Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trans Widows' Escape Committee 6: The Next Generation

561 replies

TinselAngel · 24/08/2023 22:30

Welcome to thread 6.

This is a support area for women who are, or have been, in unhappy relationships with male partners who are transitioning, or exploring their "gender identity"

If you are in that position-

  1. You are not alone
  2. It is not a situation that you should be expected to tolerate, let alone celebrate.
  3. There is always a way out, if you want it. The thread is called Escape Committee for a reason.

Remember: women talking to each other is a powerful weapon!

The main event this year outisde the thread will hopefully be the release of Vaishnavi Sundar's film about Trans Widows- Behind the Looking Glass

If you would like to donate to help Vaishnavi finish the project, details are here:

Please feel free to say "Hi" below, even if you are not a trans widow, to start the thread off.

Behind The Looking Glass - Teaser - Lime Soda Films Feature-Length Documentary

Watch our fundraiser teaser here: https://youtu.be/dH4XQ6Ie8O0Support our project: www.limesodafilms.com/donateLime Soda Films' upcoming film titled Behind T...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhAlvw_kAHs

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Groutyonehereagain · 04/07/2025 15:30

MyKindLimeCrow · 04/07/2025 14:45

It seems like it would make you so upset that he had a miserable childhood. And do you think that's because you would blame yourself? So often moms are taught that our children's experiences of life are our creation and our responsibility. And that's not true.

It is possible that he is rewriting history. It is also possible for youth to look like they are successful, loving and happy but to feel depressed and miserable too. Both can be true. And it's very common. It's part of being a teenager.

Especially for oldest kids, we have to be the family hero and be perfect and look perfect to get validation.

Do you feel like he is telling you that you should have known he was miserable? Like you should have known he wanted to transition?

He wasn’t miserable, my memories of him growing up and thriving are facts. I’m upset because he’s rewriting history. I have nothing to blame myself for. I resent the direction your post has taken.

I understand that it’s a common theme for trans people to rewrite their history.

He’s doing this to justify his appalling behaviour towards his wife, kids and the rest of his family.

MyKindLimeCrow · 04/07/2025 14:45

Groutyonehereagain · 04/07/2025 09:57

Growing up he has the eldest of three. They were really close, he was especially close to his middle brother. They were happy kids, I loved having them around. The younger two used to fight sometimes but my eldest was always the calmer one, the voice of reason when the other two were fighting. They played a lot with cars, Lego, football, etc. They had friends round regularly and were just completely normal children. My eldest did very well in education. He had plenty of male friends and started dating in his late teens. He had several lovely girlfriends. He went to uni and did well.

According to him, now, he was miserable and depressed. The happy lovely kid who used to say I love you mum and who loved his brothers and who excelled at education didn’t exist, apparently. He’s told me he lied to me and kept things from me. I won’t have it. My memories of him growing up are the true ones. He was a lovely child and teenager. It’s impossible that he was miserable and depressed. His teachers loved him, he always worked hard at school and got good reports. That simply does not equate with a depressed miserable child.

I am expected to go along with this rewritten history. I can’t, it’s my history as well and my happy memories. I have photos of a happy, joyful, smiling child. It feels like my actual son has been abducted and replaced by this aggressive, transwoman.

It seems like it would make you so upset that he had a miserable childhood. And do you think that's because you would blame yourself? So often moms are taught that our children's experiences of life are our creation and our responsibility. And that's not true.

It is possible that he is rewriting history. It is also possible for youth to look like they are successful, loving and happy but to feel depressed and miserable too. Both can be true. And it's very common. It's part of being a teenager.

Especially for oldest kids, we have to be the family hero and be perfect and look perfect to get validation.

Do you feel like he is telling you that you should have known he was miserable? Like you should have known he wanted to transition?

