Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Disappointed that Chimamanda Ngozie Adichie is promoting her use of surrogacy as compatible with feminism

316 replies

Carla786 · 20/04/2026 01:36

I loved Purple Hibiscus and recently got through the rest of her books from my library. I really like her novels and especially her GC stance, but I was discussing her on a feminist subreddit recently and her use of surrogacy came up. It's disappointing she promotes it here as compatible with feminism,

https://www.premiumtimesng.com/entertainment/naija-fashion/791804-ive-no-regrets-welcoming-my-twins-through-surrogacy-chimamanda-adichie.html

Infertility is of course extremely painful, but I don't think that justifies using another woman's womb.

‘I've no regrets welcoming my twins through surrogacy’ - Chimamanda Adichie

“I want more women to feel less ashamed of talking about reaching motherhood through non-traditional means.”

https://www.premiumtimesng.com/entertainment/naija-fashion/791804-ive-no-regrets-welcoming-my-twins-through-surrogacy-chimamanda-adichie.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Empis · 22/04/2026 06:48

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 20/04/2026 12:39

She wrote a defence of surrogacy. Her recent tragic loss of a child doesn't make her immune to having that defence critiqued.

Yeah but maybe just debate surrogacy on a different thread? I am against surrogacy too but I think continuing this debate under this thread title is horrible. She lost her child.

Of course posters have the right to critique her viewpoints on whatever thread they like... but just because you can, doesn't mean you should.

Wearenotborg · 22/04/2026 05:56

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 15:28

I think we have to be actually factual about what we are saying. Adoptive kids with fewer caregivers have less trauma. A surrogate goes from one parent to the other. the baby only knows one home and additionally,;typically lacks the genetic and social factors that predispose them to trauma. Drugs arent likely to be a factor. Nor is serious mental illness.

I get that you want people to be convinced by your arguments, but making things up isnt the way to go about it. Its okay for you to be against surrogacy just because it squicks you out. You dont have to make things up for your opinion to be valid.

To be fair I’m against all forms of human trafficking. How is it ok to sell a newborn but not a four year old? Why is human trafficking of adults prohibited but allowed for newborns?

Carla786 · 22/04/2026 00:37

Igneococcus · 21/04/2026 21:13

My friend isn't gay, his sister is. I wasn't saying it's the same as surrogacy, I was talking about family dynamics and pressure to help out a close and beloved family member. That pressure could be even higher because there is no health risk involved.

I'm sorry, I didn't follow properly. I understand what you are saying now : agree re pressure to help a family member & the dangers of this.

OP posts:
Igneococcus · 21/04/2026 21:13

Carla786 · 21/04/2026 17:42

I think the situation with your gay friend is surely different though? Presumably the lesbian he gave sperm to would be carrying her own egg, so she wouldn't be going to any more risk than a woman getting pregnant in a straight marriage would?
I respect his decision not to go through with it, but surely that's a different situation to a surrogate pregnancy where the woman is taking extra risk as she's carrying an egg that's not biologically related to her?

Edited

My friend isn't gay, his sister is. I wasn't saying it's the same as surrogacy, I was talking about family dynamics and pressure to help out a close and beloved family member. That pressure could be even higher because there is no health risk involved.

DamsonGoldfinch · 21/04/2026 21:05

Arran2024 · 21/04/2026 18:03

I find it odd that I could obtain a donated egg and mix it with my husband's sperm, carry that baby, and people say to me "yes of course you are the mother" ie the dna mother is not as important as the birth mother.

Meanwhile another woman could carry a baby for me, using my egg, mixed with my husband's sperm and people would say to me "yes of course you are the mother" ie the dna mother IS more important than the birth mother.

So, which is it? This is one of the crazy situations with reproductive technology. The child will be told whatever happened is the truth, and the "other" mother is practically written out in most cases.

Bingo. People tell themselves whatever story validates their position.

A woman who uses a donor egg to conceive her child = she is 100% the mother.
A woman who used her egg for another woman to conceive her child = she is 100% the mother.

