Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

NHS Policy Audit - working party -Thread #3

794 replies

KnottyAuty · 12/06/2025 20:57

NHS Policy Audit - working party -Thread #3

Original thread #1 here:
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5291237-nhs-policy-audit-working-party?page=1
Thread #2:
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5322494-nhs-policy-audit-working-party-thread-2

This is a thread about “keeping the receipts” on NHS Policies prior to the Supreme Court ruling on 16th April 2025.

Our working theory is that there were no single sex spaces for NHS Staff or Patients in the entire country before that date, having all been removed by stealth.

We are aiming to prove this by auditing websites and policies for all the UK trusts and using the results to raise public awareness.

As well as recording what has happened historically, the information will form a baseline so we can check which Trusts comply or defy the judgement in due course...

We are working around the country region by region. If you fancy getting involved in a bit of grassroots feminism then please do join in to help!?

Each trust takes about an hour to research and you can upload online without giving any personal details away. Comment below and we can give you the link to an online survey - it changes for each region.

Thanks soooo much to all the vipers who have helped so far and @twoloons for doing a great job with the thread wrangling!

NHS Policy Audit - working party | Mumsnet

Following on from Thread #23 of the Peggie v NHS Employment Tribunal. Anyone who wants to help with survey/audit of paperwork against the Equality Act...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5291237-nhs-policy-audit-working-party?page=1

OP posts:
Thread gallery
36
FarriersGirl · 15/06/2025 15:57

Thanks for the link @GreenAllOver. I was particularly interested in the info near the end where the CQC had figures on the reported sexual assaults and rapes in mental health units. My DSis is now retired but spent 30 years as a mental health professional both on wards and in the community. In her experience such assaults were always recorded on Datix so presumably, somewhere there would be both local and national records? Does anyone know where? Would it be worth an FOI request?

GreenAllOver · 15/06/2025 15:21

KnottyAuty · 15/06/2025 15:13

For the timeline: 16th August 2010
”fanfare” announcement of single sex wards

good quote from Andrew Lansley:

”Patients should not suffer the indignity of being cared for in mixed sex accommodation. I am determined to put an end to this practice, where it is not clinically justified.

"In the future, NHS organisations will have clear standards, spelling out when they should report a breach.

"Where NHS organisations fail to meet this standard, we will let the public know that they have failed and we will strengthen the fines which may apply.

"Patients and members of the public will be able to see which services continue to allow patients to suffer the indignity of mixed sex accommodation."

My emphasis - promising transparency and the importance privacy, dignity or safety on NHS wards.

How times have changed!?

ETA https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-10982566.amp

Edited

There’s a January 2009 speech saying much the same thing. Various different SofS’s for Health got a lot of mileage out of it as an issue.

KnottyAuty · 15/06/2025 15:13

For the timeline: 16th August 2010
”fanfare” announcement of single sex wards

good quote from Andrew Lansley:

”Patients should not suffer the indignity of being cared for in mixed sex accommodation. I am determined to put an end to this practice, where it is not clinically justified.

"In the future, NHS organisations will have clear standards, spelling out when they should report a breach.

"Where NHS organisations fail to meet this standard, we will let the public know that they have failed and we will strengthen the fines which may apply.

"Patients and members of the public will be able to see which services continue to allow patients to suffer the indignity of mixed sex accommodation."

My emphasis - promising transparency and the importance privacy, dignity or safety on NHS wards.

How times have changed!?

ETA https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-10982566.amp

OP posts:
KnottyAuty · 15/06/2025 15:04

Health Secretaries over this policy period:

2 May 1997 – 11 October 1999 Frank Dobson
11 October 1999 – 13 June 2003 Alan Milburn
13 June 2003 – 6 May 2005 John Reid
6 May 2005 – 28 June 2007 Patricia Hewitt
28 June 2007 – 5 June 2009 Alan Johnson
5 June 2009 – 11 May 2010 Andy Milburn
12 May 2010 – 4 September 2012 Andrew Lansley
4 September 2012 – 9 July 2018 Jeremy Hunt

OP posts:
KnottyAuty · 15/06/2025 14:51

@GreenAllOver id also forgotten to read that. How incredible that PfC were consulted and women not!? Amazing find!

OP posts:
TwoLoonsAndASprout · 15/06/2025 12:40

@GreenAllOver, oh I’m glad you spotted that thread with the link to the “let’s go back” thread - I was going to point it out to you but got waylaid.

