Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Save female sports evidence thread

152 replies

Helleofabore · 14/08/2024 14:13

I am conscious that the Break it Down for me thread is nearly full. I am therefore hoping that this thread can be an archive thread just for the sports evidence that we can all access and refer to. Now that MNHQ has given us the option for saving threads so we can find them easily, I figure it is a good time.

Please post studies, papers, media articles that pull together references, or informative articles, tweets, videos. Just on sport, the latest policies around sport.

I don't want to be the thread police, but ask that we keep this free of discussion. Can I ask that if you want to discuss something you see here, you start a thread to do so?

Because I would like this to be just information stashed so that people can find the links easily so they also know where to start. And getting into discussion on this thread will mean it will fill up.

Thanks.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
53
WittyLimeBiscuit · 16/10/2026 10:52

zibzibara · 14/08/2024 14:44

Excellent idea for a thread and thank you for all the resources you posted to seed it with!

Some websites that help illustrate the extent of males competing in women's sport:

www.shewon.org

www.hecheated.org

A visual depiction of male physical advantage in sports, comparing teenage boys to elite female athletes:

www.boysvswomen.com

Seconded, so useful to have everything sport related in one thread

Helleofabore · 15/10/2026 07:25

BURKE'S PAPER ON DOMINANCE REBUTTED

Here is the paper from Michael Burke.

Dominance feminism, intersectionality and why the popular understanding of women’s separate sporting spaces is a step in the wrong direction

https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17511321.2026.2731085

Michael Burke

Received 12 Aug 2025, Accepted 03 Sep 2026, Published online: 11 Oct 2026

ABSTRACT

Gender critical feminists (hereafter GCs) are winning the political battle that has been fought over the last eight years about the provision of separate sporting spaces for females – there is an accelerating trend of international, national and local sporting organizations excluding trans* women from women’s sporting competitions. The justifications used by GCs revolve around issues of fairness, safety and integrity of women’s sports. This paper suggests that the arguments utilised by GCs are the wrong strategic turn in the battle for greater power, resources and coverage for women’s sports. To make this argument, I will use ideas drawn from Catharine MacKinnon’s dominance feminism and Kimberle Crenshaw’s intersectional feminism. These positions on feminism share a number of underpinning foundations. Both champion strongly political coalitions built from women’s (and other’s) experiences on the ground. Also, both remain sceptical of the value of equal opportunities law in challenging (white) male dominance. This paper uses an intersectionally informed dominance feminism as a corrective to the uncritical embrace of sports sex categorisation taken up by GC theorists.

Conclusion: what does dominance feminism still offer us?
There are many things from MacKinnon’s body of work that remain important in contemporary debates about women in sport.

1 It is important to observe the historical intent, use, and limitations of equal opportunity legislation generally, and the anatomical exemption clause specifically, when assessing its current utility. Equal opportunity legislation is useful in breaking down historical, and at times biologically false, barriers to women’s participation in sports that they have been excluded from, and this remains a worthy pursuit of feminism (Travers 2023, 2023), but not at any broader cost;

2. Following from English, it is important that women gain greater access to a share of the scarce benefits that are available to athletes in sport, and affirmative action remedies are justified given the long history of exclusion from sports, from certain sports, from public funding opportunities that have been available to exclusively male sports, and from equitable and respectful coverage in the sports media. It is important to defend what women in sport have had some success in changing;

3 At all times, feminists should be concerned with how interventions challenge and transform the difference discourses that sustain the dominance of men in sports. Some interventions may improve the lot of individual female athletes, whilst sustaining the discourses that support male dominance. These fit in a postfeminist perspective of individual rights and choices, but remain of dubious feminist value in challenging broader structures of patriarchal dominance. In short, biologically based arguments to ban trans* women athletes from women’s sport may not be the ‘win’ that GC feminists suggest;

4 We can learn something interesting about possibilities for the transformation of male dominance in sport by listening to what those on the margins say about hegemonic beliefs about the purposes of sport, the notions of fairness, and the impacts of cultural norms. More specifically, following Travers and Yang, we should promote as many opportunities for degendered sport as are possible, both to offset any male advantage that is culturally produced because of uneven resourcing, and to offer choice to those women who would benefit from playing, or would choose to play, sport against androgenised bodies. But most importantly, in MacKinnon’s terms, degendered sports produce challenges to the difference justifications that underpin male dominance in sport, and in society.

