Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Disappointed that Chimamanda Ngozie Adichie is promoting her use of surrogacy as compatible with feminism

316 replies

Carla786 · 20/04/2026 01:36

I loved Purple Hibiscus and recently got through the rest of her books from my library. I really like her novels and especially her GC stance, but I was discussing her on a feminist subreddit recently and her use of surrogacy came up. It's disappointing she promotes it here as compatible with feminism,

https://www.premiumtimesng.com/entertainment/naija-fashion/791804-ive-no-regrets-welcoming-my-twins-through-surrogacy-chimamanda-adichie.html

Infertility is of course extremely painful, but I don't think that justifies using another woman's womb.

‘I've no regrets welcoming my twins through surrogacy’ - Chimamanda Adichie

“I want more women to feel less ashamed of talking about reaching motherhood through non-traditional means.”

https://www.premiumtimesng.com/entertainment/naija-fashion/791804-ive-no-regrets-welcoming-my-twins-through-surrogacy-chimamanda-adichie.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
OpheliaWitchoftheWoods · 20/04/2026 12:47

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 12:39

Underthemoon1 · 20/04/2026 12:25

It's great to have a thread debating surrogacy, but very unnecessary and distasteful to link it to Adichie while she greives after the recent death of one of her children.

Edited

She wrote a defence of surrogacy. Her recent tragic loss of a child doesn't make her immune to having that defence critiqued.

Underthemoon1 · 20/04/2026 12:25

It's great to have a thread debating surrogacy, but very unnecessary and distasteful to link it to Adichie while she greives after the recent death of one of her children.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 12:23

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:34

Why do you think all birth plans mean handing the baby straight over?

Most of them do, to try to spare the surrogate mother the heartbreak of bonding further with the baby she nurtured inside her and then breaking that strengthened bond.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 12:17

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:47

Her husband. Her on laws. Her parents. Her community. Society? Could be anyone. Shes been groomed since birth, remember?

Most men are pretty indifferent to having children. In societies where contraceptive use is normal, it's predominately the woman driving the pregnancy decision.

I'm not sure how having a baby is "kind" to any of the other people you list. They aren't involved in raising the child. They aren't craving a baby to cradle in their arms and raise according to their values. The "kindness" of the surrogate mother is in relieving that craving for another woman, which is where the conditioning to be kind and sacrifice herself for others kicks in.

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 12:00

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:38

Research says otherwise : - D

I am not familiar with the research but please do post more details here.

I understood from the twin adoption studies from the 1980s that the genetic component was found to be the majory factor. Sorry I don't have a link - but the rate was something like 50% for identical twins compared to 5% for non identical for different behaviours like risk taking and psychiatric problems

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 12:00

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:53

Not necessarily. I think we were thinking of more a transition over a few days/weeks where we both care for the baby.

What a lovely incredibly naive idea for everyone involved.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:53

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 11:47

So you think the baby spending a few hours or perhaps days strengthening the bond with its mother won’t make the separation more traumatic?

Not necessarily. I think we were thinking of more a transition over a few days/weeks where we both care for the baby.

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 11:52

ladykale · 20/04/2026 11:19

The comments about being a surrogate to a SIL or family member are so weird.

Does this means mums can’t do sky diving because there’s a risk? Can’t climb Mount Everest? How about skiing off piste - notable number of deaths from avalanches / other accidents?

If you have excellent healthcare, are in good health yourself, have been pregnant before and had had low risk pregnancies and are below a certain age, it’s hardly 50/50 risking death is i
I have had all my kids and I’m still at an age where I would happily act as a surrogate to my sister if she couldn’t otherwise have children! No family pressure needed - I’d be very happy to do it!

It is all about different experiences and perspectives isn't it?

If all your children are healthy and well it won't have occurred to you but since having my DS I am very aware that if something were to happen to me. other people wouldn't look after him well because he is not an easy person to care for. I know that he would be treated poorly or with indifference because that is our experience from school/medical so far. If I werent here (and even if it were his DF as carer in my absence) things would be very horrible for him.

Personally I found that my attitude to risk did change al lot after parenthood. I do worry about accidents and dying more than I used to. Even about injury - and I got breast cancer a couple of years ago and that has made it even worse! I am now very focussed on arrangements to make sure my DS will be cared for if I am not around. But that happened (to a lesser degree) even before my cancer or that I knew he would have additional needs - at a few days old even when the responsibility of what I had done hit me!

