Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Criticism of Islam is a protected belief

439 replies

theilltemperedmaggotintheheartofthelaw · 09/11/2025 21:32

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15272771/Criticism-Islam-ruled-legally-protected-belief-man-banned-fined-thousands-pounds-social-media-posts.html

I wasn't able to find the judgment. There'll be a hearing in February but it's not clear to me whether claimant's beliefs have already been tested for Grainger compliance. Either way, the tribunal will (also) have to address objectionable manifestation (Bananarama doctrine).

I've raised it here because of the parallels with Forstater. It's a constant refrain of TRAs that permitting Forstater belief is tantamount to attacking GR as a protected characteristic. They do not understand secularism (or the SC ruling).

Of course the situation is not the same insofar as Islam has not been written into our law and Muslims don't expect the rest of us to follow its rules.

Article 9, anyone?

Criticism of Islam can be a legally protected belief, judge rules

Patrick Lee is pursuing a belief discrimination claim against the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries (IFoA) after it banned him and fined him nearly £23,000 last year over a series of tweets criticising Islam.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15272771/Criticism-Islam-ruled-legally-protected-belief-man-banned-fined-thousands-pounds-social-media-posts.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Bangbangwhizzbang · 11/11/2025 14:16

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 14:14

I am also not in the US. If I was, I would be infinitely more likely to be born into an ultra religious Christian family and not even been allowed to wear jeans.

As opposed to the UK where you could have been born into a Muslim family and made to wear the Burkha?

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 14:14

EasternStandard · 11/11/2025 14:10

Lucky you’re here typing on mn rather than Afghanistan where you’d face a whole range of censure, including no voice on or offline.

I am also not in the US. If I was, I would be infinitely more likely to be born into an ultra religious Christian family and not even been allowed to wear jeans.

Bangbangwhizzbang · 11/11/2025 14:11

SerendipityJane · 11/11/2025 14:02

You may want to check those "facts". Also it's generally considered more accurate to use BCE than BC. For all sorts of reasons unsuited to this thread.

Surely, the attempt to remove Christian influence over the dating systems (though still keeping it but simply changing the name to pretend it isn’t relevant) is relevant to this thread?

EasternStandard · 11/11/2025 14:10

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 14:08

Afghanistan VS US is pretty equally no for me for very similar reasons.

Lucky you’re here typing on mn rather than Afghanistan where you’d face a whole range of censure, including no voice on or offline.

SerendipityJane · 11/11/2025 14:09

Signalbox · 11/11/2025 13:51

And yet the abortion laws have just been relaxed. We are in the UK talking about UK laws and the protection of UK citizens to criticise religion. Why the need to drag America into the discussion? We are not America.

Yet.

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 14:08

EasternStandard · 11/11/2025 14:02

Is it entirely comparable to you?

I can easily decide between Afghanistan and other western countries as a place to raise dd /dc. How about you?

Afghanistan VS US is pretty equally no for me for very similar reasons.

SerendipityJane · 11/11/2025 14:02

inkognitha · 11/11/2025 13:38

@Swiftasthewind

around 600 BC: 1st tribal king in the British Isles to be baptised
around 610 BC: Muhammad is supposed to have received his first revelation

Facts...

You may want to check those "facts". Also it's generally considered more accurate to use BCE than BC. For all sorts of reasons unsuited to this thread.

EasternStandard · 11/11/2025 14:02

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:59

I have something to say about all of these countries. Not just the Muslim ones.

Is it entirely comparable to you?

I can easily decide between Afghanistan and other western countries as a place to raise dd /dc. How about you?

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 14:01

Signalbox · 11/11/2025 13:51

And yet the abortion laws have just been relaxed. We are in the UK talking about UK laws and the protection of UK citizens to criticise religion. Why the need to drag America into the discussion? We are not America.

Because it is the West and Christian and more likely to influence our societal attitudes than what happens in DownTown Kabul.

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 14:00

Anactor · 11/11/2025 13:57

Which Christians do you know?

One that go to church and would disown their heterosexual kid for sex outside marriage, let alone a child who wants to have homosexual relationships.

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:59

EasternStandard · 11/11/2025 13:55

Do you have anything to say about practises in Afghanistan or similar?

Edited

I have something to say about all of these countries. Not just the Muslim ones.

Anactor · 11/11/2025 13:57

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:25

You don't know many Christians if that is your belief. Probably because you only know a few non church goers who loosely describe themselves as C of E.

Which Christians do you know?

EasternStandard · 11/11/2025 13:55

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:36

You realise America is the West, right? The place where little raped girls now have to continue their pregnancies? That place? Familiar?

Do you have anything to say about practises in Afghanistan or similar?

Signalbox · 11/11/2025 13:51

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:36

You realise our own politicians have been talking about restricting abortion for a whike now, yes?

And yet the abortion laws have just been relaxed. We are in the UK talking about UK laws and the protection of UK citizens to criticise religion. Why the need to drag America into the discussion? We are not America.

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:51

Bangbangwhizzbang · 11/11/2025 13:49

You realise there is a law now going through parliament making it legal up to full term?

It's always been legal up to full term depending on circumstances.

What I do know is that at two political parties want to restrict abortion. I know there was a huge anti abortion March in London a few months ago, and it is an annual event.

Bangbangwhizzbang · 11/11/2025 13:49

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:36

You realise our own politicians have been talking about restricting abortion for a whike now, yes?

You realise there is a law now going through parliament making it legal up to full term?

inkognitha · 11/11/2025 13:38

@Swiftasthewind

around 600 BC: 1st tribal king in the British Isles to be baptised
around 610 BC: Muhammad is supposed to have received his first revelation

Facts...

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:36

You realise our own politicians have been talking about restricting abortion for a whike now, yes?

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:36

SerendipityJane · 11/11/2025 13:33

The problems is that as religions Christianity and Islam are not comparable.

Christianity - based on the Bible itself - contains the philosophical basis for separating the spiritual and the mundane. (It's the very meaning of "Give unto Caesar ...." that Jesus instructed). Therefore it is possible to be a Christian in a secular society. Admittedly you have to cede your power over women people, but it can be done and lead to what you might loosely call "the West".

Islam has no such provisions. It is specifically presented as a guide to all aspects of life. There is no such division between the sacred and the profane. Ultimately it requires full control of every Muslims life.

Now as with Christianity there are a spectrum of views on this. However unlike Christianity they cannot be reconciled with a secular state.

More perceptive readers will of course notice that the alleged rising tide of Christian batshittery fundamentalism from the US makes suspiciously similar claims to Islam about there being no separation between church and state.

Personally, as someone who has very little time for people who believe in fairy stories, no matter how amusing or twee, I say a plague on all your houses.

You realise America is the West, right? The place where little raped girls now have to continue their pregnancies? That place? Familiar?

inkognitha · 11/11/2025 13:34

Swiftasthewind · 10/11/2025 22:44

That would be my university professor father, who I am going to confidently predict is infinitely more educated than you.

Can we have dates and timeline please?
If you are so educated, you won't mind sharing, will you?

SerendipityJane · 11/11/2025 13:33

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:22

Catholic countries put their religious beliefs before any sort of secular rights. So you'll see big restrictions on abortion and the like in those countries. Little welfare for single mothers. All things that promote their belief system.

The problems is that as religions Christianity and Islam are not comparable.

Christianity - based on the Bible itself - contains the philosophical basis for separating the spiritual and the mundane. (It's the very meaning of "Give unto Caesar ...." that Jesus instructed). Therefore it is possible to be a Christian in a secular society. Admittedly you have to cede your power over women people, but it can be done and lead to what you might loosely call "the West".

Islam has no such provisions. It is specifically presented as a guide to all aspects of life. There is no such division between the sacred and the profane. Ultimately it requires full control of every Muslims life.

Now as with Christianity there are a spectrum of views on this. However unlike Christianity they cannot be reconciled with a secular state.

More perceptive readers will of course notice that the alleged rising tide of Christian batshittery fundamentalism from the US makes suspiciously similar claims to Islam about there being no separation between church and state.

Personally, as someone who has very little time for people who believe in fairy stories, no matter how amusing or twee, I say a plague on all your houses.

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:32

elgreco · 11/11/2025 13:30

Churchgoing is not required as proof of faith in Christ in most protestant religions.

It is proof of your commitment to the religion rather than an association by background. The fact that hardly any of the people polled actually worship in a church is important when analysing the data.

People who have actually read the bible and believe in it are typically against homosexuality and think it is a sin. That goes without saying.

elgreco · 11/11/2025 13:30

Churchgoing is not required as proof of faith in Christ in most protestant religions.

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:30

EmmyFr · 11/11/2025 09:46

I literally quoted a poll to you that says practicing Muslims are overwhelmingly less tolerant and law-abiding than other religious people, themselves slightly less than atheists. How is that not a point ? Unless you refuse to grasp it.

When the Christians you poll haven't even seen a church for years, your data means nothing.

JadeSquid · 11/11/2025 13:27

Bangbangwhizzbang · 11/11/2025 10:18

Are you not in the UK? Or do you only watch the BBC and read The Guardian?

Yes and no I don't read those papers or sources routinely. I'm asking because I regualrly see anyone who does do that punished for doing so. Of course if someone doesnt have a job to take away, then they can just say it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread