Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Disappointed that Chimamanda Ngozie Adichie is promoting her use of surrogacy as compatible with feminism

316 replies

Carla786 · 20/04/2026 01:36

I loved Purple Hibiscus and recently got through the rest of her books from my library. I really like her novels and especially her GC stance, but I was discussing her on a feminist subreddit recently and her use of surrogacy came up. It's disappointing she promotes it here as compatible with feminism,

https://www.premiumtimesng.com/entertainment/naija-fashion/791804-ive-no-regrets-welcoming-my-twins-through-surrogacy-chimamanda-adichie.html

Infertility is of course extremely painful, but I don't think that justifies using another woman's womb.

‘I've no regrets welcoming my twins through surrogacy’ - Chimamanda Adichie

“I want more women to feel less ashamed of talking about reaching motherhood through non-traditional means.”

https://www.premiumtimesng.com/entertainment/naija-fashion/791804-ive-no-regrets-welcoming-my-twins-through-surrogacy-chimamanda-adichie.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
TempestTost · 20/04/2026 10:50

I tend to think that in many - maybe most - cases, there is not only one "feminist" argument. It's entirely possible that there can be various viewpoints within a feminist perspective on issues, and that includes things like prostitution or surrogacy. In both there is a weighing of pros and cons, and there can be differernt elements that some give more weight to than others.

It's the same with any svhool of thought you can think of. There are all kinds of disagreements within the civil rights movement. There are all kinds of disagreements within Marxism. And so on. I don't love the approach of simply declaring that people who take another view have abandoned the whole set of principles. It's usually not true.

Personally, I think there is some real merit to seeing surrogasy as dangerous to women, but if we are looking only from the perspective of the adults in the equasion, there is also something to be said for the choices of the woman carrying the child over who own body. ANd then all that becomes more complicated when you consider the larger effects on society. Many of which are nothing to do with feminism but are very real.

However, the most fundamental issue for me with this is the rights of the child, including the right to not be sold, traded, or used as a gift, and the right to a relationship with its parents - which include the surrogate because biologically she is the real mother just as much as the one donating the eggs. And that, I would say, is completely opposed to the very idea of surrogacy, and is far more fundamental than any right a woman has to bear a child to give away or sell, or to have a child through any means necessary.

ArabellaScott · 20/04/2026 10:48

Surrogacy is unfortunately big business though. Lots of money to be made in human trafficking

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:48

ArabellaScott · 20/04/2026 10:47

Any baby needs the smell, touch, sound of its mother at birth. The absence of this creates trauma and also interferes with developmental processes. We are mammals. This is basic.

Why do you think surrogacy forbids that?

ArabellaScott · 20/04/2026 10:47

Any baby needs the smell, touch, sound of its mother at birth. The absence of this creates trauma and also interferes with developmental processes. We are mammals. This is basic.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:47

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:44

When birthing her own baby, who is she being kind to?

Her husband. Her on laws. Her parents. Her community. Society? Could be anyone. Shes been groomed since birth, remember?

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:44

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:19

But if women have been groomed by birth to be compliant, how do we know when they are acting on their true urges and when they're just being kind?

When birthing her own baby, who is she being kind to?

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:40

ArabellaScott · 20/04/2026 10:38

Infants who are separated from their mother at birth suffer trauma. This is well established.

Does it show that with surrogates? Can you show that information? Because the information I am privy to says the way we adopt in this country is what causes the infants trauma. The multiple caregivers before permanent placement etc. These things are not the case for surrogates.

ArabellaScott · 20/04/2026 10:38

As well as blindingly obvious.

ArabellaScott · 20/04/2026 10:38

Infants who are separated from their mother at birth suffer trauma. This is well established.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:37

StellaAndCrow · 20/04/2026 10:31

My concern is for the baby in these situations. I feel that their needs are not being prioritised.

The difference in guidelines/assessment/monitoring between surrogacy and adoption seem so strange to me.

What does the research say about the infants long term?

StellaAndCrow · 20/04/2026 10:31

My concern is for the baby in these situations. I feel that their needs are not being prioritised.

The difference in guidelines/assessment/monitoring between surrogacy and adoption seem so strange to me.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:29

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 10:24

In a weird way the dying question is easier because one would be gone and not having to deal with any consequences. The more difficult scenarios are the ones where everyone lives but life hasn’t gone to plan - eg the disabled child. Tgat clearly didn’t factor into your thoughts then or now. That’s ok

They would have raised a disabled child. Why do you assume they would not? Can you point to a post where I said anything like that?

The truth is that when we discussed it as a 4, they asked me if I would decline nuchal screening because they wanted the baby regardless of their ability/disability. I did point out that many disabilities would become evident on scan at some point and they were fine with that. We wanted to make sure all these sorts of things were sorted before we embarked on anything formal.

So why do you assume that two grown women, one of who is already a mother, would not discuss these outcomes?

Are your family known for giving up on babies due to disability? As mine or my husband's are not.

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 10:24

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:20

No i did think about the small chance of catastrophe and decided that the benefits outweighed that remote chance that I die or can never have children again. Most women, even in the worst circumstances, give birth and can conceive and give birth again. We are remarkable.

In a weird way the dying question is easier because one would be gone and not having to deal with any consequences. The more difficult scenarios are the ones where everyone lives but life hasn’t gone to plan - eg the disabled child. Tgat clearly didn’t factor into your thoughts then or now. That’s ok

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:22

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 10:20

You can only make decisions on the information available at the time tho!

Exactly. This is becoming one of those conversations where emotion and the desire to be right outweighs one's ability to process information effectively

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:20

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 10:18

We all like to think of the best possible outcomes and minimise the negative bits. But if you’d had a very disabled child that your relatives decided not to adopt, your life would look rather different to what you’d hoped. I was interested in how you balanced these thoughts but it seems that your approach was not to think too hard about the potential downsides. No criticism- I find it interesting. (I had 2 home births and people asked me directly to my face why I would take such risks and tell me about my foolhardy choices. I’d like to be clear im not doing that - I was curious about how you worked through the risks for yourself especially when doing something others consider risky or unusual)

No i did think about the small chance of catastrophe and decided that the benefits outweighed that remote chance that I die or can never have children again. Most women, even in the worst circumstances, give birth and can conceive and give birth again. We are remarkable.

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 10:20

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:03

https://theconversation.com/surrogacy-is-booming-but-new-research-suggests-these-pregnancies-could-be-higher-risk-for-women-and-babies-239574

The researchers found pregnant women in gestational surrogacy arrangements had a rate of severe maternal complications of 7.8%, more than three times the rate of those who became pregnant naturally (2.3%) and almost twice the rate among those who got pregnant through IVF (4.3%).

It's believed that the foetus having completely different DNA from the mother is a contributing factor, along with poverty-related factors.

The timing of this research doesn't matter because your offer was made with those risks existing and you not knowing about them. The definition of "informed consent" requires you to know about these risks.

You can only make decisions on the information available at the time tho!

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:19

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:17

Read all my posts and the history of that post to understand the context in which I say that.

I am making the point that the urge of a woman to bear and birth her own child is usually not a consequence of being groomed to be kind. She can therefore consent to that, even if we argue that consent to something you've been groomed from birth to do is not truly consent.

I am very much opposed to anyone's powerful urge being used to justify commandeering someone else's body.

But if women have been groomed by birth to be compliant, how do we know when they are acting on their true urges and when they're just being kind?

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 10:18

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 09:37

Well he is their father and my husband, so naturally he would hsve had legal custody of them by default should anything happen to me. We do have a very loving and supportive family on both sides; they've helped us raise our children. There is no reason that would be any different if either of us died at any point. They would likely do even more.

Earlier I mentioned the reasons I did it. One of them is that I wanted me and my SIL specifically to go through parenthood together, at as similar stages as possible. Her two kids are between my two of mine. Hers, mine, hers, mine.

We all like to think of the best possible outcomes and minimise the negative bits. But if you’d had a very disabled child that your relatives decided not to adopt, your life would look rather different to what you’d hoped. I was interested in how you balanced these thoughts but it seems that your approach was not to think too hard about the potential downsides. No criticism- I find it interesting. (I had 2 home births and people asked me directly to my face why I would take such risks and tell me about my foolhardy choices. I’d like to be clear im not doing that - I was curious about how you worked through the risks for yourself especially when doing something others consider risky or unusual)

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:17

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 10:10

There is also a powerful urge to have sex to enable this, especially in men. Does that make prostitution or rape ok?

Read all my posts and the history of that post to understand the context in which I say that.

I am making the point that the urge of a woman to bear and birth her own child is usually not a consequence of being groomed to be kind. She can therefore consent to that, even if we argue that consent to something you've been groomed from birth to do is not truly consent.

I am very much opposed to anyone's powerful urge being used to justify commandeering someone else's body.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:15

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:12

No, it's not "the IVF".

"almost twice the rate among those who got pregnant through IVF (4.3%)."

This was one study of a small sample size. They don't have the numbers to know that and say as much. This was also retrospective. A better study would be to look at surrogates through an upcoming pregnancy and compare them to a control group of people just having IVF, rather than auditing old notes.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:13

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 10:09

And what if your plans to have more kids were bought to an abrupt end by your surrogate pregnancy?

But you do seem very over-invested in your SIL reproduction - wanting her to have children so you can parent together.

I was asked what motivated me to want to do it. Of course it is something you have to explore in great depth before you even offer so I know why I wanted to.

That was a risk I was willing to assume. I had no reason to believe the chances of that were particualrly high. As I said, the highest risk was needing a caesarean in future pregnancies.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:12

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:07

Research didnt know about them and the study has limitations. They still aren't entirely clear what is behind the elevated risk. Some evo biologists posit that it is when the surrogate is unrelated to the prospective parents. It's just theories though. It might still be the IVF.

No, it's not "the IVF".

"almost twice the rate among those who got pregnant through IVF (4.3%)."

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 10:10

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:06

You were feeling empathy. That's not what I was describing. I was describing a powerful urge to hold your own baby in your arms, an urge that goes back to the dawn of our species.

There is also a powerful urge to have sex to enable this, especially in men. Does that make prostitution or rape ok?

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 10:09

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 07:24

Sure and I have that risk with any pregnancy. I planned to have more kids. Could happen while birthing them.

And what if your plans to have more kids were bought to an abrupt end by your surrogate pregnancy?

But you do seem very over-invested in your SIL reproduction - wanting her to have children so you can parent together.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:09

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:06

You were feeling empathy. That's not what I was describing. I was describing a powerful urge to hold your own baby in your arms, an urge that goes back to the dawn of our species.

I'd say I felt my own disappointment. I really wanted to be a parenting my own children alongside her parenting hers. I wouldnt say it was empathy as ive never encountered fertility issues.

Swipe left for the next trending thread