Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Why do GC arguments focus on single-sex spaces rather than sex discrimination?

69 replies

ariel333 · 27/05/2026 19:14

From my understanding of the Supreme Court ruling, sex has to mean biological sex in the act because that’s the main reason why women are discriminated against, so that is the characteristic that has to be protected. If trans women are included as women then biological sex is no longer the protected characteristic but gender identity - and employers could go back to asking women if they intend to get pregnant in job interviews - as they used to before the Sex Discrimination Act.
This seems to me to be a pretty good argument for the necessity of sex meaning biological sex but it doesn’t seem to be used. The focus is much more on single sex spaces. Is there a reason for this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Taztoy · 04/10/2026 16:57

My rape, and subsequent need for single sex spaces and healthcare stopped me being kind.

Keeptoiletssafe · 04/10/2026 11:34

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/10/2026 11:02

It’s actually my main argument against the GRA. Granting “woman” certificates to men changes the definition of what a woman is. I’ve been honest before that I didn’t expect the SC judgment to turn out as it did. I expected them to rule that under the EA the certificate granted them women’s sex based rights except in extraordinary circumstances. I’ve never been more glad to have got it wrong.

I was so worried it would lead to all toilet cubicles becoming private. I know what a disaster this has been for health and safety.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/10/2026 11:02

It’s actually my main argument against the GRA. Granting “woman” certificates to men changes the definition of what a woman is. I’ve been honest before that I didn’t expect the SC judgment to turn out as it did. I expected them to rule that under the EA the certificate granted them women’s sex based rights except in extraordinary circumstances. I’ve never been more glad to have got it wrong.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/10/2026 10:59

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 09:24

You could end MVAWG tomorrow and make all toilets mixed sex, and ‘TWAW’ would still destroy women’s rights because it removes the concept of sex from equality law, and going back to the OP, I do think this shoukd be stressed more.

Stage 1) Greens/Libdems/SNP/labour coalition removes concept of sex discrimination from law.

Stage 2) The economic policies have been a disaster so the pendulum swings the other way and Reform/restore control government. They decide that maternity leave over burdens employers and tax payers and privatise healthcare and there is now no duty to provide any form of birth control which is a matter of conscience for the provider.

All employment rights are rolled back, but there is no way to establish how women are affected by this because ‘sex’ is not a concept recognised in law or policy.

Women lose economic power, and it is proposed that voting rights should be attached to paying tax.

Society quietly reverts back to restricting women to domesticity.

There is no explicit order that women should be second class citizens, but there also is no way to prevent them from being second class citizens.

Edited

Absolutely this.

Keeptoiletssafe · 04/10/2026 10:58

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 09:24

You could end MVAWG tomorrow and make all toilets mixed sex, and ‘TWAW’ would still destroy women’s rights because it removes the concept of sex from equality law, and going back to the OP, I do think this shoukd be stressed more.

Stage 1) Greens/Libdems/SNP/labour coalition removes concept of sex discrimination from law.

Stage 2) The economic policies have been a disaster so the pendulum swings the other way and Reform/restore control government. They decide that maternity leave over burdens employers and tax payers and privatise healthcare and there is now no duty to provide any form of birth control which is a matter of conscience for the provider.

All employment rights are rolled back, but there is no way to establish how women are affected by this because ‘sex’ is not a concept recognised in law or policy.

Women lose economic power, and it is proposed that voting rights should be attached to paying tax.

Society quietly reverts back to restricting women to domesticity.

There is no explicit order that women should be second class citizens, but there also is no way to prevent them from being second class citizens.

Edited

There is a logistical problem on how to turn all women’s cubicles into separate rooms that face directly out onto a corridor. Unless you scrap health and safety and building legislation, change decades worth of British Standards and change the Sexual Offences Act and have a free for all in any design, sod H&S.

As we know from history, women and girls have always avoided unisex toilets.

The urinary leash pulls again.

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 09:24

You could end MVAWG tomorrow and make all toilets mixed sex, and ‘TWAW’ would still destroy women’s rights because it removes the concept of sex from equality law, and going back to the OP, I do think this shoukd be stressed more.

Stage 1) Greens/Libdems/SNP/labour coalition removes concept of sex discrimination from law.

Stage 2) The economic policies have been a disaster so the pendulum swings the other way and Reform/restore control government. They decide that maternity leave over burdens employers and tax payers and privatise healthcare and there is now no duty to provide any form of birth control which is a matter of conscience for the provider.

All employment rights are rolled back, but there is no way to establish how women are affected by this because ‘sex’ is not a concept recognised in law or policy.

Women lose economic power, and it is proposed that voting rights should be attached to paying tax.

Society quietly reverts back to restricting women to domesticity.

There is no explicit order that women should be second class citizens, but there also is no way to prevent them from being second class citizens.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/10/2026 07:49

FlirtsWithRhinos · 02/10/2026 16:34

The "the employee might not be honest so there's no point" argument is bizarre.

"The employee might pretend they don't plan to commit fraud, so there's no point saying fraud won't be tolerated"

"The employee might pretend they don't plan to access confidential records they have no business accessing, so there's no point saying we need to comply with GDPR"

"The employee might claim to have skills that they do not, so there's no point in having required skills on the role definition"

Exactly!

highame · 03/10/2026 07:54

Dragging (excuse the pun) my mind back to around 2010, single sex spaces were not in the debate. The debate was about TIM being classed as women, without any debate. The panel/experts/psychologists in order to declare someone a woman were expecting anyone in the process of transitioning to live as a woman and that included all areas of their lives. This was all happening without women consenting to the process.

Before 2010, Cambridge (Newnham) was accepting TIM's without question.

Women at that time gave their tacit consent to men being in their spaces, because the majority of TIM's were body dysphoric, needing full surgery and medication, so, very few cases. Much of the current stuff grew out of autogynephilia which is a completely different issue. As far as I can tell, someone who experiences autogynephilia will want access to all spaces at all times for validation, for the buzz and wanting to see more of women's bodies in order to copy. Happy to be corrected on the bit about autogynephilia

FrippEnos · 02/10/2026 23:06

dinodart · 02/10/2026 19:42

passing has nothing to do with TW actually being women, i don't understand your point. it doesn't matter if transwomen or transmen can trick others into thinking they are a different sex than they are, it doesn't make them so. like are tomboys who dress like men and some people mistake as men actually men? no. i know a TW who passes really well, recently got "bottom surgery", not a woman tho, will never be.

One of the differences between then and now, is that trans sexuals used to police themselves and would take the new comers to one side and give them advice about what they were doing wrong.

Of course now with trans having changed so much, you no longer have to pass. Looking trans has become a thing in itself.

dinodart · 02/10/2026 19:42

PeachyDaisy · 27/05/2026 19:33

even the most TWAW person on an interview panel knows that a trans-identified man isn't actually a woman.

I think it is foolish to say that no TW could ever pass. Granted I think 99% of them don't but i do think there may be a small number that do (for example the show there's something about miriam, the guys were kissing miriam thinking it was a woman)

Edited

passing has nothing to do with TW actually being women, i don't understand your point. it doesn't matter if transwomen or transmen can trick others into thinking they are a different sex than they are, it doesn't make them so. like are tomboys who dress like men and some people mistake as men actually men? no. i know a TW who passes really well, recently got "bottom surgery", not a woman tho, will never be.

theilltemperedamateur · 02/10/2026 19:09

chirrupybird · 02/10/2026 15:33

Presumably a man turning up looking like a woman with a woman's name would be treated as a woman by an employer, they can't ask them to show their genitalia to prove they are a woman.

Employers need to know employees' sex, for safeguarding, DEI monitoring, and compliance with HSE regulations and EA2010 (particularly S158-9 and Schedule 9). An original birth certificate issued before age 18 is reliable.

Lougle · 02/10/2026 17:04

It's never been about being able to pee, has it? You take me to a room of women and ask who would prefer to pee in a stall next to another woman, or who would prefer to pee in an empty room. Take me to a room of women and ask who would prefer to strip off in front of other women, or who would prefer to strip off in a private room.

The reason this is an issue is the validation it gives to a person who has been given the right to be 'one of the gals'.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 02/10/2026 16:34

The "the employee might not be honest so there's no point" argument is bizarre.

"The employee might pretend they don't plan to commit fraud, so there's no point saying fraud won't be tolerated"

"The employee might pretend they don't plan to access confidential records they have no business accessing, so there's no point saying we need to comply with GDPR"

"The employee might claim to have skills that they do not, so there's no point in having required skills on the role definition"

Wishesandhorses · 02/10/2026 15:49

chirrupybird · 02/10/2026 15:33

Presumably a man turning up looking like a woman with a woman's name would be treated as a woman by an employer, they can't ask them to show their genitalia to prove they are a woman.