GreenAllOver · 15/06/2025 12:38

I’ve just (thanks to another thread) found some excellent research on the history of sex and gender in the NHS. I’ll add it in to the jotform when I get time, but for now here’s the link:
https://medium.com/@anneharperwright/sex-gender-the-nhs-1e8f4e6363a6

And there’s also a lot of things I want to follow up from this thread:
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3463920-Lets-go-back-to-2007?reply=83696520
For instance, I had no idea that GIRES was founded as the charitable (ie non political) arm of Press for Change. There’s also a lot on there on related issues, like the definition of ‘trans’ in law, and the suicide statistics.

If PencilsInSpace is still around and reading, her posts on that thread were fantastic, she’s clearly super knowledgable and it would be great if she was able to read this thread and add anything that she knows. She pointed out that women weren’t consulted on changes to the Sex Discrimination Act in 1999, while Press for Change were! Which reminded me, I found some Dept of Health guidance on gender and access to services written by the Men’s Health Forum, with no matching guidance by a women’s health group.

Sex, Gender & the NHS

Part 1: The “Single-Sex Hospital Wards” that have always been a lie

https://medium.com/@anneharperwright/sex-gender-the-nhs-1e8f4e6363a6

Opinionpolecat · 14/06/2025 20:40

SuppoRTT covers all of England, it’s funded by Health Education England. I’m not sure what will happen to it now HEE is going.

Blackmetallic · 14/06/2025 17:34

KnottyAuty · 14/06/2025 12:50

The special leave thing could be interesting. We would need to get comparisons with the other policies to make it meaningful. Maybe a FOI needed now to get results back in a month?

I can't speak for all professions within the NHS, or all geographical areas, but the North West has what can be a very generous & wide-ranging return to work support programme called SuppoRTT for medical/dental professionals in training programmes, it covers return from maternity/parental leave along with many other reasons for absence/being new to the NHS etc.
SuppoRTT

Supported Return to Training (SuppoRTT) | Health Education North West

https://www.nwpgmd.nhs.uk/supported-return-to-training

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 14/06/2025 16:14

GreenAllOver · 14/06/2025 16:10

I hadn’t specificallly known about GIRES’s involvement, but I have been keeping half an eye out for the conflation of GIRES and DSD/intersex, and haven’t spotted it in the guidance I’ve seen.

There’s a huge amount of content, from what I’ve uploaded to the jotform on Dept of Health guidance and BeLemonHam’s input on equality guidance. I think there’s probably enough for someone to go through and audit development of policy around sex/gender as it relates to:

  • Children and young people, especially Gillick competence (and lack of it not being a barrier to overruling parents’ wishes)
  • Older people (especially those with dementia or delirium)
  • People with mental health problems, especially those on secure (ie locked, can’t leave) wards
  • Consideration (or lack of consideration) for people who are not trans and an attempt to balance rights
  • Going ‘beyond the law’ or giving advice (eg best practice examples) which encourage readers to believe that self ID is the law
  • Positive discrimination in favour of trans employees (eg in terms of how medical leave for transition is treated, compared to comparable reasons for medical leave)
  • Privacy and dignity, and how the right to privacy about a GRC has been developed, argued and used. There’s a wider issue about using Government guidance to encourage individuals to take legal action against public bodies.
  • The legal and ethical status of Dept of Health guidance which was written by interest groups such as GIRES. With follow up questions about whether this avoided the usual civil service checks and balances (including legal checks) and the Ministerial approval process, which is necessary for democratic accountability (Nolan principles).

Thank you for that! I will do some digging…

GreenAllOver · 14/06/2025 16:10

I hadn’t specificallly known about GIRES’s involvement, but I have been keeping half an eye out for the conflation of GIRES and DSD/intersex, and haven’t spotted it in the guidance I’ve seen.

There’s a huge amount of content, from what I’ve uploaded to the jotform on Dept of Health guidance and BeLemonHam’s input on equality guidance. I think there’s probably enough for someone to go through and audit development of policy around sex/gender as it relates to:

  • Children and young people, especially Gillick competence (and lack of it not being a barrier to overruling parents’ wishes)
  • Older people (especially those with dementia or delirium)
  • People with mental health problems, especially those on secure (ie locked, can’t leave) wards
  • Consideration (or lack of consideration) for people who are not trans and an attempt to balance rights
  • Going ‘beyond the law’ or giving advice (eg best practice examples) which encourage readers to believe that self ID is the law
  • Positive discrimination in favour of trans employees (eg in terms of how medical leave for transition is treated, compared to comparable reasons for medical leave)
  • Privacy and dignity, and how the right to privacy about a GRC has been developed, argued and used. There’s a wider issue about using Government guidance to encourage individuals to take legal action against public bodies.
  • The legal and ethical status of Dept of Health guidance which was written by interest groups such as GIRES. With follow up questions about whether this avoided the usual civil service checks and balances (including legal checks) and the Ministerial approval process, which is necessary for democratic accountability (Nolan principles).
KnottyAuty · 14/06/2025 12:50

The special leave thing could be interesting. We would need to get comparisons with the other policies to make it meaningful. Maybe a FOI needed now to get results back in a month?

