Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Partner wants to spend xmas with his ex and child

141 replies

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:40

Hi. I've been with my partner for 3 years, lived together for 1.5. He has a 9 year old son with his ex. Every year he spends xmas day with his ex and their son, having xmas dinner, opening presents, etc just the three of them. Then he comes home or joins my family xmas depending on the time.

I've been okay with this previous years because of course he wants to spend xmas with his child, who doesn't? Except this year I'm going to be quite heavily pregnant at xmas and it feels weird spending xmas without him while I'm carrying his child.

He has offered a compromise in that he will only spend 4 hours there this year and not have xmas dinner with them, but it's right across the middle of the day and still feels like a lot.

Obviously, I want him to see his son, no arguing with that. But when I told him how I felt he just said of course I'd rather see my son and then said "well I'll see what ex wants to do" and then got defensive and said he'll just spend it alone then.

I think I've been quite reasonable all these years so far, but it just feels different now that I'm pregnant and I'm worried what it means for future xmases with our child - like will he just disappear on us for 4 hours on xmas day?? Note that I am not invited to have xmas with him and his ex, not that I would want to do that anyway.

Basically, my question is, am I being oversensitive by getting upset about this? I'm not sure how to get my feelings across properly without sounding bitter or jealous, which I'm not (obviously, as I've been ok with this for previous years).

OP posts:
xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 17:44

Absobeautely · 12/11/2026 16:53

It's going to be really hard on the son knowing his father chooses to live full time with his new baby but only sees him 4 days a month. How will he explain that to his first child?

Is your boyfriend not going to parent 50/50?

Prioritise yourself.

Yes it will be hard. We're currently sorting out a new custody schedule so he gets his son more so he doesn't feel left out.

OP posts:
xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 17:45

HoppityBun · 12/11/2026 17:26

The child does not “need” any such thing. What he needs is stability and to know that he isn’t being pushed aside for a new baby.

He's not being pushed aside, but I know he might feel that way. He's very excited about the baby and we're currently rearranging custody agreements so his dad can have him more so he doesn't feel like that

OP posts:
InWithPeaceOutWithStress · 12/11/2026 17:47

Maybe you should go with the 4-hour compromise offer this year to keep the peace and then devise a new arrangement for next year once your baby is here.

OneShyQuail · 12/11/2026 17:47

This is a disaster waiting to happen and should have been changed/sorted LONG before the baby was ever conceived. At best, the lad adapts to the baby and can come over to yours on xmas day/boxing day and xmas are split from here on in. At worst he doesnt have split xmas' and looses time with dad and therefore resents the baby / you.

I find it so selfish and confusing to the child this merging of a family on xmas or birthdays. Its not done on usual days, why the emphasis on xmas/birthdays.
Its better to alternate xmas/boxing day, children get two versions of Christmas then, and split the birthdays up fairly.

DontyMon · 12/11/2026 17:49

My ex and I used to spend Christmas day together with our young children. I thought it was the right thing, but looking back, there was a certain awkwardness which, I think, permeated the day- though I got on well with ex. Especially when I got a partner, who the kids loved, and it felt odd that he wasn't part of the day when he had become part of the family.

Soontobe60 · 12/11/2026 17:53

Whattodo2024 · 12/11/2026 13:46

What was wrong with 4 hours? That sounded like a good compromise. What will you do next year once you have a baby together?

No, a good ‘compromise’ is to take turns to have the DC stay with each parent.

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 17:55

InWithPeaceOutWithStress · 12/11/2026 17:47

Maybe you should go with the 4-hour compromise offer this year to keep the peace and then devise a new arrangement for next year once your baby is here.

I'm leaning towards this. I feel a bit selfish arguing with him about it because of course he wants to see his child so it feels wrong to ask him to spend it with me instead.

OP posts:
Acertwirl · 12/11/2026 18:01

To you, you are already the mother of his child. You can feel your little one kicking around and no doubt pregnancy takes it toll. You can hardly forget! But I think sometimes men don’t understand it in the same way that we do. To him the baby is something he sees on a screen every now and then something he occasionally gets to feel through your tummy. I can see why he doesn’t consider this year to be any different to the others.

Once this Christmas is out the way, it’s probably worth discussing next Christmas early on so that a plan can be made which allows him to see both his children on Christmas Day without making anyone feel pushed aside.

waterrat · 12/11/2026 18:02

Being with a young child at Christmas is such a special experience. They only belive in Santa for such a few short years (i only realised this once my kids suddenly hit late primary !)

