Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trans Green Party candidate with no British visa elected to Holyrood

530 replies

IwantToRetire · 10/05/2026 22:18

Q Manivannan, who identifies as non-binary, was elected as an MSP on the Edinburgh & Lothians East list for the pro-independence Scottish Greens.

It was reported earlier this week that the former PhD student has appealed to colleagues for £2,089 of funding for a temporary graduate visa.

This would give the anthropologist and poet a further three years to work and live in the UK, picking up the taxpayer-funded MSP salary of £77,711.

Manivannan is said to have told colleagues this would help buy time to save up the £5,047 cost of applying for a global talent visa, the UK immigration category for promising individuals in specific sectors.

The self-described “queer Tamil immigrant” was only able to stand in the election after SNP ministers loosened the rules over who could be a Holyrood candidate.

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/05/09/trans-green-party-candidate-migrant-elected-holyrood/
And at https://archive.is/LhZYy

Reform couldn't have dreamed for a better headline!

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/05/09/trans-green-party-candidate-migrant-elected-holyrood

OP posts:
Thread gallery
30
Ophir · 15/05/2026 17:09

INeedAPensieve · 15/05/2026 08:44

I actually believe that a lot of people who vote Green (having spoken to people casually prior to the election) still think they represent environmental issues and when I pointed out the crazy policies, were very surprised. Scottish voters tend to be quite partisan and will continue to vote for "their" party even if it's changed beyond all recognition. It's what the SNP relied on to keep getting votes and they were right to do so, considering they got most of the seats again. Despite their abysmal record. It's depressing but hey ho.

I agree. I’ve spoken to a couple of people about voting green, they had no idea it wasn’t all the lovely wholesome stuff

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 15/05/2026 09:19

I have to say that I’m enjoying the reaction to “Q” from the Scottish Nationalists who give the Green Party their second vote for independence reasons.

Their inclusive and progressive facade has slipped seeing foreigners elected to the Scottish parliament. 🤭🤭

WearyAuldWumman · 15/05/2026 09:10

INeedAPensieve · 15/05/2026 08:44

I actually believe that a lot of people who vote Green (having spoken to people casually prior to the election) still think they represent environmental issues and when I pointed out the crazy policies, were very surprised. Scottish voters tend to be quite partisan and will continue to vote for "their" party even if it's changed beyond all recognition. It's what the SNP relied on to keep getting votes and they were right to do so, considering they got most of the seats again. Despite their abysmal record. It's depressing but hey ho.

Yes, I'd say that that is precisely what is happening.

INeedAPensieve · 15/05/2026 08:44

I actually believe that a lot of people who vote Green (having spoken to people casually prior to the election) still think they represent environmental issues and when I pointed out the crazy policies, were very surprised. Scottish voters tend to be quite partisan and will continue to vote for "their" party even if it's changed beyond all recognition. It's what the SNP relied on to keep getting votes and they were right to do so, considering they got most of the seats again. Despite their abysmal record. It's depressing but hey ho.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 14/05/2026 19:11

Namingbaba · 14/05/2026 17:14

I agree with this. It's not just about the paperwork but also fully understanding the country and people you've to represent. In reality it takes a long time to fully understand. I've lived abroad in countries. I just can't imagine having the arrogance to say I could full represent them after such a short time.

He doesn't intend to represent them, it's all about him, he's a Green it's about getting the power to rearrange the world to suit him. Those who vote Green are nuts.

Namingbaba · 14/05/2026 17:14

WearyAuldWumman · 10/05/2026 23:59

The fact that this person is claiming to have a trans identity is irrelevant, in my opinion. However, I don't think that someone who is only in Scotland on a student visa should be able to vote on Scottish legislation.

I spent time abroad as a student, and I can't imagine having the conceit to stand for election in another country without first taking steps to secure citizenship.

I agree with this. It's not just about the paperwork but also fully understanding the country and people you've to represent. In reality it takes a long time to fully understand. I've lived abroad in countries. I just can't imagine having the arrogance to say I could full represent them after such a short time.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 14/05/2026 16:57

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 14/05/2026 14:51

That's what Polanski is advocating for, it's what the Greens mean by No Borders, everyone has the right to go where ever they want and get housing and a basic universal income where ever they are.

I am not a fan of closed borders. Closed borders hasn't worked out well for North Korea and Myanmar. At the same time, we should bar people with serious criminal records from coming in. "No borders" would allow criminals in and that's not OK.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 14/05/2026 16:55

Ophir · 14/05/2026 15:16

If they want no borders, why are they for Scexit?

They are different concepts:

  • Scexit: Scotland makes its own laws without Westminster's involvement.
  • No borders: people can move to and from Scotland at will.
Namingbaba · 14/05/2026 16:52

The self-described “queer Tamil immigrant” was only able to stand in the election after SNP ministers loosened the rules over who could be a Holyrood candidate.

Why was their need to loosen the rules? Surely even people who don't care about immigration see an issue with this? What's wrong with only having citizens??? Someone here for a few years only on a student visa who can't work full time? That is madness. The greens are absolute loons. I say this as someone who used to be a member and would like to vote for a centre-left party.

Ophir · 14/05/2026 15:16

If they want no borders, why are they for Scexit?

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 14/05/2026 14:51

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 14/05/2026 13:13

Someone found the grift, in his own words: "Artist Basic Income".

nitter.net/did_ye_AI/status/2054489685552939350#m

That's what Polanski is advocating for, it's what the Greens mean by No Borders, everyone has the right to go where ever they want and get housing and a basic universal income where ever they are.

Ophir · 14/05/2026 13:43

It’s worth watching mannivan being sworn in.. dear god

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 14/05/2026 13:13

Someone found the grift, in his own words: "Artist Basic Income".

nitter.net/did_ye_AI/status/2054489685552939350#m

SecretSquirrelLoo · 14/05/2026 09:26

Oh yes absolutely, but I didn’t expect evolution denial to be one of the issues they would horseshoe on.

Misogyny yes of course, anti-immunizations potentially. Evolution surprising.

DrBlackbird · 14/05/2026 06:51

PachacutisBadAuntie · 13/05/2026 22:38

Horseshoe theory, I think
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory
Or 'two cheeks of the same arse' also works.

Both authoritarian. And willing to engage in violence to achieve their aims. Not so much between them ultimately. Huge differences in wealth in communist Soviet Union despite the claims to ‘every man’ and all that.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 14/05/2026 06:00

I liked this comment

to be fair to the boy, he is living proof that evolution isn't happening.

😂😂😂😂

PachacutisBadAuntie · 13/05/2026 22:38

SecretSquirrelLoo · 13/05/2026 20:18

Whaaaaaat??? Nothing would make me sign up to Twitter, but this does actually tempt me. Could you possibly post more screenshots?

Isn’t believing in evolution usually a key tribal marker against MAGA and fundamentalist Christian types? How has the thinking got so bendy that this flavour of loon also rejects evolution?

Horseshoe theory, I think
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory
Or 'two cheeks of the same arse' also works.

Horseshoe theory - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory

PachacutisBadAuntie · 13/05/2026 22:35

INeedAPensieve · 13/05/2026 21:09

Ah sadly @SecretSquirrelLoo I'm also not on twitter, I managed to screenshot the wings post from my browser but I can't delve in further than that.

Ah wait I can see someone has posted a nitter link! Going to also have a peek :)

More proof the SGreens are barking mad...

You too can do this. Just click in the address bar at the top of your browser and replace x.com with nitter.net and then press return / enter.

DrBlackbird · 13/05/2026 22:17

INeedAPensieve · 13/05/2026 20:10

He also doesn't believe in evolution...

https://x.com/WingsScotland/status/2054480607929839631

Though possibly understandable since he apparently doesn't appear to believe in biology either

But incredibly rude and disrespectful whilst coming across as completely narcissistic. Great look in someone representing a broad constituency.

INeedAPensieve · 13/05/2026 21:09

Ah sadly @SecretSquirrelLoo I'm also not on twitter, I managed to screenshot the wings post from my browser but I can't delve in further than that.

Ah wait I can see someone has posted a nitter link! Going to also have a peek :)

More proof the SGreens are barking mad...

Igneococcus · 13/05/2026 21:00

SecretSquirrelLoo · 13/05/2026 20:18

Whaaaaaat??? Nothing would make me sign up to Twitter, but this does actually tempt me. Could you possibly post more screenshots?

Isn’t believing in evolution usually a key tribal marker against MAGA and fundamentalist Christian types? How has the thinking got so bendy that this flavour of loon also rejects evolution?

Nitter link:
https://nitter.net/WingsScotland/status/2054480607929839631

Heggettypeg · 13/05/2026 20:27

SecretSquirrelLoo · 13/05/2026 20:18

Whaaaaaat??? Nothing would make me sign up to Twitter, but this does actually tempt me. Could you possibly post more screenshots?

Isn’t believing in evolution usually a key tribal marker against MAGA and fundamentalist Christian types? How has the thinking got so bendy that this flavour of loon also rejects evolution?

Well, it gets tricky, doesn't it?
Poor old Darwin was pale, male, stale and English; how could he possibly be right?

SecretSquirrelLoo · 13/05/2026 20:18

Whaaaaaat??? Nothing would make me sign up to Twitter, but this does actually tempt me. Could you possibly post more screenshots?

Isn’t believing in evolution usually a key tribal marker against MAGA and fundamentalist Christian types? How has the thinking got so bendy that this flavour of loon also rejects evolution?

INeedAPensieve · 13/05/2026 20:10

He also doesn't believe in evolution...

https://x.com/WingsScotland/status/2054480607929839631

Though possibly understandable since he apparently doesn't appear to believe in biology either

Wings Over Scotland (@WingsScotland) on X

Your new MSP does not believe in evolution.

https://x.com/WingsScotland/status/2054480607929839631