Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Be Kind 2.0 and the "Persuasive TRA"

483 replies

BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 01/06/2026 12:00

This is a spinoff from another thread so as not to derail the original.

I thought it would be helpful to have a separate thread to discuss, and document, a phenomenon I have been seeing more regularly recently: the Persuasive TRA.

It occurred to me, after a few posters noted that the recent U-turns by a couple of politicians, and the wheedling TRA responses to the EHRC guidance, were akin to an abuser changing tactics and also asking us to "help" them in the new single-sex regime, that the whole thing is starting to pan out exactly as an abusive relationship often does. When is the most dangerous time for a woman in an abusive relationship? Normally, when she is leaving.

Well, women are leaving the abusive relationship with non-reality that men forced upon us some 15 years ago, and I would argue that now might be our most dangerous/difficult moment.

This is what I posted on the other thread:

I'm starting to see a bit more of what I am calling (in my own head) "Persuasive TRA." Now that they have lost everything that they bullied women for, some activists seem to be changing tack. Women must now fix the situation that TRAs have found themselves in. It seems to pivot on a sort of Be Kind 2.0.

I think women who have been in the game long enough will see through it, but we should be watchful. Stonewall is pivoting, activists are pivoting, and they will be preying on women's socialized kindness: watch for the destination and be on your guard.

I have read several posters on different threads appealing to everyone (women) to help calm trans-identified people's (men's) fears about what this new reality will look like, what it will mean for them (the men) now that they can't just do whatever they want anymore. What about the men's toilets? Are they safe? Where will they go? (Who will fix this problem?)

Well, apparently it is a problem that women can fix, if they just take a moment to think about it. Trans-identified men will be unsafe in the men's, so women need to join the fight to give these men something of their own.

Notice the pivot? The pleading? If you just... If you weren't so.... It can be different if you just... Sound familiar? To any woman who is in, or has escaped from, an abusive relationship, this will be all too familiar.

This is Be Kind 2.0. It's very similar to the original, except that instead of being forced to enjoy our abuse, we are being asked to fix it. And the "Persuasive TRAs" seem to be mobilizing, from what I have seen.

It won't start in the middle (with the women); it will start at the top (infiltrating government, think tanks, charities, etc.) and the bottom (schools). But they will use women to get this moving. Why not? It worked so well last time. And I believe that organizations like Stonewall will be leading the charge: the campaign can be something like Safe Spaces for Trans+ : All of Us Together.

If anyone else has seen this in action, it might be useful to keep a record of it here.

I imagine this thread will eventually be taken over by activists, but, until then, I would be interested in your thoughts.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 27/06/2026 17:13

EmpressaurusKitty · 27/06/2026 16:54

And they wonder why we need the LGB Alliance?

It's the wording I find so intriguing! Are they admitting that trans-identified people have an image problem? So, they're blaming LGB people. Not specifically women for once. Interesting.

Why not blame the activists for their poor image? Because they still need them.

OP posts:
BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 27/06/2026 17:11

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 27/06/2026 16:47

I feel genuinely sorry for that one; I think he has started to realise just what an ass he is being, but can't work out how to stop without looking as if he has "lost". On of his mates needs to take him to a pub and get him drunk, and then let him cry on his shoulder and go "waaah!"

It does seem like he's digging himself a hole, but a lot of it reads like "Oh, I don't know anything about UK law, so I'd better go look something up." Not realizing, or ever understanding, that posters know a lot more about it than you can find easily online! I've really only caught the last few pages, I've been "stuck" on another thread.

OP posts:
EmpressaurusKitty · 27/06/2026 16:54

BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 27/06/2026 16:43

And a doozy from the "arguing with a Terf" thread:

[my bold]
An LGBT organisation's purpose is to ensure the needs of everyone under the queer umbrella, and working on the image of trans people (which becomes the image of the entire community by association)

LGB people need to make the T look better! It's apparently right up our alley, and the raison d'être for all LGBT organizations.

And they wonder why we need the LGB Alliance?

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 27/06/2026 16:47

I feel genuinely sorry for that one; I think he has started to realise just what an ass he is being, but can't work out how to stop without looking as if he has "lost". On of his mates needs to take him to a pub and get him drunk, and then let him cry on his shoulder and go "waaah!"

BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 27/06/2026 16:43

And a doozy from the "arguing with a Terf" thread:

[my bold]
An LGBT organisation's purpose is to ensure the needs of everyone under the queer umbrella, and working on the image of trans people (which becomes the image of the entire community by association)

LGB people need to make the T look better! It's apparently right up our alley, and the raison d'être for all LGBT organizations.

OP posts:
BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 27/06/2026 11:11

Some choice examples of tactics from recent threads that I have noticed, to add to the ever-growing list:

Recognising one is trans and therefore different but valid [a pivot to persuade women that trans-identified men are not saying they are actually women? is this trying to row back years of failed pressurization, in view of recent court losses?]

which doesn't sit logically alongside the next one:

male with a female soul [I think it used to be "male with woman-gendered soul" - so this may be an old tactic dressed up in new terms (man is not just "woman" but actually "female")]

Typical (common) behaviours to a sex isn't the same as stereotypical (expectations) behaviours [this has been argued before, but the "common vs. stereotypical" dichotomy seems to be making more of an appearance lately]

And another phenomenon I've seen popping up very recently:

the Persuasive TERF - these appear to be TRAs who mostly propound GC views when it's just natter, thereby establishing their "credentials," but work to undermine good news stories by regularly pointing out minor flaws in outcomes, sowing doubt in posters' optimism.

There seem to be one or two regulars who do this. I have experienced it personally on a few of my posts.

It may simply be pessimism or irritation that one poster made a good news point that another poster wished they had been able to make first. Or it could simply be a different point of view. But some of it seems carefully devised to deflect from, or to remove, optimism in the achievements that women have made recently.

OP posts:
BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 23/06/2026 14:51

A funny one today, just because it's hotter in London that the Fifth Circle of Hell:

(with thanks to @TheywontletmehavethenameIwant

The cause seems to have gone from No Debate to If you can't baffle them with 'trans' science bore them with complete bullshit.

OP posts:
BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 20/06/2026 19:45

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 20/06/2026 19:40

Oh you beat me to it, I was just pondering if that one was just a proper wet lettuce or a new tactic of hand wringing Cassandra-like and wailing "they've won so why bother", waves white flag etc.

It really, really started out so badly, but they seem to have recruited someone else to do the responses now. The first poster was just diabolically bad.

OP posts:
BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 20/06/2026 19:44

murasaki · 20/06/2026 19:40

I haven't enjoyed one so much since yesterday's misunderstanding of Stalingrad. Is the communal braincell on annual leave?

What braincell? Did I miss something?
It truly is The Thread to End All Threads!

OP posts:
EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 20/06/2026 19:40

BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 20/06/2026 19:28

If you can bear it, this thread is The Persuasive TRA on steroids (be warned, it is a very strange thread, mostly reads as if AI generated, and sometimes reads as though there is more than one person responding):

Transgender women will not be prosecuted in the use of women’s single sex facilities | Mumsnet

I suspect the thread will just start to go downhill from here on in, with responses becoming increasingly incoherent, as they already are.

Some choice examples of "persuasion " from the thread below. Enjoy!

Transgender people have spent years transitioning and why stop now?

The reality is people can be angry and upset and take action with violence and take lives. [ok, so that's more like a threat]

I doubt staff or management will police single sex spaces.

Transgender women on medication will be threatened with violence going in the men’s spaces.

Transgender women will not care about being prosecuted. It is persecution in the public eye. [actually, the use of the term "persecution" is quite clever here, haven't heard that before. Harks back to the days of the days of the Cathars or the Spanish Inquisition]

It takes courage to prosecute and it is unsafe. Cancel culture is alive. [sounds vaguely like another threat]

It is easier to not notice a transgender woman in the women’s space and go on with your life. [this is my second fav, just pretend you don't notice!]

We need to be honest. I have a daughter to support and I need my job to pay the bills and I can’t afford to do that if I start policing the women’s spaces.

