Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Tribunal discussion thread supporting FayeRC in case against NHS England part 2

201 replies

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 20/03/2026 23:00

Today the tribunal concluded it's oral submissions 20/03/26 for the case of Faye Russell-Caldicott v. NHSE

Gardening is still underway, please search Faye Russell-Caldicott Crowd Justice to offer seeds of support. Less than 12 days left to get to target. If you're a woman, you know a woman, and you value women, this case does affect you as we could all find ourselves in this position with our employers and we need to send a message that we won't tolerate having our rights removed. Please if you can, send some gardening funds to the CJ page to help cover the legal fees associated with this case.

This is a continuation thread from: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5504170-tribunal-discussion-thread-supporting-fayerc-in-case-against-nhs-england-starting-160326?page=1

Thank you to everybody for showing your support to the wonderful @FayeRC. ❤️

It will be approximately 1 month before there's a verdict, and a provisional date set in August for a remedial hearing should the court find in FayeRC's favour.

Tribunal discussion thread supporting FayeRC in case against NHS England starting 16/03/26 | Mumsnet

Thanks for joining in this discussion in support of {mention:FayeRC} and the case against NHSE. This is a private tribunal case, so there will be no...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5504170-tribunal-discussion-thread-supporting-fayerc-in-case-against-nhs-england-starting-160326?page=1

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
14
Catiette · 23/10/2026 21:09

Thank you and well done, Faye. Really.

SternJoyousBeev2 · 23/10/2026 17:09

Thank you @FayeRC for having the nerve to see this through.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 23/10/2026 16:59

Thank you for your tenacity, @FayeRC. I hope you can finally get on with your life now, confident that you have more than done your bit.

WFTCHTJ · 23/10/2026 16:21

Well done @FayeRC . While it would be nice to see the respondents get their arses handed to them to a greater extent, we're not the ones who would have to suffer even more stress than you already have by going through the appeal process. I'm glad our arguing the toss over the Equality Act proved useful, and the moral and financial support was helpful. Hopefully with the new guidance no other woman will need to point to your case to support her own, but I'm not holding my breath on that. Thank you for seeing it through.

DrBlackbird · 22/10/2026 08:28

Thank god Faye had the stamina to go through with this tribunal but as said far too often, the process is the punishment.

This makes me feel fresh anger all over again in reading Faye’s statement to be reminded of the callous and ruthless treatment of her and her concerns by her Trust and the NHS management. Another illumination of how little women’s concerns or women’s feelings matter at the institutional level. Always.

So another thank you to Faye and the Darlington nurses, Sandie, Sarah, Jo and others back to Maya for starting the push back. Women’s fight continues.

Kirschcherries · 21/10/2026 18:12

@FayeRC well done. Thank you for being brave enough to do this I have an appreciation how hard it will have been to have this hanging over you for 4 years.

Londonmummy66 · 21/10/2026 15:53

@FayeRC - well done and thank you - you have more than done your bit!

KeepupKardigans · 21/10/2026 15:20

Well done, never once doubted your resolve on behalf of all and future women and girls. Thank you.

OhBotherSaidPoo · 21/10/2026 14:00

Well done Faye

stickygotstuck · 21/10/2026 13:57

Thank you so very much @FayeRC , and vey well done! 💐. Glad you can get on with the rest of your life without this cloud hanging over you.

@RoseInAPot , thank you for the update.

WeMeetInFairIthilien · 21/10/2026 13:38

Thank you @FayeRC

You stood up, and were counted.

You stood up, for yourself.

You stood up, for all those who could not.

Thank you.

BIWI · 21/10/2026 13:22

Well done @FayeRC Flowers

Keeptoiletssafe · 21/10/2026 13:14

@FayeRC well done xx

lcakethereforeIam · 21/10/2026 13:03

Well done that woman 👏

Wishesandhorses · 21/10/2026 12:50

Bravo Faye. Huge admiration for what you've achieved. Flowers

DontStopMe · 21/10/2026 12:41

Well done, Faye. So sorry you had to go through all this.

KittyWilkinson · 21/10/2026 12:29

Well done Faye and thanks so much for your tenacity in seeing this through. 🌹

Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/10/2026 12:24

Well done @FayeRC 💟

Hedgehogforshort · 21/10/2026 12:23

Faye has done her bit - thank you

MrsOvertonsWindow · 21/10/2026 12:21

Well done and thank you Faye.
You are hugely important in this tedious but important process of women taking our stuff back. Flowers

Shedmistress · 21/10/2026 12:17

Well done @FayeRC

wantmorenow · 21/10/2026 11:58

Well done and thank you for your update. You have achieved so much and I agree that further litigation would not be worth the costs in terms of time, emotional energy and money. Enjoy your future and know that very many women are grateful for your tenacity, courage and resilience. x

RoseInAPot · 21/10/2026 11:49

Bloody well done @FayeRC

Completely understand why you aren't going further, it isn't worth another 2 years of your life. You have done more than enough and hope your future is much less stressful!

RoseInAPot · 21/10/2026 11:46

Hopefully my post will reappear, but it has probably been removed as I linked to Faye's Crowdfunder page in order to provide her update on the case.

On her page Faye said:

"My employment tribunal case LS v NHS England, also known by my campaign name Faye Russell-Caldicott, reached final conclusion this week as neither party appealed the remedy decision that was handed down in early September. I have spent the appeal window digesting the outcome and decided I am content with the overall results.
The remedy judgment is embedded in didlaw’s press release at: https://didlaw.com/ls-v-nhs-england-remedy

The Tribunal awarded compensation for injury to feelings in the middle Vento band for the discrimination and harassment suffered, recognising the continued nature of it.
I am delighted the Tribunal recognised that the symptoms of my pre-existing condition of PTSD were exacerbated by the events set out in the claim. In other places, I felt there was a fundamental lack of understanding of PTSD and how my pre-existing condition ‘worked’ in new situations. Previously, I had provided a Disability Impact Statement (DIS) which gave examples of how my PTSD was triggered in various day-to-day situations. The purpose of this was to get NHSE to agree that my PTSD amounted to a disability under the Equality Act, which they agreed to ahead of liability hearing, so we did not need to wrangle over my disability status in the hearing. However, the remedy judgment oddly noted these examples of triggers had nothing to do with my employer’s conduct, which of course was true. However, what the judgment should have done, in my view, was to highlight other parts of the DIS where I had addressed how NHSE’s stance on facilities exacerbated and triggered my pre-existing PTSD.
Another place where the decision fell short, in my view, was the incorrect understanding that the superficially better new facilities would not have had a negative impact on me. The judgment did not make any reference to a log of my access issues in the new building despite my barrister specifically asking the panel to consider it, or any of the numerous emails from me explaining access issues in the new building. Essentially the injury to feelings awarded covered only one year in the old building and left out the impact of two years in the new building.
I felt the Tribunal placed more trust than me in NHSE’s capability to get the new policy right by not making any of the recommendations I had requested, such as seeking gender critical input from SEEN in Health or Sex Matters when developing policy, or ensuring mandatory training was appropriate.
I sat on the fence for a long time, trying to decide whether to appeal or not. Although appealing may have had some merit on the narrower points of PTSD and access issues in the new building, on the balance, I felt that another round of proceedings would offer limited benefit when weighed against the input required in terms of cost, mental effort and time.
Appeals are not for wrangling over what they might perceive to be minor issues – a judgment would have to be so perverse that no reasonable judge could have reached that conclusion. I feel arguing the point about PTSD might be an uphill battle and would put me under more stress.
Moreover, NHSE will be abolished and merged into DHSC at the end of March 2027, with significant staffing cuts and everyone dispersing in different directions with their careers, so those responsible for the policy would be paying little attention to my EAT proceedings in a couple of years’ time. Holding relevant teams accountable and concluding the matter is important to me.
I keep reminding myself that I have done my part by winning two harassment claims and one indirect discrimination claim against the national, umbrella NHS organisation. I filed an ET complaint in April 2024 when the other ET cases on facilities in the NHS were not in the public eye yet, it was pre-Supreme Court ruling and we had the unlawful 2011 EHRC guidance in place. It seemed that only women’s organisations had got the law right and institutions were unwilling to listen to them.
I myself had to battle poor in-house legal advice at NHSE which suggested that it should be me who was directed to other facilities. In cross examination, we heard from an NHSE witness who explained their persistence not to amend the policy despite the SC ruling was because they were worried about potential future tribunal claims from trans colleagues if they changed the policy, whilst sitting in an actual tribunal session for not changing the said policy.
I am delighted to see NHSE is now moving to a very different position compared to a few years back. In July 2026, two weeks before my remedy hearing, NHSE changed its trans staff policy so that facilities were to be used according to biological sex. Furthermore, on 15 October 2026, NHSE published guidance to NHS Trusts on how to arrange staff facilities and patient accommodation.
Personally, I am delighted to see my journey of in-house complaints and ET proceedings that lasted for four years coming to an end. I would not have got the right outcome without several key people.
I would like to thank my counsel Naomi Cunningham from Outer Temple and solicitors Elizabeth McGlone, Manuela de Castro and Beatrice Young from didlaw. You have all been invaluable on this journey.
Thank you Professor Jo Phoenix for providing a report to the ET, as well as several of my SEEN in Health colleagues at NHS England who provided evidence of their negative experiences when challenging unlawful policy and practices around sex and gender critical belief.
Thank you Sandie Peggie and Darlington nurses for challenging similar policy in other locations. The same goes to “Sarah Summers”, another anonymous woman, who challenged charity rape support services in Brighton – your public campaign was actually one of the first moments that made me feel my boundaries were not unreasonable.
I would like to thank the Good Law Project for challenging the EHRC draft guidance and the subsequent High Court result one week before my liability hearing – it was incredibly helpful. (May there be many more foxes roaming around freely!)
A huge thank you goes to Mumsnet users for explaining key elements of legislation. Keyboard warriors are often dismissed but you were truly instrumental in helping me understand how a legal argument for women’s rights might flow, which helped me raise this with NHSE first informally.
Thank you to Tribunal Tweets for reporting on the proceedings. The full Tribunal Tweets substack with cross examination transcripts can be found here: https://tribunaltweets.substack.com/p/faye-russell-caldicott-vs-nhs-england
And finally, from the bottom of my heart, thank you all donors. You have covered large parts of legal costs which I could not have done alone. Likewise, people who shared my posts helped my campaign, so you truly supported this successful ET outcome.
Yours faithfully,
Faye"

My bold and italics 😄

LS v NHS England – Remedy  - Didlaw

Following the successful outcome in LS v NHSE the remedy judgment of Leeds ET has now been handed down.  The Claimant was awarded a sum for injury to feelings, to include a payment for interest.  Disappointingly, and despite the evidence given on behal...

https://didlaw.com/ls-v-nhs-england-remedy

RoseInAPot · 21/10/2026 11:37

"My employment tribunal case LS v NHS England, also known by my campaign name Faye Russell-Caldicott, reached final conclusion this week as neither party appealed the remedy decision that was handed down in early September. I have spent the appeal window digesting the outcome and decided I am content with the overall results.
The remedy judgment is embedded in didlaw’s press release at:"

https://didlaw.com/ls-v-nhs-england-remedy

https://www.crowdjustice.com/case/single-sex-facilities-at-work/

LS v NHS England – Remedy  - Didlaw

Following the successful outcome in LS v NHSE the remedy judgment of Leeds ET has now been handed down.  The Claimant was awarded a sum for injury to feelings, to include a payment for interest.  Disappointingly, and despite the evidence given on behal...

https://didlaw.com/ls-v-nhs-england-remedy

Swipe left for the next trending thread