Page 5 | How to talk to 5yo DS about non-binary / trans teacher

NorthernLoon · 2025-05-01T19:38:03+00:00

DS is in reception. We received a message from the school recently advising that one of his teachers was leaving, and welcoming that teacher's replacement. The new teacher's title is "Mx" which Google tells me is a non-gendered title. So far so good. Today DS met the new teacher for the first time and has come home saying the teacher "looks a bit like a woman, but not really, and has a man's voice". He didn't ask any specific questions about that, so I didn't offer any explanation. (And I'm aware I might be jumping to the wrong conclusion - could just be a slightly masculine looking woman with a 40-a-day habit for all I know!) But assuming the teacher is a TW, how do I talk about that with a 5yo?! I don't want him to get in trouble at school. But I'm not happy to teach him a belief system i don't agree with. He knows basic male/female anatomy, the correct names for private parts, and that he is a boy because he has a male body. He's gone through various sparkly/pink phases, and my sister is a fairly tomboyish PE teacher. So we've talked in very basic terms about social stereotypes around "gender" and how they don't really mean anything. But where do I go from here? He's a gentle little boy - he would never want to hurt anyone, and he hates getting told off. But he would absolutely go into school and say "My mum says Mx ... is really a man". And my personal beliefs aside, I don't think that's helpful for anyone.

WorthyOtter · 02/05/2025 23:41

This is wild! Very confusing for a 5 yo. I don't think moving him is the answer but some clarity from school would be good

GiddyCrab · 02/05/2025 23:33

My child would be going to a different school.

Screamingabdabz · 02/05/2025 23:25

TypeForMiles · 02/05/2025 09:01

I'd go with being child-led. They ask questions, give them answers. Say as much as necessary to answer the questions, as little as possible to give them space to be curious and come up with their own next questions.

It'd be very weird to discuss or speculate about an adult's private parts with a child.

Starting off with basic respect, we call people by the names and titles they prefer.

We might call people by the names and titles ‘they prefer’ but it’s still a head fuck when you’re being coerced to call a cat a table. You know it’s a cat, they know they’re a cat, but we are having to collude in some big massive lie about it being a table!

As an adult I’m uncomfortable with it. But it’s even more inherently unhealthy and a perverse thing to make 5 year olds do - ignore the evidence of their own eyes. I’d be looking to move schools too.

proximalhumerous · 02/05/2025 23:01

ScunneredWife · 02/05/2025 22:56

That’s not transphobic, it’s common sense and entirely reasonable!

Show quote history

I think it's just too confusing for young children, but the TRAs would be up in arms of course.

ScunneredWife · 02/05/2025 22:56

proximalhumerous · 02/05/2025 22:52

I'm sure plenty would describe me as transphobic, but I really don't think there should be a place for this in primary schools.

That’s not transphobic, it’s common sense and entirely reasonable!

ScunneredWife · 02/05/2025 22:55

ArminTamzerian · 02/05/2025 22:31

Ms doesn't indicate your marital status. No need for the Mx bollocks

Show quote history

Did you miss the part where I said I was just relating someone else’s experience and also the part where I said the OPs situation sounded less straight forward but I have known females to use Mx for reasons unrelated to gender fuckery? Are you quite okay?

proximalhumerous · 02/05/2025 22:52

I'm sure plenty would describe me as transphobic, but I really don't think there should be a place for this in primary schools.

LovelySG · 02/05/2025 22:35

newtlover · 01/05/2025 22:14

'I don't know, but you can ask them'

^ this

ArminTamzerian · 02/05/2025 22:31

ScunneredWife · 01/05/2025 21:25

I worked with a Mx. She was recently divorced and, when changing her name, decided to use a title which didn’t indicate her marital status (in the same way that men are allowed to exist outside their marital status)

It sounds like there’s more than that going on here, and I’d definitely want to know more in your position, because there are some red flags there. I just thought I’d chuck my experience of Mx into the chat alongside the others

Ms doesn't indicate your marital status. No need for the Mx bollocks

WearyAuldWumman · 02/05/2025 22:30

MrsKeats · 02/05/2025 22:24

100% this.

Show quote history

The problem is that similar might happen somewhere down the line at the new school.

MrsKeats · 02/05/2025 22:24

Lovelyview · 01/05/2025 20:44

Honestly, I'd move him to a new school. A 5 year old should not be subjected to someone's batshit ideology.

100% this.

Original poster

NorthernLoon · 02/05/2025 21:44

Sorry I haven't come back to the thread much; been a busy day. Thank you for all the advice.
To clarify, I was never going to go in all guns blazing without knowing what the actual situation was with this teacher, and I will definitely establish the facts before I say anything concrete to DS.
My concern was more about how I answer any potential questions when I don't know the facts, and how to balance my own views against the risk of DS receiving prejudicial treatment in school. I've received some great advice in that regard so thank you.
There have also been some good suggestions here as to how I can raise it with the school and ask for clarification, so, again, thank you. Also some scenarios I hadn't considered - my mind went straight to TW, autogynephilia etc, when the person may just be a gender non-conforming man/woman. It's been helpful for me to reflect on why I'm comfortable with the latter when I'm so uncomfortable with the former. (And that reflecting hasn't changed my position but it was helpful in clarifying it.)

Apologies I can't respond to each comment in the thread but I'm grateful that you've taken the time to read and reply :)

OP posts:

Leafstamp · 02/05/2025 14:24

cariadlet · 02/05/2025 06:50

I would pop into school and ask at the office. Say your ds isn't sure if his teacher is male or female and you couldn't tell him because the title is ambiguous and you haven't met the teacher yourself.

If the member of staff doesn't give enough clarity, push politely eg if they say the teacher is a woman or non binary, ask whether it's someone born female or someone born male but now identifying as a woman or nb.

If the teacher is male, you can tell your son that the teacher is a man but some men like to wear dresses and make up. That's fine because we can all dress however we want but it's a bit confusing if you haven't seen a man dress like that before.

This seems a good suggestion.

I think you need to find out if this teacher is gaslighting children or not.

If they are concealing their sex and not allowing children to refer to them as a man or a woman (and use the respective pronouns) then that is an indication of a school that does not put the safety and wellbeing of their pupils first.

Children are not there to validate an adult’s made up identity.

Original poster

NorthernLoon · 02/05/2025 14:16

Nomoreidea · 02/05/2025 13:10

How does a child in reception have a form teacher? I thought that would be for secondary only. And only seeing this new teacher once or twice a week.

Maybe form teacher isn't the right word. It's a 2-form entry school, so there are two reception teachers, one of whom is responsible for DS's class. That teacher calls the register in the morning, teaches him phonics, maths, doss his parents evening etc. There are a couple of subjects that are taught by other teachers - Mx Smith is one of these.

OP posts:

viques · 02/05/2025 13:31

cariadlet · 02/05/2025 12:50

So how do you propose finding out the sex of a teacher who is using a pronoun usually adopted by gender ideologists?

If the teacher is a man pretending to be a woman and the children are supposed to believe that he's a woman then he is using young children to validate his mental illness/fetish. I would also worry about gender ideology being pushed at the school

If the teacher is a man asking children to pretend that he's a woman, then he's also telling them to ignore their instincts as even very young children can correctly sex people. Encouraging children to ignore their instincts is a safeguarding red flag.

Wanting to find out what's happening isn't being a weird parent, it's being a concerned, responsible one.

Show quote history

Well the parents could go and see for themselves ,speak to the teacher and form an opinion. which I think is a pretty sensible starting point. Or they could set up a WhatsApp page and try to rally other parents into a lynch mob . Which is not a sensible starting point

QuickPeachPoet · 02/05/2025 13:26

Lovelyview · 01/05/2025 20:44

Honestly, I'd move him to a new school. A 5 year old should not be subjected to someone's batshit ideology.

First answer nails it

drspouse · 02/05/2025 13:19

TypeForMiles · 02/05/2025 09:01

I'd go with being child-led. They ask questions, give them answers. Say as much as necessary to answer the questions, as little as possible to give them space to be curious and come up with their own next questions.

It'd be very weird to discuss or speculate about an adult's private parts with a child.

Starting off with basic respect, we call people by the names and titles they prefer.

You are aware sex affects many many more body parts than just genitals?

Justme56 · 02/05/2025 13:15

Nomoreidea · 02/05/2025 13:10

How does a child in reception have a form teacher? I thought that would be for secondary only. And only seeing this new teacher once or twice a week.

It’s quite normal for teachers to job share. My DS had 2 teachers in one year at primary. Also some may have other responsibilities which means they have to be covered. It depends how the school allocates staff.

Nomoreidea · 02/05/2025 13:10

How does a child in reception have a form teacher? I thought that would be for secondary only. And only seeing this new teacher once or twice a week.

Zippidydoodah · 02/05/2025 13:08

I don’t know why you have to say anything at all.

i went to look at secondary schools for my daughter and there was a Mx. I think female at birth but quite masculine looking; short hair and dungarees etc. Had a pride flag on the wall. I’m sure there were genuinely confused teenagers at that school, who found comfort in Mx science teacher.

As long as the teacher just does their job, what’s the problem? Five year olds are way more tolerant than adults.

LittleBitofBread · 02/05/2025 13:02

PhoebesPony · 02/05/2025 08:21

Oh lord, find out first!! Lots of women look masculine or have deep voices. I think you're rather jumping to conclusions!

I agree, find out for sure first. Or just watch and wait and see if your child says anything else, or if any other children or parents make comments.

cariadlet · 02/05/2025 12:50

viques · 02/05/2025 09:11

Yes, do do this, because the staff at reception will be only to happy to discuss any and all information about staff members and their sexuality/gender identity/ marital status/ dress preferences with random parents. It’s what they are there for after all, and don’t worry, the discussion will be totally confidential and they will not speak to other members of staff or the SMT about little x’s weird parent.

Show quote history

So how do you propose finding out the sex of a teacher who is using a pronoun usually adopted by gender ideologists?

If the teacher is a man pretending to be a woman and the children are supposed to believe that he's a woman then he is using young children to validate his mental illness/fetish. I would also worry about gender ideology being pushed at the school

If the teacher is a man asking children to pretend that he's a woman, then he's also telling them to ignore their instincts as even very young children can correctly sex people. Encouraging children to ignore their instincts is a safeguarding red flag.

Wanting to find out what's happening isn't being a weird parent, it's being a concerned, responsible one.

Doingmybest12 · 02/05/2025 09:45

You seem to be assuming an awful lot. If you think the school is ok and well run , why wouldn't you think they know how to manage situations like this professionally or that the teacher wouldn't know what to say in response to innocent questions.

EasternStandard · 02/05/2025 09:17

Difficult one op. I wouldn’t want the dc to have to lie to validate an adult.

But check what the situation is first.

viques · 02/05/2025 09:11

cariadlet · 02/05/2025 06:50

I would pop into school and ask at the office. Say your ds isn't sure if his teacher is male or female and you couldn't tell him because the title is ambiguous and you haven't met the teacher yourself.

If the member of staff doesn't give enough clarity, push politely eg if they say the teacher is a woman or non binary, ask whether it's someone born female or someone born male but now identifying as a woman or nb.

If the teacher is male, you can tell your son that the teacher is a man but some men like to wear dresses and make up. That's fine because we can all dress however we want but it's a bit confusing if you haven't seen a man dress like that before.

Yes, do do this, because the staff at reception will be only to happy to discuss any and all information about staff members and their sexuality/gender identity/ marital status/ dress preferences with random parents. It’s what they are there for after all, and don’t worry, the discussion will be totally confidential and they will not speak to other members of staff or the SMT about little x’s weird parent.