Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trans Green Party candidate with no British visa elected to Holyrood

530 replies

IwantToRetire · 10/05/2026 22:18

Q Manivannan, who identifies as non-binary, was elected as an MSP on the Edinburgh & Lothians East list for the pro-independence Scottish Greens.

It was reported earlier this week that the former PhD student has appealed to colleagues for £2,089 of funding for a temporary graduate visa.

This would give the anthropologist and poet a further three years to work and live in the UK, picking up the taxpayer-funded MSP salary of £77,711.

Manivannan is said to have told colleagues this would help buy time to save up the £5,047 cost of applying for a global talent visa, the UK immigration category for promising individuals in specific sectors.

The self-described “queer Tamil immigrant” was only able to stand in the election after SNP ministers loosened the rules over who could be a Holyrood candidate.

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/05/09/trans-green-party-candidate-migrant-elected-holyrood/
And at https://archive.is/LhZYy

Reform couldn't have dreamed for a better headline!

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/05/09/trans-green-party-candidate-migrant-elected-holyrood

OP posts:
Thread gallery
30
Hoardasurass · 10/05/2026 22:35

Echobelly · 10/05/2026 22:22

I find it hard to be bothered by this. And I don't see why people should be bothered by her getting paid for doing a job, plenty of people on visas do that and presumably she's going to get a visa in order to that - according to this story she was allowed to stand under the current rule. Some people might not like that rule, but she's done nothing wrong. Non-story nonsense from the Telegraph.

He not her and if you want to use his preferred pronouns that would be they/them
Now to the point in question he is a foreign national only here on a student visa with a work limit of 20 hours and a ban on employing anyone else. The role of a MSP is a full-time job with a requirement to hire and employ consultancy staff therefore he is not eligible for the role and should never have been on the list.
He is applying for a graduate visa which he wont have by tge time he will need to be sworn in so if he takes office he will automatically be in breach of his visa rules and liable for deportation.
Even if he already had a graduate visa it only lasts for 3 years and cant be extended.
He claims he will get a global talent visa after his graduate visa but being a MSP is not covered by it nor does he fit any of the other criteria.
All of that is before we discuss whether someone without indefinite leave to remain or citizenship should be able to be a member of parliament or not

AntiRacistFella · 10/05/2026 22:35

KnottyAuty · 10/05/2026 22:30

You may not be bothered but you also seem to be unaware of the controversy regarding Commonwealth visitors to the UK being able to vote in UK elections. This is a legacy issue which is not reciprocated and which is past its sell by date. Australians would be horrified if UK citizens were able to vote in its elections for example. It means that there are more potential votes outside the UK than in it! But this is an odd quirk which has only recently come to light for the UK. The idea that someone can now aslo stand as an elected representative without indefinite leave to remain in the country is just weird. What if they don't get a visa because they don't meet the criteria? How can they extend a student visa and also be working? This looks to me like someone trying to swindle the system.

"Swindle the system" - how is this not a personal attack clearly against the Mumsnet talk guidelines?

KnottyAuty · 10/05/2026 22:30

Echobelly · 10/05/2026 22:22

I find it hard to be bothered by this. And I don't see why people should be bothered by her getting paid for doing a job, plenty of people on visas do that and presumably she's going to get a visa in order to that - according to this story she was allowed to stand under the current rule. Some people might not like that rule, but she's done nothing wrong. Non-story nonsense from the Telegraph.

You may not be bothered but you also seem to be unaware of the controversy regarding Commonwealth visitors to the UK being able to vote in UK elections. This is a legacy issue which is not reciprocated and which is past its sell by date. Australians would be horrified if UK citizens were able to vote in its elections for example. It means that there are more potential votes outside the UK than in it! But this is an odd quirk which has only recently come to light for the UK. The idea that someone can now aslo stand as an elected representative without indefinite leave to remain in the country is just weird. What if they don't get a visa because they don't meet the criteria? How can they extend a student visa and also be working? This looks to me like someone trying to swindle the system.

Echobelly · 10/05/2026 22:22

I find it hard to be bothered by this. And I don't see why people should be bothered by her getting paid for doing a job, plenty of people on visas do that and presumably she's going to get a visa in order to that - according to this story she was allowed to stand under the current rule. Some people might not like that rule, but she's done nothing wrong. Non-story nonsense from the Telegraph.

IwantToRetire · 10/05/2026 22:19

Rookie trans Green MSP blasted over ‘disgraceful’ comments about late Queen

Duane, a biological male who uses she/her pronouns, was catapulted into Holyrood as a Green candidate on the Glasgow regional list.

Scottish Greens chiefs have tried to play down the tweet.

A party spokesman said: “It was intended as a joke when it was made years ago and ahead of the Queen’s death. It has been deleted.”

After being elected, Duane said: “I know that some will focus on the fact that I am the first black MSP and one of the first openly trans MSPs but that’s not what this election was about.”

The MSP previously hit the headlines over pledges to force the Scottish Parliament to lift its ban on trans people using toilets in their lived gender.

https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/16245137/rookie-trans-msps-twisted-lizzie-lizard-taunt/

Iris Duane of the Green Party celebrates at Glasgow Central at Glasgow International Arena.

Rookie trans Green MSP blasted over 'disgraceful' comments about late Queen

A GREEN MSP was blasted last night over a crass death wish “joke” against the late Queen when she was in declining health. Iris Duane also referred to the late monarch — who opened the Scottish Par…

https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/16245137/rookie-trans-msps-twisted-lizzie-lizard-taunt/

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread