Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

‘Trans children more likely to be white and privileged’ says head

154 replies

hholiday · 23/05/2025 06:08

In The Times today. https://www.thetimes.com/uk/education/article/trans-children-white-privilege-katherine-birbalsingh-73d578v7q

There is no statistical evidence of the headteacher’s claim in the article (it’s anecdotal, based on the fact she teaches at an inner city London school and says it’s not really an issue there). And the Cass review and others have given other explanations for the transgender trend among young people, eg autism. But I thought it was really interesting it was being discussed at all - and so bluntly. It would be interesting if this view does get looked into a bit more, as I suspect if there’s one thing likely to bring the transgender movement skidding to a halt among kids, it would be the idea that it’s something for the rich and privileged.

Trans children more likely to be white and privileged, says head

Katharine Birbalsingh said her school in London was unlikely to have many trans pupils because its intake mainly came from ethnic minorities

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/education/article/trans-children-white-privilege-katherine-birbalsingh-73d578v7q

OP posts:
atoo · 23/05/2025 06:44

I have no data or expertise, but it's possible for something to be simultaneously a trauma response for one group of children, e.g. CSA victims, and also at the same time a luxury belief or self-indulgent posturing for another group, e.g. privileged white kids. Trans is not necessarily just one thing.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 23/05/2025 06:34

BettyFilous · 23/05/2025 06:19

There is a significant cohort of looked after children in the adolescent trans population. This head teacher may not be seeing them at her school. It doesn’t mean they don’t exist. She is not as well informed on this issue as she thinks she is.

The data shows she's correct with GIDS evidenceing over 80% white british referrals.
Children looked after by the state were one of the first groups to be relentlessly targeted by dubious trans activists and organisations. Children alienated from / rejected by their families were such easy pickings.
Once the intimidation of teachers was completed by disciplining any of them who dared suggest safeguarding instead of transitioning children in their care, targeting all children was easy for transactivists.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37698232/

Such a massive failure of schools to safeguard children from immense harm.

Demographics of referrals to a specialist gender identity service in the UK between 2017 and 2020 - PubMed

Trends in clinical referrals to specialist gender services historically comprised more assigned male at birth young people. In the last decade, this has shifted in adolescent samples to more assigned female young people. An updated review of the curren...

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37698232/

BettyFilous · 23/05/2025 06:19

There is a significant cohort of looked after children in the adolescent trans population. This head teacher may not be seeing them at her school. It doesn’t mean they don’t exist. She is not as well informed on this issue as she thinks she is.

hholiday · 23/05/2025 06:09

Archive link here: archive.is/alC3d

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread