Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Trans women ARE biological women"

832 replies

TangenitalContrivance · 18/04/2025 10:09

I see this argument and comment more and more the last few weeks and hugely over the last 3 days.

For example:

https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/comments/1k1tliv/trans_women_are_biological_women/

This statement, and the comments underneath it absolutely baffle me.

The approach, one that I am sure will only work with a minority of the people who said TWAW, is to undermine the definition of words, yet again, and deliberately cloud the water when it comes to speaking clearly and using terms that everyone agrees with

I have seen it said in more places than Reddit however, and by respected people

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
Needspaceforlego · 23/04/2025 20:49

Will the Terfs be really sad 😔 not having men and their smelly farts in the toilets?
Aww Dear! Least the Terfs loos will be clean 👌

But we all know the issue isn't just toilets, it's Changing rooms,
hospital wards,
prisons,
domestic abuse shelters,
rape crisis centers,
military barracks (wtf),
youth hostels,
girl guide tents,
single sex beauty couses, (see Isla Bryson)
boarding schools,
childrens homes,
Female being searched by trans police
Female police being asked to search trans

...I'm sure there must be more places, that have fallen for TWAW

SerafinasGoose · 23/04/2025 20:46

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/04/2025 09:56

A bit of infighting here about “the trans man gotcha” https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/s/BCaItGHQM5

Jeeze. Look at that thread. The 'divine essence' of femininity is the very antithesis of what GC women typically believe.

I am female. I inhabit a female body. The rest is just feelz, and an inner womanly essence is not a thing I have ever experienced nor would claim. I doubt whether such a thing even exists, and if it does it's certainly not empirically proveable.

It's a strange combination of doublethink and projection to accuse others of precisely the bunkum you and your 'allies' argue on a more or less daily basis.

ThatCyanCat · 23/04/2025 18:48

Lemonz · 23/04/2025 17:03

Going by Reddit, they seem to think that most women don't actually value single sex spaces and once there is a third unisex space, it will be a lot more popular and the 'terfs' will then end up feeling sad and ostracised alone in our single sex spaces, unfulfilled with nobody to be cross with. While the TiMs and 'inclusive' women have a lovely party in the mixed sex loos 😆

A) I think it's very unlikely that most women would choose mixed sex over single sex in most scenarios if offered a genuine choice.

B) Personally I don't care at all where other women are getting changed or going to the toilet. It's not a bonding exercise or 'validating' for me. I'd bet a lot that this is a majority attitude.

C) The prospect of having nobody to be cross with because nobody is violating my boundaries doesn't sound bad, it sounds like a blissful relief. Crazy they think this could be a downside.

Edited

Going by Reddit, they seem to think that most women don't actually value single sex spaces and once there is a third unisex space, it will be a lot more popular and the 'terfs' will then end up feeling sad and ostracised alone in our single sex spaces, unfulfilled with nobody to be cross with.

They shouldn't threaten us with a good time.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 23/04/2025 18:43

I don't suppose it would catch on, but here's a suggestion:

  • single sex ladies as now
  • urinal (and handwash!) only
  • single toilet "gender neutral" rooms, perhaps with baby changing
  • disability equipped room

That really should cover almost everyone's needs.

Waitwhat23 · 23/04/2025 18:15

I'm imagining a marching band of women playing the dambuster's theme through pretend trumpets

'All together now, duun, dun, dun, duuun dundadundun'

(Edited to add, this is in response to a previous post! I haven't (yet) lost the plot.)

nicksplat doug GIF
SionnachRuadh · 23/04/2025 18:12

I mostly use Reddit for looking at amusing pictures of cats. Pro tip is not to go into the comments, because even the cat subs make AIBU look like the House of Lords.

MarieDeGournay · 23/04/2025 18:07

Lemonz Going by Reddit..

I'd like to take a moment to salute the brave women who are making these daring sorties into Reddit territory, so the rest of us don't have to.
I can only imagine the horrors that you face there and I want you to know that your sacrifice is appreciated <uplifting music swells in background>🎖🎖🎖

Lemonz · 23/04/2025 17:39

TheOtherRaven · 23/04/2025 17:29

The narrative is gently starting to glide in the direction of fine lets have lots of really nice third spaces pdq. And great, lets.

They actually will add to genuine accessibility for many as well as leave women in peace.

Edited to add: happy to contribute to a dish of party hats to go alongside the san pro if that helps.

Edited

Except they say that the 'terf only' space will be the third space 😄 Great idea lads.

But yes, it is nice to see them taking the idea semi seriously as it has long been suggested as a solution. It would be nice for lots of people to have that option.

We all know that toilets are really not the most important thing anyway. Not unimportant, but not close to hospital wards, rape crisis services, prisons, sports, etc.

I don't actually mind mixed sexed toilets usually, as long as properly labelled, though I wouldn't choose them over single sex all other things being equal - but it's vital that everyone can make informed decisions.

TheOtherRaven · 23/04/2025 17:29

Lemonz · 23/04/2025 17:03

Going by Reddit, they seem to think that most women don't actually value single sex spaces and once there is a third unisex space, it will be a lot more popular and the 'terfs' will then end up feeling sad and ostracised alone in our single sex spaces, unfulfilled with nobody to be cross with. While the TiMs and 'inclusive' women have a lovely party in the mixed sex loos 😆

A) I think it's very unlikely that most women would choose mixed sex over single sex in most scenarios if offered a genuine choice.

B) Personally I don't care at all where other women are getting changed or going to the toilet. It's not a bonding exercise or 'validating' for me. I'd bet a lot that this is a majority attitude.

C) The prospect of having nobody to be cross with because nobody is violating my boundaries doesn't sound bad, it sounds like a blissful relief. Crazy they think this could be a downside.

Edited

The narrative is gently starting to glide in the direction of fine lets have lots of really nice third spaces pdq. And great, lets.

They actually will add to genuine accessibility for many as well as leave women in peace.

Edited to add: happy to contribute to a dish of party hats to go alongside the san pro if that helps.

Walkaround · 23/04/2025 17:28

Lemonz · 23/04/2025 17:03

Going by Reddit, they seem to think that most women don't actually value single sex spaces and once there is a third unisex space, it will be a lot more popular and the 'terfs' will then end up feeling sad and ostracised alone in our single sex spaces, unfulfilled with nobody to be cross with. While the TiMs and 'inclusive' women have a lovely party in the mixed sex loos 😆

A) I think it's very unlikely that most women would choose mixed sex over single sex in most scenarios if offered a genuine choice.

B) Personally I don't care at all where other women are getting changed or going to the toilet. It's not a bonding exercise or 'validating' for me. I'd bet a lot that this is a majority attitude.

C) The prospect of having nobody to be cross with because nobody is violating my boundaries doesn't sound bad, it sounds like a blissful relief. Crazy they think this could be a downside.

Edited

To be fair, I will use whichever toilet has the shortest queue and most toilet paper, unless the toilets are poorly maintained and supervised so that I feel unsafe, in which case I’d either hold on, however uncomfortable, or choose the ladies’ toilets if there are enough other women using them at the same time that they feel the safest bet as a consequence.

EasternStandard · 23/04/2025 17:16

Waitwhat23 · 23/04/2025 15:43

It's when you get the pure numpties who say 'well, we should just have terf toilets!' as if it's some sort of winning point.

And you think, so, female single sex toilets? That's....sort of the whole point.

Ha so true. You get it on here. Women can just say er ok then. Sign here we’re happy with that.

Lemonz · 23/04/2025 17:03

Waitwhat23 · 23/04/2025 15:43

It's when you get the pure numpties who say 'well, we should just have terf toilets!' as if it's some sort of winning point.

