Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What does your partner think?

169 replies

Loopinlouie92 · 23/07/2025 08:08

I’m GC and my boyfriend is more on the fence about things. I think both of us are usually quite good at managing differences of opinion. But this means a lot to me and I’m finding it really hard not having his support. I feel that it is creating a gulf between us. Does your partner also have GC views or do they think differently about things?

OP posts:
Postre · 24/07/2025 17:06

Really thought this thread was going to be about the hatred I have for people who ignore what you've decided or assume choices are too complex for you and ask what your male partner thinks!

Leafstamp · 24/07/2025 17:01

My DH and DCs are all sex realist, thank goodness. But DH does get a bit annoyed with me talking about it all the time

Absentmindedsmile · 24/07/2025 14:27

Mine is a sex realist. Like me. I couldn’t love him more when he expresses his disdain / disgust at men pretending to be women to get into women’s and girls’ spaces / sports / awards.
Present how you like, not anyone else’s business, but don’t expect to con the system or other people. Is what my husband thinks.

MrsTerryPratchett · 24/07/2025 14:19

Grammarnut · 24/07/2025 11:27

My late DH was such.

Lovely to hear and I’m sorry for your loss. Flowers

TheOldSilverBirch · 24/07/2025 12:31

I’m so envious of those with partners who aren’t of the be kind twaw variety. I accept everyone has the right to their opinion, but it makes me sad (and angry if I’m honest). I’ve also had other people close to me telling me I’m a bigot and must be a trump supporter. I’m pretty left wing. I take great pleasure in making it known that my views seem to align with the morning star 😆

SickandTiredofEverything · 24/07/2025 12:22

My partner (man) is even more militant than me about the matter. Pointed out and challenged so many errors in his employer's (local gov) policies confusing sex and gender that he has now been added as a member of the women's network(!) so that he can be included to preview materials before issue. He is slowly radicalising all of his friends and admitted he has been less productive than usual this week as he has had one eye on the sandie peggie trial. Probably helps he has 2 daughter's one of which is gay

Karatema · 24/07/2025 12:17

foodymcfoodface · 23/07/2025 10:19

I notice it’s men with DDs who get it. One disadvantage of having only DSs

Edited

Not true, we only have DS and DGS and my DH is fully on board with my GC view (although I love the Gender Atheist term from a PP 😀).
My DS do prove this point! One of my DS is a full on TRA and it’s the one subject we never discuss because he knows we’ll never agree.
The other just keeps quiet because he knows his DW and I will never agree (she went to school with a bloke who transed) and he doesn’t want to get caught in the cross fire! 🤣

ISaySteadyOn · 24/07/2025 12:15

DH was ahead of me. He is like @MrsTerryPratchett 's DH. He pointed out to me the problems when I was a staunch BeKinder (wasn't called that then but still existed), but I didn't really get it until I had children. Now we're completely on the same page.

NeatOchreShark · 24/07/2025 11:58

donkey86 · 23/07/2025 10:27

My DH is totally TWAW. We’ve had to agree not to talk about it. On the rare occasion someone else brings something up he gets very agitated if I express a GC opinion. It makes me quite sad.

We have two young daughters and I asked him how he would feel if, when they’re older, a teen boy declared he was a girl and wanted to share a changing room with them. He said that would be fine. I asked what if it made our girls uncomfortable and he said he hoped that they wouldn’t be so ‘bigoted’ but if they were then they should be the ones to go and change elsewhere. I don’t think it’s going to be possible change his mind. I’m trying to bring the girls up to see the GC point of view, but only when he’s not around to hear.

this is scaryyyyy. Check his search history.

Grammarnut · 24/07/2025 11:56

milislovelybut · 23/07/2025 17:29

@Loopinlouie92 I could have written this. I’ve been following the Sandie Peggie ET on tribunal tweets daily and I see my husband roll his eyes a bit when I tell him the latest jaw dropping cock up by NHS Fife. He can’t see why I get so invested as he says it will all be sorted out once more people become aware of the issues. But I don’t see any GC reporting on mainstream media (such as the BBC) about it so how will the public get to know. Very frustrating.

Exactly. It's an important case and yet it is hardly to never mentioned on any mainstream media. If you didn't go on particular social media you would not know. Had a mind-blowing conversation with step-son and his partner the other day (both GC but not great readers etc). DiL had visited Brighton and it came up that all the toilets (bar one) was unisex, which she did not like. Step-son remarked that Trump had thrown men out of women's sports so his solution would work in the UK. DiL commented 'bloody UK!' i.e. this rubbish is supported here, so I chipped in with SC ruling, Peggie and Darlington nurses cases and said that the UK is in the forefront of the struggle against this rubbish: Terf Island. They did not know, because it doesn't turn up in mainstream media nor in social media that most people go on - it's on MN, on bits of Twitter/X, on parts of substack and you need to go looking for it.
I was a bit appalled but, on thinking about it, not surprised. And this is why the whole trans agenda has got so far; most ordinary people haven't a clue about what has happened and the damage it has done.

NeatOchreShark · 24/07/2025 11:55

omg I actually couldn't imagine my boyfriend disagreeing w me on this. You ladies with DHs who are very staunchly TWAW - If I were you I would honestly be checking his search history because for a straight married man with kids to be staunchly and passionately TWAW...well, that would make me think maybe he's questioning his own gender.

Grammarnut · 24/07/2025 11:46

PermanentTemporary · 23/07/2025 17:17

I’ve seen a lot of sneering about Dr Upton crying. To me it is straightforwardly part of the sexist and homophobic landscape that may make men feel that if they have emotions that are inconvenient or if other people think they are ‘weak’, they must not be real men. Given the high completed suicide rates among doctors and among men, it’s certainly understandable that other doctors were keen to support Dr U in that state.

Of course there are other ways to frame this; the class/hierarchy angle is one of the most useful. But lots of comment I’ve seen is not that sophisticated, it’s pretty much just ‘he’s a weakling ho ho’. Quite telling.

The misogynistic intent of his 'crying' is obvious - he wanted to contrast with Peggie who stood up and complained, so he put on the 'poor wee man who knows he's really a woman - see, she's made him cry' act.
The class/heirarchy aspect is obvious. He ranks higher than Peggie on both counts and has been supported in this by women like Isla Bumba (?) who doesn't know whether she is a woman or not. (Do a cheek swab, ducks, that will tell you instantly.)

Worldgonecrazy · 24/07/2025 11:36

DH is baffled that anyone would think TWAW, and is truly disgusted by the performative AGP male we sometimes have the misfortune to see around our locality, often to be seen doing a selfie photo shoot, or wearing floaty tennis skirts that just happen to get caught in the wind to show his frilly knickers.

I know the issue causes strong feelings on both sides, but I do not believe I could be married to anyone who thought otherwise.

DD thinks I’m a bigot and said she would be open to dating a trans person. She hadn’t actually met any in real life so I await the realisation of what that means.

Grammarnut · 24/07/2025 11:36

SamiSnail · 23/07/2025 16:31

I asked him how he would feel if, when they’re older, a teen boy declared he was a girl and wanted to share a changing room with them. He said that would be fine. I asked what if it made our girls uncomfortable and he said he hoped that they wouldn’t be so ‘bigoted’ but if they were then they should be the ones to go and change elsewhere.

Sorry, I'm not just furious at him, I am furious at you STAYING WITH HIM, @donkey86 . Your husband is saying it's fine for a male sexual predator to expose himself to his own daughters and if they complain, they are the ones in the wrong! Wtf are you doing? He is beneath scum! This is about safeguarding! He is not even fit to be around his own daughters if that is what he thinks. Shame on you for staying with him, I would be out of there like a shot and demanding only supervised visitation with him if I were you. How could you? How could you stay with a predator supporter? These men are terrible, but I condemn women who stay with them worse because they should know better.

Edited

It's not just to blame @donkey86 for her H's stupid beliefs nor staying with him if there are other factors in his favour. However, she should consider he is a safeguarding risk to their DDs if he thinks it is ok for a male to be in a female changing room exposing themselves. She should talk to him - not row - but point out that he is a safeguarding problem which means she cannot safely leave their DDs in his care especially in a setting where they may have to undress e.g. taking them swimming, gym etc.
Also, he gets agitated when she mentions GC beliefs so he knows, deep down, he is wrong. She should express her GC beliefs whenever the opportunities arise and certainly not conceal teaching DDs GC views.
He's an idiot. She should make this clear to him. He may leave, of course, or he may realise he is a prize idiot and change his mind.

Grammarnut · 24/07/2025 11:27

MrsTerryPratchett · 23/07/2025 14:23

I’m in a very woke (right-on in old money) industry and always have been. People wonder why I married a vaguely ‘old fashioned’ sort of man from a male-dominated one. It’s because well-meaning, slightly crusty, strong and loving gentlemen can be trusted to believe in underlying values. They might be mildly sexist to start with, but having a strong mum, sister, wife and now daughter means his protective impulses and basic goodness apply. So he agrees. He had no opinion, because he mostly ignores the slings and arrows of social change. Now he’s firmly MN GC.

Give me that over a ‘this is what a feminist looks like’ brocialist any day.

My late DH was such.

Grammarnut · 24/07/2025 11:22

donkey86 · 23/07/2025 10:27

My DH is totally TWAW. We’ve had to agree not to talk about it. On the rare occasion someone else brings something up he gets very agitated if I express a GC opinion. It makes me quite sad.

We have two young daughters and I asked him how he would feel if, when they’re older, a teen boy declared he was a girl and wanted to share a changing room with them. He said that would be fine. I asked what if it made our girls uncomfortable and he said he hoped that they wouldn’t be so ‘bigoted’ but if they were then they should be the ones to go and change elsewhere. I don’t think it’s going to be possible change his mind. I’m trying to bring the girls up to see the GC point of view, but only when he’s not around to hear.

He may get a rude awakening if he finds his DDs have to share a dormitory with an intact male who says he's a 'girl'. One can but hope. 💐

KnottyAuty · 24/07/2025 08:37

PermanentTemporary · 23/07/2025 16:50

I passionately believe that dp has a right to his own views. I’m about as extreme as you can get, I think, but in my own way - there’s are things I’ve seen on the on the GC side that I think are very wrong (look at all the online sneering at Dr Upton crying at work, for example - straightforward sexism imo) and there are things I agree with on the TRA side (but they wouldn’t care, because I won’t go anywhere near TWAW so they just assume I vote Reform, or something).

DP thinks he agrees with me but he doesn’t, not really. He does on the surface but I know if his daughter decided to transition he wouldn’t just accept her (so would I), he would be a campaigner before you could say knife. It’s ok. I just accept that on this, he hasn’t really thought about it very much, whereas I’ve been in this issue since 1995.

Just to pick up on your comment about Dr Upton crying. I saw the “sneering” as questioning what some think is performative. It’s thought that the Dr maybe spent up to 30mins searching for the senior consultant after leaving the nurse in the changing room. There are no witnesses (so far) to confirm this - which is odd in a busy department - we just know that the Dr was in floods of tears by the time of meeting Elsbeth Pitt. While I agree that men do have a lot more restrictions on their behaviour and clothing etc in this case there are questions about the timing & sincerity of the tears for believability of the evidence rather than acceptability from a male iyswim. Sorry for the digression

HumphreyCushionintheHouse · 24/07/2025 04:58

My DH and both our kids are as GC as I am. Oldest kid is late 20s, youngest is mid teens. Everyone voices their opinion and is unimpressed with where we’ve been on TRA rights, and we live in the US so we’re still dealing with some lunacy.

Im a registered Democrat, DH and eldest would say they’re libertarian but vote differently each time, youngest is leaning like a Democrat but not if the dems stay on this track. They all have no time for TRA extremism.

FizzyLemons · 24/07/2025 04:05

DH and both young adult kids are fully GC, although none of them are particularly keen to discuss it with me as apparently I go on a bit. Surely not. I do make them listen when important things come up, and DH posted the Supreme Court decision on his social media (he's quite active on SM, I'm not). I wondered how that would go, but all responses bar one were postive (and that one made no sense at all, something about male judges making decisions for women??). DH has asked me why women 'let this happen' (men in their toilets and changing rooms, men winning their medals and awards), I didn't really have an answer.

TheOldSilverBirch · 24/07/2025 03:30

A subject to be avoided for me, I am GC, he is not, and calm conversation seems impossible. I wish it were different.

NameinVane · 24/07/2025 01:25

My DH hadn’t really given it a lot of thought but nodded along with me a few years ago ago when I was going through my “err hang on a minute” enlightenment.

Then a colleague of his became a TIM and at first he would mention that this person was featured in the newsletter and emails were sent round about it in a celebratory way and he thought that was generally a nice albeit unnecessary thing to do.

He then told me a few months later that the TIM colleague wore clothes that wouldn’t be acceptable for women at work to wear (very short dresses, very high heels) and there were mutterings from staff and that this person had announced that he was going to start using the female toilets. I asked DH if anyone had bothered to check with all the women he worked with if they were ok with this or if anyone had clocked the obvious discrepancy in having and enforcing a business dress code for everyone except the person who had just announced he now identified as a woman. DH- not without some self interest realising that if it became litigious it would be his problem- was then fairly quick to raise it with his (female) boss who in turn was pretty quick to say we need to handle this carefully but he can’t use the ladies and someone needs to have a word about dress code. As far as I know it was resolved. This was all about 5 years ago and being GC wasn’t really acceptable, especially in that kind of workplace, I do think it was easier for him to raise it as a middle aged male in a senior position.

TheaBrandt1 · 24/07/2025 00:39

Mine is always instinctively suspicious of men’s motives and will automatically take the woman’s side so is naturally GC without knowing what GC is.

Notfinanciallyresponsibleforyou · 24/07/2025 00:01

My DP is gender critical and believes that people can’t just change sex.

He most certainly doesn’t want our girls to lose out to men taking their places in sports teams or them being injured as a result of playing against males.

One of our friends from a different culture said that if you have a boy you only have one cock to think about but if you have a girl you worry about all the cocks. They deliberately chose an all-girls school as they didn’t want any cocks around their daughters and that included changing rooms. Not all cultures will necessarily find it easy to accept TWAW

MistyGreenAndBlue · 23/07/2025 23:27

donkey86 · 23/07/2025 17:55

That’s a bit harsh. Maybe if it was a real situation it might lead to the end of our relationship. Certainly we’d have a lot to hash out and it might be incompatible at that point. But I’m not going to leave him over a hypothetical situation that he probably (I hope) hasn’t even thought through properly.

But it's not exactly hypothetical is it? He's telling you who he is. He's a typical misogynist who believes men's feelings are more important than the safety of even his own children let alone other women and children. He sounds frightening.

I don't think you and your children are safe with this man and I hope you decide to get away from him. He doesn't care about any of you. That's what he's telling you. Believe him.

anyolddinosaur · 23/07/2025 22:22

Supportive up to a point and willing to spend money on gardening. Dont think he will speak out to male friends who are TWAW if I'm not there.