Both of these can’t be true. Spaghetti logic doesn’t work for children.

Carla786 · 21/04/2026 18:10

Arran2024 · 21/04/2026 18:03

I find it odd that I could obtain a donated egg and mix it with my husband's sperm, carry that baby, and people say to me "yes of course you are the mother" ie the dna mother is not as important as the birth mother.

Meanwhile another woman could carry a baby for me, using my egg, mixed with my husband's sperm and people would say to me "yes of course you are the mother" ie the dna mother IS more important than the birth mother.

So, which is it? This is one of the crazy situations with reproductive technology. The child will be told whatever happened is the truth, and the "other" mother is practically written out in most cases.

Good point, exactly.

OP posts:
Arran2024 · 21/04/2026 18:03

I find it odd that I could obtain a donated egg and mix it with my husband's sperm, carry that baby, and people say to me "yes of course you are the mother" ie the dna mother is not as important as the birth mother.

Meanwhile another woman could carry a baby for me, using my egg, mixed with my husband's sperm and people would say to me "yes of course you are the mother" ie the dna mother IS more important than the birth mother.

So, which is it? This is one of the crazy situations with reproductive technology. The child will be told whatever happened is the truth, and the "other" mother is practically written out in most cases.

Carla786 · 21/04/2026 17:51

SpidersAreShitheads · 21/04/2026 16:23

@Forecastsayssnowbutthereisnosnow I didn’t reference that post as I wasn’t on it but I’ve seen the comments you are referring to and they’re just jaw dropping. Misandry certainly seems to be a real concern for that poster - mentioned on multiple threads - so you may well be right.

Back on topic for this thread, @ArabellaScott that story is shocking! Where’s the safeguarding for babies? A friend of mine has just adopted a young baby and the checks are rigorous. This is the concern re surrogacy - where do the rights of the baby figure? Or their safety?

I suppose the difference with surrogacy is that the man is usually biologically related, and sometimes the woman (if her own eggs are used). But in this case arguably the biological egg/sperm connection is being weighed above the womb connection, to terrible consequences.

Moreover, arguably men don't have the same impetus to bond biologically often (I think) and this must be taken into account.

OP posts:
Carla786 · 21/04/2026 17:42

Igneococcus · 21/04/2026 08:41

My sister is a bit like that. The time and care she gave to our mum after her devastating stroke (she died in January) is astonishing. She would feel under so much pressure to go along if that question were put to her.
I have a friend in the US who was asked by his lesbian sister if he'd donate sperm for her wife to get pregnant with and he thought it through very carefully and then declined. He is very close to her and her wife, they live in ultra-progressive Portland OR, and he really fretted about it but in the end decided he didn't want to do it. He really hated being put into this position and it didn't even involved being pregnant himself.

I think the situation with your gay friend is surely different though? Presumably the lesbian he gave sperm to would be carrying her own egg, so she wouldn't be going to any more risk than a woman getting pregnant in a straight marriage would?
I respect his decision not to go through with it, but surely that's a different situation to a surrogate pregnancy where the woman is taking extra risk as she's carrying an egg that's not biologically related to her?

OP posts:
Carla786 · 21/04/2026 17:39

GlovedhandsCecilia · 21/04/2026 08:12

You know the vast majority of women, even in war and famine, have healthy babies, right? Maternal mortality, especially for moddle classed white women, is very low in the UK. I would take that tiny risk to make a woman very close to me a mother, even though my risk of death is slightly higher due to.my demographic.

Again, I think it depends on your family values. We know that the natives here have been dealing with the destruction of the family for about 2 generations now.

Re the alleged 'destruction of the family' in white British communities, it's worth noting that black British women are more likely to be single parents. (I understand you are black and referring to black communities in your paras on extended families?)
Maybe it's better to accept that there are strengths and weaknesses in families of all demographics rather than accuse any demographic of 'destroying the family'?

https://blackballad.co.uk/solo-parenting#:~:text=Black%20Women%20&%20Solo%20Parenting,are%20'lone%20parent%20families

OP posts:
UtopiaPlanitia · 21/04/2026 17:11

I firmly believe that altruistic surrogacy provides cover and offers legitimacy to the horrors of commercial surrogacy.