And you think, so, female single sex toilets? That's....sort of the whole point.

Going by Reddit, they seem to think that most women don't actually value single sex spaces and once there is a third unisex space, it will be a lot more popular and the 'terfs' will then end up feeling sad and ostracised alone in our single sex spaces, unfulfilled with nobody to be cross with. While the TiMs and 'inclusive' women have a lovely party in the mixed sex loos 😆

A) I think it's very unlikely that most women would choose mixed sex over single sex in most scenarios if offered a genuine choice.

B) Personally I don't care at all where other women are getting changed or going to the toilet. It's not a bonding exercise or 'validating' for me. I'd bet a lot that this is a majority attitude.

C) The prospect of having nobody to be cross with because nobody is violating my boundaries doesn't sound bad, it sounds like a blissful relief. Crazy they think this could be a downside.

Endthisshit · 23/04/2025 16:28

I would place a bet that all the little handmaidens are ageeeing with them and affirming their biological status to correspond with their demanded identity

BundleBoogie · 23/04/2025 16:26

Waitwhat23 · 23/04/2025 15:43

It's when you get the pure numpties who say 'well, we should just have terf toilets!' as if it's some sort of winning point.

And you think, so, female single sex toilets? That's....sort of the whole point.

I love it when they argue themselves round to our points. They know we are right about everything - they just fight it.

SionnachRuadh · 23/04/2025 16:15

Terf toilets would be great. Have any of these transmen ever been in a men's toilet? Do they have no sense of smell?

MarieDeGournay · 23/04/2025 16:10

ThatCyanCat · 23/04/2025 11:02

But they never demand third spaces, that's the issue. They want the women's spaces for men and nothing else will do. Some...person on here the other day was complaining that these third spaces don't exist so trans people can't use them. I said they would exist by now if TRAs had used their resources to fight for them rather than to erase women. They then complained that GC women should have been fighting for them and it wasn't TRA's responsibility. When I said we were too busy funding and fighting for our own spaces and not to be erased in law, as it now seems was always our legal right and this was on them to obtain if they wanted it, they gave a reason-free response of pure guff, dancing around the question of why third spaces aren't an option.

They do not want third spaces and they never did and never will. The purpose is to colonise female spaces as validation tools for men, nothing else.

I agree that for the loudest TRAs, it's the women's toilet or nowhere, 'third' spaces won't do.
It's just that I've seen 'we must provide them with third spaces' or something similar again and again in the media, and on MN.
Maybe it's intended to indicate a level of empathy and so as not appear too gleeful about the SC ruling.

It might turn out that 'third' spaces end up being used mostly by all the women who insist that they've been using unisex toilets for years now and there's absolutely no problem with themSmile

ErrolTheDragon · 23/04/2025 15:56

Needspaceforlego · 23/04/2025 12:30

Just a thought on the idea of 3rd spaces, would that not really mean 2 sets of mens toilets? The normal mens and the trans??

What happens if other sub-sets of men start asking for separate toilets, 🤔?

3rd spaces is just ludicrous the more you think about it

No. Anyone can use mixed sex loos. They’re useful for parents with opposite sex children, for instance - probably far more of those than trans and NB people! They’re an excellent thing in addition to single sex facilities.

BiologicalRobot · 23/04/2025 15:49

I'm okay with Terf toilets 😈

Waitwhat23 · 23/04/2025 15:43

It's when you get the pure numpties who say 'well, we should just have terf toilets!' as if it's some sort of winning point.

And you think, so, female single sex toilets? That's....sort of the whole point.

Needspaceforlego · 23/04/2025 12:30

Just a thought on the idea of 3rd spaces, would that not really mean 2 sets of mens toilets? The normal mens and the trans??

What happens if other sub-sets of men start asking for separate toilets, 🤔?

3rd spaces is just ludicrous the more you think about it

Signalbox · 23/04/2025 12:16

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/04/2025 09:56

A bit of infighting here about “the trans man gotcha” https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/s/BCaItGHQM5

“I am a trans man that has been assaulted three separate times in public toilets. Each time it was by cis women who thought I was in the "wrong" one, twice by cleaners who were cleaning the mens and clearly thought I was too clocky to be in there.”

😂 at the idea that female cleaners are policing male toilets and physically attacking anyone who doesn’t look male enough.

ThatCyanCat · 23/04/2025 11:02

MarieDeGournay · 23/04/2025 09:18

Your response was to the 'Have you ever met a transwoman' failed 'gotcha'.

It highlights one of my big problems with the TRA arguments: they are so anecdotal. Now I enjoy a good anecdote as much as the next person, but when it comes to massive societal change - changing language, the law, education, medicine, building regs etc etc - I demand more than anecdotes.

There are non-anecdotal things like facts, statistics, a sense of proportion, justice, fairness, logic, common sense which should be much more important to policy-makers, education, legislators etc than the slew of anecdotes like

'I know two transwomen and they are lovely lovely people therefore sex is a spectrum, GC women are transphobes, JKR is the Devil Incarnate, and every building now needs a 'third' space which is only a 'third' space because we either can't count, or disabled people and their spaces don't count - but anyway that's irrelevant, my lovely lovely trans friends are sad and they are demanding 'third spaces' to make them happy, because they just want to pee, so -

What do we want? Third Spaces! When do we want them? Now. How do we propose financing and building them, and continuing to guarantee single sex facilities? Not our problem, bigots!

But they never demand third spaces, that's the issue. They want the women's spaces for men and nothing else will do. Some...person on here the other day was complaining that these third spaces don't exist so trans people can't use them. I said they would exist by now if TRAs had used their resources to fight for them rather than to erase women. They then complained that GC women should have been fighting for them and it wasn't TRA's responsibility. When I said we were too busy funding and fighting for our own spaces and not to be erased in law, as it now seems was always our legal right and this was on them to obtain if they wanted it, they gave a reason-free response of pure guff, dancing around the question of why third spaces aren't an option.

They do not want third spaces and they never did and never will. The purpose is to colonise female spaces as validation tools for men, nothing else.

SionnachRuadh · 23/04/2025 10:54

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/04/2025 09:56

A bit of infighting here about “the trans man gotcha” https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/s/BCaItGHQM5

Well that's about as rational as I would expect from young women who want to use the men's toilets

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/04/2025 09:56

A bit of infighting here about “the trans man gotcha” https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/s/BCaItGHQM5

MarieDeGournay · 23/04/2025 09:18

Alltheprettyseahorses · 22/04/2025 10:38

This is the kind of thing that really gets on my nerves. The idea behind it is that if I met a transwoman I would immediately fall on my knees and repent the delusion that I was a human being with rights, quickly followed by fully embracing my true purpose as a support animal for the Glorious One. It's not going to happen.

Your response was to the 'Have you ever met a transwoman' failed 'gotcha'.

It highlights one of my big problems with the TRA arguments: they are so anecdotal. Now I enjoy a good anecdote as much as the next person, but when it comes to massive societal change - changing language, the law, education, medicine, building regs etc etc - I demand more than anecdotes.

There are non-anecdotal things like facts, statistics, a sense of proportion, justice, fairness, logic, common sense which should be much more important to policy-makers, education, legislators etc than the slew of anecdotes like

'I know two transwomen and they are lovely lovely people therefore sex is a spectrum, GC women are transphobes, JKR is the Devil Incarnate, and every building now needs a 'third' space which is only a 'third' space because we either can't count, or disabled people and their spaces don't count - but anyway that's irrelevant, my lovely lovely trans friends are sad and they are demanding 'third spaces' to make them happy, because they just want to pee, so -

What do we want? Third Spaces! When do we want them? Now. How do we propose financing and building them, and continuing to guarantee single sex facilities? Not our problem, bigots!