It will be the disabled toilets business will use as third and fourth spaces. The toilet will be clogged or dirty so it will be bad for disabled people. :(

A risk assessment was carried out and the men’s is not 💯 safe for transgender women of risk of harm.

I’ve met trans women and they respect women’s rights.

Transgender women have won.

[...And my all time fav... drumroll please...] - We need a truce of sorts.

And there it is, ladies and germs:

THEY WANT A TRUCE.

<giggles>

Oh you beat me to it, I was just pondering if that one was just a proper wet lettuce or a new tactic of hand wringing Cassandra-like and wailing "they've won so why bother", waves white flag etc.

murasaki · 20/06/2026 19:40

I haven't enjoyed one so much since yesterday's misunderstanding of Stalingrad. Is the communal braincell on annual leave?

murasaki · 20/06/2026 19:37

It is truly the thread of all the talents. I keep meaning to start dinner but it's addictive....

BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 20/06/2026 19:28

If you can bear it, this thread is The Persuasive TRA on steroids (be warned, it is a very strange thread, mostly reads as if AI generated, and sometimes reads as though there is more than one person responding):

Transgender women will not be prosecuted in the use of women’s single sex facilities | Mumsnet

I suspect the thread will just start to go downhill from here on in, with responses becoming increasingly incoherent, as they already are.

Some choice examples of "persuasion " from the thread below. Enjoy!

Transgender people have spent years transitioning and why stop now?

The reality is people can be angry and upset and take action with violence and take lives. [ok, so that's more like a threat]

I doubt staff or management will police single sex spaces.

Transgender women on medication will be threatened with violence going in the men’s spaces.

Transgender women will not care about being prosecuted. It is persecution in the public eye. [actually, the use of the term "persecution" is quite clever here, haven't heard that before. Harks back to the days of the days of the Cathars or the Spanish Inquisition]

It takes courage to prosecute and it is unsafe. Cancel culture is alive. [sounds vaguely like another threat]

It is easier to not notice a transgender woman in the women’s space and go on with your life. [this is my second fav, just pretend you don't notice!]

We need to be honest. I have a daughter to support and I need my job to pay the bills and I can’t afford to do that if I start policing the women’s spaces.

It will be the disabled toilets business will use as third and fourth spaces. The toilet will be clogged or dirty so it will be bad for disabled people. :(

A risk assessment was carried out and the men’s is not 💯 safe for transgender women of risk of harm.

I’ve met trans women and they respect women’s rights.

Transgender women have won.

[...And my all time fav... drumroll please...] - We need a truce of sorts.

And there it is, ladies and germs:

THEY WANT A TRUCE.

<giggles>

Transgender women will not be prosecuted in the use of women’s single sex facilities | Mumsnet

You can support transgender rights or not but the law isn’t itself politics. Transgender women will not be prosecuted in the use of women’s single sex...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5544790-transgender-women-will-not-be-prosecuted-in-the-use-of-womens-single-sex-facilities

OP posts:
TrainedByTheBiddyMafia · 20/06/2026 17:25

And frankly my message to men like my husband who are uncomfortable with them in the men’s toilets is

‘I don’t fucking care, they are men which makes them a problem for men to solve’

TrainedByTheBiddyMafia · 20/06/2026 17:21

EdithStourton · 20/06/2026 08:37

So we have to be nice to men who didn't stand up to the more aggressive elements in their midst? Because there were precious few moderate voices.

And we still come back to how do you tell and inbuilt male physical advantage.

How can you tell that the man in a nice dress going into the ladies loos/ changing rooms is not a pervert?
How can you tell that the convicted criminal with a penis is 'genuinely' trans and not going to prey on women once he is sent to a women's prison?
How do you negate the inbuilt physical advantage of a bloke in a skirt taking part in women's sports?

Until we can deal with those issues, transwomen can stay out of female spaces.

They are men and they just need to stay out of all female spaces for ever. I don’t care if they think they’re the ‘nice’ TW, there is nothing they can do that means they aren’t men. I interact with them politely as I do anyone else when I encounter them day to day but I’ve never met one where they weren’t sexually creepy in some way so I will never want one around in a situation where I’m vulnerable.

