To find it heartening that despite so many famous people being anti JKR, their are still so many who are prepared to work on HP?

That chart has been proven as a misrepresentation of the situation. Incarceration is not the same as offending. For example, most rapes of women are not reported therefore its impossible to know the extent of male violence to compare it with trans women.

I thought the same. The misogynistic user name is a bit of a clue.

The same reason why pedophilia or rape or domestic violence is everyone’s 'problem' even if we aren't all children or women. That's how civilised society works.

It IS a male problem. Caused by men and experienced by men. It’s for men to solve, not for women to be made more vulnerable.

We’re not everyone’s Mummies. We don’t need to wipe your bottoms for you or solve all your problems. Sort your own problems out like big boys.

@Namelessnelly oh they are still knocking around on another thread.

No problem!

That's not a comment on Katie Dolatowski, a man who pretends to be a woman, and the 12yo girl he raped in a female supermarket toilet.

I would like to know what you have to say about that, as you've said men who are pretending to be women and women face the same risks.

Same!!! I was just thinking I recognised the style of posting! Probably name changed after he got his arse handed to him last time.

consensus expertise

Is that a new buzzword?

I’m thinking godtierkaren is possibly the same as howesitgoin - another professional thread derailer.

Humans cannot change sex. Gender critical is the slur used. Sex realist is how I refer to myself. I am not ‘critical’ of anyone except the adults peddling nonsense to children about being born in the wrong body. That is racketeering.

So you agree statistical percentages matter? That's progress. Now do trans women v 'biological' men.

Ummm. But it is. Why is male on male violence women’s problem to solve? We’ve got enough to do dealing with male on female violence. Let men sort themselves out. They got this. I believe in them.

Apparently it’s absolutely fine as long as it’s a girl dick and the owner has lady feelz

Thats how ludicrous the argument gets

True, but according to Gender Critical logic 'that's a man problem'.

'Social responsibility for me but not for thee.'

I feel that the actors and crew are saying that they agree with her (or at least, dont disagree), without actually saying that they agree, if you see what I mean.

They're saying nothing of the sort. They're professionals, getting paid to star in one of the biggest media franchises of all time.

But that’s not women’s problem. Why does the fact that some men are in danger from other men mean that men should have access to female spaces? Maybe the trans activists could start a campaign encouraging men to be kinder to men with a trans identity.

This is why we need a third option.

Men’s safety isn’t women’s responsibility. We’ve got enough on keeping ourselves safe.

Quite. We’ve even got idiots claiming that men can become women if they have special feelings, and if they do claim this, we can remove decades of hard-won women’s rights AND drive a coach and horses through safeguarding provisions for children, who can be put at risk of sexual abuse if it suits the whims of adult men.

Utter madness.

🤔

No. You’ve proved your point earlier when you said cubicles offer privacy. So cubicles in the men’s offer those men with a trans identity all the privacy and safety they need. Therefore there is absolutely no need for males to use female spaces. You sorted it with your previous post. Unless of course, there is another reason these men with a trans identity want access to female spaces….

You’re a disgrace.

Females aren't exactly above committing sex crimes as well.

Tbf, I suppose there are a lot of men who would harass or beat up a man in a dress, heels, and makeup. And if the trans woman was someone who was on the smaller side and had done the full transition, including the hormone therapy and breast surgery, it's also possible that they would pass as a woman and get harassed and maybe attacked for being a woman in the male toilets. And if someone tried to rape a trans woman, there's a risk of them visiting even more violence on them on discovery that they're a biological man.

People will like working on her projects for their own CVs and paychecks. The actors aren’t going to work and discussing women’s rights issues all day - they are turning up to make JKR’s magical worlds a visual reality. The hysteria online on places like X is created by activists who are tiny in number and angry that the excessive attention they get isn’t enough.
How many people work at minimum wage while the CEO is on millions? How many people have colleagues with very different political opinions but never discuss politics in order to maintain a working relationship? Same difference. Laurie etc aren’t expected to make public statements about trans issues- they are hired to promote the HP world.

Anything you would like to say about Katie Dolatowski and the 12 yo girl he raped in a supermarket toilet?