Well... the shoes...
To me, if we start at the top, scanning down, we have "Elegant hair, elegant dress... Santa's little elf." Or perhaps... "Elegant hair, elegant dress, ... one of the ugly sisters in Cinderella).
I LOATHE them. In part because they remind me of Irregular Choice shoes which I LOATHE. (In part because they are almost always worn by women who say things like "I'm so funny, me!" who, secretly, I think are a)never funny at all, and b) should get over themselves and grow up.
OK - enough about my peculiarities. I will now be polite.
Politely, they are such a different style from the dress, and so very eye-catching in their own right, that to my eye they distract from everything else going on.
I would even (shock horror) prefer the boots.
On the patterned tights, I have this feeling that tights should not be any color that isn't a natural leg color. Otherwise, you look like Robin Hood in the pantomime or someone who sells LulaRoe and has piles of "exciting" leggings in the garage that were the result of their failed pyramid scheme plans.
I could, perhaps, (for an entirely different outfit) like a burgundy lacey tight. And I am certain @EleanorMc67, could pull of colored tights extremely stylishly. And, with navy, I do occasionally wear a charcoal grey tight (or used to. It's been a good few years, now I think of it).