Please or to access all these features

The royal family
Thread gallery
18
Skyseek · 13/11/2026 12:50

BigWillyLittleTodger · 13/11/2026 12:42

It’s a worry isn’t it? All this stumbling, normally when they are chopping carrots is the usual MO, it’s becoming a health and safety issue.

Ah an attempt at wit rather than engagement with the facts. What more did I expect?

Circumspection · 13/11/2026 12:55

smilesy · 13/11/2026 12:46

No the Lemon Moose is most definitely not new here. They are a founder of several threads and an expert on all things constitutional, medical and Commonwealth. Allegedly 😎

eta hence the yada yada yada

Edited

More than a few actually.

bongowrongosruffledplumage · 13/11/2026 13:00

“ However the inherent value of the picture does not justify the level of exposure and praise. This comes only because a royal is involved.”

George's Kingfisher
BananaPeels · 13/11/2026 13:03

Skyseek · 13/11/2026 12:31

@BeLemonMoose i think you are new here. Did you stumble in like me, led on by a trending thread? I’ve had my knuckles rapped already for being a bit of a bore and even having the audacity to comment. I think we need to leave them to it. You may as well bark at the moon. ‘Yada yada’ kind of tells you all you need to know.

if anyone is interested, this is the second time there’s been a ‘copy’ of artwork put out by this branch of the royal family without crediting the source material. Both artists tugged their forelock in public at the ‘honour’ of having their work copied. Not sure what they said in private…

In terms of facts, it’s 99.9% certain this is work from Tutorial link Access is payable, the composition is broken down to four stages and the final result is dependent on using the specific paper and type of pencils - you’re not producing this with dried up felt tips on the back of a cereal pack. Is it a good outcome from a tutorial of this type? Yes of course. But the context is key. It’s a great job following a tutorial. However the inherent value of the picture does not justify the level of exposure and praise. This comes only because a royal is involved. It’s indicative not just of privilege but of vanity and a lack of regard for the creators of the original work.

you do appreciate you are talking about it and giving exposure? You don’t have to comment on it.

my kids play instruments. They play other people’s tunes after being given step by step instructions. Are you saying they are untalented because they can’t just pick up the instrument and play by themselves and they don’t compose their own music?

Skyseek · 13/11/2026 13:33

BananaPeels · 13/11/2026 13:03

you do appreciate you are talking about it and giving exposure? You don’t have to comment on it.

my kids play instruments. They play other people’s tunes after being given step by step instructions. Are you saying they are untalented because they can’t just pick up the instrument and play by themselves and they don’t compose their own music?

The music comparison is a false one. If you were playing in public (which is a fair comparison to publishing a piece of art in a magazine) there ARE rules on copyright that protect the creator. For example with musicals, schools apply for permission to perform and sometimes pay a fee. It would even be unusual to go to a kids concert and not see the name of the composition PLUS the composer included would it not?

CoffeeCantata · 13/11/2026 13:33

BemusedAmerican · 13/11/2026 11:35

My elementary school had us in weekly art classes from kindergarten through sixth grade and I still can't draw anything bother than stick figures.

Last year I went to a Wadruna concert. The lead singer talked about how important it is for everyone to sing, even if they aren't great at it, just for the joy of singing. That today people aren't encouraged in artistic endeavors just for enjoyment. He really made me think. He used to work with young children before Wadruna.

This is SO, SO important. Everyone has a voice and it’s free. Nearly everyone has access to paper and a pencil. The creative arts are absolutely crucial to a full, happy life and we should promote creativity for everyone. Although G is at Eton what he produced is not beyond the resources of most people.

BananaPeels · 13/11/2026 13:37

Skyseek · 13/11/2026 13:33

The music comparison is a false one. If you were playing in public (which is a fair comparison to publishing a piece of art in a magazine) there ARE rules on copyright that protect the creator. For example with musicals, schools apply for permission to perform and sometimes pay a fee. It would even be unusual to go to a kids concert and not see the name of the composition PLUS the composer included would it not?

no the comparison would be if george was filmed playing the piano and maybe played a bit of bohemian rhapsody and they uploaded a bit on the internet and just said, ‘here’s George playing the piano- we’re super proud’ and left it at that.

smilesy · 13/11/2026 13:38

Skyseek · 13/11/2026 13:33

The music comparison is a false one. If you were playing in public (which is a fair comparison to publishing a piece of art in a magazine) there ARE rules on copyright that protect the creator. For example with musicals, schools apply for permission to perform and sometimes pay a fee. It would even be unusual to go to a kids concert and not see the name of the composition PLUS the composer included would it not?

