Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Surrogacy in Ukraine - Times article

166 replies

Soontobe60 · 20/02/2022 09:20

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/surrogate-mothers-fear-pressure-to-flee-ukraine-gsntx9z7f?shareToken=39849d90d0863ecb43166b4738993526
So it would seem that in Ukraine, they admit that surrogacy is big business that will suffer economically if Russia invades. And the poor foreign clients will want the surrogates to move out of the country if it happens - despite them having their own families! Talk about exploitation!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
FannyCann · 25/02/2022 22:22

Exactly @Soontobe60

Soontobe60 · 25/02/2022 22:13

When I posted the link originally, I didn’t even consider how worse it could get, and now the reality is here. The comments of those people who have contracted women in Ukraine to incubate their babies are beyond awful.
It’s almost as if the mothers are not seen as being human beings - they’re just equipment that has to be kept safe in order to do a good job.
Human trafficking in full view of the world.

OP posts:
KimikosNightmare · 25/02/2022 22:01

@YetAnotherSpartacus

I'd love one of the surrogacy apologists to come and tell us how the this is all going to be ok, no harm done

Exactly.

Hope you're not holding your breath.
Syeknom · 25/02/2022 21:59

☹️

HermioneWeasley · 25/02/2022 21:58

$90k

I wonder how much the woman risking her life, and life changing birth injuries gets from that?

It makes me sick. Women’s bodies are not a workplace. This is human trafficking

FannyCann · 25/02/2022 21:44

"We put in two embryos, and she lost one."

"This is our fourth surrogate."

"So, I don't really know anything except her husband and son moved with her. And that they were not happy to move. They did not want to leave."

How much more does anyone want to know about commercial surrogacy? I just can't say all the things I think when I read those statements. It's modern day slavery.

FannyCann · 25/02/2022 21:38

This is second part of a two-part post about what it's like to be an intended parent doing surrogacy in Ukraine right now.
3 minute read
Your surrogate is in Lviv.
Correct. And we have been told that there is zero fighting in Lviv, there is tons of food, and everything is — I don't want to use the word normal — but everything is normal over in Lviv.
Okay, good. And can you remind me of your due date?
She's eight weeks now, so end of October, beginning of November. She had some complications early on with the pregnancy. We put in two embryos, and she lost one. And now there's just one baby.
You have been concerned about your last remaining frozen embryo too. Has it been moved to safety?
Yes. We got confirmation yesterday that the embryo and my husband's remaining sperm was shipped to Lviv and it arrived safely. I actually kind of freaked out, because originally they said that if you move your embryos and biomaterials to Lviv, you would not have access to it — they would lock it down and you wouldn't be able to use it for six months, seven months, eight months, whenever they open it. So I kind of freaked out because, you know, God forbid this doesn't work, we need access to our embryo. But that rule has changed. We can access it. It's not going into lockdown.
There was some question about the price for moving that material.
We did not have to pay for it. They moved all of the embryos and biomaterial to safety at no charge to the intended parents.
How and when did you learn out about the invasion?
On CNN, MSNBC. My parents called me yesterday morning. My dad's like, 'Turn the news on.'
What were you thinking when you heard?
I was panicking. I was worried. I've developed some friendships that I think are going to last a lifetime.
Do you know anything about your surrogate's family situation? Is her family safe?
The only thing I know is that her husband and child are with her in Lviv. This is our fourth surrogate. My husband and I decided that we did not want to meet the surrogate until she passed the three month mark, because it's too hard. We got so attached to the second surrogate, and then it didn't work out. So, I don't really know anything except her husband and son moved with her. And that they were not happy to move. They did not want to leave.
And how do they feel now? Are they glad they did? Do you know?
I don't know.
So what are the things on your mind right now?
I'm worried about, you know, if and when the city of Kyiv falls, what's next? You know, are the Russians going to continue to move throughout the country? And how safe is Lviv? When is there going to be bombing, when is it going to be unsafe to stay in Lviv? What are the contingency plans when Lviv becomes unsafe?
And what are you hearing?
That they'll move them to another safe town. That's great. But what happens when Ukraine is not safe anymore? They said it depends on the point in pregnancy of the surrogate. I would assume a surrogate who was seven months, eight months, nine months, about to give birth, is more immediate than someone who's only three months or four months. That's my interpretation, but I don't know.
Final thoughts?
Selfishly, I'm really concerned about my surrogate and my baby. But, you know, I'm also thinking about the woman in the clinic, who I saw every day for 17 days, when I went to Kyiv for IVF. She administered my shots. Where is she? Where is her family?

myyellowcar · 25/02/2022 21:30

What could possibly go wrong when you start buying and selling human beings across the globe.