OP posts:
KnottyAuty · 14/06/2025 12:46

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 14/06/2025 11:18

I know. I hate to use the “cult” word on here, because at the end of the day we are collecting hard evidence, and throwing unfounded opinions around doesn’t help things. However, forcing a wedge between a person and their family — in favour of another group — is cult-like, and I am not remotely comfortable seeing it in NHS policy documents.

It’s Orwellian to assume that a family automatically doesn’t have best intentions and are harmful, therefore should be separated from their relative. Goes against principles used in adoption and social work and SEN etc. you know - like safeguarding?!?

OP posts:
GreenAllOver · 14/06/2025 12:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Cantunseeit · 14/06/2025 12:22

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 14/06/2025 11:18

I know. I hate to use the “cult” word on here, because at the end of the day we are collecting hard evidence, and throwing unfounded opinions around doesn’t help things. However, forcing a wedge between a person and their family — in favour of another group — is cult-like, and I am not remotely comfortable seeing it in NHS policy documents.

Just looking at the Rainbow Badge Assessment for Kent Community Health NHS Foundation Trust as a proxy for policies as no FOI on the policies for this one. Found this which might be a breadcrumb worth following on the relatives vs community point (my bold):

"Are the Trust's compassionate and/or special leave policies inclusive of loved ones/chosen families/close support networks and supporting someone through transition?

This is an unscored question.

The special leave policy mentions that leave will be granted if there's a 'bereavement of a close member of your immediate network', which we believe covers chosen family, but could be made explicit to avoid there being any disparity of approval. Chosen families, loved ones and close support networks are those who are not biologically related or near relatives but take the place of these familial roles. This can be particularly significant to those who are estranged from their families, an issue that disproportionately affects LGBT+ people.

Action: Within the special leave policy include loved ones/chosen families/close support network in definitions of family."

AnotherVice · 14/06/2025 12:10

@YellowRoom Have you see the AGP fetishy photos on Steph Meech’s Facebook profile? 🤮

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 14/06/2025 11:18

Cantunseeit · 14/06/2025 11:13

Ouch!

I know. I hate to use the “cult” word on here, because at the end of the day we are collecting hard evidence, and throwing unfounded opinions around doesn’t help things. However, forcing a wedge between a person and their family — in favour of another group — is cult-like, and I am not remotely comfortable seeing it in NHS policy documents.

Cantunseeit · 14/06/2025 11:13

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 14/06/2025 09:43

Indeed! And thank you - I should find a few of those, because I think that there are also strong recommendations that familial support is vital for patient recovery, and discouraging this is really anti-good-health, if nothing else (and it’s so much else).

The dementia one I mentioned went further and said that family was to be sidelined in favour of the “trans community.”

Ouch!

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 14/06/2025 09:43

Cantunseeit · 14/06/2025 09:39

Actually, that policy- led push to sideline and disregard relatives that don’t agree with the trans identity runs right through more generally. I nearly included an example yesterday but didn’t because it is in all of them. The views of the relatives of non-trans people should be sought and taken into consideration but the families of trans people who don’t agree with the patient should be ignored.

same for children with the “even when not Gillick competent” line

Indeed! And thank you - I should find a few of those, because I think that there are also strong recommendations that familial support is vital for patient recovery, and discouraging this is really anti-good-health, if nothing else (and it’s so much else).

The dementia one I mentioned went further and said that family was to be sidelined in favour of the “trans community.”

Cantunseeit · 14/06/2025 09:39

Actually, that policy- led push to sideline and disregard relatives that don’t agree with the trans identity runs right through more generally. I nearly included an example yesterday but didn’t because it is in all of them. The views of the relatives of non-trans people should be sought and taken into consideration but the families of trans people who don’t agree with the patient should be ignored.

same for children with the “even when not Gillick competent” line

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 14/06/2025 09:34

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 14/06/2025 09:28

@KnottyAuty, you already know about this, but just for everyone on here, I am looking at the dementia angle.

There are two issues - non-trans dementia patients who want same-sex care being given trans-identified carers and being told that these are same-sex.

