Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Disappointed that Chimamanda Ngozie Adichie is promoting her use of surrogacy as compatible with feminism

316 replies

Carla786 · 20/04/2026 01:36

I loved Purple Hibiscus and recently got through the rest of her books from my library. I really like her novels and especially her GC stance, but I was discussing her on a feminist subreddit recently and her use of surrogacy came up. It's disappointing she promotes it here as compatible with feminism,

https://www.premiumtimesng.com/entertainment/naija-fashion/791804-ive-no-regrets-welcoming-my-twins-through-surrogacy-chimamanda-adichie.html

Infertility is of course extremely painful, but I don't think that justifies using another woman's womb.

‘I've no regrets welcoming my twins through surrogacy’ - Chimamanda Adichie

“I want more women to feel less ashamed of talking about reaching motherhood through non-traditional means.”

https://www.premiumtimesng.com/entertainment/naija-fashion/791804-ive-no-regrets-welcoming-my-twins-through-surrogacy-chimamanda-adichie.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:07

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:03

https://theconversation.com/surrogacy-is-booming-but-new-research-suggests-these-pregnancies-could-be-higher-risk-for-women-and-babies-239574

The researchers found pregnant women in gestational surrogacy arrangements had a rate of severe maternal complications of 7.8%, more than three times the rate of those who became pregnant naturally (2.3%) and almost twice the rate among those who got pregnant through IVF (4.3%).

It's believed that the foetus having completely different DNA from the mother is a contributing factor, along with poverty-related factors.

The timing of this research doesn't matter because your offer was made with those risks existing and you not knowing about them. The definition of "informed consent" requires you to know about these risks.

Research didnt know about them and the study has limitations. They still aren't entirely clear what is behind the elevated risk. Some evo biologists posit that it is when the surrogate is unrelated to the prospective parents. It's just theories though. It might still be the IVF.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:06

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 09:57

I cried over my SIL negative pregnancy tests many times. As did she and her husband and it affected my husband, too.

You were feeling empathy. That's not what I was describing. I was describing a powerful urge to hold your own baby in your arms, an urge that goes back to the dawn of our species.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:03

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 09:54

From what to what?

Bear in mind, this was back in 2012. So any research you refer to regarding risk would have to be before then for it to be relevant to my choice.

https://theconversation.com/surrogacy-is-booming-but-new-research-suggests-these-pregnancies-could-be-higher-risk-for-women-and-babies-239574

The researchers found pregnant women in gestational surrogacy arrangements had a rate of severe maternal complications of 7.8%, more than three times the rate of those who became pregnant naturally (2.3%) and almost twice the rate among those who got pregnant through IVF (4.3%).

It's believed that the foetus having completely different DNA from the mother is a contributing factor, along with poverty-related factors.

The timing of this research doesn't matter because your offer was made with those risks existing and you not knowing about them. The definition of "informed consent" requires you to know about these risks.

Surrogacy is booming. But new research suggests these pregnancies could be higher risk for women and babies

This link might be explained by a woman’s immune response when carrying a baby that’s not genetically hers.

https://theconversation.com/surrogacy-is-booming-but-new-research-suggests-these-pregnancies-could-be-higher-risk-for-women-and-babies-239574

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 10:03

Infertility is a very real form of grief but that doesn’t require other women to pit themselves at risk to make it better, nor does it make it right to conceive children with the purpose of removing them from their mother.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 09:57

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 09:56

I have seen women crying because they want a baby, including single women. The urge to procreate, to pass on one's own genes and hold one's own baby in one's arms, is powerful in those who experience it.

This isn't in any way comparable to the situation of agreeing to bear a baby to hand over to someone else.

I cried over my SIL negative pregnancy tests many times. As did she and her husband and it affected my husband, too.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 09:56

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 07:29

No that isnt what you said, you said:

"You can’t provide informed consent when you have been groomed but as women, that’s exactly what we’re subjected to from the moment we can understand speech. Surrogates are women who have been unconsciously coerced into carrying a child because it’s a “kind” thing to do"

You said that as women have been groomed from birth, we are incapable of giving informed consent. That means that we cant consent to sex as we have been groomed to be compliant. Are we really saying yes? When we agree to have a baby with our husband, is it because we enthusistically consent to it, or because we've been told to.be kind?

Because it sounds more like you think women can only truly consent to things you agree with otherwise they are being exploited.

I have seen women crying because they want a baby, including single women. The urge to procreate, to pass on one's own genes and hold one's own baby in one's arms, is powerful in those who experience it.

