Please or to access all these features

The royal family
Thread gallery
18
CoffeeCantata · 14/11/2026 06:28

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 23:20

So the palace pressed the artist to say something positive. They must be feeling under attack.

BeLemonMoose…

Could I suggest a career in thriller-writing? You have the most lurid imagination and convoluted take on the most banal, innocent things. Jeffrey Archer has just popped his clogs so there’s a gap in the market.

Palace gets its heavies to shut up an artist who might otherwise sue because a young schoolboy was inspired to reproduce their drawing. Hmmm. On reflection, it’s not quite The Day of the Jackal, is it?

I just cannot believe the effort you are putting in to make a massive mountain out of this tiny molehill.

CoffeeCantata · 14/11/2026 06:22

Serenster · 14/11/2026 05:18

The woman whose Christmas card was copied was in the UK and may not have felt able to pursue legal action for financial reasons or for fear of being made out to be the bad guy and blacklisted elsewhere

I can’t imagine why starting legal action against a primary school child who was inspired by your artwork and made absolutely no commercial gain from making a personal copy would make you look like the bad guy. Oh, wait, of course it would, because it would be a lunatic thing to do…

This is getting bonkerser and bonkerser!

bongowrongosruffledplumage · 14/11/2026 05:40

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 23:20

So the palace pressed the artist to say something positive. They must be feeling under attack.

Where on earth is your proof of that?

I’ll wait.

Serenster · 14/11/2026 05:18

The woman whose Christmas card was copied was in the UK and may not have felt able to pursue legal action for financial reasons or for fear of being made out to be the bad guy and blacklisted elsewhere

I can’t imagine why starting legal action against a primary school child who was inspired by your artwork and made absolutely no commercial gain from making a personal copy would make you look like the bad guy. Oh, wait, of course it would, because it would be a lunatic thing to do…

Circumspection · 14/11/2026 02:47

I am really tickled the at idea that “The Palace”
have so much influence in American that they just just phone up an artist and force them to make a statement. Or what?

wordler · 14/11/2026 01:39

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 23:20

So the palace pressed the artist to say something positive. They must be feeling under attack.

LOL - the artist will be thrilled with how things turned out. They got the publicity without alienating any of the pro or anti royal tribes.

I bet their sales have skyrocketed - I even considered getting the tutorial - it’s very reasonable and you get three different birds. I then remembered that I have nowhere near the skill to make the purchase worth it.

Although everyone who keeps saying it’s not that much of an achievement for George keeps tempting me.

Circumspection · 14/11/2026 00:51

BemusedAmerican · 14/11/2026 00:16

Its great publicity for the artist. I looked up the artist who designed the coronation invitation for KC and bought his book on heraldry. I'm going to look at this art is a website. If he has books. Out, Im going to suggest that my Iibrary buy them.

It is great publicity for the artist’s tutorials and quite funny to think he’d put out such tutorials then feel ill-used when people actually followed them and drew birds!

Circumspection · 14/11/2026 00:48

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 23:20

So the palace pressed the artist to say something positive. They must be feeling under attack.

Now that’s a creative take.

BemusedAmerican · 14/11/2026 00:16

Its great publicity for the artist. I looked up the artist who designed the coronation invitation for KC and bought his book on heraldry. I'm going to look at this art is a website. If he has books. Out, Im going to suggest that my Iibrary buy them.

jeffgoldblum · 13/11/2026 23:40

.

Always Sunny Fx GIF
Skyseek · 13/11/2026 23:35

MrsFinkelstein · 13/11/2026 23:18

Well the artist absolutely isn't bothered and thinks George did exceptionally well and hopes he'll continue.

I did do Art at school (won a couple of school & local contests, but by no means an expert), that's a really good, detailed piece of work for a 12yo IMO. He's definitely advanced for his age.

Yes, that’s why I said re: copyright ‘if the artist is minded to do so. However, there’s an imbalance of power here. This guy is in the US and is a little more removed but the woman whose Christmas card was copied was in the UK and may not have felt able to pursue legal action for financial reasons or for fear of being made out to be the bad guy and blacklisted elsewhere. Pragmatically, better to ride the publicity and stick a grin on. More to be gained long term that way. Also worth remembering this is fait accompli; it couldn’t have been known that the artist would be ‘happy’ as they weren’t asked!

BigWillyLittleTodger · 13/11/2026 23:33

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 23:20

So the palace pressed the artist to say something positive. They must be feeling under attack.

Yes apparently the King himself sent the heavies round to threaten him that he will wake up with a horses head on his pillow if he doesn’t comply.

jeffgoldblum · 13/11/2026 23:26

.

Burnie Burns Conspiracy GIF by Rooster Teeth
BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 23:20

MrsFinkelstein · 13/11/2026 23:18

Well the artist absolutely isn't bothered and thinks George did exceptionally well and hopes he'll continue.

I did do Art at school (won a couple of school & local contests, but by no means an expert), that's a really good, detailed piece of work for a 12yo IMO. He's definitely advanced for his age.

So the palace pressed the artist to say something positive. They must be feeling under attack.

jeffgoldblum · 13/11/2026 23:19

Circumspection · 13/11/2026 19:04

This thread should be subtitled “Angry birds”

Angry birds you say……..

Dance Eyebrows GIF by Angry Birds
MrsFinkelstein · 13/11/2026 23:18

Well the artist absolutely isn't bothered and thinks George did exceptionally well and hopes he'll continue.

I did do Art at school (won a couple of school & local contests, but by no means an expert), that's a really good, detailed piece of work for a 12yo IMO. He's definitely advanced for his age.

George's Kingfisher
George's Kingfisher
George's Kingfisher
George's Kingfisher
Circumspection · 13/11/2026 23:01

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 22:52

You are suggesting to someone that they should say their piece and then let it go.

I am suggesting you should take your own advice.

OK.

Back on topic, I enjoyed the article and would consider subscribing to The Country Life for more nature content. It’s also gotten me looking at tutorials and thinking about art. I might take another class at my local brewery/art house.

I have also learned more about birds than I have in years.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 22:52

Circumspection · 13/11/2026 22:50

I don’t think you read any of my posts. Your comment doesn’t make sense if you do.

You are suggesting to someone that they should say their piece and then let it go.

I am suggesting you should take your own advice.

Skyseek · 13/11/2026 22:52

bodleian3 · 13/11/2026 22:24

But it's simply good form to credit your sources when doing this sort of thing in an important publication that's sold for monetary gain. It's also a matter of basic professional courtesy to those people who have to sing for their suppers and don't live inside cosseted privileged lives.

copyright is a complicated area however, I think @Serenster is incorrect. If the original artist wanted to make something of it they could. The purpose of the tutorial is to help someone create a derivative image for personal pleasure. Not for publication. And definitely not for unattributed publication. The original artist owns the interpretation and the steps to get to the final image. If you stick it on the fridge at home, non issue. If you publish it, unattributed, in a magazine, then you may have an issue. Even if the original artist derived his art from a photo he did not have permission to use, that’s an additional copyright issue it doesn’t cancel out this copyright issue.

just like with the music example, the sewing pattern example doesn’t track. If you wear an item you made from a pattern, that’s personal use. If you sell the dress down the market or you take it as a sample to H&M and ask them if they want to buy the design from you, then copyright will become relevant.

what should have happened is that the original artist should have been approached and the derivative nature of the image captured in a caption. That satisfies copyright law and basic good manners.

Circumspection · 13/11/2026 22:50

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 22:44

You first

I don’t think you read any of my posts. Your comment doesn’t make sense if you do.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 22:44

Circumspection · 13/11/2026 22:40

It’s also good form to say your peace then let it go? Or is it speak your piece?

I did appreciate that you wrote “our president” in as a lady pants one but I don’t think we show ourselves off here as so much better than the man pants types.

You first

Circumspection · 13/11/2026 22:40

bodleian3 · 13/11/2026 22:24

But it's simply good form to credit your sources when doing this sort of thing in an important publication that's sold for monetary gain. It's also a matter of basic professional courtesy to those people who have to sing for their suppers and don't live inside cosseted privileged lives.

It’s also good form to say your peace then let it go? Or is it speak your piece?

I did appreciate that you wrote “our president” in as a lady pants one but I don’t think we show ourselves off here as so much better than the man pants types.

bodleian3 · 13/11/2026 22:24

Serenster · 13/11/2026 21:40

Whether legal or not (and the artist, like the previous artist whose work was copied, has said they are not bothered), by not sharing the context and origins of the art, the ability of the child is inflated and the credit for the original artist and teaching content is not given. It exposes vanity, self aggrandisement, lack of consideration to the original artist, a failure to learn from the last time this happened… undesirable qualities and undesirable behaviours from those in positions of power and influence.

I repeat here the comments I made on the other thread. To start this with, this is clearly and undeniably legal. We have forgery, breach of copyright and fraud to cover art-based intellectual property issues - obviously none of which are remotely relevant here.

The drawing tutorial that George presumably followed was expressly designed, released and publicised to enable people to follow it and produce their own pencil drawing of a kingfisher. The artist therefore entirely intended its use to result in an image based upon the tutorial steps they created. This is not a case of “copying”. It is no different to somoene buying a sewing pattern and creating their own piece of clothing using it. Each resulting piece (garment/artwork) will be the unique work of the person making it, even if it’s based upon the guidelines provided. To say someone wearing a skirt they sewed themselves that unless they immediately tell everyone they encounter “This skirt is Butterick pattern 6999” they are committing some form of civil or criminal wrong is just ridiculous.

But it's simply good form to credit your sources when doing this sort of thing in an important publication that's sold for monetary gain. It's also a matter of basic professional courtesy to those people who have to sing for their suppers and don't live inside cosseted privileged lives.

bongowrongosruffledplumage · 13/11/2026 21:56

Show even the slightest milk of human kindness towards Harry and Meghan, given the industrial quantities of vitriol directed at them, and you're immediately enrolled as a compulsory member of the Sussex Squad, issued your complimentary membership badge and cast beyond the pale.

Well that is nonsense for starters. That does not happen in my experience. Every time I’ve spoken about them - especially so with everything at the moment - most have agreed/ been sympathetic.

You can be critical of some of their choices but appreciative of the difficulties they have faced.

Unfortunately even the slightest criticism is met with accusations of being haters, cruelty, racism etc.

Never the twain shall meet it would seem - which is utterly ridiculous.

smilesy · 13/11/2026 21:48

Serenster · 13/11/2026 21:40

Whether legal or not (and the artist, like the previous artist whose work was copied, has said they are not bothered), by not sharing the context and origins of the art, the ability of the child is inflated and the credit for the original artist and teaching content is not given. It exposes vanity, self aggrandisement, lack of consideration to the original artist, a failure to learn from the last time this happened… undesirable qualities and undesirable behaviours from those in positions of power and influence.

I repeat here the comments I made on the other thread. To start this with, this is clearly and undeniably legal. We have forgery, breach of copyright and fraud to cover art-based intellectual property issues - obviously none of which are remotely relevant here.

The drawing tutorial that George presumably followed was expressly designed, released and publicised to enable people to follow it and produce their own pencil drawing of a kingfisher. The artist therefore entirely intended its use to result in an image based upon the tutorial steps they created. This is not a case of “copying”. It is no different to somoene buying a sewing pattern and creating their own piece of clothing using it. Each resulting piece (garment/artwork) will be the unique work of the person making it, even if it’s based upon the guidelines provided. To say someone wearing a skirt they sewed themselves that unless they immediately tell everyone they encounter “This skirt is Butterick pattern 6999” they are committing some form of civil or criminal wrong is just ridiculous.

Thank you @Serenster. It’s a shame that you have had to repeat yourself on this thread as well as the other one. It’s like Groundhog day