EdithStourton · 20/06/2026 08:37

JadeLeader · 20/06/2026 01:34

"they think we're so stupid we'll forget the threads of violence and take pity on them"

Because absolutely all TRAs are absolutely identical and there is absolutely no room for nuance, right?

So we have to be nice to men who didn't stand up to the more aggressive elements in their midst? Because there were precious few moderate voices.

And we still come back to how do you tell and inbuilt male physical advantage.

How can you tell that the man in a nice dress going into the ladies loos/ changing rooms is not a pervert?
How can you tell that the convicted criminal with a penis is 'genuinely' trans and not going to prey on women once he is sent to a women's prison?
How do you negate the inbuilt physical advantage of a bloke in a skirt taking part in women's sports?

Until we can deal with those issues, transwomen can stay out of female spaces.

Shedmistress · 20/06/2026 08:27

JadeLeader · 20/06/2026 01:34

"they think we're so stupid we'll forget the threads of violence and take pity on them"

Because absolutely all TRAs are absolutely identical and there is absolutely no room for nuance, right?

Nuanced threats of violence or nuanced attitudes of men who say they are women? What nuance?

Every man who says he is a woman is a threat to women the same as every man is a threat because nobody knows which men will flip and which women they will flip on.

murasaki · 20/06/2026 01:47

No, of course not all the same, but we agree on these issues.

Yes, happy to be called a TERF, as I do not want biological men claiming the word woman or being in single sex female spaces. I am happy to include transmen in my feminism as they are women and i am glad they have protedlcted maternity rights etc. But not men claiming to be women.

JadeLeader · 20/06/2026 01:42

murasaki · 20/06/2026 01:40

There's not much nuance in a threat of rape with a splintery rolling pin, as made by one of the TRAs finest.

Not, I strongly suspect, for the first time in your life, you've completely missed the point.

Pop question; do you believe all TERFs are the same? Do you even identify yourself with that label? What does it mean to you?

murasaki · 20/06/2026 01:40

There's not much nuance in a threat of rape with a splintery rolling pin, as made by one of the TRAs finest.

FrippEnos · 20/06/2026 01:39

JadeLeader · 20/06/2026 01:34

"they think we're so stupid we'll forget the threads of violence and take pity on them"

Because absolutely all TRAs are absolutely identical and there is absolutely no room for nuance, right?

What "nuance" would you like to see?

If a trans person or ally knows that tsupports a group that not only intimidates and threatens violence but have people that have acted upon those threats of violence then they are supporting that violence.

JadeLeader · 20/06/2026 01:34

Daleksatemyshed · 01/06/2026 12:19

I'm glad it's not just me Op, I've noticed a change of tone, not from all of them, but quite a few doing the couldn't we get along, can't you see if you just accepted us as your fellow women it would all be fine. They know the tides running against them now, they think we're so stupid we'll forget the threads of violence and take pity on them.

"they think we're so stupid we'll forget the threads of violence and take pity on them"

Because absolutely all TRAs are absolutely identical and there is absolutely no room for nuance, right?

TrainedByTheBiddyMafia · 19/06/2026 19:41

Shedmistress · 01/06/2026 13:14

I would encourage everyone to reflect back to male TRA allies that they should be starting 'You can pee next to me' campaigns and arrange to accompany their men who say they are women friends into the male toilets for safety.

Maybe they can make their own badges and hand them out at work?

This is an interesting one, it took me a while to get through to my ‘DH’ that trans activists declaring these men were women was a real issue that was negatively affecting me. He now accepts I was right but he doesn’t want to share toilets with these men either now he has seem some of the news reports I’ve provided him to show why women have good reason to be uncomfortable.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 19/06/2026 16:57

Thelnebriati · 19/06/2026 15:53

I'm a massive cynic, and I suspect part of the reason for the recent change of tactic from aggressive to persuasive is that Andy Burnham wants to be PM.

Huh?

BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 19/06/2026 15:57

Thelnebriati · 19/06/2026 15:53

I'm a massive cynic, and I suspect part of the reason for the recent change of tactic from aggressive to persuasive is that Andy Burnham wants to be PM.

Interesting, although I'm not catching your drift? Can you elaborate please?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread