Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Partner wants to spend xmas with his ex and child

141 replies

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:40

Hi. I've been with my partner for 3 years, lived together for 1.5. He has a 9 year old son with his ex. Every year he spends xmas day with his ex and their son, having xmas dinner, opening presents, etc just the three of them. Then he comes home or joins my family xmas depending on the time.

I've been okay with this previous years because of course he wants to spend xmas with his child, who doesn't? Except this year I'm going to be quite heavily pregnant at xmas and it feels weird spending xmas without him while I'm carrying his child.

He has offered a compromise in that he will only spend 4 hours there this year and not have xmas dinner with them, but it's right across the middle of the day and still feels like a lot.

Obviously, I want him to see his son, no arguing with that. But when I told him how I felt he just said of course I'd rather see my son and then said "well I'll see what ex wants to do" and then got defensive and said he'll just spend it alone then.

I think I've been quite reasonable all these years so far, but it just feels different now that I'm pregnant and I'm worried what it means for future xmases with our child - like will he just disappear on us for 4 hours on xmas day?? Note that I am not invited to have xmas with him and his ex, not that I would want to do that anyway.

Basically, my question is, am I being oversensitive by getting upset about this? I'm not sure how to get my feelings across properly without sounding bitter or jealous, which I'm not (obviously, as I've been ok with this for previous years).

OP posts:
Hayley1256 · 13/11/2026 00:02

I'd say agree to the 4 hours next year but I really think he needs to agree to alternating Christmas days - especially if the custody agreement is up for discussion! If alternate or split.

MarginWalker · 12/11/2026 23:58

I find this arrangement of playing happy family when they were never a real family (op says her partner left before the baby was born ) incredibly uncomfortable and I can’t see why they would do it this way. Couldn’t you have come along? Couldn’t it be some other arrangement besides a fake family?

Sleepyjeans · 12/11/2026 23:50

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 17:43

He's usually pretty good at taking my feelings into consideration, he just gets very defensive, then once he's gone away and had a think he comes back with a compromise or something.

Of all the "find an excuse for my boyfriend treating me poorly" phrases this one takes the cake. Look, he just rates you as less important, and your child as less important than his real family - that's how he sees them. It's not going to get better so make sure you keep working, squirrel money away and make sure you have supports in place.

Given that he won't marry you, you should get legal advice for how much financial protection you can actually ensure for yourself when you move into the single mum phase, as is very likely.

PBramble · 12/11/2026 23:45

Sorry if it's already been answered but why aren't you going as well? Me and my ex do alternate christmas' but on her birthday everyone comes here including ex's wife, and her daughter, my partner and his son and my ex parent in laws if they are around too.

HeddaGarbled · 12/11/2026 23:31

I know it’s the norm to make the children commute between divorced parents at Christmas (and generally) but that’s to meet the wishes of the parents not the children.

I kind of admire a man who doesn’t make the child commute for his convenience. Bit shit for his next girlfriend and baby, though. I expect he’ll have to give in once the baby arrives, and everyone will pretend the first child is fine with it.

Quitelikeit · 12/11/2026 23:13

If anyone asked me to give up time with my child on Xmas day they would soon be told where to go!!!!!

on a side note I’d never ever date someone with kids under 21!!!

Easterchicken · 12/11/2026 23:10

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:58

The arrangements are he has him every other weekend, but they're quite flexible if things need to be changed etc. On his son's birthday they spend they day together the three of them. I understand our child is kind of abstract at the moment, so it's difficult for him to comprehend, which is why I think I might be overreacting.

He sounds like a deadbeat other than occasions
Every other weekend

What a copout

Bufftailed · 12/11/2026 23:09

MiddleAgedDread · 12/11/2026 13:42

this is seriously weird, his DS needs to move between his mum and dad, why on earth are they pretending to play happy families one day a year?

We do the same. I don’t think it is that rare

Hard for OP, but 4 hours seems ok. Need a new plan for next year. Can ex and dc come to you? Or is that too much?

Easterchicken · 12/11/2026 23:05

I find it truly bizarre that you are adult enough to move in with a man (with a kid) sleep with a man (with a kid) get impregnated by a man (after a very short amount of time for all these points... With a man with a kid) yet do not have the ability or confidence in your relationship to discuss your concerns.. With said man... With a kid

You are about to have his child yet you are too afraid to even raise a concern with him

Next year there will be two children

You need to grow up and figure this out

Pyjamatimenow · 12/11/2026 22:52

This has disaster written all over it. Why on earth would you get pregnant by someone so clearly not invested in you? I’d be going it alone at this point.

mrswithkidsx · 12/11/2026 22:45

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:40

Hi. I've been with my partner for 3 years, lived together for 1.5. He has a 9 year old son with his ex. Every year he spends xmas day with his ex and their son, having xmas dinner, opening presents, etc just the three of them. Then he comes home or joins my family xmas depending on the time.

I've been okay with this previous years because of course he wants to spend xmas with his child, who doesn't? Except this year I'm going to be quite heavily pregnant at xmas and it feels weird spending xmas without him while I'm carrying his child.

He has offered a compromise in that he will only spend 4 hours there this year and not have xmas dinner with them, but it's right across the middle of the day and still feels like a lot.

Obviously, I want him to see his son, no arguing with that. But when I told him how I felt he just said of course I'd rather see my son and then said "well I'll see what ex wants to do" and then got defensive and said he'll just spend it alone then.

I think I've been quite reasonable all these years so far, but it just feels different now that I'm pregnant and I'm worried what it means for future xmases with our child - like will he just disappear on us for 4 hours on xmas day?? Note that I am not invited to have xmas with him and his ex, not that I would want to do that anyway.

Basically, my question is, am I being oversensitive by getting upset about this? I'm not sure how to get my feelings across properly without sounding bitter or jealous, which I'm not (obviously, as I've been ok with this for previous years).

I hate to be the one to say it but the fact that you aren’t invited or they can’t split the day up is weird and in my opinion he isn’t over the ex. There’s no reason (especially if they don’t live really far away) that his son could come to you in the afternoon or you could have a fake Christmas Boxing Day etc there’s so many other choices. This is really strange! Coming from a family who’s split. What’s he going to do when the baby is born disappear all morning on their future Christmases too? You need to set clear boundaries now for the future it’s a hard choice now to make your life easier going forwards. I’d give him a clear choice and if he doesn’t go with it leave him.

Arabelllllllla · 12/11/2026 22:43

catherinewales · 12/11/2026 22:36

By changing it as soon as baby comes his child will feel pushed out. You’ve got a few years at least till baby understands. I would say reduce it each year. This year he doesn’t have lunch next year he reduces it a bit more and then the next year a bit more and by that time he’ll be a moody teenager and won’t get out of bed till midday so it won’t feel as if he’s missing then. Then you can start alternating each year.

I also think this is a fair comment. A 6 month old has no idea what is going on, and I say that from recent experience.

Arabelllllllla · 12/11/2026 22:42

I think its reasonable to let him do it this year, it will be the last one before your baby is born. Everything will change next year.

This is about his child, not you. You are an adult, Christmas is for kids particularly when they're small.

I agree once your own child is born things will need to change, and you definitely do need to tell him that and come up with a plan. But this year leave him be, it isnt for the ex girlfriend, its for his small child.

catherinewales · 12/11/2026 22:36

By changing it as soon as baby comes his child will feel pushed out. You’ve got a few years at least till baby understands. I would say reduce it each year. This year he doesn’t have lunch next year he reduces it a bit more and then the next year a bit more and by that time he’ll be a moody teenager and won’t get out of bed till midday so it won’t feel as if he’s missing then. Then you can start alternating each year.

20centurySteph · 12/11/2026 22:23

I think the four hours even if it’s in the middle of the day is a good compromise. I think it matters less this year because the baby isn’t here. I think it will be different and grow and change. Both after you have baby and as the baby grows up. But this year you could certainly go to your family as you’ve done before. I think your family would be dying to have the new baby next year.

I also think if your stepson wishes you were part of Christmas, then maybe the answer is your partner brings him to yours for a few hours. So he and his mom get the morning to open presents and celebrate and he comes to celebrate with you and his sibling a little later.

oviraptor21 · 12/11/2026 22:22

Maybe not rock the boat this year but next year you need to get the more usual arrangement in place where the DS spends time with the ex and spends time with you and DH. DH joining Ex on Christmas Day, and spending even 4 hours there when he has his own family to consider, is inappropriate.

Bunnylove19 · 12/11/2026 22:21

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:40

Hi. I've been with my partner for 3 years, lived together for 1.5. He has a 9 year old son with his ex. Every year he spends xmas day with his ex and their son, having xmas dinner, opening presents, etc just the three of them. Then he comes home or joins my family xmas depending on the time.

I've been okay with this previous years because of course he wants to spend xmas with his child, who doesn't? Except this year I'm going to be quite heavily pregnant at xmas and it feels weird spending xmas without him while I'm carrying his child.

He has offered a compromise in that he will only spend 4 hours there this year and not have xmas dinner with them, but it's right across the middle of the day and still feels like a lot.

Obviously, I want him to see his son, no arguing with that. But when I told him how I felt he just said of course I'd rather see my son and then said "well I'll see what ex wants to do" and then got defensive and said he'll just spend it alone then.

I think I've been quite reasonable all these years so far, but it just feels different now that I'm pregnant and I'm worried what it means for future xmases with our child - like will he just disappear on us for 4 hours on xmas day?? Note that I am not invited to have xmas with him and his ex, not that I would want to do that anyway.

Basically, my question is, am I being oversensitive by getting upset about this? I'm not sure how to get my feelings across properly without sounding bitter or jealous, which I'm not (obviously, as I've been ok with this for previous years).

Did you not consider the existing child and Christmas plans before you got pregnant? The new baby doesn’t eclipse his love and need to be with his son you will be disappointed to know!

TB23 · 12/11/2026 22:20

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:53

Also to add they haven't always done this. When they first broke up (before me + him were together) he just popped over for presents for an hour or so. It's only in the past 4-5 years or so that he's been going for the whole day. They broke up before his son was born.

I assume from this that his ex doesn't have a new partner, as otherwise you would surely be splitting or alternating Christmas or at least all spending Christmas together. Honestly, I am divorced myself and a stepmum and don't have any time or understanding for weird power plays like this by his ex. He needs to come up with a proper solution now, before the baby arrives. Going on his own to spend most of Christmas Day there in past years was honestly ludicrous and very disrespectful to you as his partner.

TB23 · 12/11/2026 22:11

Quite frankly, this arrangement is incredibly stupid and needs to change. If they want to have Christmas together (and honestly a split Christmas or alternating Christmas where his son comes to yours is the far better option), then it would mean all of you. This weird playing happy families to the exclusion of new partners is awful - and confusing for the son anyway. And I say this as divorced mum of two boys for 13 years and stepmum to two girls for the past 11 years.

Bananacrepewithnuts · 12/11/2026 19:49

ClaredeBear · 12/11/2026 13:43

They can start alternating Xmas / Boxing Day. This wouldn’t be so bad if you were all spending Xmas day together but when you’ve another on the way, I don’t understand how it could continue to work out. Have you spoken to other people who share children/Christmas?

Yes. They will have to start alternating Xmas the same as most other spilt families manage it.

It's not ideal and it's never easy but when you don't stay with the other parent these are the tough times that everyone concerned has to navigate.
X

Sassylovesbooks · 12/11/2026 19:45

I understand why your partner and his ex had this arrangement, when they first separated. The issue is, that now, your partner isn't single, hasn't been for 3 years and you're pregnant.

This arrangement isn't going to be able to continue, because it's no longer going to be appropriate. Your partner needs to arrange with his ex, so that his son spends every other Christmas Eve/Day with him. This is what most co-parents have to do, and it's the most sensible option.

You aren't being unreasonable at all.

JJMama · 12/11/2026 19:35

Rubyreds45 · 12/11/2026 13:47

I just can’t understand this OP, you didn’t think to discuss these arrangements before you decided to add a baby?

Took the words out of my mouth.

Besidemyselfwithworry · 12/11/2026 19:20

xmasquandary26 · 12/11/2026 13:46

Thank you. I do have a great relationship with his son and he often asks why I can't be there too or is sad when I say I won't be there.

You have 2 choices

invite his ex and son over and be adult about it and share the day

or set up an arrangement where his son alternates between you and his Mum

what was the plan when you were going to have the baby? And also, you have had this situation and YOU chose to have a baby with this man. I personally wouldn’t have thought this was ok.

Coconutter24 · 12/11/2026 19:16

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 12/11/2026 17:41

Let him this year
next year it’s all about your babies first Xmas, have him bring the son over to yours for a bit

Let him?

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 12/11/2026 19:15

Acertwirl · 12/11/2026 18:01

To you, you are already the mother of his child. You can feel your little one kicking around and no doubt pregnancy takes it toll. You can hardly forget! But I think sometimes men don’t understand it in the same way that we do. To him the baby is something he sees on a screen every now and then something he occasionally gets to feel through your tummy. I can see why he doesn’t consider this year to be any different to the others.

Once this Christmas is out the way, it’s probably worth discussing next Christmas early on so that a plan can be made which allows him to see both his children on Christmas Day without making anyone feel pushed aside.

Bollocks. This is a man who already has a child. He probably has a better idea of what’s coming with the new baby than OP does. First time dads might fit this description, but it doesn’t apply here.