Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trans identifying male Harriet Haynes loses court case to play in women's pool

116 replies

ArabellaScott · 01/08/2025 12:13

A great win for Lynn Pinches!

Congratulations to her, and the EBPF.

'CASE DISMISSED! The case against EBPF by Harriet Haynes. '

Haynes to pay costs.

Earlier articles:

Males banned from women's pool:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/articles/c1k4gd2vge9o

Haynes sues:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/2025/04/08/transgender-pool-player-harriet-hayes-suing-governing-body/

Pool Federation:

https://ebpf.uk/

Judgement:

https://jrlevins.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/K01CT207-judgment-1-8-25-handed-down.pdf

'CONCLUSION
267 Having come to the end of what is essentially a long footnote to this judgment, I reiterate that in my view the effect of the decision in FWS is that the claim fails at the first hurdle because there has been no gender reassignment discrimination. The claim must therefore be dismissed. '

A player takes a shot during a game of pool

Transgender women banned from female pool category

The Ultimate Pool Group (UPG) ban transgender women from female category after landmark UK Supreme Court ruling that the legal definition of a woman is based on biological sex.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/articles/c1k4gd2vge9o

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ArabellaScott · 01/08/2025 14:28

WandaSiri · 01/08/2025 14:26

Just noticed that the BBC headline is "Transgender women banned from female pool category"
Instead of the expected "Transgender women banned from pool"

Another small win?

Maybe?

It perhaps makes it clearer (a little) that so called 'transgender women' are men. But given that up to a third of people think that 'transgender women' refers to females identifying as men, who knows?

OP posts:
WandaSiri · 01/08/2025 14:26

ArabellaScott · 01/08/2025 12:13

A great win for Lynn Pinches!

Congratulations to her, and the EBPF.

'CASE DISMISSED! The case against EBPF by Harriet Haynes. '

Haynes to pay costs.

Earlier articles:

Males banned from women's pool:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/articles/c1k4gd2vge9o

Haynes sues:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/2025/04/08/transgender-pool-player-harriet-hayes-suing-governing-body/

Pool Federation:

https://ebpf.uk/

Judgement:

https://jrlevins.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/K01CT207-judgment-1-8-25-handed-down.pdf

'CONCLUSION
267 Having come to the end of what is essentially a long footnote to this judgment, I reiterate that in my view the effect of the decision in FWS is that the claim fails at the first hurdle because there has been no gender reassignment discrimination. The claim must therefore be dismissed. '

Just noticed that the BBC headline is "Transgender women banned from female pool category"
Instead of the expected "Transgender women banned from pool"

Another small win?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 01/08/2025 14:10

TheAutumnCrow · 01/08/2025 14:00

I don’t see how any week can be, if she’s going to carry on pretending that the FWS Supreme Court ruling is just a little thing in Scotland to do with public boards.

This. Some of the arguments in this case are frankly silly.

TheAutumnCrow · 01/08/2025 14:00

NebulousDog · 01/08/2025 13:52

It’s not been a great week for Jane Russell.

I don’t see how any week can be, if she’s going to carry on pretending that the FWS Supreme Court ruling is just a little thing in Scotland to do with public boards.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 01/08/2025 13:53

More good news. Women being given our sports back

NebulousDog · 01/08/2025 13:52

It’s not been a great week for Jane Russell.

Charabanc · 01/08/2025 13:49

Excellent news.

Applefantea · 01/08/2025 13:40

Another win, thank god.

ArabellaScott · 01/08/2025 13:34

Columbidae · 01/08/2025 13:02

I'm very glad they won and grateful to Lynne Pinches for standing up.

Reading the judgement, it was disappointing to see, re. encouraging women's participation (my bolding):

"266 As to the second aim, I accept that women have been historically underrepresented among pool players. The FargoRate data indicates that in America they still are, and that is likely to be the case in the UK as well. Encouraging greater female participation is a clearly legitimate aim. I do not accept, however, that (were it not for the need to achieve fairness) excluding trans women from female competitions would be a proportionate means of achieving it. The Defendants’ evidence was that the only complaints they received other than those about fair competition were objections to sharing toilets, and that is an issue which could arise whenever trans women are present, whether or not they are competing in the same event."

The judge makes clear that if there hadn't been physical differences in performance he(?) would have thought it reasonable for trans women to play in women's tournaments to increase female participation.

Women have the right to compete against and socialise in a competitive environment exclusively with other women.

Edited

Yeah. At least the SC judges carefully considered the matter and made a ruling that hopefully protects women anyway.

OP posts:
Columbidae · 01/08/2025 13:02

I'm very glad they won and grateful to Lynne Pinches for standing up.

Reading the judgement, it was disappointing to see, re. encouraging women's participation (my bolding):

"266 As to the second aim, I accept that women have been historically underrepresented among pool players. The FargoRate data indicates that in America they still are, and that is likely to be the case in the UK as well. Encouraging greater female participation is a clearly legitimate aim. I do not accept, however, that (were it not for the need to achieve fairness) excluding trans women from female competitions would be a proportionate means of achieving it. The Defendants’ evidence was that the only complaints they received other than those about fair competition were objections to sharing toilets, and that is an issue which could arise whenever trans women are present, whether or not they are competing in the same event."

The judge makes clear that if there hadn't been physical differences in performance he(?) would have thought it reasonable for trans women to play in women's tournaments to increase female participation.

Women have the right to compete against and socialise in a competitive environment exclusively with other women.

FranticFrankie · 01/08/2025 12:59

A win for Common Sense (which can often not be common) 🎉

NotfinanciallyresponsibleforyouSadTimes · 01/08/2025 12:56

Good news.

Great that Haynes has to pay costs. If only the same could be said for Upton.

Helleofabore · 01/08/2025 12:29

This is good to read.

We are pleased to announce that our clients, the English Blackball Pool Federation, have successfully defended the discrimination claim brought against them by the transgender player, Harriet Haynes.

This is the first case to apply FWS and to consider the sport exception under s. 195 EqA. We will be publishing the judgment on our website shortly.

https://x.com/jrlevinslaw/status/1951219812048248915?s=46

https://x.com/jrlevinslaw/status/1951219812048248915?s=46

SirChenjins · 01/08/2025 12:26

Another excellent result as the scales continue to tip back towards common sense and biological reality. Generations from now will look back at this time and think wtaf.

Heartening to read that Mr Haynes will pay costs.

Helleofabore · 01/08/2025 12:23

Well done Lynn in huge effort in protecting female sports!

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 01/08/2025 12:14

The judgement is well worth reading! Fantastic result!!