There are many of the usual fallacies in this paper. However, Jon Pike has a concise analysis of the paper.

https://x.com/runthinkwrite/status/2110395656439582806?s=20

-start-

Here's a somewhat interestingly wrong paper (OA) in Sports, Ethics and Philosophy which earns a🧵 (link at the end). It's from Michael, an occaisional sparring partner here, do don't be abusive, please. It opens:

"Gender critical feminists (hereafter GCs) are winning the political battle that has been fought over the last eight years about the provision of separate sporting spaces for females - there is an accelerating trend of international, national and local sporting organizations excluding trans* women from women's sporting competitions. It must now be recognised that the GC voice in global sport is powerful. Sport has grown popular support for the more general GC position, explained by Bassi and LaFleur as ' .... centered"

and puts some of the credit in the right place, adknowledging Martina
and Sharron for providing 'broad commensical opposition' ...

  1. "The GC presentations of cis women and girl athletes as vulnerable and in need of spaces separated on biological grounds from men and boys are more easily digestible than presentations of cis women as vulnerable in other separate spaces such as prisons. As Jones and Travers explain, ' ... anti-trans policies that target trans girls and women in the sociocultural realm of sports seem to deliver what the bathroom controversy only promised: urgent policing and surveillance of gender-suspicious bodies ... in rigidly gendered spaces' (Jones and Travers 2023, 93);
  2. High-profile successful ciswoman athletes and ex-athletes like Martina Navratilova and Sharron Davies, knowledgeable spokespeople for the GC position in sports, have helped to produce broad commonsensical opposition (Dembroff 2020) to
• inclusive trans* policies inside, and beyond, sport;
  1. Physical/safety threats posed by trans* women to cis women in sport are presented as scientifically justified and a necessary consequence of essential structures and practices of some sports (Pike 2021);
  2. GC views, including the suggestion that single-sexed spaces are needed for individual women to experience individual choice and achievement (Bassi and Lafluer
2022), are exaggerated in sport and intertwined with a long history of fairness-based arguments about the need for protection of women's sport from/by 'real men' masquerading as women. These arguments exist in the popular perceptions of most people from 'across the political spectrum' (Jones and Travers 2023, 95) about the necessity for segregated sport."

... “It must now be recognised that the GC voice in global sport is powerful.” is a welcome concession. But Burke argues the success is a strategic mistake: accepting sex differences in performance makes women “second-class athletes.” ...

...Burke doesn’t deny the science. He “happily concede[s] the arguments of the anatomists.” His worry is this: how can women demand equal pay and resources while accepting evidence that they’re slower?...

Here's the section, which follows an account of the work of @FondOfBeetles
on Pool and diffference in strength at the break

"Asked more bluntly, how can women athletes logically make claims to equal resourcing and pay, when they also accept and use a legal framework that states, and pursue scientific evidence to show, that they
are second-class athletes to men?"

... This is the same slippage I criticised in my JPS review of Bekker & Mumford’s Open Play: from “slower” (etc) (descriptive) to “inferior” (normative). Burke drops their sex denial but keeps the slippage. So his case rests on that slippage alone... https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00948705.2026.2623888

.. So, it fails. This is how Flyweights hit less hard than heavyweights. Paralympians are slower than Olympians. Nobody thinks flyweight boxing is thereby second-class boxing. Mumford rightly refuses to call Paralympians “inferior.” ...

... Athletic excellence is class-relative. The boxing world implicitly understands this and has a phrase for it "pound-for-pound". Sha'Carri Richardson female sprinter is a great sprinter. Her achievement isn’t diminished by the existence of faster men. ...

... Nor do resource claims rest on performance parity. Women deserve equal resources because women and men are of equal worth, not because they’d run 9.6 with more track time. Tie resources to times and you’ve already lost. ...

