Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Conference plunged into turmoil over priority 'equity cards' eg trans woman furious a biological woman allowed to go first

42 replies

IwantToRetire · 30/03/2026 20:44

Okay - this is a DM article - so now doubt they have picked on the most extreme instances, but thought it quite funny:

A political conference for Canada's New Democratic Party descended into chaos after progressive activists got into heated arguments over 'equity cards.'

NDP members from across the nation gathered in Winnipeg, the capital of the Manitoba province, over the weekend to elect the party's new leader.
The event was billed as an opportunity for progressive Canadians to 'come together to debate ideas, celebrate our shared values, and help shape the future of our movement,' the NDP convention website said.

But footage from the event revealed frustration among delegates over the alleged misuse of so-called equity cards, colored coded cards that identified a party member as being part of a marginalized group that granted them special privileges.

'Equity' is a woke buzzword that means equality of outcomes. Progressives say that equality, generally taken to mean equal opportunities, can be discriminatory because some minority groups must first overcome disadvantages that others do not have.

One delegate was outraged that she was allegedly skipped in the speaker queue despite having been standing at the podium with her gender equity card.

A transgender woman who argued her 'rights are under attack' claimed it was 'frustrating' that a 'cis gender woman had spoken over me.'
Similarly, a black woman argued that equity cards for women like her 'have no value outside of this space.'

Conference chair Adrienne Smith, who identifies as non-binary, also seemed a bit testy and snapped at a delegate in a keffiyeh after being addressed as 'madame chair.'

Continues at https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15691203/canada-ndp-conference-equity-cards-chaos.html and https://archive.is/NIS2p

(NB I did try to find a news report about the Conference but this is the only one that came up. If anyone has any news about the Conference that says a bit more than this would be interested to know what happened in terms of achieving conference aims!)

Chaos after woke lawmakers give minorities 'equity cards' to cut line

New Democratic Party members from across Canada gathered in Winnipeg, the capital of the Manitoba province, over the weekend to elect the party's new leader.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15691203/canada-ndp-conference-equity-cards-chaos.html

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IwantToRetire · 01/04/2026 18:34

I must admit that when I saw who the new leader was, and how the political agenda of the party was presented, whether the Conference wasn't a bit like having a creche at an event.

ie you dont want silly childish behaviour disrupting an adult discussion (allowing that people do have different politcals to one's own) so you allow them to have their very own (irrelevant) play acting at politics and the established norms of party politics carries on.

ie the white male establishment keeps their hold on positions of powers.

OP posts:
SionnachRuadh · 01/04/2026 12:27

Alex makes King Charles look common.

See also Corbyn's former chief of staff Andrew Drummond-Murray of Mastrik, who prefers to just go by "Andrew Murray" when being a man of the people.

There's a surprising number of prominent communists in Debrett's.

Lalgarh · 01/04/2026 12:13

Cf Britain's poshest communist Alex Kalinicos

TheKeatingFive · 01/04/2026 11:48

PeachyDaisy · 01/04/2026 11:45

He's not just any white male, he is a nepo baby. His father was a former leader of the party and his wife is a very famous activist/writer. His family is extremely famous and wealthy (ironically for a party that is supposed to be for the "working-class")

Edited

Many such cases!

PeachyDaisy · 01/04/2026 11:45

DrBlackbird · 01/04/2026 09:01

And yet a straight white male is the new leader. Truly, plus ça change,plus c'est la même chose. But agree on the inveigling.

He's not just any white male, he is a nepo baby. His father was a former leader of the party and his wife is a very famous activist/writer. His family is extremely famous and wealthy (ironically for a party that is supposed to be for the "working-class")

Lalgarh · 01/04/2026 11:37

@Echobelly !!! You're not Sonia are you

TheKeatingFive · 01/04/2026 10:32

Echobelly · 01/04/2026 09:44

Tbh, it doesn't sound like it was 'chaos' or 'turmoil' at all. Some people made criticisms of a system and the writer decided that the speaker 'seemed a bit testy' about being misgendered. Maybe they were, maybe that was entirely the writer's projection, but unless you were there you'll never know I guess.

What I do know is the Mail has a vested interest in portraying women and left wing people, and especially left wing women, as silly, petty and hysterical, so I'm calling hyperbole on their description of what happened. Don't get me wrong, as a lefty myself I think leftist people can be daft and nitpicky, but it feels like this Mail report is making mountains out of molehills.

It's like when papers have headline about 'CELEB'S FURY OVER INCIDENT' and it turns out they expressed no more than mild disapproval about something

I didn't read the DM article.

I saw vids on X. The whole thing was ridiculous.

Not in a 'this is chaos' way, but more in a 'this is the kind of nonsense so-called intelligent people are spending their time on' way.

Echobelly · 01/04/2026 09:44

Tbh, it doesn't sound like it was 'chaos' or 'turmoil' at all. Some people made criticisms of a system and the writer decided that the speaker 'seemed a bit testy' about being misgendered. Maybe they were, maybe that was entirely the writer's projection, but unless you were there you'll never know I guess.

What I do know is the Mail has a vested interest in portraying women and left wing people, and especially left wing women, as silly, petty and hysterical, so I'm calling hyperbole on their description of what happened. Don't get me wrong, as a lefty myself I think leftist people can be daft and nitpicky, but it feels like this Mail report is making mountains out of molehills.

It's like when papers have headline about 'CELEB'S FURY OVER INCIDENT' and it turns out they expressed no more than mild disapproval about something

JellySaurus · 01/04/2026 09:25

MaturingCheeseball · 01/04/2026 08:45

I’d laugh if it wasn’t so worrying that these clowns have inveigled their way into institutions.

Actually what they need to do is have a major conference to compile a thorough list of who trumps who in victimhood. Obviously a straight white male is absolutely at the bottom (sub bottom, really) but who will come out on top? Interesting!

Unless he wears a she/her badge, in which case he boings straight up into top position.

Lalgarh · 01/04/2026 09:21

MaturingCheeseball · 01/04/2026 08:45

I’d laugh if it wasn’t so worrying that these clowns have inveigled their way into institutions.

Actually what they need to do is have a major conference to compile a thorough list of who trumps who in victimhood. Obviously a straight white male is absolutely at the bottom (sub bottom, really) but who will come out on top? Interesting!

I keep trying to figure out how the Cleese/ Barker / Corbet class sketch would work with intersectionality but I can't compute. I think they'd have to be on moving platforms or a see saw

TheKeatingFive · 01/04/2026 09:06

The loony left continue to outdo themselves.

What a bunch of f*cking muppets.

They need to go do some manual labour/shelf stacking/caring jobs for a while and then come back and talk to us about their 'oppression' 🙄

DrBlackbird · 01/04/2026 09:01

MaturingCheeseball · 01/04/2026 08:45

I’d laugh if it wasn’t so worrying that these clowns have inveigled their way into institutions.

Actually what they need to do is have a major conference to compile a thorough list of who trumps who in victimhood. Obviously a straight white male is absolutely at the bottom (sub bottom, really) but who will come out on top? Interesting!

And yet a straight white male is the new leader. Truly, plus ça change,plus c'est la même chose. But agree on the inveigling.

MaturingCheeseball · 01/04/2026 08:45

I’d laugh if it wasn’t so worrying that these clowns have inveigled their way into institutions.

Actually what they need to do is have a major conference to compile a thorough list of who trumps who in victimhood. Obviously a straight white male is absolutely at the bottom (sub bottom, really) but who will come out on top? Interesting!

TheBeaTgoeson1 · 01/04/2026 08:25

Yeah, daily mail and that.

Shedmistress · 01/04/2026 02:23

Oh Canada.

SionnachRuadh · 01/04/2026 00:49

Hang on, Naomi Klein's husband is the new leader? For someone who doesn't believe in capitalism, she's got a very entrepreneurial attitude to the family business.

Reading about this on wiki and the nomination rules hurt my brain:

To be nominated, candidates require at least 500 signatures from party members, at least half of which must be from female-identified members and at least 100 from "other equity-seeking groups," including Indigenous people, LGBTQIA2S+ people, persons with disabilities, and visible minorities.

RovingPublicEnquiry · 31/03/2026 23:06

That Daily Mail article reads like a Saturday Night Live skit. Especially when you find out that the one in the keffiyeh who got snapped at for misgendering the chair is ALSO non binary.

I despair that this is reality.

Lalgarh · 31/03/2026 22:33

The all time classic, as posted elsewhere, is from the DSA, the US equivalent of the Socialist Workers Party (but maybe not with the cover ups of sexual assault)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/_NdE9CjkvTY?si=XKBNdtz6wrrK1Ogc

IwantToRetire · 31/03/2026 17:20

Not saying I agree with the politics of the new leader of this party, but how stupid to let these silly student antics divert attention from the actual point of the Party.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/mar/30/canada-avi-lewis-elected-new-democratic-party

Fun fact. He is married to Naomi Klein who wrote an article about how he should be elected the new leader. But I wasn't prepared to pay to be able to read it.

Avi Lewis, elected to lead Canada’s New Democratic party, promises ‘NDP comeback’

Ex-TV host pledged to centre party around equity, with higher wealth taxes, green energy and tuition-free education Sign up for the Breaking News US email to get newsletter alerts in your inbox

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/mar/30/canada-avi-lewis-elected-new-democratic-party

OP posts:
TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/03/2026 14:59

Thanks for the link, the Victim Olympics sponsored by the Omnicause. 😂

DrBlackbird · 31/03/2026 09:33

@Abhannmor I guess it depends on how we’re defining eloquent but I’m using it for when people seemingly sound plausible and in doing so are persuasive. Such people can also be verbose and fool people in this manner. It’s dangerous. One of my very early experiences of TRAs advocacy was watching the YouTube posted by the trans man Jamie and partner. Both criticising JKRs essay. Both talking a million miles an hour so verbose, yes. Both attributing claims to JKR that she had not made, but also sounded eloquent in doing so. Both have PhDs so practiced in the art of using rhetoric to say nothing. Both sounding plausible to my then teenager DCs being swayed by their eloquence.

@TempestTost learn something new every day as I didn’t appreciate it was the CCF, the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation under Tommy Douglas that started nationalised (provincial) healthcare and not the once proud NDP.

Again we see evidence of how gender ideology tag teams with progressive or liberal organisations and ruins them from the inside out. It’s criminal.

RoyalCorgi · 31/03/2026 09:18

TheAutumnCrow · 31/03/2026 00:41

So one of those equity cards is like playing your joker on It’s A Knockout?

(One for the gimmers there.)

It's exactly like that.

And as always with this stuff, it's part comical, part terrifying. You can laugh at these loons but then you discover, as a PP said, that this woman was instrumental in taking money away from a women's rape crisis centre, and it's not so funny after all.

Abhannmor · 31/03/2026 09:14

DrBlackbird · 31/03/2026 08:16

This is why trans activists focus on gaining control of the levers of power behind the scenes: establishing ideological control in institutions through workshops/struggle sessions. Embedding their ideology into law and policy, not by convincing the public they are right, but by lobbying behind closed doors. Once laws and policies are changed, enforcing public compliance through courts and tribunals. Smith may cut a ridiculous figure, but don't underestimate her.

Whoever Nick is, he’s right to point out the danger of eloquent, driven, self serving and ruthless TRAs. Most humans are too busy just living so when a few ultra determined people, who have no other focus in life, push to remake the world in their own specific image, they can do so much damage.

This has reminded me to donate to the VRR.

Are these nutters really eloquent. Or just verbose , loquacious, whatever the word is ? I know what you mean though. I had a friend we used to call Many Words a Minute. You could never process her output fast enough to argue back. But at least she wasn't a little proto fascist like Citizen Smith here.

Interesting that the woman who addressed her as Madame Chair is wearing a keffiyeh. Will there be a split I wonder.

1000StrawberryLollies · 31/03/2026 09:04

What a pathetic farce!

A transgender woman who argued her 'rights are under attack' claimed it was 'frustrating' that a 'cis gender woman had spoken over me.'

Of course the irony is that it's the transwoman, and indeed transwomen in general, who are actually trying to 'skip the queue' - by choosing to identify into a group they categorically do not belong to, which is more disadvantaged than their own.

DrBlackbird · 31/03/2026 09:02

IwantToRetire · 31/03/2026 00:30

Well this explains a lot about her:

"She was instrumental in cutting municipal funding to Vancouver Rape Relief, a women's shelter that refuses to admit men."

Angry

It is impressive that the VRR still manages to centre females.

Being girls and women in this world often impacts both how we look and how we act in private and in public; what we are allowed to do, encouraged to do, and rewarded for; and also, what we are discouraged from doing, prohibited to do, or punished for. And from that place, in a woman-only space, with other women—who have the shared experience of being born without a choice to the oppressed class of women—we come together to organize and strategize our resistance and our fight for all women’s liberation.

We know that people whose behaviour is not consistent with the patriarchal socially imposed definition of manhood or womanhood, including trans people, suffer discrimination and violence. Trans people deserve and must live in safety, and have the equal rights and opportunities that are promised to us all. While some of our core services are not open to people who do not share our life experience of being born females and raised as girls into our current womanhood, we have a collective commitment to see to the safety anyone who calls our crisis line, including trans people.