Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

2001 channel 4 documentary on porn

533 replies

darleneconnor · 04/04/2011 13:00

hcdocu.blogspot.com/

The best anti-porn evidence I've seen.

(Please watch with caution, some scenes are upsetting)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SueSylvesterforPM · 01/05/2011 09:30

porn does have some relevance as more and more foreign stuff is creeping in.

SueSylvesterforPM · 01/05/2011 09:29

random fact for any doubters

thanks to sexual exploitation /trafficking
there are more slaves in the world TODAY than at the height of the slave trade.

cloudyweather · 30/04/2011 21:24

sorry-i havent seen all of the thread [im trying to catch up]
does anyone mind if i jump in here?
i watched this yesterday and i vomited-i still feel horrible today!
poor poor women!
i hope that this has changed peoples mind about porno-its not a fun thing!
everytime people think porno is a good thing and watch it/buy it-its like saying its ok for women to be abused.
the porno "indistry"is the same as the prostitution "indistry"-they both equel abuse!
as you can see-the "men"arent even there for the sex-they have to be given a hard on even before they start-its all about money and degrading the women!
the bit that they didnt mention was-if a woman gets a period-
she is ordered to shove a bit of sponge right up inside her--itdont matter if this cause infection-or kills her-just dont show anyone youre a woman-the great unclean!
oh and whoe betide that when shes getting raped-sorry i mean shagged-
the sponge dropps-or blood comes through-or the "man" notices-
shes in for a whack!if the "man"that rapes her dont give her a whack-the "man"that owns her will!
the "men"hold the women in so low regard-that they are audashious enough to think the women are thick-"come on babe-i love you-and if you loved me you would do this for me"[thats when they aint whacking the women or drugging them up]-the women are not thick-just trapped!
as for the deranged fucker in the film that was getting stroppy and nasty cos the woman got upset-my god-my god-i would love to spend five minutes with him!!!
the astounding thing is-women being abused like this is bigger now than its ever been[i feel]Sad

sakura · 29/04/2011 09:36

Claig, I'm a socialist as you know, but I'd vote for Sarah Palin. SHe'd got to be better than the other muppets they've had for the past 50 years or so.

sakura · 29/04/2011 09:35

God is Andre the #$@% still around.

I've just watched that video. Steven Walker is a sound bloke, a man of integrity.

Max Hardcore is in jail but I'll be popping the champagne corks when he's dead, and I won't be the only woman. That will be his legacy.

claig · 11/04/2011 20:47

If Sarah Palin becomes President, I think more laws against obscenity will be created, and more Max Hardcores will find themselves in jail.

claig · 11/04/2011 20:44

If Sarah Palin becomes President of the United States, she may well roll back some of these liberal, progressive policies that led to this proliferation.

FuppyGish · 11/04/2011 20:44

This is sort of connected but not quite sure how - I watched Paranormal Activity a while back and kept thinking how lovely and real looking the main woman was. A very attractive lady but 'normal' if that makes sense. I looked at the forums on imdb afterwards and there were 100s of threads all of them from men (i assume from the usernames, could be wrong) saying how fat and disgusting this actress was. Really highlighted what we now expect to see on screen in terms of thinness and perfection. Was depressing.

As for horrors, I find horrors from the 1970s/80s terrifying and recently identified that its because the people in them, men and women, are normal. So normal breasts, all shapes and sizes, normal arms/legs cellullite lumps and bumps, whereas todays actresses (especially) are all size 4 with round breasts and are utterly 'perfect'. Noticed it most in the original Friday 13th and then the very poor remake.

No idea where Im going with this, but all these 'beautiful' women make me very ashamed of my size 14 droopy chested body Sad

claig · 11/04/2011 20:34

I think it has spread due to our permissive society, which was encouraged by the progressives and liberals. Mary Whitehouse knew what would happen and fought against it. George Bush and the Christian right were against it, the Church is against it, so I don't think it is about men trying to stop women advancing.

It is a deliberate policy by certain elements to undermine society, as Mary Whitehouse was aware. It is the same as the extreme horror films which now proliferate and the glamourisation of drugs, violence and prostitution that we see on our TVs, in music videos and Hollywood movies.

sethstarkaddersmackerel · 11/04/2011 20:22

'Or because as women are getting better jobs/more equality (more than before) this is a way for men to regain control and 'fight back'?'

I think that one sounds likely but it would be hard for anyone to prove.

'Is it because its now available? So men would always have wanted it but wasn't available before?'

I hope not - it would be such a depressing view of men. I think with sex, people are conditioned to want particular things, and they want this stuff because they've been taught to want it, not because that is the way their sexuality will inevitably be. But the general view of women in the patriarchy makes it a logical step: if men are taught to hate women they will be more likely to want to express that through violent porn.

sethstarkaddersmackerel · 11/04/2011 20:19

I think Dines puts it down to desensitisation and internet sites competing with each other, so it's like an arms race as to which one can be the most outrageous and thus get the most attention and hence the most hits.

FuppyGish · 11/04/2011 20:16

SGM - Thank you, will go have a look.

Beachcomber · 11/04/2011 20:10

You said it K999 - porn is filmed prostitution.

And prostitution is pay to rape.

Therefore porn is filmed pay to rape.

The purpose of porn is to wank to pay to rape images. (One purpose -there are others which are even more sinister.)

And that this is legal, in so called civilised society, is a human rights travesty and a fairly obvious manifestation of the oppression of women. Welcome to the sex class - it's not a nice feeling is it?

K999 · 11/04/2011 20:02

I have never really given any great deal of thought to porn before this thread. However it has really opened my mind and I have learned a lot. Especially the stuff about the women who are usually victims of rape, childhood sexual abuse, drug addiction etc. I have always been against prostitution and now it seems that porn is just prostitution being filmed and then viewed....Shock

StewieGriffinsMom · 11/04/2011 19:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

StewieGriffinsMom · 11/04/2011 19:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

FuppyGish · 11/04/2011 19:47

Has anyone got any research on why this sort of gross porn (not that its not all gross) is getting more and more popular/prevalent?

Is it because its now available? So men would always have wanted it but wasn't available before?

Or because once you've seen more extreme porn you get desensitised and therefore want more and more 'nasty' stuff? Like with horror films.

Or because as women are getting better jobs/more equality (more than before) this is a way for men to regain control and 'fight back'?

Might be a feminism 101 question, apologies if it is, it just struck me as strange that theres a call for this nasty crap.

ThatVikRinA22 · 11/04/2011 19:12

mumble - i dont think your understanding perhaps the type of porn Max Hardcore makes

im sorry to repeat this but in some of his films he has used a speculum to open a womans anus to the most extreme level before urinating inside her and having her then suck it back out with a length of hose - i think thats abuse and i think that is real, its not acting, being beaten is real, watching him force his fingers down a girls throat to make her vomit is real, its not acted - google him and if you can watch some of the vidoes on the web that are made by him and still say its all acted out and not remotely abusive then i think you may have a problem. Felicity in that film ran screaming and crying from the room after he had choked her and stopped her breathing. she told him she felt abused. she said she didnt want to carry on - and he then coerced and cajoled and bullied and swore at her until she was ready to carry on.
some porn, is acting. its what i used to think porn was, old school, plumber comes to fix tap and fucks someone over a kitchen table. the type of porn Hardcore makes is not remotely like this - he wants to abuse young woman on film because some people get off on it. he is a very very sick man. im shocked that anyone could watch the documentary linked from OP in full and not be shocked.
have you watched the whole thing?

mumblecrumble · 11/04/2011 19:02

Its really not a stupid question.

People filming adults having sex with children is illegal, films showing adults having sex with adults dressed up as school girls isn;t.

Obviously somebody film an adult having sex with a dead person is illegal, but I asked if it was illegal if the dead person was actually alive and acting.

Now, if that is clear and you still want to mock me being interested in somthing and not having all the answers feel free. Not really in the spirit of mumsnet that.

Also beach, I didnlt suggest the penatration wasn;t real but the sadism - i.e. when she was being slapped and called names after signing a form that said this was OK.

I;m not suggesting that all porn is free from abuse but stillf eel I;m being incredibly misunderstood.

Chorus all you like. I really really do know what chorus means. Beachcomber, do you think your attidutude on this thread encourages thinking about it? Or just calls them stupid? Unfit to teach? Bad parent etc...

Beachcomber · 11/04/2011 18:53

Is this where we get to chorus 'but porn is real' again?

Thanks for your comment mumble, I think you have a lot of thinking to do on this issue - as we all do when we start out confronting the realities of porn (that those are real women who really are being penetrated like that).

mydaddrivesarustycar · 11/04/2011 18:50

Very late to the thread but watched the documentary last night and found it really disturbing.

Max Hardcore looks like the fucking devil when he is raping that woman. Absolutely shocking and disturbing.

StewieGriffinsMom · 11/04/2011 18:44

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

K999 · 11/04/2011 18:41

I think I am correct Mumble to say that necrophelia and bestiality are illegal!!

mumblecrumble · 11/04/2011 18:36

Stewie.

I was not being stupid - you misunderstood, made an asumption then were very agressive and rude.

I asked if porn showing beastiality and necro were illegal. Did you assume I meant some kind of documentary where everything was real, where boobs are made of flesh and where the man in the plumbers uniform really does fix the tap?!?!?!!?

Beachcomber - I think what you said was really interested and what i hoped to hear/learn from on this thread. So you think i was wrong in suggesting she was driven by money and that she feared that chap [I use chap generally for 'male' so please don;t misunderstand and I think I am trivialising this].

dirgeinvegas · 11/04/2011 09:17

That's exactly what I thought Fuppy, what does he do to the women he sees who don't have documentary film crew following them?

I have had nightmares since watching this documentary. I cannot believe some of the dismissive/she-knew-what-she-was-getting-into posts.