... So Burke faces a dilemma. If “slower” really entails “inferior,” no change of discourse can alter that, and his advice reduces to “stop saying things that are true, because they are uncomfortable!” (and MB had the answer to that). But if it doesn’t, his argument fails.

-end-

(apologies for the formatting fails)

Jon Pike (@runthinkwrite) on X

Here's a somewhat interestingly wrong paper (OA) in Sports, Ethics and Philosophy which earns a🧵 (link at the end). It's from @MichaelSabres14, an occaisional sparring partner here, do don't be abusive, please. It opens:

https://x.com/runthinkwrite/status/2110395656439582806?s=20

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 23/09/2026 13:30

CURRENT COUNT (2026) MALE ATHLETES TAKE 2293 GOLD MEDALS IN FEMALE SPORTS CATEGORIES IN THE USA

https://concernedwomen.org/concerned-women-research-finds-increase-in-trans-identifying-men-winning-gold-medals/

Concerned Women Research Finds Increase in Trans-Identifying Men Winning Gold Medals

22nd September 2026

Concerned Women for America Legislative Action Committee (CWALAC) found that trans-identifying males have stolen over 2,293 gold medals from women and girls in the United States and is calling on Congress to protect biological women and girls from this injustice.

It goes on…

”With data compiled from HeCheated on recorded incidents of natal males’ disruption in female events since the mid-1980s, CWALAC research found that:

Trans-identifying males have stolen over 2,293 gold medals from women and girls in the United States, pushing each rightful champion down to second place.

Trans-identifying male athletes have stolen over $501,498 in prize money from women in professional sports.

In California alone, over 611 women and girls have taken silver below a male allowed to compete in the women’s category.

Trans-identifying males have competed in more than 14,301 female sport events, amateur and professional. “

Concerned Women Research Finds Increase in Trans-Identifying Men Winning Gold Medals

For Immediate Release: September 22, 2026 | Contact: [email protected] WASHINGTON, DC – Concerned Women for America Legislative Action Committee (CWALAC) found that trans-identifying males have stolen over 2,293 gold medals from women and girls i...

https://concernedwomen.org/concerned-women-research-finds-increase-in-trans-identifying-men-winning-gold-medals/

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · 14/09/2026 13:04

Yes, please do start a proper discussion thread @TransParentlyAnnoyed so we can address your many erroneous points.

Starting with oh, it's okay that "only" 28 women lost out on places in grassroots football to men. A strange comment from a professed "feminist".

Oh hang on, I forgot that you prefer to operate only on broadcast mode and not actually engage here in good faith.

My apologies for derailing, @Helleofabore.

Helleofabore · 14/09/2026 12:54

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 14/09/2026 10:15

How about this.

  1. You could fit all the decent trans athletes at college level and above in the USA on a minibus. And lots would be trans men.
  2. When trans women & girls were banned from grassroots football in the whole of the UK, 28 were found to be playing. In many areas, there were none at all.
  3. Most trans children do no sport at all, because they're scared. Even Parkrun isn't safe for them.
  4. Women are amazing. We have fought to be given equal access to table sports,& games, and are now being told that we're not as good as men and never can be. That it's not parental expectation, inequality of access at teenage level, sexism, male hostility, care responsibilities and financial pressures which keep women from playing games like chess, it's being born female. That is a massive, massive step backwards.
  5. There's already sex testing in sport and trans women have been banned from Olympics down to grassroots level. The only trans woman ever to gain a medal remains Caitlyn Jenner.
  6. Trans women are a tiny minority and very few of them do sport, let alone at elite level - from which they are already banned. Yet the obsession with them remains, despite the huge damage it is doing to the perception of women's sporting excellence.
  7. The biggest issues in women's sport are equality of access, prize equality, equality of access to coaching, sexism and predatory cis male coaches.
  8. The lack of trans athletes in women's sport has led to a massive feeding frenzy every time a woman (almost always a woman of colour) is rumoured to be a man in disguise. Even though there is sex testing in sport. Where is JK Rowling's apology to Lin Yu Ting for calling her a man and accusing her of VAWG, for example? These frenzies happen because there are no trans women in sport, but the hunger to take a woman apart for the crime of perceived masculinity, remains. It used to be because they were alleged to be gay, now it's because they're alleged to be evil men in disguise. Go figure.
  9. Please directly support women's sport. Go to women's cricket, it's an amazing day out - and current equality of access to coaching means women are breaking records every single year. Show that it's supported and get us a proper Ashes series, which the women fully deserve.
10. Any decent female runner will easily outpace a random trans woman turning up to Parkrun. Stop talking down elite female athletes. 11. Transitioned trans women lose most of their physical advantage over cis women. No transitioned female athletes have ever won an Olympic medal, when they were allowed to compete. Or even got close. 12. Cis men do not value women's sporting prizes, and are not turning up in droves untransitioned in pink shorts with the aim of stealing our (usually rubbish) trophies. This is a myth used to justify transphobia. 13. Just because you feel repulsed to see a woman doing mild exercise while dressed in her normal running gear, does not mean she is committing a crime. 14. Women are amazing. Look how we're doing in endurance events. Don't help men exclude us from challenging for the big money in table sports. 15. That list of trans women who've won in 'female events'? It includes the trans woman who won Jeopardy! And hot dog eating contests, a whole host of tame games and not much else.