Part of the reason for my “yada”comment is that posters on another thread have already established that not only is this piece of art available via a tutorial, it is also available for free for anyone to copy (sorry, can’t remember he website but feel free to check the other thread). So this has been done already elsewhere and it has been established that no copyright infringements or forgeries have taken place 😊

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 13:55

BananaPeels · 13/11/2026 13:37

no the comparison would be if george was filmed playing the piano and maybe played a bit of bohemian rhapsody and they uploaded a bit on the internet and just said, ‘here’s George playing the piano- we’re super proud’ and left it at that.

Agreed. And then royal supporters started claiming this meant George was talented.

pilates · 13/11/2026 13:56

Skyseek · 13/11/2026 12:31

@BeLemonMoose i think you are new here. Did you stumble in like me, led on by a trending thread? I’ve had my knuckles rapped already for being a bit of a bore and even having the audacity to comment. I think we need to leave them to it. You may as well bark at the moon. ‘Yada yada’ kind of tells you all you need to know.

if anyone is interested, this is the second time there’s been a ‘copy’ of artwork put out by this branch of the royal family without crediting the source material. Both artists tugged their forelock in public at the ‘honour’ of having their work copied. Not sure what they said in private…

In terms of facts, it’s 99.9% certain this is work from Tutorial link Access is payable, the composition is broken down to four stages and the final result is dependent on using the specific paper and type of pencils - you’re not producing this with dried up felt tips on the back of a cereal pack. Is it a good outcome from a tutorial of this type? Yes of course. But the context is key. It’s a great job following a tutorial. However the inherent value of the picture does not justify the level of exposure and praise. This comes only because a royal is involved. It’s indicative not just of privilege but of vanity and a lack of regard for the creators of the original work.

Who cares? I would be proud if one of mine produced a piece of work like that.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 14:00

pilates · 13/11/2026 13:56

Who cares? I would be proud if one of mine produced a piece of work like that.

Of course. Parents are supposed to be proud. I am sure Catherine and William are proud.
But royal supporters should not be pretending this is a sign of talent.

Circumspection · 13/11/2026 14:02

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 13:55

Agreed. And then royal supporters started claiming this meant George was talented.

It is objectively excellent for an amateur.

smilesy · 13/11/2026 14:02

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 13:55

Agreed. And then royal supporters started claiming this meant George was talented.

He is talented. Just because he was potentially tutored in how to do this drawing, doesn’t mean that he would automatically have produced something so accomplished. That is how art lessons work. You get instruction and advice but what you produce will still depend on your skill
level. Again there are apparently actual art teachers who are saying this as per the other thread. But you carry on denigrating the work of a young boy for no apparent reason other than it makes you feel superior or something. I’m baffled as to any other reason you could have 😎

BigWillyLittleTodger · 13/11/2026 14:07

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 14:00

Of course. Parents are supposed to be proud. I am sure Catherine and William are proud.
But royal supporters should not be pretending this is a sign of talent.

I’m still waiting for your credentials as an art critic, particularly for 12 year old children.

CoffeeCantata · 13/11/2026 14:08

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 14:00

Of course. Parents are supposed to be proud. I am sure Catherine and William are proud.
But royal supporters should not be pretending this is a sign of talent.

Take it from me - it is.

I try to make art myself and I’ve seen lots of teenage art. This is really good for a 12 year old.

muminherts · 13/11/2026 14:10

Does the artistic value necessarily matter most? Isn’t it a sign that a child is painstaking, made an effort, cares and is interested in the subject? We have an increasingly polarised society and while I don’t personally think a monarchy is the ideal system ultimately, I do think the royal family as an institution is currently valuable for societal cohesion.

Skyseek · 13/11/2026 14:12

smilesy · 13/11/2026 13:38

Part of the reason for my “yada”comment is that posters on another thread have already established that not only is this piece of art available via a tutorial, it is also available for free for anyone to copy (sorry, can’t remember he website but feel free to check the other thread). So this has been done already elsewhere and it has been established that no copyright infringements or forgeries have taken place 😊

the ‘yada’ comment is asinine. I’m on this thread, not another. You seriously expect posters to search out other relevant threads, distil the contributions, then ensure that no repetition occurs in another place? Am I meant to mind-read the threads you have read or am I to look through the entire site?

No one mentioned forgery - that would be passing off George’s picture as that of the original artist when this is about quite the opposite. What happened here is more nuanced. Whether legal or not (and the artist, like the previous artist whose work was copied, has said they are not bothered), by not sharing the context and origins of the art, the ability of the child is inflated and the credit for the original artist and teaching content is not given. It exposes vanity, self aggrandisement, lack of consideration to the original artist, a failure to learn from the last time this happened… undesirable qualities and undesirable behaviours from those in positions of power and influence.

CoffeeAndACroissant · 13/11/2026 14:12

It's a lovely piece of art.

I could attend the same art class and copy the same picture and it would look like utter shite. Do you know why? Because I'm utterly crap at art. I have many talents, but art isn't one of them.

It still takes a lot of skill to come up with a picture like that, copy or no copy.

CoffeeCantata · 13/11/2026 14:13

smilesy · 13/11/2026 14:02

He is talented. Just because he was potentially tutored in how to do this drawing, doesn’t mean that he would automatically have produced something so accomplished. That is how art lessons work. You get instruction and advice but what you produce will still depend on your skill
level. Again there are apparently actual art teachers who are saying this as per the other thread. But you carry on denigrating the work of a young boy for no apparent reason other than it makes you feel superior or something. I’m baffled as to any other reason you could have 😎

I am just laughing my arse off at the posters pompously informing us that this is easy and not very good and shows no talent…until one of them shows us just how easy it is by having a go themselves.

I have never done proper gymnastics but when I watch competitors, even at school level, I have absolutely no doubt that what they’re doing is NOT easy.

Unless you’ve tried it yourself you are on very shaky ground belittling anyone’s skills.

bongowrongosruffledplumage · 13/11/2026 14:16

I see lots of self-aggrandisement.

And undesirable qualities and undesirable behaviours.

BananaPeels · 13/11/2026 14:16

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 13:55

Agreed. And then royal supporters started claiming this meant George was talented.

Gosh if you think a child playing bohemian rhapsody isn’t talented just because they have been tutored then you have exceedingly high standards! This is comparable.

stuffedanimalsandchocolate · 13/11/2026 14:17

It's a very good picture

The problem is that the magazine and his parents presented it as his own original work, and on top of that named the wrong species -- they made a big deal about it being a picture of the only British species of kingfisher when it is in fact an American species

They also presented it with some guff about it being evidence of PG's childhood lived beyond screens.... when it is in fact from an internet tutorial

Nothing wrong with following a tutorial from the internet of course, but it's the way it's been presented to the public that is stupid

Poor kid, it's a good drawing, I hope he isn't put off by this chatter around it

BananaPeels · 13/11/2026 14:19

Skyseek · 13/11/2026 14:12

the ‘yada’ comment is asinine. I’m on this thread, not another. You seriously expect posters to search out other relevant threads, distil the contributions, then ensure that no repetition occurs in another place? Am I meant to mind-read the threads you have read or am I to look through the entire site?

No one mentioned forgery - that would be passing off George’s picture as that of the original artist when this is about quite the opposite. What happened here is more nuanced. Whether legal or not (and the artist, like the previous artist whose work was copied, has said they are not bothered), by not sharing the context and origins of the art, the ability of the child is inflated and the credit for the original artist and teaching content is not given. It exposes vanity, self aggrandisement, lack of consideration to the original artist, a failure to learn from the last time this happened… undesirable qualities and undesirable behaviours from those in positions of power and influence.

You are reading far more into this than necessary. He’s 13. He did a picture. They shared it. That’s the sum total of everything we know. They never said he did it from nature. They never said it was original work. They never said he was Picasso. It was just a picture that he drew and they liked it and shared it.

stuffedanimalsandchocolate · 13/11/2026 14:21

stuffedanimalsandchocolate · 13/11/2026 14:17

It's a very good picture

The problem is that the magazine and his parents presented it as his own original work, and on top of that named the wrong species -- they made a big deal about it being a picture of the only British species of kingfisher when it is in fact an American species

They also presented it with some guff about it being evidence of PG's childhood lived beyond screens.... when it is in fact from an internet tutorial

Nothing wrong with following a tutorial from the internet of course, but it's the way it's been presented to the public that is stupid

Poor kid, it's a good drawing, I hope he isn't put off by this chatter around it

Here's the original article

George's Kingfisher
smilesy · 13/11/2026 14:24

Skyseek · 13/11/2026 14:12

the ‘yada’ comment is asinine. I’m on this thread, not another. You seriously expect posters to search out other relevant threads, distil the contributions, then ensure that no repetition occurs in another place? Am I meant to mind-read the threads you have read or am I to look through the entire site?

No one mentioned forgery - that would be passing off George’s picture as that of the original artist when this is about quite the opposite. What happened here is more nuanced. Whether legal or not (and the artist, like the previous artist whose work was copied, has said they are not bothered), by not sharing the context and origins of the art, the ability of the child is inflated and the credit for the original artist and teaching content is not given. It exposes vanity, self aggrandisement, lack of consideration to the original artist, a failure to learn from the last time this happened… undesirable qualities and undesirable behaviours from those in positions of power and influence.

Ok, but there are posts on the other thread that use the exact same references as your original post - nepotism, Tony Hart’s gallery etc. So it was reasonable to assume you had read the other thread.

As for the rest of your above post, get over yourself with your hyperbole 😂If the worst we have to worry about wrt to abuses of power is being ridiculously offended by a child’s drawings, I think we are in Utopia