This shows how inhumane surrogacy is, buying a baby is not engineering some philanthropic great gift. At the end of the day the buyers want their baby and they don’t really care about much else. Apparently they don’t even care about their actual baby enough to think about how traumatic it is for them to be removed from the only comfort they've ever known at days old.

NotMeekNotObedient · 25/02/2022 21:18

Absolutely sick.

The poor mothers and babies, exploited and purchased.

FannyCann · 25/02/2022 21:16

There are definitely problems associated with moving surrogate mothers to other jurisdictions @OchonAgusOchonOh

Ukraine borders with several countries, I was looking at a map today and hadn't realised how many countries share maybe just a short stretch of border with Ukraine and there will be different laws relating to surrogacy depending where they go.
I have seen reports of surrogate mothers being required to tell big lies about their circumstances and the parentage of the baby they are carrying in some other countries they end up giving birth in.

The truth is McMafia is much involved with many of the agencies there and they will find a way to sidestep the law wherever they are. It's called people trafficking.

FannyCann · 25/02/2022 21:11

Doesn't sound as if the well being of the surrogate mothers is the priority from this article.

www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jun/15/the-stranded-babies-of-kyiv-and-the-women-who-give-birth-for-money

OchonAgusOchonOh · 25/02/2022 20:52

@Soontobe60

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/surrogate-mothers-fear-pressure-to-flee-ukraine-gsntx9z7f?shareToken=39849d90d0863ecb43166b4738993526 So it would seem that in Ukraine, they admit that surrogacy is big business that will suffer economically if Russia invades. And the poor foreign clients will want the surrogates to move out of the country if it happens - despite them having their own families! Talk about exploitation!!
I read somewhere that the won't move the women out of the Ukraine despite the danger as if the babies are born in a country with different laws, the contract won't hold up and the birth mother would be classed as the mother legally.
FannyCann · 25/02/2022 20:45

And then the self justification:

"To get to the spot where you need to use surrogacy — that in itself means that you've been through a lot. This is not anybody's first choice. In our case, this has been four years and many miscarriages and finding out ultimately that I couldn't carry."

And I find this VERY hard to believe.

"In Ukraine, I think because of the culture and the people, I think there's a level of commitment to making sure that the surrogates are taken care of. I can't speak for anybody else, I don't know what anyone else's experiences are like, but there's a huge focus on my surrogate's health, and how she feels about treatments."

Maybe they are with a very good ethical agency. Maybe.
But I've read plenty of articles that suggest the opposite. Such that I feel a tiny - teeny tiny - modicum of sympathy for commissioning parents too as these agencies are all about the profit and are not remotely interested in protecting the interests of commissioning parents. They are just a source of income.

It's a while since I've watched it but the YouTube documentary about poor little baby Bridget also featured British parents who had been appalled by the lack of care for their sickly baby after it had been born.

Babyvenusplant · 25/02/2022 20:43

[quote Slothtoes]I feel so frightened for everyone in Ukraine, what an absolutely terrifying situation. And the impossible situation for women and couples involved in surrogacy there.

In Covid ‘stranded’ babies were left to cry alone in rows of cots in Ukraine hotel rooms, with one supervising adult to feed them, awaiting collection by international parents who weren’t allowed to into the country. This is a video report about it which should come with a trigger warning.
BBC News Coronavirus: Surrogate babies stranded in Ukraine
www.bbc.com/news/av/world-europe-52673225[/quote]
Made me cry, those poor babies

FannyCann · 25/02/2022 20:37

"How much input did you have into the decision to move her? And did you talk to her about it?
We talk almost daily, via text. And yes, we were very involved in the decision to have her moved. But our agency was one of the very first ones that moved anybody. At the time, it was sort of thought that they're just being very cautious. But ultimately we did have a say. And she was also, of course, consulted. I mean, it's her body and her person, and she should be consulted on all decisions, and be okay with them."