But recruitment can protect single sex spaces by making it clear to employees that there is no need to disclose BUT no one may enter spaces designated for a sex they are not. And intentional invasion of those spaces will result in disciplinary action. And lets be honest, the issue is not and has never been the theoretical men who look and behave so like women that nobody would ever know without DNA analysis. The whole issue and vast raft of issues for women have arisen from men who are very, very obviously men, behaving like men, looking like men and invading women's spaces.

The advice coming out around the time of the SCJ was as I remember, that there is obviously no need to bother proving whether the man in front of you lying his head off and shouting threats is actually the sex he obviously is; your job is to protect single sex spaces for the entire group with that characteristic. So suspicion or doubt is perfectly enough, and you offer said person your gender neutral space as their accessible alternative. Job done. If he wants to take you to court and prove at length he IS in fact female via a judge providing him with a DNA swab test - and let's face that isn't going to happen in any of the cases that pushed all these court judgments - then even so the employer has not discriminated against him because a perfectly accessible space was offered and available, and there was a duty to protect women's spaces without making a damn great huge time consuming and embarrassing song and dance about it for everyone.

ChequerToRed · 02/10/2026 15:43

Sex discrimination and misogyny are baked into the very heart of the trans movement. For all the ‘stunning and brave’ transwomen we see in the media, on those rare times when we see a transman who isn’t Elliot Paige it’s usually because they’re pregnant or had a baby. It reduces ‘woman’ down to nothing but the trappings and argues vociferously that the things that make actual women women are irrelevant. Trans women are only as prominent and listened to as they are because they’re men. Women are insulted and treated as badly as they are when they object to males in their spaces because they’re women.
There's nothing actually progressive about it at all.

chirrupybird · 02/10/2026 15:33

ariel333 · 27/05/2026 19:14

From my understanding of the Supreme Court ruling, sex has to mean biological sex in the act because that’s the main reason why women are discriminated against, so that is the characteristic that has to be protected. If trans women are included as women then biological sex is no longer the protected characteristic but gender identity - and employers could go back to asking women if they intend to get pregnant in job interviews - as they used to before the Sex Discrimination Act.
This seems to me to be a pretty good argument for the necessity of sex meaning biological sex but it doesn’t seem to be used. The focus is much more on single sex spaces. Is there a reason for this?

Presumably a man turning up looking like a woman with a woman's name would be treated as a woman by an employer, they can't ask them to show their genitalia to prove they are a woman.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/10/2026 15:29

Changing room in an American school with some little incel forcing teen girls to change in front of him. About 2014/15. I never bought into it but thats when I fully could see what a problem it was.

BackToLurk · 02/10/2026 15:25

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 02/10/2026 15:21

For me it was prisons & homelessness hostels, & the corruption of medicine.

I’ve been (briefly) homeless & who knows: I may yet find myself in prison, & we all need accurate medical information.

I went AWS > prisons > homelessness hostels > hostels more broadly > sport > data quite quickly with some overlap. TBH, toilets was quite far down. It was singlesextoilets (Not sure if that's the correct username) that got me thinking more about that provision.

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 02/10/2026 15:21

BackToLurk · 01/10/2026 13:33

For me all-women shortlists was my entry into the debate. Toilets came later.

For me it was prisons & homelessness hostels, & the corruption of medicine.

I’ve been (briefly) homeless & who knows: I may yet find myself in prison, & we all need accurate medical information.

Keeptoiletssafe · 02/10/2026 15:05

For me it was about why Approved Document T didn’t specify toilet door gaps for single sex toilets when I knew they saved lives. They can have them but they weren’t specifically mentioned. My design comments to the government, and those of a charities, were ignored. Then I analysed why and found out that transactivists preferences were overiding health and safety design features. It’s all there in documents. This came as a surprise.

I started looking at design and safety for all demographics and found the incidents of women and children being assaulted and raped in toilets of private designs very disturbing. As well as people dying in toilets and not even having a chance of being rescued in time because no one saw them.

Yet a private compartment is the toilet design we are getting more of, as a ‘solution’ to getting rid of the traditional single sex toilet washrooms with their cubicle door gaps for health and safety. We are designing-in crime.

For me, it’s about basic health and safety. ‘Inclusive’ toilets are not as healthy or safe as their designs focus on individual segregation and privacy.

If you want to get more into psychology/philosophy look up Marlow’s pyramid of needs for safe spaces. I want provision and that provision to be safe. Those are the very base levels for what is a basic necessity. You need them first. The self actualisation needs are much higher up.

p.s. There is no evidence to suggest that men are less safe going into men’s toilets if they are transwomen. What does make a difference to all men and boys is the design of the toilets.

teawamutu · 02/10/2026 08:46

FrippEnos · 01/10/2026 19:16

teawamutu

We make it damn clear that it's on men to do their bit to protect and accept their gender-nonconforming fellow men

Yet there is no evidence that men are doing anything to hurt their "gender-nonconforming fellow men".

If they were then it would be all over social media and the various pro TQ+ sites.

Yet they are very quiet on this "issue".

No, I agree there's no evidence.

But the main pretext for TIMs demanding access to women's spaces is that they'd be at risk from men, given that almost all sexual and other violence is committed by males and you can't tell which ones are going to be a problem (YES. WE KNOW. THAT'S WHY YOU CAN'T COME IN etc etc etc).

So men have to do their bit to be more welcoming. Or not, and point out that it's all bullshit. Don't care. Just don't do the 'ah come on girls, shove up' bit.

Not women's problem to solve.

FrippEnos · 01/10/2026 19:16

teawamutu

We make it damn clear that it's on men to do their bit to protect and accept their gender-nonconforming fellow men

Yet there is no evidence that men are doing anything to hurt their "gender-nonconforming fellow men".

If they were then it would be all over social media and the various pro TQ+ sites.

Yet they are very quiet on this "issue".

Wishesandhorses · 01/10/2026 19:05

Well we could do the whole dance in miniature

They just want to pee!
Yes. So do women who can't do mixed sex spaces.

Vulnerable men!
Yes. Gay ones. Disabled ones. Young ones. Are they all coming in the women's?

But dignity, privacy!
Yes. Women who need single sex spaces need that too. What do we do with them when the women who feel savourish towards a particular group of men have made those women excluded from facilities and resources?

Mixed sex spaces are othering
Now we're getting to it. So it isn't about peeing or access - because other vulnerable people and people with opposite sex carers etc would benefit too - although there's a MNetter with strong research about the much lower safety of these necessarily single use enclosed rooms they're still in some cases a better provision and at least the choice/dignity requested.

So the actual issue after all this, ends up being, a man who identifies as a woman is deeply hurt and invalidated that a facility exists for biological women that he cannot enter, because this confirms that a man with a trans identity is not a real, actual woman.

And that is something that sadly, hopefully with support, he is going to have to learn to cope with.

He cannot trump the needs of women, because obvious sexism and equality. (Although plenty will argue that men just are more valuable than women, and women have no business saying no to men, particularly about their bodies. Hence why marital rape went on into the 90s.)

Those women have the same needs he does.

And women and gay legal protections in law cannot exist unless sex means sex.

So the only option to help and respect those people with gender identities is additional services and provision.

<Mega mix now follows>

IwantToRetire · 01/10/2026 18:42

Also, because like everything else, the argument is that men's rights are the most important to preserve, support.

Women are just being uppity and non supportive of men to be so trivial as to insist that as a sex class they have the right to women only facilities, services.

The sheer cheek of women think they have equality!

Just to repeat myself, never forget how easy it was for TW rights to get support from most of society was because it is built on the fundamental driving force in society the MRAs.

And in fact if anything the MRAs are now even more blatant than they were is you take what is happening in the virtual world as well as IRL.

The basis of women's oppression is their sex class. Anything that the oppressing sex class, men, can do to deny that reality is a useful tool.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 01/10/2026 17:29

TRAs are obsessed with getting transwomen access to the women's bogs so they keep dragging focus back to "but they just want to peeeeeee".

It's as simple as that.

I think it's the combination of something both very trivial but also very private that is so compelling. It's like the harem, the convent, the girls' school. It's a closed door where things they can't see happen. The secret everyday life of women they are sure must exist. They want to be right inside that mysterious feminine space.

I am far more concerned with what it means for women (in the original female sense) to disconnect the concept of "woman" culturally and linguisticly from the female body, and the utter wildness of a group of people who can look at the history and indeed current differences betwen outcomes for women and men and say "nope, no need to have separate and unique names for the male and female half of himanity, but by God we need a word that lumps transwomen's feelings and female bodies in together as basically the sane thing"

But TRAs never want to talk about that.