Cheers.

This is not a discussion thread. Please start your own thread if you have not got any studies, statistics or expert evidenced comment to post.

It very clearly says ‘evidence thread’ on the title and it also asks only for evidence in the OP.

OP posts:
TransParentlyAnnoyed · 14/09/2026 10:15

Helleofabore · 14/08/2024 14:13

I am conscious that the Break it Down for me thread is nearly full. I am therefore hoping that this thread can be an archive thread just for the sports evidence that we can all access and refer to. Now that MNHQ has given us the option for saving threads so we can find them easily, I figure it is a good time.

Please post studies, papers, media articles that pull together references, or informative articles, tweets, videos. Just on sport, the latest policies around sport.

I don't want to be the thread police, but ask that we keep this free of discussion. Can I ask that if you want to discuss something you see here, you start a thread to do so?

Because I would like this to be just information stashed so that people can find the links easily so they also know where to start. And getting into discussion on this thread will mean it will fill up.

Thanks.

How about this.

  1. You could fit all the decent trans athletes at college level and above in the USA on a minibus. And lots would be trans men.
  2. When trans women & girls were banned from grassroots football in the whole of the UK, 28 were found to be playing. In many areas, there were none at all.
  3. Most trans children do no sport at all, because they're scared. Even Parkrun isn't safe for them.
  4. Women are amazing. We have fought to be given equal access to table sports,& games, and are now being told that we're not as good as men and never can be. That it's not parental expectation, inequality of access at teenage level, sexism, male hostility, care responsibilities and financial pressures which keep women from playing games like chess, it's being born female. That is a massive, massive step backwards.
  5. There's already sex testing in sport and trans women have been banned from Olympics down to grassroots level. The only trans woman ever to gain a medal remains Caitlyn Jenner.
  6. Trans women are a tiny minority and very few of them do sport, let alone at elite level - from which they are already banned. Yet the obsession with them remains, despite the huge damage it is doing to the perception of women's sporting excellence.
  7. The biggest issues in women's sport are equality of access, prize equality, equality of access to coaching, sexism and predatory cis male coaches.
  8. The lack of trans athletes in women's sport has led to a massive feeding frenzy every time a woman (almost always a woman of colour) is rumoured to be a man in disguise. Even though there is sex testing in sport. Where is JK Rowling's apology to Lin Yu Ting for calling her a man and accusing her of VAWG, for example? These frenzies happen because there are no trans women in sport, but the hunger to take a woman apart for the crime of perceived masculinity, remains. It used to be because they were alleged to be gay, now it's because they're alleged to be evil men in disguise. Go figure.
  9. Please directly support women's sport. Go to women's cricket, it's an amazing day out - and current equality of access to coaching means women are breaking records every single year. Show that it's supported and get us a proper Ashes series, which the women fully deserve.
10. Any decent female runner will easily outpace a random trans woman turning up to Parkrun. Stop talking down elite female athletes. 11. Transitioned trans women lose most of their physical advantage over cis women. No transitioned female athletes have ever won an Olympic medal, when they were allowed to compete. Or even got close. 12. Cis men do not value women's sporting prizes, and are not turning up in droves untransitioned in pink shorts with the aim of stealing our (usually rubbish) trophies. This is a myth used to justify transphobia. 13. Just because you feel repulsed to see a woman doing mild exercise while dressed in her normal running gear, does not mean she is committing a crime. 14. Women are amazing. Look how we're doing in endurance events. Don't help men exclude us from challenging for the big money in table sports. 15. That list of trans women who've won in 'female events'? It includes the trans woman who won Jeopardy! And hot dog eating contests, a whole host of tame games and not much else.

