Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Gender Critical guy - How can I help the cause?

245 replies

MyShyCat · 16/05/2026 22:41

Hoping that the amazing women of Mumsnet can help me. I am firmly in the Gender Critical camp. I peaked many years ago after the birth of my daughter. I simply got to the point where I couldn't ignore the craziness that we were all being expected to accept. Amazing women on Youtube like Magdalen Berns, Posie Parker, Helen Joyce, Jo Bartosch, Arielle Scarcella and Kathleen Stock were able to perfectly articulate all the thoughts that were flying around my head.

Like many of us I have watched with horror as bit by bit the rights of women and girls have been systematically dismantled. There have undoubtedly been successes on our journey back to reality but Sall Grover's defeat the other day has really made me wobble.

My problem is I not sure what to do to help the cause. I feel like I should be more vocal or active - not exactly Bill Board Chris levels of "being out there" but I think I need to actually be a bit braver and make my voice heard.

If anyone has any suggestions as to how a 53 year-old father of a teenage girl can take a more active role in this fight, then I would love to hear more.

I'm not sure I can just carry on watching youtube clips and tutting anymore! All suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

I WOULD RATHER BE RUDE THAN A "F**KING LIAR."

OP posts:
singthing · 20/05/2026 20:34

MyShyCat · 20/05/2026 14:36

singthing... You OK hun?

Did you not like me pointing out that you didn't really care until you had a daughter, even though you said it yourself?

"...after the birth of my daughter. I simply got to the point where I couldn't ignore the craziness..."

If you just want praise for joining in, then you still don't really get it. That's fine, we all had to reach the peak, but maybe don't act otherwise.

MyShyCat · 20/05/2026 19:08

Ilikeanicecupofteainthemorning · 20/05/2026 18:33

you need to make male spaces welcoming to transwomen

eg- sticker in men's toilets- 'transwomen welcome here' 'transwomen safe here'

talk with other MEN about how to do this

obviously challenge misogyny in any form from other men

engage with all the men who think the correct opinion is TWAW etc, create the space for them to really think about what that means- not just to women but to gay boys and men

Interesting idea but I do wonder how possible it is to make Male Toilets attractive to Trans Women when actually the"attractive" bit for Trans women is simpy to inhabit women only spaces.

Thank-you everyone for all of the really useful ideas.

This is why I plucked up the courage to knock on the door of what someone described earlier as "a pit of vipers."

You have all been really kind with your time and not at all as scary as I thought you might be.

There just aren't any groups like this for blokes. Please do let me know if you hear of any Gender Critical, motorbike riding, rock-climbing, wine-drinking, father-of-daughters groups in the South West.

OP posts:
Ilikeanicecupofteainthemorning · 20/05/2026 18:33

you need to make male spaces welcoming to transwomen

eg- sticker in men's toilets- 'transwomen welcome here' 'transwomen safe here'

talk with other MEN about how to do this

obviously challenge misogyny in any form from other men

engage with all the men who think the correct opinion is TWAW etc, create the space for them to really think about what that means- not just to women but to gay boys and men

HenriettaSwanLeavitt · 20/05/2026 18:32

@MyShyCat You have twice been rude to respected FWR women on this thread. Please stop posting and re-read the thread.

Taztoy · 20/05/2026 18:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’m a survivor of a rape so violent that the police categorised it as attempted murder. I can’t describe it on here as it’s deleted on the grounds that it’s too upsetting for others to read. He raped me vaginally, orally and attempted to anally rape me. He also assaulted me. And did other things that, as I said, I can’t describe.

Your entitlement is showing.

Do your own leg work. Women arent support humans.

MyShyCat · 20/05/2026 18:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Taztoy · 20/05/2026 18:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I can assure you I am female.

Why do women have to do the work for you? can’t you figure it out for yourself?

PrizedPickledPopcorn · 20/05/2026 18:27

thekindoflovewemake · 20/05/2026 18:25

Well ain’t you the lucky one?

