Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sex Matters - Respond now to the consultation on digital ID - 5th May deadline

58 replies

KnottyAuty · 01/05/2026 09:13

https://sex-matters.org/take-action/respond-to-the-consultation-on-digital-id/

Make sure the government gets sex right on digital ID – respond before Tuesday 5th May.

Respond to the consultation on digital ID

Make sure the government gets sex right on digital ID – respond before Tuesday 5th May.

https://sex-matters.org/take-action/respond-to-the-consultation-on-digital-id/

OP posts:
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 02/05/2026 11:02

@BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth people lie but (a) it can eventually be checked against the birth register which does keep the birth sex even after a GRC and (b) there can be penalties for providing false information or for not correcting it in time which is one of the questions in the consultation.

The optional bit helps because single-sex services can be "no sex marker no access". The sex marker is not just "optional for those who happen to want it" it can be required for those who want to access a single-sex service or used to prove their sex when they need to.

Some feminists may argue "we can always tell" but I don't agree. Yes we can nearly always tell but I can't always tell myself, OK given enough time and the right context yes I'll be able to figure it out but that's not "always". And it's better for all sorts of reasons (including the number of trans people who have ASCs) to have an objective marker for sex that isn't the judgment of the poor receptionist.

Nothing's perfect and I think this is better than trying to ignore sex. I get why the govt doesn't want to go there but I do!

BusyAzureTraybake · 02/05/2026 10:55

BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 02/05/2026 08:25

Thanks for reminding us and posting the link, Knotty.

I must admit, I am confused. On the Sex Matters page, there's this:

It will include a person’s full name, date of birth, nationality and a photo, but not their sex.

Also this:

People should have the option of not having their sex on digital ID. But if they choose to have sex included, it should be accurate.

I don't understand why we want ID cards to include sex as optional for those who want it. Surely, it just opens the whole system up to abuse? I know Sex Matters say that recorded sex should be accurate, but when has that ever stopped anyone from lying about their sex? And who is the government going to employ (i.e. pay money for) to check that every marker on every ID record is "accurate." No one in government or civil service is either competent or available enough to do that!

Feminists have been arguing for more than a decade that we can always tell who is male and who is female. Why should we need to use digital ID to "prove" we are female (to date, use single-sex services, use the gym, etc. )?

Doesn't encouraging a "let's hope this is accurate " marker on an ID just make a mockery of everything we have been saying? And throws caution to the wind in the face of those who will exploit this potential loophole? Won't this potentially reduce "female" to a digital footprint, rather than a biological reality?

Just leave sex off the digital ID. I want people to go back to accepting the reality of their senses, and to be able to challenge those living within their own fantasy bubbles. And, we see things are starting to move in that direction, finally, albeit slowly. Why would we want to set that back?

Allowing the inclusion of sex on a digital ID could be the first step to self-id by the back door.

Or am I missing something here? Happy to be corrected.

Edited

I think the idea is for Sex to be cross-referenced with original birth certificates, which are being digitised (for people born in UK).

More details here: https://sex-matters.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/Putting-sex-on-digital-ID-briefing.pdf

https://sex-matters.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/Putting-sex-on-digital-ID-briefing.pdf

StillSpartacus · 02/05/2026 10:51

Done. Top tip for anyone else - it’s probably easier to complete on a pc than a phone!

BridgetPhillipsonIsACowardlyJobsworth · 02/05/2026 08:25

Thanks for reminding us and posting the link, Knotty.

I must admit, I am confused. On the Sex Matters page, there's this:

It will include a person’s full name, date of birth, nationality and a photo, but not their sex.

Also this:

People should have the option of not having their sex on digital ID. But if they choose to have sex included, it should be accurate.

I don't understand why we want ID cards to include sex as optional for those who want it. Surely, it just opens the whole system up to abuse? I know Sex Matters say that recorded sex should be accurate, but when has that ever stopped anyone from lying about their sex? And who is the government going to employ (i.e. pay money for) to check that every marker on every ID record is "accurate." No one in government or civil service is either competent or available enough to do that!

Feminists have been arguing for more than a decade that we can always tell who is male and who is female. Why should we need to use digital ID to "prove" we are female (to date, use single-sex services, use the gym, etc. )?

Doesn't encouraging a "let's hope this is accurate " marker on an ID just make a mockery of everything we have been saying? And throws caution to the wind in the face of those who will exploit this potential loophole? Won't this potentially reduce "female" to a digital footprint, rather than a biological reality?

Just leave sex off the digital ID. I want people to go back to accepting the reality of their senses, and to be able to challenge those living within their own fantasy bubbles. And, we see things are starting to move in that direction, finally, albeit slowly. Why would we want to set that back?

Allowing the inclusion of sex on a digital ID could be the first step to self-id by the back door.

Or am I missing something here? Happy to be corrected.

71Alex · 02/05/2026 07:56

Done

BusyAzureTraybake · 01/05/2026 22:39

On my list too!

KnottyAuty · 01/05/2026 21:17

Well done! Im yet to have a look but it’s on the list for this weekend

OP posts:
MassiveWordSalad · 01/05/2026 10:23

I’ve just done this and come to check if there was a thread. Cheers Knotty 😊