Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

New Zealand nurse needs help

78 replies

anyolddinosaur · 15/06/2026 07:29

Being supported by the New Zealand version of the Free Speech Union who say

"Cath Simpson has spent more than 25 years as a registered nurse.
In August, she will appear before the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal - not for anything she did caring for a patient, but for a handful of posts she wrote on her own personal account, in her own time.
Those posts were her lawful opinions on matters of public debate - Covid, abortion, gender and politics - the kind of views thousands of New Zealanders hold and share every day.

One member of the public complained, then declined to take the matter any further. That should have been the end of it.
Instead the Nursing Council pressed on, engaging a King's Counsel to argue that a nurse's private political views make her a "risk to public safety."

There is no allegation she harmed anyone. A quarter-century of care now hangs on what she posted online.
This is not what professional regulators were built to do.

Their job is to protect the public from incompetent or dishonest practice - not to police the private opinions of the people they license. Once they cross that line, no professional's voice is safe: not a nurse's, not a teacher's, not yours.
The Free Speech Union is working to end this for good.

We are backing a Regulated Professions Neutrality Bill, led by our Chair Stephen Franks, to draw a hard line these regulators cannot cross - part of our wider work defending professionals across health, law and education."

Searching for part of that text should find a garden.

OP posts:
lcakethereforeIam · 15/06/2026 08:57

I think support is being asked as part of a solution to a bigger problem. From the crowdfunder

We are backing a Regulated Professions Neutrality Bill, led by our Chair Stephen Franks, to draw a hard line these regulators cannot cross - part of our wider work defending professionals across health, law and education.

But laws take time, and Cath's hearing is in August. She cannot wait.

The most urgent thing we can do right now is defend her - and we are supporting her defence in full.

You need not agree with a word Cath wrote to see what is at stake.

I agree I'd like to know what she wrote. If it was something egregiously horrible she might not be the best poster girl for the campaign.

TheHateUGive · 15/06/2026 07:46

What did she say about covid? We had that one nurse here whi was telling people it was all a lie. Also abortion? What was she saying? It could have been anything from i would never have an abortion to women who have abortions will burn in hell. So what was it?

Arlanymor · 15/06/2026 07:36

It very much depends on what she said doesn't it? I thought we pretty much didn't want our medical professionals to be overtly political because that leads to things like women being called 'chest feeders'. A quick google shows that she said something about Te Pāti Māori MPs... but interestingly doesn't say what. I sincerely hope it wasn't something that could be construed as racist, given that she has to provide care to Māori patients. Without context you can't possibly ask for people to blindly support someone without any information on what it is they have expressed. Freedom of speech, doesn't include freedom to incite hatred.