The level of ownership and entitlement is off the scale - "We were very involved in the decision to have her moved"

and yet they clearly think they are so reasonable: "she was also, of course, consulted. I mean, it's her body and her person, and she should be consulted on all decisions, and be okay with them."
That's big of them.

FannyCann · 25/02/2022 20:31

Part One, below, is a Q&A with a Canadian whose child is due in April. I spoke to her last night.

Your baby will be born soon.
End of April.
When you first did the embryo transfer, and were thinking about the birth, what did you envision?
Our surrogate was going to give birth in Kyiv. There's a maternity hospital there. We would fly in about two weeks prior and be, if not present, present shortly thereafter. And then we'd go through the process of bringing him home.
And as things started to heat up in the last couple of weeks, how did the plan evolve?
So she is in Lviv now. I think there were two concerns. Number one was that she was going to a place that had good medical care. But also a place that was considered to be safe in terms of what we were hearing about possible invasion.
How much input did you have into the decision to move her? And did you talk to her about it?
We talk almost daily, via text. And yes, we were very involved in the decision to have her moved. But our agency was one of the very first ones that moved anybody. At the time, it was sort of thought that they're just being very cautious. But ultimately we did have a say. And she was also, of course, consulted. I mean, it's her body and her person, and she should be consulted on all decisions, and be okay with them.
And how did she feel about the idea of moving?
To be honest, she wasn't very happy about it. I think a lot of Ukrainians at the time were not convinced that this was a real threat. And, you know, she's got family, and I think there was a concern about her going to Lviv. In her particular case, it puts her even farther away from her family. It wasn't that she was saying no, it was just that she needed to understand why the move was taking place.
Did she end up bringing her family with her?
I don't know if she doesn't want them to come or if they physically can't come — it was lost in translation. We obviously said if she wants them to be with her, we would cover all costs related with that, and support her in whatever way needed.
And now there has been an invasion. What is the plan now?
I don't think that there is a plan. I think there are a number of different plans. It literally, I think, will be a day-by-day thing.
So sometime towards the end of April you're going over.
We're going somewhere. I don't know where that will be. I think there's a number of different options. Poland is one. Moldova is another. It'll be dependent on where she gives birth, first of all, and then, what the process is to get into the country and bring our son home.
Is there any discussion right now of taking your surrogate outside of the country?
Yes, but that's still under review right now. It's going to depend on her safety ultimately, and also what she's comfortable with. I mean, you have to have a certain level of trust in your surrogate to be able to make the right decision for herself and for our son. And in our particular case, I do trust her.
How was she today [Thursday, 24 Feb]?
She was calm, actually. She's trying to not watch the news. She reiterated that it's her responsibility to take care of our son and keep him safe. That's what she's trying to focus on. As well as, you know, interacting with her family and making sure that they're safe.
Was today worse than previous days? Or has it been bad the whole time?
Today was worse. This is the only bad day I've had, if I'm being honest. A lot of people did not think that this was actually a possibility, especially to this extent. And so definitely today was by far the worst day.
It's frightening. As humans, we'd like certainty. With the IVF process, for anybody that's been through it, the one thing you don't have is certainty. And so the anxiety is familiar, but it's coming from a place that you don't expect.
What do you want people to know about international surrogacy, and about surrogacy in Ukraine in particular?
To get to the spot where you need to use surrogacy — that in itself means that you've been through a lot. This is not anybody's first choice. In our case, this has been four years and many miscarriages and finding out ultimately that I couldn't carry.
We looked at surrogacy in Canada, we looked at surrogacy in the US. And to be honest, we didn't have good experiences. International surrogacy has given us the possibility to have a family, which is something that at one point I didn't think we would be able to have.
In Ukraine, I think because of the culture and the people, I think there's a level of commitment to making sure that the surrogates are taken care of. I can't speak for anybody else, I don't know what anyone else's experiences are like, but there's a huge focus on my surrogate's health, and how she feels about treatments. And we did not get that level of care in North America. And I wish that people knew that, you know, it's not just a baby making machine, this is a place that offers people hope that don't have it.
The reality is she will be a member of our family for the rest of our lives. Our son will know who she is, and hopefully, will get to meet her when he's older.

FannyCann · 25/02/2022 20:29

I'm not sure if this link will work as it's a paid for subscription.
Update interview with Canadian baby buyers commissioning parents.

https://ukrainesurrogacydispatches.substack.com/p/two-days-after-the-invasion-intended-fbb?r=3qvki&utmcampaign=post&utmm_medium=email

Slothtoes · 25/02/2022 07:49

Will the Ukrainian women still get paid whatever happens? Absolutely crucial to them. Moving countries till the baby is born and then trying to come back to Ukraine isn't going to be safe or realistic. It’s unbelievably awful whichever way you look at it. All that’s obviously just in one small subset of Ukrainian society at the moment. Sad

Slothtoes · 25/02/2022 07:49

Now Russia has actually invaded, there must be UK people who will never be able to get to Ukraine to collect a surrogate-born baby that’s already born, or which a Ukrainian woman is currently pregnant with. Or it could be a few years until they can get there to collect the baby, which by then is not surrogacy, it’s presumably a whole other process? Someone will have to be the baby’s parent in Ukraine. What happens to the woman while all this is worked out? How can she have a safe birth, in hospital if needed? What happens to bringing up the baby afterwards? What happens if she wants an abortion or if the UK parents want her to because they can’t collect the baby? What if the woman doesn’t want to do that, because she can’t leave her home safely or doesn’t want to leave her kids, or you know, she just doesn’t want to?

Abortion and safe aftercare will be one of the first services to stop in a war- hospital staff and other people are either fleeing to any safety they can find, or are too terrified to leave their homes and the hospitals will be focusing on casualties and the mortuary.

Weatherwax13 · 25/02/2022 07:24

I read an article about this yesterday (I'm currently in Oz)
There was absolutely zero mention of the women carrying these babies.
Or what was proposed for the babies after birth (or where the ones already born are?)
I am sure the Australian purchasers parents are worried sick about the babies as stated in The Age.
But those poor women and babies. Normally I research these things further as I'm hugely concerned about all aspects of surrogacy.
But this time I feel too helpless and scared to look into it any further.

Slothtoes · 25/02/2022 07:12

I feel so frightened for everyone in Ukraine, what an absolutely terrifying situation. And the impossible situation for women and couples involved in surrogacy there.

In Covid ‘stranded’ babies were left to cry alone in rows of cots in Ukraine hotel rooms, with one supervising adult to feed them, awaiting collection by international parents who weren’t allowed to into the country. This is a video report about it which should come with a trigger warning.
BBC News Coronavirus: Surrogate babies stranded in Ukraine
www.bbc.com/news/av/world-europe-52673225

FannyCann · 24/02/2022 22:09

That Instagram post is sickening @OhHolyJesus

It would make me laugh if it didn't make me cry - people who wouldn't dream of eating a battery farmed egg, who agonise over factory workers paid slave wages for companies like Nike no Adidas, but they think nothing of renting a womb without a care for the woman going through pregnancy and childbirth before giving up the baby she has carried.

Delphinium20 · 24/02/2022 21:45

@OhHolyJesus What will the commissioning parents do to protect the welfare of the 'local surrogates' once they have the baby they paid for and are running for safety themselves? Luckily for them they have a safe country to return to. Will they take her with them? Will they take her other kids too?

Fast forward 20 years and a savvy young person is studying history and sees their birth coincided with the Russian invasion. How will parents answer these questions to their adult children?

OhHolyJesus · 24/02/2022 21:19

I thought the same @Delphinium20.

What will the commissioning parents do to protect the welfare of the 'local surrogates' once they have the baby they paid for and are running for safety themselves? Luckily for them they have a safe country to return to. Will they take her with them? Will they take her other kids too?

I agree @EsmaCannonball it will be weaponised as an argument to keep surrogacy on U.K. soil and as you say the cost of living is going up so we can anticipate women being more drawn to surrogacy.

(That would work for the surrogacy agencies, like the one TwoDads run, as they need 'breeding stock' to be 'matched'.)

Delphinium20 · 24/02/2022 20:53

There's something really wrong about fast retrieval of your commissioned baby while its birth mother is left behind in a country under siege.