Vexatious litigant status requires, I think, a minimum of two claims struck out totally without merit. A friend who was sued won after the particulars (but not the claim in itself) were struck out and I'm aware of another case where the final judgement was that the proceedings were an abuse of process. Most others have either been withdrawn, settled, or lost.
SH has, to date, filed three claims against me. I knew I was never going to recover costs (SH is not a person of means despite the public facade that no-one believes). But I have never paid anyone nor have I ever apologised. I'm obviously very supportive of Matthew and the landscape has shifted enough that the high court is now at the very least wary of new claims.
Although the criteria for VL status is prima facie strict, the Attorney General does have discretion to consider the dynamics of repeated litigation. SH is going to be SH and, at this point, there needs to be pressure on the judiciary to look at the totality of the litigation because they are allowing someone to repeatedly use the Scrounge With Fees scheme to, in my view, abuse numerous people through litigation knowing that they will never pay costs.
The judge yesterday started to grasp it all towards the end (she's only had one of SH's cases before her whereas Judge Nicklin was aware of most of them) and it's really not a bad outcome for Matthew. There are rarely grand wins in litigation and the claim is now essentially dead given that the March hearing will award today's costs to Matthew.