ReduXX and Surrogacy Concern are two female-focussed orgs I follow on TwiX who document cases of sex offenders who buy children through surrogacy:
https://x.com/SurrogConcern/status/2046461426785550605?s=20

Alternate link:
https://nitter.net/SurrogConcern/status/2046461426785550605?s=20

This case is also shocking:
https://x.com/LiveAction/status/2046272690214801520?s=20

Non-TwiX link:
https://nitter.net/LiveAction/status/2046272690214801520?s=20

ArabellaScott · 21/04/2026 16:49

Hm.

Speaking of adoption. Another content warning, I'm sorry. The news is horrible today.

A baby was allegedly abused and killed by his adoptive parent/s. Another strong content warning. Do avoid if you're not feeling strong.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c393eww1pero

SpidersAreShitheads · 21/04/2026 16:23

@Forecastsayssnowbutthereisnosnow I didn’t reference that post as I wasn’t on it but I’ve seen the comments you are referring to and they’re just jaw dropping. Misandry certainly seems to be a real concern for that poster - mentioned on multiple threads - so you may well be right.

Back on topic for this thread, @ArabellaScott that story is shocking! Where’s the safeguarding for babies? A friend of mine has just adopted a young baby and the checks are rigorous. This is the concern re surrogacy - where do the rights of the baby figure? Or their safety?

CassOle · 21/04/2026 16:10

That's shocking.

Forecastsayssnowbutthereisnosnow · 21/04/2026 16:08

SpidersAreShitheads · 21/04/2026 15:28

At the risk of summoning that particular poster again who I have absolutely no desire to interact with, on another post she was defending the use of very unpleasant, graphic language used by a man against a woman. Her position is that a man saying “fuck <insert woman’s name> with a splintery rolling pin” is perfectly normal, colloquial language - and apparently a woman uses exactly the same language in her workplace. She very much thought it was acceptable language. Just like this thread, she spent many pages across multiple days scolding women for being wrong.

On another thread a woman posted about her (very senior) position in a company and described pretty horrendous behaviour from her male boss. This same poster from this thread with a fondness for defending the use of splintery rolling pins appeared, randomly accused the woman of lying, and suggested she brought it all on herself. It was truly bizarre. Thankfully she was a lone voice - yet again.

That’s why I won’t interact with them. They always seem to appear on contentious threads and take a view that’s unpleasant, oppositional, and often misogynistic. I never see them arguing for women’s rights or safety with the same passion - weirdly though, they seem very enthusiastic when supporting positions which are harmful or damaging to women, either as a collective sex class or individually.

I have no issue with others who hold different views - but when someone consistently takes a view that’s anti-women, that’s a very different matter.

I agree with everything you say other than the assumption that the poster is definitely a woman.

The same poster has also dropped in to warn users about the awfulness of misandry and the risks mothers pose to "lots" of babies on a thread about the sexual abuse and murder of a baby by his adopted father and his male partner. I knew which poster I was reading by the style of response without even looking at the name.

ArabellaScott · 21/04/2026 15:57

Content warning.

A story about a man who is charged with pimping and sex trafficking, who has bought a baby via surrogacy.

https://reduxx.info/canada-local-pride-organization-founder-facing-sex-trafficking-charges/

SpidersAreShitheads · 21/04/2026 15:28

CassOle · 21/04/2026 14:14

What?
How can anyone think that is OK?

At the risk of summoning that particular poster again who I have absolutely no desire to interact with, on another post she was defending the use of very unpleasant, graphic language used by a man against a woman. Her position is that a man saying “fuck <insert woman’s name> with a splintery rolling pin” is perfectly normal, colloquial language - and apparently a woman uses exactly the same language in her workplace. She very much thought it was acceptable language. Just like this thread, she spent many pages across multiple days scolding women for being wrong.