And the second came from one of the policy documents which stated that trans patients with dementia often “detransition” (that is, forget that they were trans). The policy document instructed staff to discourage contact with any family who went along with (the document used the words “took advantage of”) this dementia-induced detransition, which is (as far as I understand) completely contrary to all best care instructions for dementia sufferers.

I should say - if anyone comes across anything related to this - including personal experience or news articles or anything, do share on here.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 14/06/2025 09:28

@KnottyAuty, you already know about this, but just for everyone on here, I am looking at the dementia angle.

There are two issues - non-trans dementia patients who want same-sex care being given trans-identified carers and being told that these are same-sex.

And the second came from one of the policy documents which stated that trans patients with dementia often “detransition” (that is, forget that they were trans). The policy document instructed staff to discourage contact with any family who went along with (the document used the words “took advantage of”) this dementia-induced detransition, which is (as far as I understand) completely contrary to all best care instructions for dementia sufferers.

KnottyAuty · 14/06/2025 09:10

Cantunseeit · 14/06/2025 08:27

I’ve seen a few that use “hate crime” to describe behaviour that doesn’t fully comply with the trans person’s wishes. Possibly linked with using the wrong pronouns. I think this is a difficult angle though as obviously trans people should not be discriminated against or harassed. I’m not sure how overt the threat is to people who won’t comply and how much only implied (but clarified by cases like Sandie’s)

Likewise, similar challenges with highlighting all the time off and kid gloves treatment for staff transitioning. I remember thinking “I bet they don’t have a check list like this for mothers returning after maternity leave” but then of course perhaps they do and the NHS is just a great employer…

I think the deception angle could be a story in its own right- how many policies we’ve only seen thanks to Ermine and how many claim single sex accommodation on websites but have hidden policies that make this a lie.

One other, that I think might be difficult to pursue sensitivity, is the inclusion of definitions for “intersex” in the policies. Some are really out there and even the less obscene don’t fit with a 21 century health service. Raises the question (for me) of who is actually writing / responsible for these policies? Surely no medically trained people would be including the term Intersex (and certainly not the definitions I’ve seen). Also saying intersex people don’t have the pc of sex. It’s truly batshit

and on who’s writing them / is there a story of the origin of the whole thing which explains why so much of them are the same- points to a centralised solution as almost all Trusts are using the same stem with a variety of embellishments (which are also repeated by other Trusts)

sorry - that turned out longer and more rambling than expected! I’ll have a proper think and come back with any other thoughts (hopefully in concise bulletpoints).

Thanks - interesting points.

On the deception - regarding advertising/promising single sex and then in policy (not public facing) deciding that this isn’t the case, is THE story… But probably only at the end once we can evidence this and that politicians promises to protect SSS were false.

The hate crime is an interesting angle because that does impact on others - DBS checks would fail impacting on someone’s ability to make a living. Now obviously “true” harassment of a trans person is different to someone else’s (article 8 human right) to assert their own boundaries and state basic facts in an appropriate context and a respectful way. But I suppose we would actually need some examples of people who had suffered a detriment due to this NHS policy to make this newsworthy… anyone seen stories about that?

Thanks for those pointers - does this spark any ideas for others here?

OP posts:
Cantunseeit · 14/06/2025 08:27

I’ve seen a few that use “hate crime” to describe behaviour that doesn’t fully comply with the trans person’s wishes. Possibly linked with using the wrong pronouns. I think this is a difficult angle though as obviously trans people should not be discriminated against or harassed. I’m not sure how overt the threat is to people who won’t comply and how much only implied (but clarified by cases like Sandie’s)

Likewise, similar challenges with highlighting all the time off and kid gloves treatment for staff transitioning. I remember thinking “I bet they don’t have a check list like this for mothers returning after maternity leave” but then of course perhaps they do and the NHS is just a great employer…

I think the deception angle could be a story in its own right- how many policies we’ve only seen thanks to Ermine and how many claim single sex accommodation on websites but have hidden policies that make this a lie.

One other, that I think might be difficult to pursue sensitivity, is the inclusion of definitions for “intersex” in the policies. Some are really out there and even the less obscene don’t fit with a 21 century health service. Raises the question (for me) of who is actually writing / responsible for these policies? Surely no medically trained people would be including the term Intersex (and certainly not the definitions I’ve seen). Also saying intersex people don’t have the pc of sex. It’s truly batshit

and on who’s writing them / is there a story of the origin of the whole thing which explains why so much of them are the same- points to a centralised solution as almost all Trusts are using the same stem with a variety of embellishments (which are also repeated by other Trusts)

sorry - that turned out longer and more rambling than expected! I’ll have a proper think and come back with any other thoughts (hopefully in concise bulletpoints).