Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Scottish Greens being sexist again

586 replies

fromorbit · 12/04/2025 11:38

With Sparkles no longer a member other male Scottish Greens have had to step up to continue their terrible reputation. They are doing their bit.

Scottish Greens council candidate claimed JK Rowling was a Holocaust denier and said trans rapist Isla Bryson was a woman
Exclusive: Eryn Browning has been chosen by the Scottish Greens to contest a by-election in Clydebank Waterfront but offensive historic posts have resurfaced.
https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/scottish-greens-council-candidate-claimed-35039831?int_source=nba

There is hope the Scottish Greens might plunge into civil war after their conference. Patrick Harvie is standing down as leader but Slater is standing again and there is opposition over her elitist behaviour.
https://archive.is/ESYZg

Scottish Greens council candidate claimed JK Rowling was a Holocaust denier

Exclusive: Eryn Browning has been chosen by the Scottish Greens to contest a by-election in Clydebank Waterfront but offensive historic posts have resurfaced.

https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/scottish-greens-council-candidate-claimed-35039831?int_source=nba

OP posts:
Thread gallery
102
SinnerBoy · 21/05/2026 15:42

TWETMIRF · Yesterday 18:28

Nothing will stop me using my fire, especially with oil prices as they are. Just wish I could still buy proper coal as this smokeless stuff is rubbish.

I bank my wood burner down overnight with anthracite substitute. Stoveheat Premium, its usually still glowing when I get up.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 20/05/2026 23:06

TWETMIRF · 20/05/2026 21:19

Ha ha. Just feels like a more accurate version. For those that haven't got it transwoman excluding transman including rad fem. I'm not a terf, I'm a twetmirf.

I'm a bit embarrassed that I've only just worked that out. I pride myself on understanding unfamiliar acronyms!

TWETMIRF · 20/05/2026 21:19

CompleteGinasaur · 20/05/2026 18:43

Absolutely agree. But I really posted to say that I've noticed your username/acronym at intervals over the last few years and, well ok, maybe I wasn't trying that hard, but I could never work it out. Then a week or so ago it burst upon me like Saul on the road to Damascus. Feeling very, very stupid now...!

Ha ha. Just feels like a more accurate version. For those that haven't got it transwoman excluding transman including rad fem. I'm not a terf, I'm a twetmirf.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 20/05/2026 19:20

I saw that story today too, @Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g - it comes as no surprise that the Greens are bending over backwards for MANnivannen, but an actual, real woman was discouraged from continuing with her candidacy.

They just love shooting themselves in the foot, don’t they!

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/05/2026 19:15

Quelle surprise.

Scottish Greens being sexist again
CompleteGinasaur · 20/05/2026 18:43

TWETMIRF · 20/05/2026 18:28

Yep. Nothing will stop me using my fire, especially with oil prices as they are. Just wish I could still buy proper coal as this smokeless stuff is rubbish.

The Greens care far more that I use correct sex pronouns for trans people than that I have an open fire in my house.

Absolutely agree. But I really posted to say that I've noticed your username/acronym at intervals over the last few years and, well ok, maybe I wasn't trying that hard, but I could never work it out. Then a week or so ago it burst upon me like Saul on the road to Damascus. Feeling very, very stupid now...!

TWETMIRF · 20/05/2026 18:28

Yep. Nothing will stop me using my fire, especially with oil prices as they are. Just wish I could still buy proper coal as this smokeless stuff is rubbish.

The Greens care far more that I use correct sex pronouns for trans people than that I have an open fire in my house.

ArabellaScott · 20/05/2026 17:24

As ever, urban people have little idea what rural life is like.

CompleteGinasaur · 20/05/2026 13:10

I stay regularly with friends on the Isle of Lewis. If they had to stop burning peat, which I'm pretty sure is horrific for particulate matter and all manner of phenols, not just in winter but a fairly large chunk of the rest of the year too, I'd be chatting to a couple of woman-shaped icicles the next time I went up. Traditional and romantic though, innit, from the point of view of Holyrood. Just absolutely bloody necessary if you live up there.

Hoardasurass · 20/05/2026 12:51

Turtlesgottaturtle · 20/05/2026 12:19

Wood burners are harmful to the health of both owners and neighbours, in villages, towns and cities. Try driving through any Scottish village on a winter evening with your car window open and you'll be breathing in smoke. They cause a long list of very serious health problems. And if people have them as "back-ups" they will use them even when a back-up isn't needed. There's plenty of strong research on this, and it's recognised as a problem internationally. In the UK, wood burners cause more small particulate emissions than all of road transport. Those small emissions are the most dangerous kind.
Find someone who denies this and you've found yourself someone who has spent money on a wood burner, loves sitting in front of their wood burner and has maybe exposed their children to it - they're in denial.

Nobody drives through Scotland on a winters night with their window open (or atleast no sane person does)
Large sections of Scotland either have no access to mains gas or lose all power for weeks at a time everytime there's a bad storm so wood burners or coal fires are all they have to heat their homes, which is why the ban on gas boilers and wood burning stoves was scrapped, not dieing from hypothermia is more important than smoke free air

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 20/05/2026 12:48

Turtlesgottaturtle · 20/05/2026 12:19

Wood burners are harmful to the health of both owners and neighbours, in villages, towns and cities. Try driving through any Scottish village on a winter evening with your car window open and you'll be breathing in smoke. They cause a long list of very serious health problems. And if people have them as "back-ups" they will use them even when a back-up isn't needed. There's plenty of strong research on this, and it's recognised as a problem internationally. In the UK, wood burners cause more small particulate emissions than all of road transport. Those small emissions are the most dangerous kind.
Find someone who denies this and you've found yourself someone who has spent money on a wood burner, loves sitting in front of their wood burner and has maybe exposed their children to it - they're in denial.

And properties with no neighbours anywhere near? Testing levels in a real house and levels outside makes sense. I note that currently within a property a CO monitor is mandatory but not a particle sensor. I have stayed in a house where solid fuel is the only realistic heating option. The blanket ban is authoritarian.

ArabellaScott · 20/05/2026 12:23

Woodburners are a total pain in the arse. Enormously time and labour intensive. For some people, they are necessary.

Given fuel uncertainty and geo politics as they are, plus climate change, moving away from a cheap and plentiful and renewable source of fuel in favour of fossil fuels is foolhardy.

ArabellaScott · 20/05/2026 12:20

Maybe the problem is the conflation of 'smoke' and 'pollution'.

Because of course fossil fuels pollute, just different types of particulates.

There is a very long list in that link above of what you can and can't burn in a smoke-free zone.

Turtlesgottaturtle · 20/05/2026 12:19

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 20/05/2026 11:55

I think there's a case for banning wood burners in built up areas. In sparsely populated areas the particulate emissions disperse rapidly rather than build up to concerning levels.

Wood burners are harmful to the health of both owners and neighbours, in villages, towns and cities. Try driving through any Scottish village on a winter evening with your car window open and you'll be breathing in smoke. They cause a long list of very serious health problems. And if people have them as "back-ups" they will use them even when a back-up isn't needed. There's plenty of strong research on this, and it's recognised as a problem internationally. In the UK, wood burners cause more small particulate emissions than all of road transport. Those small emissions are the most dangerous kind.
Find someone who denies this and you've found yourself someone who has spent money on a wood burner, loves sitting in front of their wood burner and has maybe exposed their children to it - they're in denial.

ArabellaScott · 20/05/2026 12:14

There's already legislation for that I think. Certainly is on coal burning in urban areas

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 20/05/2026 11:55

ArabellaScott · 20/05/2026 08:56

Polluting of what?

And the CO2 emissions?

I would be cautious about all research that supports oil and gas over timber, tbh. Who funded the research and how rigorous is it? I dont have time to dig right now but some of the studies were very flawed, lumping in open fires with stoves, and using tiny samples. Stoves create interior air pollution when refuelling, but so does a toaster while in use.

We can power our homes using renewable electricity. As a back up source, timber is cheap, renewable and plentiful.

Energy needs should be plural to cover shortages or power cuts.

The Scotgov tried to suggest that a portable gas fire was a better option than a woodstove for back up heating.

Madness.

I think there's a case for banning wood burners in built up areas. In sparsely populated areas the particulate emissions disperse rapidly rather than build up to concerning levels.

ArabellaScott · 20/05/2026 08:56

Polluting of what?

And the CO2 emissions?

I would be cautious about all research that supports oil and gas over timber, tbh. Who funded the research and how rigorous is it? I dont have time to dig right now but some of the studies were very flawed, lumping in open fires with stoves, and using tiny samples. Stoves create interior air pollution when refuelling, but so does a toaster while in use.

We can power our homes using renewable electricity. As a back up source, timber is cheap, renewable and plentiful.

Energy needs should be plural to cover shortages or power cuts.

The Scotgov tried to suggest that a portable gas fire was a better option than a woodstove for back up heating.

Madness.

WaterThyme · 19/05/2026 21:40

ArabellaScott · 11/05/2026 20:50

Its bollocks, though.

On this occasion, @ArabellaScott I have to disagree with you. I rarely do.

This BMJ paper points out that even ecodesign wood burning stoves emit over 465 times the 2.5mm particulates that a gas boiler would. They are over 60 times as polluting as oil-fired heating.

https://www.bmj.com/content/392/bmj.s360

I accept that wood-burning stoves are much loved by many and may be easier to use for many who don’t have access to gas. Nonetheless they are far more polluting.

Lalgarh · 19/05/2026 17:02

Problems with pushing buttons

🔘

https://nitter.net/DownWithTheSNP/status/2056741278662922615#m

Waitwhat23 · 12/05/2026 13:56

DuesToTheDirt · 12/05/2026 10:52

Just a thought - if Mannivan were withdrawn, who would take his place? Looks like Chas Booth is the next on the list. I know nothing about him. From his facebook page he is strongly pro-cycling and pro-environment, so maybe not a bad choice.

From my knowledge of him, he consistently attended his regular surgeries in Leith and was fairly vocal in supporting local events. Has actual environmental experience.

On the other hand, he has pronouns in his Bluesky bio. And is part of the Scottish Greens which tells its own story.

CassOle · 12/05/2026 11:02

"pro-cycling and pro-environment"

In current day Greens? That will never do. 😉

DuesToTheDirt · 12/05/2026 10:52

Just a thought - if Mannivan were withdrawn, who would take his place? Looks like Chas Booth is the next on the list. I know nothing about him. From his facebook page he is strongly pro-cycling and pro-environment, so maybe not a bad choice.

ArabellaScott · 12/05/2026 09:37

https://www.thetimes.com/article/fd5f742f-e4f6-40ce-9b60-7b4fc360246e

'Ian Blackford, the SNP’s former Westminster leader, said it “beggars belief” that the Greens had put forward a candidate for parliament who was in the UK on a student visa
.Speaking in a personal capacity, Blackford is a member of the recently formed ethics and integrity commission, which has a remit of protecting standards in public life across the UK.

He added: “Quite frankly this should be an automatic vetting fail as a candidate on a student visa does not satisfy the ability to enter into full-time work.
“Selecting such a candidate undermines trust in politics and how on earth some can expect to be sworn in as an MSP without establishing the right to work is beyond me.
“The Greens are treating the electorate with contempt and given that Q Manivannan cannot satisfy the right-to-work requirements he should not be permitted to take his seat. The Greens ought to propose their next-placed candidate in their place.”

Manivannan said:...
“I am a Commonwealth citizen and am currently on a student visa which will expire later this year. Having passed my grant-funded PhD and viva, I am able to work full time.
“I am in the process of transitioning to a graduate visa which will allow me to stay in the UK for a further three years.'

so, self ID appears to extend to nationality.

SNP veteran calls on Greens to withdraw MSP on student visa

Ian Blackford says it ‘beggars belief’ that Q Manivannan was cleared to stand despite uncertainty over their long-term right to work

https://www.thetimes.com/article/fd5f742f-e4f6-40ce-9b60-7b4fc360246e