Cheers.

Helleofabore · 14/09/2026 07:14

USA RUGBY CEO INTERVIEW ON THE CHANGES TO WOMEN’S SPORTS

An interview between two male people. This is enlightening in how this CEO prioritises male people and how he emotional he is that some male people will be negatively impacted by the change.

https://x.com/JenniferSey/status/2099266309892784427/video/1?s=46

note: the music has been added by ICONS.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 13/09/2026 17:27

DETECTING SEX CATEGORY BY GAIT STUDY

www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnhum.2020.00320/full

Table 2 shows that sex can be identified from gait by the study cohort with 65% accuracy just from dots on the joints over a 3.8 second duration.

To be clear, 65% accuracy from dots over a less than 4 second duration! It was still over 60% accuracy from 0.4 seconds.

This is a fairly handy graphic. It is basic and is not showing q-angles but it communicates the basics.

Abstract
This paper explores in parallel the underlying mechanisms in human perception of biological motion and the best approaches for automatic classification of gait. The experiments tested three different learning paradigms, namely, biological, biomimetic, and non-biomimetic models for gender identification from human gait. Psychophysical experiments with twenty-one observers were conducted along with computational experiments without applying any gender specific modifications to the models or the stimuli. Results demonstrate the utilization of a generic memory based learning system in humans for gait perception, thus reducing ambiguity between two opposing learning systems proposed for biological motion perception. Results also support the biomimetic nature of memory based artificial neural networks (ANN) in their ability to emulate biological neural networks, as opposed to non-biomimetic models. In addition, the comparison between biological and computational learning approaches establishes a memory based biomimetic model as the best candidate for a generic artificial gait classifier (83% accuracy, p < 0.001), compared to human observers (66%, p < 0.005) or non-biomimetic models (83%, p < 0.001) while adhering to human-like sensitivity to gender identification, promising potential for application of the model in any given non-gender based gait perception objective with superhuman performance.

Save female sports evidence thread
OP posts:
Lalgarh · 06/09/2026 10:21

Do you think a general Canada LGBTQ thread might work? I'm not there myself by the way and I've not been following the sports thing very closely

Helleofabore · 06/09/2026 10:11

Lalgarh · 06/09/2026 09:54

I reckon this would do well with its own thread Lalgarh. This one is just for linking studies, statistics, significant policy changes and expert opinion that supports protecting female sports categories or is important to highlight and keeping it easy to find that information.

If you start a thread, I will be very happy to join you on it.

OP posts:
Lalgarh · 06/09/2026 09:54

Just spotted this on Reddit. 31 year old male competing against girls as young as 14 in Canadian hockey league

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/news%2Fvictoria%2Ftransgender-hockey-player-dominates-womens-league-sparking-safety-fears-for-schoolgirls%2Fnews-story%2F6652fe4f2d78cb2a96940ddbaf506522

Helleofabore · 05/09/2026 10:47

https://x.com/mara_yamauchi/status/2096144220176171058?s=46

Here is a good analysis by Mara of how male people entering as female athletes impact others.

“Parkrun: good illustration today of how self-ID corrupts age grade rankings.

A male in his 60s ran parkrun in Australia in the Female category. If he’d run in the Male category, he’d have been 6th in the age grade rankings with a score just over 70%. But because he ran in the Female category, his age grade score was just over 86%. This rocketed him up to the top spot by a massive margin (well over 10%).

The runners who got bumped down were:

1. A young man who was 1st to finish so he was robbed of being 1st by time and 1st by age grade.

2. A woman in her 60s who’s a devoted parkrunner & has done >100 parkruns;

3. A man in his 60s, also devoted & is close to having done 200 parkruns;

4. A woman who, despite being in her 40s, was near the top of the Female finishing order. She’s done >70 parkruns;

5. A man who, despite being in his 50s, was near the top of the Male finishing order. He’s done >50 parkruns.

All these very good runners who are devoted parkrunners suffering unfairness & being robbed of their hard-earned place in the age grade rankings, and all for what? So that parkrun can indulge the beliefs of men who say they are women. So much unfairness inflicted on men & women bc parkrun can’t bring itself to say no to these men & implement sex at birth categories.”

Mara Yamauchi profile picture

Mara Yamauchi (@mara_yamauchi) on X

Parkrun: good illustration today of how self-ID corrupts age grade rankings. A male in his 60s ran parkrun in Australia in the Female category. If he’d run in the Male category, he’d have been 6th in the age grade rankings with a score just over 70%....

https://x.com/mara_yamauchi/status/2096144220176171058?s=46

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 05/09/2026 04:15

THE PARKRUN IS FAILING FEMALES VIDEO (2024 ) AND SAVE WOMEN’S SPORTS VIDEO (2025)

The ‘Parkrun is failing’ video briefly goes through the argument of ‘it is not a competition’ and describes how by including male people in the female category, parkrun is the very opposite of being ‘inclusive’.

It is similar to this ‘Save Women’s Sports’ video

Mara says, "I'm here with a lot of my fellow sex realists. We are quietly protesting against parkrun's gender self ID categories. Any male if he says he's a woman or even if he doesn't say he's a woman, any male is welcome in the female category."

"Official results are published every week in descending order of speed. The rankings mean in reality it is a race and that is unfair for women and girls."

And then

"You can call it anything you like, but the facts of Parkrun are, measured courses, start and finish line."

Other brave women also keep raising the valid points such as:

"it's a race if you run it like a race"

and

"That opportunity to treat it like a race should be there for everybody because it is there for men"

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/i0kW3LiNFEM

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 05/09/2026 03:26

This is not a discussion thread. Please start a thread to discuss anything from this thread. It takes up valuable space and makes the thread less useful.

Apologies for being rude.

OP posts:
AimsAndObjectives · 04/09/2026 22:25

Britinme · 04/09/2026 22:12

I was asked on a thread recently about males with CAIS and how they should be regarded. Obviously CAIS is a male-specific DSD, but I don't believe they undergo virilisation at puberty do they?

No, they don't and I think that athletes with CAIS are an exception that the IOC makes for participation in female sports. However, I think that there is still some research to be done on whether the presence of a Y chromosome does confer other advantages and I think that there is also an issue with where to draw the line between PAIS (which is partial androgen insensitivity syndrome) and CAIS (complete insensitivity).

Britinme · 04/09/2026 22:12

I was asked on a thread recently about males with CAIS and how they should be regarded. Obviously CAIS is a male-specific DSD, but I don't believe they undergo virilisation at puberty do they?

sheitani · 04/09/2026 16:24

The image below is useful for understanding how males with DSD 5-ARD may be misidentified as females at birth, especially in countries with poor health services. The micropenis is assumed to be a "phalliform clitoris" and the blind vaginal pouch is assumed to be a vagina (without a cervix or uterus).
At puberty the internal testes produce large amounts of testosterone and the 5-ARD male undergoes virilisation. This combined with absence of menstruation, means that adult males with 5-ARD know they are males, but some countries use the erroneous female birth certificate to their advantage by having these males compete in the female category (Semenya, et al.)

Save female sports evidence thread
borntobequiet · 03/09/2026 07:38
  • Decisions should be based on science and common sense, not on scare tactics that talk about strong men playing and showering with young girls. People should focus on the real issues of safety and fairness.

Madly contradictory. Almost as though they don’t know the meanings of the words “safe” and “fair”.