This isn't in any way comparable to the situation of agreeing to bear a baby to hand over to someone else.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 09:55

At the time I was going to do it, they were pretty sure that elevated risk was to do with having IVF. I was happy to assume those risks. I would have done it to have my own babies if i needed to. Even after having my first without assistance.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 09:54

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 09:49

That risk is tripled if you are carrying another woman's baby. Tripled.

From what to what?

Bear in mind, this was back in 2012. So any research you refer to regarding risk would have to be before then for it to be relevant to my choice.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 09:49

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 07:24

Sure and I have that risk with any pregnancy. I planned to have more kids. Could happen while birthing them.

That risk is tripled if you are carrying another woman's baby. Tripled.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 09:37

Shedmistress · 20/04/2026 09:35

No she didnt. She just responded like people so in conversations.

Ok

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 09:37

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 09:27

I didn’t mention selfish. I was genuinely interested in whether/how you considered the risks and rewards.

We all - mothers - take these risks and some address them more directly than others.

Taking such risks for one’s own benefit is more understandable than when someone else will benefit - by that I mean you obviously found some benefit in helping a family member which offset the risks to you and your own child to a high degree.

It’s also interesting how you only mentioned “their father” and no wider circle of carers, not least your sister in law who would seem an obvious candidate to be a significant help

Edited

Well he is their father and my husband, so naturally he would hsve had legal custody of them by default should anything happen to me. We do have a very loving and supportive family on both sides; they've helped us raise our children. There is no reason that would be any different if either of us died at any point. They would likely do even more.

Earlier I mentioned the reasons I did it. One of them is that I wanted me and my SIL specifically to go through parenthood together, at as similar stages as possible. Her two kids are between my two of mine. Hers, mine, hers, mine.

Shedmistress · 20/04/2026 09:35

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 09:20

She answered the post as if she was the one who wrote the paragraph I quoted. I'm not sure why.

No she didnt. She just responded like people so in conversations.

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 09:27

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 08:32

Their father.....

These risks are present in all pregnancies. If it was somehow selfish for me to have my own children after I had my son, then it would have been also selfish to risk my life with a surrogate pregnancy. We don't usually call women selfish for having more than one child on the basis that the pregnancy risked her life.

We probably have women here who had a much higher risk first pregnancy than I did, meaning their chance of another high risk pregnancy was much increased. They still had subsequent children knowing they could die in the pregnancy and leave their existing children motherless.

I didn’t mention selfish. I was genuinely interested in whether/how you considered the risks and rewards.

We all - mothers - take these risks and some address them more directly than others.

Taking such risks for one’s own benefit is more understandable than when someone else will benefit - by that I mean you obviously found some benefit in helping a family member which offset the risks to you and your own child to a high degree.

It’s also interesting how you only mentioned “their father” and no wider circle of carers, not least your sister in law who would seem an obvious candidate to be a significant help

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 09:20

Shedmistress · 20/04/2026 09:03

a - yes people respond to other people's posts in internet forums, its kinda what people do.
b - she said she wrote the POST that you QUOTED saying 'you did not write the QUOTE'. which was not even in the POST that you QUOTED.

She answered the post as if she was the one who wrote the paragraph I quoted. I'm not sure why.

MassiveWordSalad · 20/04/2026 09:18

Yes, Chimamanda has really gone down in my estimation. It’s a massive disappointment that someone who has written so eloquently as a feminist is able to contort their principles when they want something incompatible with those principles.

I agree with the points that PP have made about surrogacy being incompatible with feminism, and being incompatible with the needs of a new-born baby. A baby should only be taken from the woman who birthed it in extreme circumstances, such as they death of the mother or a safeguarding situation.

We do need to have hard conversations about fertility and the ‘right’ to have a biological child. Just because we have the technology available, doesn’t mean we should use it in this way.

Rightsraptor · 20/04/2026 09:17

I've loved Chimamanda's books but won't be buying any more if that's what she spends the money on.

Shedmistress · 20/04/2026 09:03

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 08:53

No, I directly replied to a quote by @SpidersAreShitheads. Then @BootMaker came to answer the question which didnt make sense because that isn't who wrote the paragraph I quoted. Bootmaker then insisted that she did write the quote.

a - yes people respond to other people's posts in internet forums, its kinda what people do.
b - she said she wrote the POST that you QUOTED saying 'you did not write the QUOTE'. which was not even in the POST that you QUOTED.

ArabellaScott · 20/04/2026 08:57

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 08:56

I believe in abortion to the point of birth, not because I want to 'kill babies' but because every other option supposes that the woman is less important than the feotus and so few women actually would take that option (and only then for extreme reasons), that we shouldn't even have the conversation, the conversation feels regressive.

Until birth the health of the mother must always be prioritised (and is) but I cannot accept the woman’s right not to have a child living with adoptive parents that she never sees should be higher than the right of a viable full term baby to live. And at term that is the only choice - the baby is still has to be born. And if the mother’s right to not have biological offspring-spring is so high then why not kill the baby after birth?

Yes, babies are dependent on adults for a good long while. Where is the line drawn?

Fwiw I think UK laws and limits have it about right.

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 08:56

I believe in abortion to the point of birth, not because I want to 'kill babies' but because every other option supposes that the woman is less important than the feotus and so few women actually would take that option (and only then for extreme reasons), that we shouldn't even have the conversation, the conversation feels regressive.

Until birth the health of the mother must always be prioritised (and is) but I cannot accept the woman’s right not to have a child living with adoptive parents that she never sees should be higher than the right of a viable full term baby to live. And at term that is the only choice - the baby is still has to be born. And if the mother’s right to not have biological offspring-spring is so high then why not kill the baby after birth?

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 08:53

Shedmistress · 20/04/2026 08:43

For goodness sakes.

You said 'You didn't write that quote.' to @BootMaker

You meant '"With surrogacy it’s impossible to give informed consent because what a woman is actually doing is simply yielding to the societal view that she must be kind, helpful, and put herself last. You can’t provide informed consent when you have been groomed but as women, that’s exactly what we’re subjected to from the moment we can understand speech."' which was written by @SpidersAreShitheads and had already been replied to by @BootMaker

You said it to look like you meant a post written by @BootMaker

Why you are unable to follow your own bloody rabbit holes I have no idea but you make every little thing all about you and deliberately confuse people to what end I have no idea.

No, I directly replied to a quote by @SpidersAreShitheads. Then @BootMaker came to answer the question which didnt make sense because that isn't who wrote the paragraph I quoted. Bootmaker then insisted that she did write the quote.

Shedmistress · 20/04/2026 08:43

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 07:33

Nobody used AI, I think i just uncovered you using 2 accounts though and that is why you thought you typed the words i quoted.

For goodness sakes.

You said 'You didn't write that quote.' to @BootMaker

You meant '"With surrogacy it’s impossible to give informed consent because what a woman is actually doing is simply yielding to the societal view that she must be kind, helpful, and put herself last. You can’t provide informed consent when you have been groomed but as women, that’s exactly what we’re subjected to from the moment we can understand speech."' which was written by @SpidersAreShitheads and had already been replied to by @BootMaker

You said it to look like you meant a post written by @BootMaker

Why you are unable to follow your own bloody rabbit holes I have no idea but you make every little thing all about you and deliberately confuse people to what end I have no idea.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 08:32

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 08:22

And the lifelong care issue?

ETA who was to be the nominated career for your child if you died?

Edited

Their father.....

These risks are present in all pregnancies. If it was somehow selfish for me to have my own children after I had my son, then it would have been also selfish to risk my life with a surrogate pregnancy. We don't usually call women selfish for having more than one child on the basis that the pregnancy risked her life.

We probably have women here who had a much higher risk first pregnancy than I did, meaning their chance of another high risk pregnancy was much increased. They still had subsequent children knowing they could die in the pregnancy and leave their existing children motherless.

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 08:22

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 08:17

The same as any mother who prefers not to die in her subsequent pregnancies.

And the lifelong care issue?

ETA who was to be the nominated career for your child if you died?

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 08:17

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 08:04

Yes - thats the point. What plans did you make for those scenarios?

The same as any mother who prefers not to die in her subsequent pregnancies.

WydeStrype · 20/04/2026 08:13

Surrogacy involves a baby, not just the mother's body. So it is not merely a discussion of the mother's bodily autonomy. The baby is a sentient human being, who is trafficked and traded to satisfy adult desires.

Trading humans is abhorrent and should never happen. Deliberately conceiving a human baby with the sole intention of removing them at birth is barbaric.

We understand and acknowledge the need for other infant mammals to be left with their mother's for weeks after birth. We understand this benefits their growth, development, their immune system, their neurological mapping and their physiological and emotional regulation. But with human babies born into surrogacy we deliberately create a primal wound and negatively impact their physical and emotional well being. How can this ever be ok?

If a baby is not the surrogate's biologically then we know this leads to more risk of complications for surrogate and baby and it makes no difference to the primal wound for the baby who only knows that mother's heartbeat, voice and smell.

Swipe left for the next trending thread