On another thread a woman posted about her (very senior) position in a company and described pretty horrendous behaviour from her male boss. This same poster from this thread with a fondness for defending the use of splintery rolling pins appeared, randomly accused the woman of lying, and suggested she brought it all on herself. It was truly bizarre. Thankfully she was a lone voice - yet again.

That’s why I won’t interact with them. They always seem to appear on contentious threads and take a view that’s unpleasant, oppositional, and often misogynistic. I never see them arguing for women’s rights or safety with the same passion - weirdly though, they seem very enthusiastic when supporting positions which are harmful or damaging to women, either as a collective sex class or individually.

I have no issue with others who hold different views - but when someone consistently takes a view that’s anti-women, that’s a very different matter.

CassOle · 21/04/2026 15:23

Thanks for clarifying. I'm glad that the poster concerned wasn't saying that it was OK.

Carla786 · 21/04/2026 14:53

CassOle · 21/04/2026 14:14

What?
How can anyone think that is OK?

I've seen the thread and I didn't agree with pp's position, but I also didn't think she was saying it was OK.

OP posts:
Carla786 · 21/04/2026 14:45

GlovedhandsCecilia · 21/04/2026 08:12

You know the vast majority of women, even in war and famine, have healthy babies, right? Maternal mortality, especially for moddle classed white women, is very low in the UK. I would take that tiny risk to make a woman very close to me a mother, even though my risk of death is slightly higher due to.my demographic.

Again, I think it depends on your family values. We know that the natives here have been dealing with the destruction of the family for about 2 generations now.

Risks are higher for surrogacy though as the child isn't genetically related.

What do you mean by 'natives' here and destruction of the family?

OP posts:
CassOle · 21/04/2026 14:14

StellaAndCrow · 21/04/2026 13:28

Well it's from the person who thought it was ok for someone to say that women should get raped with splitered baseball bats, so I guess it's just more of the same from them.

What?
How can anyone think that is OK?

Arran2024 · 21/04/2026 14:09

GlovedhandsCecilia · 21/04/2026 08:38

If you use a surrogacy agency in the UK, you hsve counselling where they screen for your suitability on all sides. Not everyone passes. That is why some people do it "informally", purely because they wouldn't meet the approved standards in a developed country. Similar to international adoption. And that was from my research in 2012 so they already had this counselling in place.

How can you do surrogacy "informally"? The baby is legally the child of the woman who birthed it and private adoption is illegal in the UK. You have to go through an agency to make it legal to hand the baby over.

StellaAndCrow · 21/04/2026 13:28

ArabellaScott · 21/04/2026 08:26

Bloody hell, that is one of the cruellest and most insensitive responses to a post I've read yet.

Opheliawitchofthewoods Flowers

Well it's from the person who thought it was ok for someone to say that women should get raped with splitered baseball bats, so I guess it's just more of the same from them.

Helleofabore · 21/04/2026 12:45

I remember there was a poster once on MN who discussed their surrogacy decision and experience. If I remember correctly, the woman told us that she had no regrets but that the friend had become very distant with the child as the child got older. Which was not the arrangement. When we heard more and more of the story, the emotional dynamic between the friends seemed to indicate that there was a need in the friend who carried the child to experience pregnancy again.

Often when you start to unpick some of these surrogacy arrangements, there are unexpected unhealthy dynamics on either side of the arrangement. I really could see where these arrangements would become unwanted by one party.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 21/04/2026 12:18

GlovedhandsCecilia · 20/04/2026 15:48

Groomed from birth by your own admission so now none of us can trust your yes ever means yes. You might just be fawning.

Given the enmeshed family relationship dynamics that you consider to be routine and desirable and the strong people-pleasing actions you describe yourself as taking towards your in-laws, I would argue that if anyone on this thread has been groomed successfully to doormat themselves for their relatives, it's you, and your offer to bear your SIL's child is born of that emeshment and desire to people-please.

Swipe left for the next trending thread