Anyway all that is only relevant in the sense that I have become acutely aware that there seems to be a "bekind" issue with surrogacy. It seems to encourage women to remain naive to a lot of the significant difficulties until it is too late. It will be years before the results of studies are available but my hypothesis is that the outcomes will be around the same as adoption - where at least prospective parents are screened and counselled to an degree that doesn't seem to be the case with surrogacy.

OpheliaWitchoftheWoods · 20/04/2026 11:48

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 11:47

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:38

Research says otherwise : - D

What research says genetic factors can be parented out? Please provide a link to research supporting your position,

Humptydumptysat · 20/04/2026 11:47

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:34

Why do you think all birth plans mean handing the baby straight over?

So you think the baby spending a few hours or perhaps days strengthening the bond with its mother won’t make the separation more traumatic?

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:38

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 11:35

"the way we adopt in this country is what causes the infants trauma"

I am sure the process for adoption is problematic but we cannot escape our genes or the resulting brain chemistry. The circumstances leading to adoption are very complicated and genetic factors cannot be parented out.

Research says otherwise : - D

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 11:35

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:40

Does it show that with surrogates? Can you show that information? Because the information I am privy to says the way we adopt in this country is what causes the infants trauma. The multiple caregivers before permanent placement etc. These things are not the case for surrogates.

"the way we adopt in this country is what causes the infants trauma"

I am sure the process for adoption is problematic but we cannot escape our genes or the resulting brain chemistry. The circumstances leading to adoption are very complicated and genetic factors cannot be parented out.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:34

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:59

That baby knows the heartbeat of its mother from within the womb, before birth. The very first breath it takes, it inhales its mother's smell. Newborns instinctively seek their mothers' breasts to feed.

Handing the baby to the commissioners breaks that bond that predates birth.

Why do you think all birth plans mean handing the baby straight over?

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:31

WydeStrype · 20/04/2026 11:28

But you ignore the child in this, don't you?

It is so fundamental, that babies should not be deliberately conceived to be traded/gifted/sold. The women are part of but not in any way the sole consideration.

We always ignore the baby's thoughts when we conceive one.

KnottyAuty · 20/04/2026 11:29

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:29

They would have raised a disabled child. Why do you assume they would not? Can you point to a post where I said anything like that?

The truth is that when we discussed it as a 4, they asked me if I would decline nuchal screening because they wanted the baby regardless of their ability/disability. I did point out that many disabilities would become evident on scan at some point and they were fine with that. We wanted to make sure all these sorts of things were sorted before we embarked on anything formal.

So why do you assume that two grown women, one of who is already a mother, would not discuss these outcomes?

Are your family known for giving up on babies due to disability? As mine or my husband's are not.

I have only asked questions because I am curious and because I asked about the disability question a couple of times and you ignored it, referring only to your own mortality. From that I inferred that you hadn't discussed it. I'm not judging as you seem to think - and as I explained above - because of my own experiences of pregnancy related queries/risk approach. One of my children is disabled - it is not an easy road and fraught with worry for the future. It wasn't a birth injury but I know people who have had to deal with this and it is a lot harder than the nuchal test discussion which is somewhat abstract (or at least it was for me)

WydeStrype · 20/04/2026 11:28

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:26

Sure but you know adult women with full mental capacity? We are able to discuss these issues and work out a way that we all feel happy to proceed. Again, why do you think so little of women that we cannot navigate this issue ourselves?

Why not be supported in having the right conversations, instead of trying to forbid a woman from using her body how she sees fit?

But you ignore the child in this, don't you?

It is so fundamental, that babies should not be deliberately conceived to be traded/gifted/sold. The women are part of but not in any way the sole consideration.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:28

WydeStrype · 20/04/2026 11:24

They're not weird at all.

I'm close to all my siblings and siblings in law. We love and support each other and our dc are all growing up together as a happy cousin tribe. They spend Christmases, birthdays and holidays together and everyone gets on.

However. We all parent differently. Our dc are all having very different childhoods. Their parents all have different finances, energy levels and priorities. I sometimes think their choices are mad and their priorities nuts.

I absolutely wouldn't not want my dc being brought up in their households and for that to be their experience of childhood. I would not want to hand over a baby and then have to bite my tongue and or feel responsible for what they experience and are subjected to.

It is not weird to raise concerns and issues. You can love your sister but not want to end up incontinent on her behalf.

Well thats about whatever goes on in your family member's house. Me and my SIL have very similar values and parenting styles.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 11:26

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:55

You're missing the point.

Legally, the surrogate mother is the mother until the adoption takes place. Legally, the commissioners can refuse to adopt and there's not a damned thing the surrogate mother can do about that. That this wouldn't happen in your family doesn't mean it wouldn't happen elsewhere. It already has.

It's not possible to craft laws that protect the surrogate mother from that outcome without those same laws being used to force her to relinquish the child if she changes her mind. Such laws would also put the surrogate mother at risk of being coerced into prenatal tests, abortion, and having her medical decisions overridden by the commissioners. Either the child is legally the surrogate mother's or legally the commissioners', you cannot have it both ways.

The fairest kindest legal solution is to simply outlaw surrogacy.

Sure but you know adult women with full mental capacity? We are able to discuss these issues and work out a way that we all feel happy to proceed. Again, why do you think so little of women that we cannot navigate this issue ourselves?

Why not be supported in having the right conversations, instead of trying to forbid a woman from using her body how she sees fit?

WydeStrype · 20/04/2026 11:24

ladykale · 20/04/2026 11:19

The comments about being a surrogate to a SIL or family member are so weird.

Does this means mums can’t do sky diving because there’s a risk? Can’t climb Mount Everest? How about skiing off piste - notable number of deaths from avalanches / other accidents?

If you have excellent healthcare, are in good health yourself, have been pregnant before and had had low risk pregnancies and are below a certain age, it’s hardly 50/50 risking death is i
I have had all my kids and I’m still at an age where I would happily act as a surrogate to my sister if she couldn’t otherwise have children! No family pressure needed - I’d be very happy to do it!

They're not weird at all.

I'm close to all my siblings and siblings in law. We love and support each other and our dc are all growing up together as a happy cousin tribe. They spend Christmases, birthdays and holidays together and everyone gets on.

However. We all parent differently. Our dc are all having very different childhoods. Their parents all have different finances, energy levels and priorities. I sometimes think their choices are mad and their priorities nuts.

I absolutely wouldn't not want my dc being brought up in their households and for that to be their experience of childhood. I would not want to hand over a baby and then have to bite my tongue and or feel responsible for what they experience and are subjected to.

It is not weird to raise concerns and issues. You can love your sister but not want to end up incontinent on her behalf.

ladykale · 20/04/2026 11:19

The comments about being a surrogate to a SIL or family member are so weird.

Does this means mums can’t do sky diving because there’s a risk? Can’t climb Mount Everest? How about skiing off piste - notable number of deaths from avalanches / other accidents?

If you have excellent healthcare, are in good health yourself, have been pregnant before and had had low risk pregnancies and are below a certain age, it’s hardly 50/50 risking death is i
I have had all my kids and I’m still at an age where I would happily act as a surrogate to my sister if she couldn’t otherwise have children! No family pressure needed - I’d be very happy to do it!

Beowulfa · 20/04/2026 10:59

The adoption process has changed hugely in this country; now being child-focussed with honesty and openness about the child's birth parents and the circumstances under which they were removed, and ongoing social worker involvement. It is now acknowledged that removing an infant from its mother is a serious step that should only be undertaken if it's the least worst scenario.

There is no equivalent attitude in surrogacy. Would commercial agencies even co-operate with any attempt at a long-term study of outcomes (of both child welfare, and the mental and physical health of the "gestational carrier")? How can you monitor outcomes with private, altruistic arrangements?

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:59

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:48

Why do you think surrogacy forbids that?

That baby knows the heartbeat of its mother from within the womb, before birth. The very first breath it takes, it inhales its mother's smell. Newborns instinctively seek their mothers' breasts to feed.

Handing the baby to the commissioners breaks that bond that predates birth.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 10:55

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 10:29

They would have raised a disabled child. Why do you assume they would not? Can you point to a post where I said anything like that?

The truth is that when we discussed it as a 4, they asked me if I would decline nuchal screening because they wanted the baby regardless of their ability/disability. I did point out that many disabilities would become evident on scan at some point and they were fine with that. We wanted to make sure all these sorts of things were sorted before we embarked on anything formal.

So why do you assume that two grown women, one of who is already a mother, would not discuss these outcomes?

Are your family known for giving up on babies due to disability? As mine or my husband's are not.

You're missing the point.

Legally, the surrogate mother is the mother until the adoption takes place. Legally, the commissioners can refuse to adopt and there's not a damned thing the surrogate mother can do about that. That this wouldn't happen in your family doesn't mean it wouldn't happen elsewhere. It already has.

It's not possible to craft laws that protect the surrogate mother from that outcome without those same laws being used to force her to relinquish the child if she changes her mind. Such laws would also put the surrogate mother at risk of being coerced into prenatal tests, abortion, and having her medical decisions overridden by the commissioners. Either the child is legally the surrogate mother's or legally the commissioners', you cannot have it both ways.

The fairest kindest legal solution is to simply outlaw surrogacy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread