I said. Also, the logic of NB without a gender sounds as if gender is now binary rather than a spectrum.

I don't feel I have a gender, which is why I identify as nb

I thought someone who didn't feel they had a gender was agender, and someone who is NB does have a gender, which is non-binary gender.