I think this is a hard situation for you but if you could enjoy a chilled time on your own with your feet up while he has his 4 hours...i think id do that this time.

SpainToday · 12/11/2026 18:09

The child should come to you and your partner, for either part of the day or alternate Christmases - that’s a standard arrangement

Happyjoe · 12/11/2026 18:12

He can't be in two places at once and he will have to treat his children equally. That either comes into alternating Xmas/boxing day or splitting the day.

This year, 4 hours with his son seems fair, it will go in a flash.

wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 18:22

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:40

Hi. I've been with my partner for 3 years, lived together for 1.5. He has a 9 year old son with his ex. Every year he spends xmas day with his ex and their son, having xmas dinner, opening presents, etc just the three of them. Then he comes home or joins my family xmas depending on the time.

I've been okay with this previous years because of course he wants to spend xmas with his child, who doesn't? Except this year I'm going to be quite heavily pregnant at xmas and it feels weird spending xmas without him while I'm carrying his child.

He has offered a compromise in that he will only spend 4 hours there this year and not have xmas dinner with them, but it's right across the middle of the day and still feels like a lot.

Obviously, I want him to see his son, no arguing with that. But when I told him how I felt he just said of course I'd rather see my son and then said "well I'll see what ex wants to do" and then got defensive and said he'll just spend it alone then.

I think I've been quite reasonable all these years so far, but it just feels different now that I'm pregnant and I'm worried what it means for future xmases with our child - like will he just disappear on us for 4 hours on xmas day?? Note that I am not invited to have xmas with him and his ex, not that I would want to do that anyway.

Basically, my question is, am I being oversensitive by getting upset about this? I'm not sure how to get my feelings across properly without sounding bitter or jealous, which I'm not (obviously, as I've been ok with this for previous years).

What’s the plan for next year ? His son should be able to have some time at Xmas with you all next year as part of your family . I wouldn’t be ok with this and it has to be faced now before your child arrives . So both children are happy and included .

Cora0 · 12/11/2026 18:43

Your stepson needs to come to you at some point to celebrate this year and all the years going forward. I think that if you don’t put your foot down now then next year it’s going to be “Oh but our child is a baby and won’t know the difference” and then the following year “Our child is a toddler, he won’t remember” and then “But stepson will be upset.” You’ll have an excuse every year for him to piss off to his ex’s house.

He keeps telling you “things will be different” but won’t commit to what that looks like. It’s time for him to stop with the procrastinating lip service and actually put the changes in place. And doing it this year, before the baby is born, will show the stepson that he’s included in the family from the very start.

As an aside, you’ve mentioned him suddenly wanting more than 3-4 days of custody per month now that you’re pregnant. Make sure he is taking care of his son during that time and not making you do the childcare, school runs, etc. because you’re on maternity leave and “have the time.”

Dweetfidilove · 12/11/2026 18:44

I think I've been quite reasonable all these years so far, but it just feels different now that I'm pregnant and I'm worried what it means for future xmases with our child - like will he just disappear on us for 4 hours on xmas day??

Accountability is a good thing. You were not being reasonable. You accepted a pattern of behaviour that is unacceptable to most people, and now your circumstances are changing, you're expecting him to change too. Except, he doesn't have to, because it was written on the tin when you bought it.

I understand that you are worried, but unless he wishes to change this set up, your child may very well have to miss him for part of Christmas Day. He likes playing happy families in two separate places, so this may very well be the ongoing arrangement.

Notimeforaname · 12/11/2026 18:46

Fairest thing he can do is split his day between both kids when the second is born.

TraitorOrFaithful · 12/11/2026 18:46

I agree with saying yes to the four hour suggestion for this year and negotiating hard for a change from next year onwards.

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 12/11/2026 19:15

Acertwirl · 12/11/2026 18:01

To you, you are already the mother of his child. You can feel your little one kicking around and no doubt pregnancy takes it toll. You can hardly forget! But I think sometimes men don’t understand it in the same way that we do. To him the baby is something he sees on a screen every now and then something he occasionally gets to feel through your tummy. I can see why he doesn’t consider this year to be any different to the others.

Once this Christmas is out the way, it’s probably worth discussing next Christmas early on so that a plan can be made which allows him to see both his children on Christmas Day without making anyone feel pushed aside.

Bollocks. This is a man who already has a child. He probably has a better idea of what’s coming with the new baby than OP does. First time dads might fit this description, but it doesn’t apply here.

Coconutter24 · 12/11/2026 19:16

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 12/11/2026 17:41

Let him this year
next year it’s all about your babies first Xmas, have him bring the son over to yours for a bit

Let him?

Besidemyselfwithworry · 12/11/2026 19:20

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:46

Thank you. I do have a great relationship with his son and he often asks why I can't be there too or is sad when I say I won't be there.

You have 2 choices

invite his ex and son over and be adult about it and share the day

or set up an arrangement where his son alternates between you and his Mum

what was the plan when you were going to have the baby? And also, you have had this situation and YOU chose to have a baby with this man. I personally wouldn’t have thought this was ok.

JJMama · 12/11/2026 19:35

Rubyreds45 · 12/11/2026 13:47

I just can’t understand this OP, you didn’t think to discuss these arrangements before you decided to add a baby?

Took the words out of my mouth.

Sassylovesbooks · 12/11/2026 19:45

I understand why your partner and his ex had this arrangement, when they first separated. The issue is, that now, your partner isn't single, hasn't been for 3 years and you're pregnant.

This arrangement isn't going to be able to continue, because it's no longer going to be appropriate. Your partner needs to arrange with his ex, so that his son spends every other Christmas Eve/Day with him. This is what most co-parents have to do, and it's the most sensible option.

You aren't being unreasonable at all.

Bananacrepewithnuts · 12/11/2026 19:49

ClaredeBear · 12/11/2026 13:43

They can start alternating Xmas / Boxing Day. This wouldn’t be so bad if you were all spending Xmas day together but when you’ve another on the way, I don’t understand how it could continue to work out. Have you spoken to other people who share children/Christmas?

Yes. They will have to start alternating Xmas the same as most other spilt families manage it.

It's not ideal and it's never easy but when you don't stay with the other parent these are the tough times that everyone concerned has to navigate.
X

TB23 · 12/11/2026 22:11

Quite frankly, this arrangement is incredibly stupid and needs to change. If they want to have Christmas together (and honestly a split Christmas or alternating Christmas where his son comes to yours is the far better option), then it would mean all of you. This weird playing happy families to the exclusion of new partners is awful - and confusing for the son anyway. And I say this as divorced mum of two boys for 13 years and stepmum to two girls for the past 11 years.

TB23 · 12/11/2026 22:20

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:53

Also to add they haven't always done this. When they first broke up (before me + him were together) he just popped over for presents for an hour or so. It's only in the past 4-5 years or so that he's been going for the whole day. They broke up before his son was born.

I assume from this that his ex doesn't have a new partner, as otherwise you would surely be splitting or alternating Christmas or at least all spending Christmas together. Honestly, I am divorced myself and a stepmum and don't have any time or understanding for weird power plays like this by his ex. He needs to come up with a proper solution now, before the baby arrives. Going on his own to spend most of Christmas Day there in past years was honestly ludicrous and very disrespectful to you as his partner.

Bunnylove19 · 12/11/2026 22:21

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:40

Hi. I've been with my partner for 3 years, lived together for 1.5. He has a 9 year old son with his ex. Every year he spends xmas day with his ex and their son, having xmas dinner, opening presents, etc just the three of them. Then he comes home or joins my family xmas depending on the time.

I've been okay with this previous years because of course he wants to spend xmas with his child, who doesn't? Except this year I'm going to be quite heavily pregnant at xmas and it feels weird spending xmas without him while I'm carrying his child.

He has offered a compromise in that he will only spend 4 hours there this year and not have xmas dinner with them, but it's right across the middle of the day and still feels like a lot.

Obviously, I want him to see his son, no arguing with that. But when I told him how I felt he just said of course I'd rather see my son and then said "well I'll see what ex wants to do" and then got defensive and said he'll just spend it alone then.

I think I've been quite reasonable all these years so far, but it just feels different now that I'm pregnant and I'm worried what it means for future xmases with our child - like will he just disappear on us for 4 hours on xmas day?? Note that I am not invited to have xmas with him and his ex, not that I would want to do that anyway.

Basically, my question is, am I being oversensitive by getting upset about this? I'm not sure how to get my feelings across properly without sounding bitter or jealous, which I'm not (obviously, as I've been ok with this for previous years).

Did you not consider the existing child and Christmas plans before you got pregnant? The new baby doesn’t eclipse his love and need to be with his son you will be disappointed to know!