Dadhouse · 04/07/2025 10:25

My brother is a middle-aged agp trans.
My mum and me are feminists and very protective of woman's rights, that hasn't changed. My mum is very considerate of my brother's now ex. She gets no blame, only the usual protective sadness that losing a lovely person in the family for 25 years brings.
Her maternal attitude to my brother as an individual is still very instinctive but sadly, after going through, surprise, support, bafflement, is now in anger since he basically only cares for himself over and over again. He really has become rather unpleasant, picking fights, pushing his agenda at all costs and opportunities.
He is on very thin ice with her now and is too self centred to realise.

Groutyonehereagain · 04/07/2025 09:57

MyKindLimeCrow · 04/07/2025 03:46

That is terrible. I'm so sorry. How did he rewrite his teen years if you don't mind sharing. Is his father still in the picture?
His new boyfriend is a total stranger he just met two weeks ago. It's not normal to bring someone immediately into your family events like that.

Growing up he has the eldest of three. They were really close, he was especially close to his middle brother. They were happy kids, I loved having them around. The younger two used to fight sometimes but my eldest was always the calmer one, the voice of reason when the other two were fighting. They played a lot with cars, Lego, football, etc. They had friends round regularly and were just completely normal children. My eldest did very well in education. He had plenty of male friends and started dating in his late teens. He had several lovely girlfriends. He went to uni and did well.

According to him, now, he was miserable and depressed. The happy lovely kid who used to say I love you mum and who loved his brothers and who excelled at education didn’t exist, apparently. He’s told me he lied to me and kept things from me. I won’t have it. My memories of him growing up are the true ones. He was a lovely child and teenager. It’s impossible that he was miserable and depressed. His teachers loved him, he always worked hard at school and got good reports. That simply does not equate with a depressed miserable child.

I am expected to go along with this rewritten history. I can’t, it’s my history as well and my happy memories. I have photos of a happy, joyful, smiling child. It feels like my actual son has been abducted and replaced by this aggressive, transwoman.

TheAngryLioness · 04/07/2025 09:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Thank you for supporting us and being kind. Hope you feel better for venting. Yes it is similar to a break up but imagine they changing their personality and living their life in a make believe world and still convincing the world that they are the same person.

Lovelyview · 04/07/2025 08:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Your lack of empathy for women's feelings really does show what a complete male you are. Bog off.

TheAngryLioness · 04/07/2025 07:30

Groutyonehereagain · 04/07/2025 03:33

‘The amount of entitlement and gall it takes to spring this on someone and expect them to be ok with it is just stunning, in the realm of them being delusional and out of touch with reality.’

I totally relate to this. I’ve been bullied and battered because I’ve struggled with the situation. He rewrote his childhood and teenage years and expected me to go along with it. He left his wife and three young children and expected me to be happy for him.

He now has a transwoman boyfriend and I’m expected to welcome both of them as a couple into my home. After two years I’m still reeling from his announcement and I’m now expected to have two of them at my birthday party. I can’t do it and he’s not happy. He uses the grandchildren as a weapon to control me.

I am so sorry to hear you go through this pain for your child. I dont know how my mother in law is going to cope with this transition of my children's father (I do not like calling him husband anymore). I was saying to my sister in law i cn divorce him but a parent and child unfortunately do not have much choice. Big hugs from me xx

MyKindLimeCrow · 04/07/2025 03:46

Groutyonehereagain · 04/07/2025 03:33

‘The amount of entitlement and gall it takes to spring this on someone and expect them to be ok with it is just stunning, in the realm of them being delusional and out of touch with reality.’

I totally relate to this. I’ve been bullied and battered because I’ve struggled with the situation. He rewrote his childhood and teenage years and expected me to go along with it. He left his wife and three young children and expected me to be happy for him.

He now has a transwoman boyfriend and I’m expected to welcome both of them as a couple into my home. After two years I’m still reeling from his announcement and I’m now expected to have two of them at my birthday party. I can’t do it and he’s not happy. He uses the grandchildren as a weapon to control me.

That is terrible. I'm so sorry. How did he rewrite his teen years if you don't mind sharing. Is his father still in the picture?
His new boyfriend is a total stranger he just met two weeks ago. It's not normal to bring someone immediately into your family events like that.

