Any recommended genderist writers?

Omg …

The context is what an individual personally values more in order to define themselves as in their sex or gender.

Omg …

The context is what an individual personally values more in order to define themselves as in their sex or gender.

So again, you’re claiming someone is men or woman depending on how strictly they adhere to regressive sexist stereotypes? How is sex a value based system?

Again, stereotypes & typical behaviours are two very different things. And I'm not claiming they are a man or woman its upto their values of whether sex or gender defines them more personally. Your values clearly consider sex to be a defining identity characteristic others don't.

So who decided these behaviours are “typical”
Noone decides they are typical by virtue of being the most expressed by an overwhelming majority. That's what typical means 'usually'.

"What gendered behaviours are “typical” for women then that would determine if someone is seen as a woman or not?"

The most common choices women make in terms of consumerism, employment, special interest & life choices are examples. You can google them yourself if they aren't obvious to you.

An individuals being an individual vary on what particular inclinations they have in common with women that would make them identify as one so I couldn't speak for all of them.

Sex is not a value based system.

It's a system to classify reproductive class across species based on scientific understanding.

Sex has consequences for male and female mammals, so in a limited number of situations we provide sex specific services.

We never provide gender specific services because there is no need.

So again, you’re claiming someone is men or woman depending on how strictly they adhere to regressive sexist stereotypes? How is sex a value based system? So who decided these behaviours are “typical”? If enough people do not adhere to them, surely that makes them “atypical”? What gendered behaviours are “typical” for women then that would determine if someone is seen as a woman or not?

I’m also concerned that Emily seems to only have gender stereotypes for men and women? What about the demi greybois? Or the Quoigender? What are the gender stereotypes for those @EmilyinEverton ?

Research on gendered choices is usually conducted in most egalitarian countries like Sweden to allow for more organic gendered inclinations to be measured which interestingly show even bigger differences than those with less freedom.

Research on gendered choices is usually conducted in most egalitarian countries like Sweden to allow for more organic gendered inclinations to be measured which interestingly show even bigger differences than those with less freedom.

Sex is not a value based system.

It's a system to classify reproductive class across species based on scientific understanding.

Sex has consequences for male and female mammals, so in a limited number of situations we provide sex specific services.

We never provide gender specific services because there is no need.

Research on gendered choices is usually conducted in most egalitarian countries like Sweden to allow for more organic gendered inclinations to be measured which interestingly show even bigger differences than those with less freedom.

Um, typical behaviours aren't expectations they are simply the most common behaviours to a particular sex so they are hardly rejected by everyone else.

So they can use the gender neutral, single sex spaces designated for their sex can’t they?

Like I said sex & gender are ultimately values based systems so one doesn't necessarily trump the other. Different countries globally have differing policies so there's no objectively correct action.

I think I might just identify as a tradwife and tell DH he’s now responsible for the money 😁

To be fair, I am quite happy to agree that the thing that makes me female is my reproductive system. The rest of me is just plain old human.

‘Typical’ behaviours are only ‘typical’ within specific cultural, geographical and/or historical contexts. That suggests someone’s transness is dependent on when and where they were born. Unlike their sex.

Um, typical behaviours aren't expectations they are simply the most common behaviours to a particular sex so they are hardly rejected by everyone else.

So they can use the gender neutral, single sex spaces designated for their sex can’t they?

Like I said sex & gender are ultimately values based systems so one doesn't necessarily trump the other. Different countries globally have differing policies so there's no objectively correct action.

Ewwwww that is the grossest, most sexist thing I’ve ever heard. REPRODUCTIVE FEMALE!!!! Did you mean to be so offensive? That is the most misogynistic thing the TRA has ever said. Reducing women to the ur reproductive organs? Wow!

So transpeople are basing their identity on sexist regressive stereotypes rejected by everyone else? That still does not make them anything but GNC members of their sex does it? And therefore, as they are not members of the opposite sex, they do not belong in the spaces designated for the sex class to which they do not belong. You said sex and gender were different. So they can use the gender neutral, single sex spaces designated for their sex can’t they?

TBH I'm so worn down by having been the only parent for so long, and having to make all the decisions, and worry about how I'm going to pay all the bills, and what I do when the DC are ill, that being a trad wife for a few days might be quite nice.

Only a few days mind you, I'm not very good at behaving myself either. But the break does sound tempting.

Because that's where self identification matters. What an individual identifies with more in terms of sex or gender can vary. IE a butch reproductive female may consider her reproductive traits a defining characteristic & identify as a cis woman or they may consider themselves a trans man because gender is their defining characteristic. Ultimately personal identity is a values based system.

Apparently so! I’m sobbing into my coffee here. My life is meaningless now.

Because that's where self identification matters. What an individual identifies with more in terms of sex or gender can vary. IE a butch reproductive female may consider her reproductive traits a defining characteristic & identify as a cis woman or they may consider themselves a trans man because gender is their defining characteristic. Ultimately personal identity is a values based system.

That's ironically stereotypical….& particularly convenient for those who feel 'challenged' by expressions of typical gender associations. It's interesting that those who seem most bothered by typical behaviours are those that don't express them ….some would say thats rooted in an insecurity complex.

The fact of the matter is typical behaviours are typical because most people are inclined towards them that's proven in consumerist, employment, life & special interest choices.

For people who like to pontificate about the delusions of others they sure do like to delude themselves about the obvious differences in gendered behaviour performed by most around the globe.