Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Why is it that the trans issue is the only one where people are cancelled if they disagree with it?

130 replies

TFImBackIn · 25/05/2026 16:12

I was thinking today how there are people who vote differently to me, who are carnivores or vegan, who believe in capital punishment, who believe in unregulated drugs, who do or don't believe in climate change, who follow different religions, who think nobody has ever landed on the moon and so on, but it's possible to have a discussion about it - even if that ends pretty briefly in "We'll have to agree to disagree on that" - and it doesn't end in someone being cancelled.

The trans debate is the only one - as far as I can see - that's not allowed to be debated. I've not heard of people disowning their families over any of the above topics. If someone disagrees with someone else on those topics - and a million others - nobody says they're being violent and they're afraid of them and need to get away from them and be safe.

What Rachel Dolezal told everyone she was black and people discovered she wasn't - and worse when she wanted to represent black women and their struggle - then black women everywhere were allowed to say she was wrong and that their struggle and lived experience wasn't hers. There was no argument at all - maybe Rachel muttered a bit about it but everyone felt free to ridicule her for taking that on.

How come, then, when a fifty-year old Philip Bunce - "Call me Pippa or Pips" - was ranked number 32 in Top 100 Women in Business, women weren't allowed to say that was unfair and that our struggle and lived experience wasn't his?

What is it about this particular issue that makes people want to silence us, when other topics can be freely discussed?

OP posts:
cheezncrackers · 25/05/2026 16:19

Very good points OP that I completely agree with.

Emptybath · 25/05/2026 16:18

Expand your horizons and you will find Jews for being Jewish, or anyone supporting the right of Israel to exist, or anyone or business even remotely connected to Israel are facing harassment, initimidation, ostracisation and cancellation on an even worse scale than GC women faced, terrible though that has been.

So no, it’s not just GC women.

Mmmnotsure · 25/05/2026 16:17

Because the people it punches down on are women.

EmpressaurusKitty · 25/05/2026 16:17

It’s a men’s rights issue.

Shedmistress · 25/05/2026 16:15

Because the activists are utterly demented?