Groutyonehereagain · 04/07/2025 03:33

‘The amount of entitlement and gall it takes to spring this on someone and expect them to be ok with it is just stunning, in the realm of them being delusional and out of touch with reality.’

I totally relate to this. I’ve been bullied and battered because I’ve struggled with the situation. He rewrote his childhood and teenage years and expected me to go along with it. He left his wife and three young children and expected me to be happy for him.

He now has a transwoman boyfriend and I’m expected to welcome both of them as a couple into my home. After two years I’m still reeling from his announcement and I’m now expected to have two of them at my birthday party. I can’t do it and he’s not happy. He uses the grandchildren as a weapon to control me.

MyKindLimeCrow · 04/07/2025 03:22

TheAngryLioness · 03/07/2025 12:44

I feel guilty for not supporting him and want so much for things to go back like they were. Its moved so quickly its unbelievable. From coming out (finding out!) to he wanting to put makeup on and long hair with long nails etc. He is a clever person and has never shown any kind of such fetish behaviour in our relationship ever. So I am stumpped at all this. He is going through lot of guilt and shame but at the same time cannot stop himself to dress and present himself as a woman going forward. I can see our breakdown of relationship is troubling him immensely too and not something he wants either. So just torn between all this 💔 😞 😪

Right now the only person he is concerned with is him and that is probably going to continue for a long time. Most of these AGPs are covert narcissists. Once they rip off the band aid of coming out, nothing can stop the progression of their transition. They will risk their job, family, kids, wife, house, pets, and their own safety to do this.

My point is that you have to stand up for you and your kids because no one else is going to do that. Do not let him guilt you into feeling bad about not being pansexual. He knew when you got married that you were straight. To expect you to accept this is like doing reverse conversion therapy on someone.

The amount of entitlement and gall it takes to spring this on someone and expect them to be ok with it is just stunning, in the realm of them being delusional and out of touch with reality.

MyKindLimeCrow · 04/07/2025 03:08

Groutyonehereagain · 04/07/2025 02:35

Thanks for posting. What you say definitely resonates with my experience as a mother of a white, middle aged, transwoman.

It is so rare to see them dressing in a plain conservative way in their free time. Its usually clothing that is very body conscious, shows a lot of skin, especially cleavage. Lots of purple wigs, 4 inch heels, thigh boots, things that we associate with a woman looking sexy.

The emphasis on looks is interesting because if they just want to be a woman, you would think there would be a variety of dress and styles like there naturally is with women. But the focus is on sexual attention.

One of the people who wrote the Matrix movies is a transwoman who publicly admits that watching trans porn made her want to come out and be seen because the transwomen in porn were so highly desired and eroticized.

MyKindLimeCrow · 04/07/2025 02:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It’s incredibly invalidating to call trans widows narcissists or attention seekers. That kind of comment is an attempt to silence women whose stories challenge your comfort.

The term trans widow exists because we need a way to find each other. What many of us went through involved deception, sexual boundary violations, and the loss of a shared reality, which is not just a breakup, but a deep psychological rupture. When you’ve been gaslit in your own home and told your trauma isn’t real, finding language for it is survival.

If our truth bothers you so much, it’s worth asking why. What is it about our pain that feels threatening to you? No one’s forcing you to be here, but trying to shut people up in a space designed for healing says a lot more about you than it does about us.

We’re not here to make others comfortable. We’re here to speak the truth and reclaim our voices. That’s not narcissism, it’s recovery.

Groutyonehereagain · 04/07/2025 02:35

MyKindLimeCrow · 04/07/2025 02:20

I have no idea. It seems like an addiction in the way they live it out. Risking everything for a fetish is bizarre. I do believe that it becomes a part of their identity and that they want everyone to know that they too are part of an oppressed group.

Also almost all of these late lifers think that they are ugly men. Hardly any of them are. But men hardly ever get sexual attention. Its absolutely nothing compared to the attention that a man in a dress gets from other TIMs and men who like them and want a man with breasts and a penis.

The most searched for thing in porn is a man with a penis and breasts. The amount of attention they can get in gay bars and online just feeds their ego and the fetish. My ex got so much attention in gay bars. He was treated like a celebrity sometimes and people wanted to take their photo with him.

The other thing is if you look around there are almost no married father late lifers who aren't white. I think they want to be a part of the special group and get attention and be relevant. A white man who is middle aged is pretty boring.

Its a way for them to divorce themselves from white male privilege and say they aren't part of the oppressing group, they are the world's most victimized group of people who ever existed. Even though the majority of them act with male entitlement, and expect to be catered to and to have their wife turn herself into a lesbian just for him.

I'm not saying trans people aren't oppressed but I think the AGP types, the white middle aged husbands and fathers are an entirely different group. And they are oppressed but I think in a way that's part of the appeal.

Edited

Thanks for posting. What you say definitely resonates with my experience as a mother of a white, middle aged, transwoman.

MyKindLimeCrow · 04/07/2025 02:27

TheAngryLioness · 03/07/2025 20:28

Thank you for your kind words xx I am sorry you had to go through this too and to find out that he was taking hormones!! I cannot see him in any feminine way so i doubt we will ever remain friends. I will have to be civil to him for my children. I lived my life in Mills and Boons world as a teenager and always wanted a man in my life 💔 We have 2 beautifiul children. They dont know yet but he says the children will be fine knowing that he is trans and it wouldnt affect them. I am dreading for their mental health as it is going to be a double heartache for them knowing that we are seperating and their Dad doesn't feel like Dad anymore. Its all so weird and confusing for a child I think. 😕 Really I am weeping as I type and not ready for this change. 😪😪

Edited

Are you in therapy for yourself? I recommend it.

I'm so sorry you are going through this. People just have no idea the level of betrayal this is. There is so much shame and grief. Almost every woman I know in this situation thought about unaliving herself or attempted. And that's why I wanted to recommend therapy and getting as much support as you can.

Do you have family and friends you can rely on?

Kids are unpredictable. Some are just fine with the change and some are upset by it. Some turn out to be lgbtq themselves so that adds another layer of complexity to all of it.

MyKindLimeCrow · 04/07/2025 02:20

TheAngryLioness · 03/07/2025 21:14

@MykindLimeCrow I am.so sorry to read your experience. I dont understand what goes on in theory head that they think it will give them.more happiness than being with their lively family and home they have built. Does this Dysphoria so bad that you cannot make a rational decision? He said that trans are so marginalised why would he choose to embrace it. Says he can't help it and it is killing him not to be expressing himself as a woman 🤷‍♀️

I have no idea. It seems like an addiction in the way they live it out. Risking everything for a fetish is bizarre. I do believe that it becomes a part of their identity and that they want everyone to know that they too are part of an oppressed group.

Also almost all of these late lifers think that they are ugly men. Hardly any of them are. But men hardly ever get sexual attention. Its absolutely nothing compared to the attention that a man in a dress gets from other TIMs and men who like them and want a man with breasts and a penis.

The most searched for thing in porn is a man with a penis and breasts. The amount of attention they can get in gay bars and online just feeds their ego and the fetish. My ex got so much attention in gay bars. He was treated like a celebrity sometimes and people wanted to take their photo with him.

The other thing is if you look around there are almost no married father late lifers who aren't white. I think they want to be a part of the special group and get attention and be relevant. A white man who is middle aged is pretty boring.

Its a way for them to divorce themselves from white male privilege and say they aren't part of the oppressing group, they are the world's most victimized group of people who ever existed. Even though the majority of them act with male entitlement, and expect to be catered to and to have their wife turn herself into a lesbian just for him.

I'm not saying trans people aren't oppressed but I think the AGP types, the white middle aged husbands and fathers are an entirely different group. And they are oppressed but I think in a way that's part of the appeal.

BeeSouriante · 04/07/2025 01:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheAngryLioness · 03/07/2025 23:57

Damaya · 05/09/2023 14:45

Just saying hi. I’m in the US and was invited here after reaching out to the trans widows page. I found them on YouTube was interested in more support. I’m really needing support as I feel so alone and silenced.

I finalized my divorce with my ex husband this year after he came out as male to female transgender. This was my partner of 22 years and a 15 year marriage. He was my high school sweetheart and I came from a very traumatic childhood and we moved out together. Now at 40 I am starting over and I can’t trust my judgement in men. I can’t get a fresh start from him because we share a child together and my state being very liberal has deemed it in my (special needs) child’s best interest to have equal time with “Dad”. My sons Daddy chose to come to his elementary school dressed as a “sexy witch” for Halloween last year. That is what my state thinks is in my child’s best interest. My son has autism and can’t even totally pick up on the looks from others but I can.

Because I make more money I pay child support to my ex husband even though he has full time employment because my state feels I should supplement “her” income. They don’t consider I am disabled, did not instigate the change that shattered our lives or the costs that I have to pay for my and my child’s therapy to try to recover from this change and the ongoing psychological damage. We are struggling!

I don’t know I can ever fully recover but I am feeling some positive energy reading others stories. I can never feel like I have a voice. No one wants to hear how this impacts families and ruins lives. They only care about my spouse who was a shitty abusive alcoholic husband even during the marriage! At one point his online purchases had the DEA come to our home. He put holes in our walls during his rages and damaged our property to frighten me.

We went to a marriage therapist (I think of him as a terror-pist now) when he first came out who told me I was a lesbian because I had fallen in love with my husband and my husband had always been a woman and just didn’t fully acknowledge it! I’ve heard this a few times now from others and it is just so wild to me! This was my marriage ending moment. I knew I wasn’t a lesbian (nothing against lesbians but I’m not one and this man wasn’t going to tell me I was).

Hope you are ok xxx

TheAngryLioness · 03/07/2025 21:14

@MykindLimeCrow I am.so sorry to read your experience. I dont understand what goes on in theory head that they think it will give them.more happiness than being with their lively family and home they have built. Does this Dysphoria so bad that you cannot make a rational decision? He said that trans are so marginalised why would he choose to embrace it. Says he can't help it and it is killing him not to be expressing himself as a woman 🤷‍♀️

Delphinium20 · 03/07/2025 20:52

I'm so sorry. Just wanted to come here and say that. I believe you'll find light at the end of the tunnel, but going through it sounds tough. Best of luck to you! You're far better off w/out him in the long run. I'm sorry for your children, too.

TheAngryLioness · 03/07/2025 20:28

Tygadlas · 03/07/2025 19:18

Dear Angry Lioness, I want to congratulate you on finding us and deciding after six months that separation is best for you.
Would you read some advice? Do not be tempted to take any responsibility for where your husband is now. He is well supported by a website showing him his every move and what to say to you should you pass any comment deemed negative by his community. He is also urged to separate from anyone not fully supporting him.
I was shocked by my partner's teenage legs! By the time I caught up he was two years in on hormones.
Why should you turn yourself inside out to 'understand'? You may remain friendly but you have a life as a straight woman. Do you share children?

Thank you for your kind words xx I am sorry you had to go through this too and to find out that he was taking hormones!! I cannot see him in any feminine way so i doubt we will ever remain friends. I will have to be civil to him for my children. I lived my life in Mills and Boons world as a teenager and always wanted a man in my life 💔 We have 2 beautifiul children. They dont know yet but he says the children will be fine knowing that he is trans and it wouldnt affect them. I am dreading for their mental health as it is going to be a double heartache for them knowing that we are seperating and their Dad doesn't feel like Dad anymore. Its all so weird and confusing for a child I think. 😕 Really I am weeping as I type and not ready for this change. 😪😪

Tygadlas · 03/07/2025 19:18

Dear Angry Lioness, I want to congratulate you on finding us and deciding after six months that separation is best for you.
Would you read some advice? Do not be tempted to take any responsibility for where your husband is now. He is well supported by a website showing him his every move and what to say to you should you pass any comment deemed negative by his community. He is also urged to separate from anyone not fully supporting him.
I was shocked by my partner's teenage legs! By the time I caught up he was two years in on hormones.
Why should you turn yourself inside out to 'understand'? You may remain friendly but you have a life as a straight woman. Do you share children?

TinselAngel · 03/07/2025 18:30

TheAngryLioness · 03/07/2025 12:44

I feel guilty for not supporting him and want so much for things to go back like they were. Its moved so quickly its unbelievable. From coming out (finding out!) to he wanting to put makeup on and long hair with long nails etc. He is a clever person and has never shown any kind of such fetish behaviour in our relationship ever. So I am stumpped at all this. He is going through lot of guilt and shame but at the same time cannot stop himself to dress and present himself as a woman going forward. I can see our breakdown of relationship is troubling him immensely too and not something he wants either. So just torn between all this 💔 😞 😪

You honestly have nothing to feel guilty about. It’s absolutely fine to put yourself first.

OP posts:
MyKindLimeCrow · 03/07/2025 14:49

TinselAngel · 02/07/2025 23:25

In our film I talk about how we’re criticised for “not loving the real them” when it’s hardly our fault that they got us to fall I love with a different version of themselves.

They create an entirely false version of themselves to get us to love them. That's what narcs do. I so agree with this.

And a lot of people say they are the same person after transition. But then say that taking female hormones changes the way they think and feel. So which is it?

One of my friends ex wrote on his X feed that he used to tell everyone that he was going to be the same person after transition but that he lied and he feels like a totally different person. He put up laughing emojis and had a bunch of his TIM friends commenting on how true and hilarious all of it is.

As for my ex, he was taking low doses of estrogen and T blockers behind my back. I didn't realize until 3 years after our divorce. We were in therapy and I was talking about how his libido had tanked and how he had all the signs of low testosterone and that I was worried for his health.

Our therapist suggested he get his Testosterone tested and his immediate response was "I don't want it to change my personality." We were both confused and asked what he was talking about and he said "testosterone replacement".

He also made several comments about that when we went to get the results of his test (I went with him because I knew he was being weird about it and I couldn't figure out what was going on.) When she told him, a 36 year old man, that he had the testosterone level of an 80 year old, he wasn't worried or surprised. He didn't ask what was wrong with him. All he said was "I don't want it to change my personal ity."

So clearly he thought these low doses of estrogen and testosterone blockers were changing his personality in some way. He kept the levels low enough that he still produced sem3n and he had minor breast development that looked like small moobs from being a bit over weight.

They know this changes them. That's why they do it.

TheAngryLioness · 03/07/2025 12:44

socialworker222 · 03/07/2025 07:25

The film is so moving and raw. It's exceptionally brave (a word heavily overused by the trans lobby) as are transwidows and their children.
Lioness there is often a timing issue too. This has been a recent bombshell for you, but for him it will be progress on a very long-term Project Me. My ex was coldly unsympathetic to my distress and that of his children, partly because he was a self-absorbed person prior to this, but also because he had planned, networked and led a secret life for years before. It's the worst thing that happened in my life, but many here will testify that there is peace down the road for you.

I feel guilty for not supporting him and want so much for things to go back like they were. Its moved so quickly its unbelievable. From coming out (finding out!) to he wanting to put makeup on and long hair with long nails etc. He is a clever person and has never shown any kind of such fetish behaviour in our relationship ever. So I am stumpped at all this. He is going through lot of guilt and shame but at the same time cannot stop himself to dress and present himself as a woman going forward. I can see our breakdown of relationship is troubling him immensely too and not something he wants either. So just torn between all this 💔 😞 😪

socialworker222 · 03/07/2025 07:25

The film is so moving and raw. It's exceptionally brave (a word heavily overused by the trans lobby) as are transwidows and their children.
Lioness there is often a timing issue too. This has been a recent bombshell for you, but for him it will be progress on a very long-term Project Me. My ex was coldly unsympathetic to my distress and that of his children, partly because he was a self-absorbed person prior to this, but also because he had planned, networked and led a secret life for years before. It's the worst thing that happened in my life, but many here will testify that there is peace down the road for you.