Helleofabore · 03/09/2026 07:19

A PLEA FROM ACTIVISTS THAT THE PUBLIC OPINION IS ‘HARDENING’

There are quite a few inconsistencies in this article, including how supposedly children’s sex categories for sport don’t matter while calling for organisations to follow the science (which shows that advantage exists even in prepubescent children …)

in particular it says this:

“Public opinion is hardening against trans women playing in sports, and it has triggered a witch hunt that is threatening to infect every aspect of trans life.”

I have copied and pasted most of the abridged article below without changing the formatting.

https://x.com/searchlightinst/status/2094855730511909069?s=46

Mara Keisling, a senior fellow at Searchlight and the founding executive director of the National Center for Transgender Equality, gives her thoughts on Sophie Cunningham's latest comments — as more and more conservative pundits amplify them over the course of this week.

You can read her full piece (https://www.wordsinsearchlight.org/p/dont-turnover-trans-sports-to-sophie)
and abridged below.

As someone who’s been in the trans activism space for decades, I’m of two minds about it. First, young trans kids should be able to compete in the sports leagues of their choosing.
If the children are prepubescent, it couldn’t affect the competitive integrity of the league, so there is simply no reason why they should not be able to play with their friends. Cunningham’s comments don’t recognize that nuance.

There is also nowhere in the United States where young girls play sports against biological men, and there is not and should not be anywhere that adult men share locker rooms or take showers with young girl athletes. No one finds that acceptable.

On the other hand, I think the trans community should recognize that when we go beyond prepubescent youth sports, many sports leagues, including the WNBA, need eligibility rules. And many, if not most, people in the United States honestly do worry about and object to trans women having a competitive advantage in women’s sports.

A recent poll from Pew found that 73% of voters said they were uncomfortable with trans athletes competing on sports teams that do not match their sex at birth.

In the greater scheme of trans issues, this is not even close to the most important topic. But it has become the primary way the typical American hears about our cause. It is also the issue that has been used to bludgeon trans people and supportive Democrats. Competitive sports matter in our society and we need to be pragmatic about that.

Transgender women and girls playing on women’s or girls’ teams is a relatively new issue, but public opinion has moved rapidly against it. So much so that I cannot imagine that we will be able to win the issue for the foreseeable future. In fact, I think trying to argue for participation in elite sports will only turn more Americans against trans rights and empower anti-trans politicians to attack us.

Here are the guidelines I would propose:

  • Decisions should be made by sports associations and leagues based on legitimate safety and fairness concerns. Politicians should stay out of it as much as possible, and worry about protecting all of their constituents and especially all children.
  • There should be no un-American blanket bans on any type of person. Rather, specific participation decisions should be made according to the age of the athlete and the particular sport they are playing.
  • Decisions should be based on science and common sense, not on scare tactics that talk about strong men playing and showering with young girls. People should focus on the real issues of safety and fairness.
  • Science should continue studying the effects of testosterone on sports performance.
  • And lastly, the youngest children should be allowed to play in a safe and fair way without getting caught up in shameful political posturing.

Public opinion is hardening against trans women playing in sports, and it has triggered a witch hunt that is threatening to infect every aspect of trans life. On sports in particular, it has harmed trans children who just want to play sports with their friends. Prepubescent children should be exempted from these bans, which are made by the wrong people.

(the article goes on)

Don’t turn over trans sports to Sophie Cunningham

We need a way forward that protects trans children and understands public opinion

https://www.wordsinsearchlight.org/p/dont-turnover-trans-sports-to-sophie

OP posts:
impossibletoday · 07/08/2026 19:10

LTA widens support for womens game to all levels of competitive matches

British tennis bans transgender women from all competitive female matches

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/e2a47b30e80f5b95

British tennis bans transgender women from all competitive female matches

LTA extends prohibition to internal club competitions in move praised by Sharron Davies

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/e2a47b30e80f5b95

OP posts:
SwirlyGates · 30/07/2026 21:02

It's always enlightening to do a simple word count on these articles. "Trans" (either as a prefix or a separate word) is used 5 times, e.g. "FAW has engaged with transgender participants"; "women" or "women", or even "female" - take a wild guess now.... yes you're right, 0 times.

Apollo441 · 30/07/2026 20:51

Kicking and screaming but one by one they are being forced to acknowledge thr Supreme Court decision. It will be a long road but the direction of travel in one way.