After discussing with a group of women of whom quite a few said they hadn’t been sexually assaulted, it became clear that the meaning of the phrase is rather a grey area.

A lot of them thought sexual assault just meant rape, when in fact it covers a multitude of actions (and once that was cleared up, it was a case of “I had that one boyfriend who forced me to do….”there was a guy in the pub who…” “there was that time when I was in a club and that guy” etc etc)

I thought exactly the same. She’s not being told about the reality of other people’s experience. So many women deny their reality of being regularly groped.

thekindoflovewemake · 20/05/2026 18:25

OrlandointheWilderness · 20/05/2026 16:26

@TransParentlyAnnoyedI hate to break your entirely made up statistics, but I’ve never been sexually assaulted. And I know far more women who haven’t than have.

Well ain’t you the lucky one?

After discussing with a group of women of whom quite a few said they hadn’t been sexually assaulted, it became clear that the meaning of the phrase is rather a grey area.

A lot of them thought sexual assault just meant rape, when in fact it covers a multitude of actions (and once that was cleared up, it was a case of “I had that one boyfriend who forced me to do….”there was a guy in the pub who…” “there was that time when I was in a club and that guy” etc etc)

Theeyeballsinthesky · 20/05/2026 18:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Tatzoy is a lovely long term poster here

you must know mumsnet is reputed to be a next of vipers and FWR the vipiest of it all!!

the emails to the gym sound a very good practical action

PrizedPickledPopcorn · 20/05/2026 18:24

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 20/05/2026 14:31

The 'gender critical' movement is founded on hollow, elitist fantasies of saviourism. That's why it appeals to you and you want more. It excuses cis men from examining their own attitudes, behaviours and violent peers in favour of blaming a minority.

It ignores several realities, notably that:

  • trans people are individuals, not a hive mind
  • trans people have always existed
  • trans women like & respect women, because they are women
  • trans men exist
  • the anti-trans movement is heftily funded by anti-abortion, misogynistic, deeply homophobic orgs who want to set precedents for challenging bodily autonomu
  • regret rate for transition is low
  • the vast, vast majority of sexual assaults against women in so-called 'safe spaces' (we have no safe spaces) are carried out by violent cis men - who usually face no consequences - and pretending that banning trans women will fix that is patronising, sexist & wrong
  • very few trans people do sport
  • being trans is normal

Being anti-trans isn't activism. It's bigotry.

What bollox. All the accusations you make against so called cis men are exactly as relevant to men with trans identities. Everything you do to support women and girls is useless if you don’t excluded trans identified men and boys from the women and girls category.

Make women’s prisons safer? Get men with trans identities out of them.
Make women’s sports more inclusive? Get men with trans identities out of them.
Improve women’s healthcare? Focus on and treat women’s health without including men’s health.

It’s so obvious, but you choose not to see because it’s inconvenient to you. Well guess what, I have trans ID’d family members too, and they’d be a whole lot safer without people like you pushing trans ideology.

Lovelyview · 20/05/2026 18:21

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 20/05/2026 14:31

The 'gender critical' movement is founded on hollow, elitist fantasies of saviourism. That's why it appeals to you and you want more. It excuses cis men from examining their own attitudes, behaviours and violent peers in favour of blaming a minority.

It ignores several realities, notably that:

  • trans people are individuals, not a hive mind
  • trans people have always existed
  • trans women like & respect women, because they are women
  • trans men exist
  • the anti-trans movement is heftily funded by anti-abortion, misogynistic, deeply homophobic orgs who want to set precedents for challenging bodily autonomu
  • regret rate for transition is low
  • the vast, vast majority of sexual assaults against women in so-called 'safe spaces' (we have no safe spaces) are carried out by violent cis men - who usually face no consequences - and pretending that banning trans women will fix that is patronising, sexist & wrong
  • very few trans people do sport
  • being trans is normal

Being anti-trans isn't activism. It's bigotry.

'Transwomen' think women are a costume they can wear. They do not like or respect women. Women are adult human females. No man can be a woman.

ohnonotthisargumentagain · 20/05/2026 18:20

Of course people pay more attention to men! This has always been a problem. We might wish it wasn’t true but it is. While we work on the problem of getting people to listen to women we may as well take advantage of the male voices speaking up in support of us.

MyShyCat · 20/05/2026 18:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lovelyview · 20/05/2026 18:14

SidewaysOtter · 20/05/2026 13:25

Give over @2021x, the OP just wants to help (and protect his teenage daughter) and you want to turn this into some hand-wringing session on “checking one’s privilege” or some such?

OP, I’ve been in this fight a fair while and I’d say:

Support the fundraisers, esp the legal action crowdfunders and amplify them;
Support groups like WRN, FWS and Sex Matters;
Subscribe to newsletters (WRN, FWS, Sex Matters etc) and support campaigns that ask for action like letter writing;
Check your daughters’ school’s policies on single sex facilities/sports and challenge if necessary/possible; and
Have conversations with people - especially your daughter. The more people a) know about this stuff and b) know that their friends and family are in support of women’s rights, the better. It also helps to challenge misconceptions.

I'd agree with all these and add - write to your mp - repeatedly.

It's really important that men get involved in this and don't just think it's a women's thing. The more voices, the better.

Taztoy · 20/05/2026 18:14

Look at your internalised attitudes mate.

wnats the relevance of you being a man? Do you not have the ability to google? Do you think people will pay you more attention or something if you campaign because behold a man?

ohnonotthisargumentagain · 20/05/2026 18:08

Good to have you on board. In addition to the helpful suggestions above are you aware that women speaking out in the workplace seem to face much harsher reactions than men? It would be great if you could keep speaking up in meetings, training and discussions to express concerns and remind people of the law. The more voices on this the more likely are daughters will be safe.
most important for your daughter is to tell her that her rights and boundaries matter and it is not unkind to maintain those boundaries. Also stick to referring to people by their biology as it makes the truth of what is happening in any situation much more obvious.

OrlandointheWilderness · 20/05/2026 16:26

@TransParentlyAnnoyedI hate to break your entirely made up statistics, but I’ve never been sexually assaulted. And I know far more women who haven’t than have.

OpheliaWitchoftheWoods · 20/05/2026 16:15

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

spannasaurus · 20/05/2026 15:49

OP, are you a member of any teachers union? If so could you think about standing for election for a union post or joining some committees.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/05/2026 15:43

WhatNextImScared · 17/05/2026 08:10

Or to put it another way: why is OP particularly passionate about the one area of feminist debate/action that doesn’t involve him having to change his behaviour/doesn’t apply to him in any way (because he’s a cis man)? Hmmmm.

There is no such thing as a “cis man”. He’s a man, other men are men, “trans women” are all men. Hope that helps.

BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 20/05/2026 15:35

This is just a pile of slogans pretending to be an argument.

ok, so I now need this on a Tshirt!

SSSIS, I'll borrow this, if you don't mind, as a shortcut next time someone comes out with the predictable lines of drivel.

(and the next time we both likely get deleted!)

OP, sorry for the me-rail. I hope you find your path in this ridiculous fight we've had to join in order to protect our children.

MyShyCat · 20/05/2026 15:23

Hard agree. ZERO men in womens sport.

OP posts:
Ghostmartin · 20/05/2026 15:21
  • very few trans people do sport

😂PMSL at this being offered as an "argument". The figures don't matter. One is too many. NO MEN IN WOMEN'S SPORT.

Seriestwo · 20/05/2026 15:11

We need more men to speak up. Other men listen to men more than they’re listen to women, sad but true. So tell your friends and get them to join in too.

go to a meet up. There’s one outside the Australian embassy on Saturday can make it to London. People are friendly and F2F is much better than online