Please or to access all these features

Baby names

Find baby name inspiration and advice on the Mumsnet Baby Names forum.

Name regret...

109 replies

Lyndsey8880 · 04/11/2026 13:47

Hi all,
I had my baby in a whirlwind at 30+3 back in July.
Completely unexpected spontaneous labour and spent 6 long weeks in the NICU.
We had a few names, but for about a week he was 'boy'

Then it came to me being discharged...
I said to my partner that I'm not leaving him alone and nameless - but none of the names we picked seemed to work, so we randomly chose Isaac and that was that.

Fast forward to now, 16 weeks + 5 days actual age. Out of the NICU for 10 weeks.
I suddenly noticed i wasnt saying his name or calling him by his name, and then realised that actually... i dont think I like the name at all, i dont think I like the sound of the name, and it really doesnt suit him.

So now im in the dilemma of thinking up other names (he reminds of a rough and tumble type of kid!) Or whether im being silly and his name will grow to be him

But I feel this real disconnect with the name. I love my son with all my heart, he's a character, and a fighter, but the name just doesnt feel right.

Anyone ever had this and eventually loved the name and thought yes its the one?

Or anyone ever changed their child's name?

(I know its easy to do within the first year.. just keen to hear thoughts!)

I have some names i think suit him much more...
Remy
Frankie
Bobby

A bit old school bruiser type names.
But then a name is just a name!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Maglia · 05/11/2026 00:14

I think Isaac is lovely but I think you should change it. Keep Isaac in his names and add another unless that would make it ridiculously long. It'll always be part of his story. If he wants to go by Isaac instead when he is older, accept that with good grace.

I love Remy. It may have been extended to some girls recently but it's still a boys' name.

Pallisers · 05/11/2026 00:12

I love the name Isaac and love Zac even more. But if neither you nor your dh like it and if you are having trouble with it then you should change it.

I'd take a minute if I were you and not rush it. Imagine he doesn't have a name at all and then the two of you should do a few lists of names you'd love to use.

PunnyDeer · 05/11/2026 00:07

Lyndsey8880 · 04/11/2026 14:16

I agree with the Remy thing nowadays, but it is a boys name historically, its just been used primarily for girls in recent times.

Why is that weird?
Weird that you get a feeling of who your child is going to be?

Im not saying my thoughts make sense, which is why im so stuck. But something isnt clicking.

Remy/Remi sounds boyish to me! Reminds me of the French books/movies Rémi Sans Famille. But then again, I didn’t grow up in the UK, so things might be different here.

I think you should maybe give it a bit of time and see if Isaac grows on you, if not, then definitely change it to something you and your partner like better xx

I think all the names you picked, including Isaac, are lovely

Whoops75 · 05/11/2026 00:02

Worry can become a bad habit and now that he is safe and well maybe this is something to focus on. Before you ties yourself up in knots I would suggest counselling.

Honestly I don’t LOVE any of my kids names, I was in my 20’s having them and now I’m 50 I would chose differently but it makes no difference to them. Isaac will like his name and his life once his mom is ok. Steady yourself before changing anything x

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 05/11/2026 00:01

JoleneJoleneJoleneJoleneJolene · 04/11/2026 18:22

In my area in the late 80s & 90s a Rem or Remmer was slang for remedial (not proud of that!) And Rim/Rimmer has rim job connotations

Same here - not proud and not that I like to dwell on it, but if I hear 'Remy', I also think back to the 80s and the horrible slur used for children in the 'remedial' class, or just generally those considered not very intelligent.

Obviously, this won't be a thing for many younger parents now; and certainly not the newborn children who are being named.

I wouldn't personally associate 'rem' with 'rim', but I guess it depends a lot on your accent and how the vowels are pronounced.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 04/11/2026 23:56

HappyImarriedaDarren · 04/11/2026 13:59

I’m not sure which is/are the old school bruiser types, Remy, Frankie and Bobby? All sound quite ‘soft’ in the nicest possible way.

change Isaac’s name if you want to, especially if your partner agrees. Alternatively is there a derivative you like? Zac or Isa?

If you want to change it how about Nathaniel? Nat, Natty, Nate, Nathan, covers all bases!

Isa is a Scottish name, and very much a female one - usually short for Isabel. To be honest, once you've said 'Isa', it's hardly any more effort to add the 'c' sound on the end.

Toddlingabout2 · 04/11/2026 22:22

How about Zachary? So an extension of the name Isaac, so keeping his history of his birth and taking it forward in a positive way?

2chocolateoranges · 04/11/2026 21:57

I love the meaning of Isaac, it means “he will laugh” and “he will rejoice” both such positive associations to the name, laughter, joy and happiness in one bundle of fun!

WitchesBritches · 04/11/2026 21:56

I think Alyssa & Issac are lovely together.

I think no matter what you had called him, you'd be feeling like this at this point in time.

I wouldn't have been my first choice, but I've met a few few in the past few years and it's really grown on me. I certainly like it a lot more than Remy (especially for a boy) or Frankie. But that's not really relevant because he's not my baby!!

I do think you've been through a terrible terrible time & some therapy might help you to come to terms with what you've been through and also his name.

Would your daughter find it unsettling to have his name changed? Do you think? Might she want to change her or might she then be worried you might change hers??

Snicksnacksnora · 04/11/2026 21:48

maybe you should think in another way, and I might struggle explaining.
so pretend you’ve changed his name and now he is called one of your other names. No-one is going to call him Isaac again. How would you feel? I think it’s a lovely name and it has a precious meaning! Especially after his tricky start! Only you know xxx

NEMammy · 04/11/2026 21:46

Hi OP, sorry to hear you had such a tough start with him. I have a little boy who was nameless for a while because we just couldn’t settle on a boy name we liked! The boy name we had was scrapped after the midwife commented on how popular it had been at the time. I felt such immense pressure to choose a name and when we decided, I also struggled and found it hard to say aloud. He’s a cheeky 5 year old now and his name is perfect and suits him. It’s Isaac. Looking back I think it maybe didn’t feel “cute” enough for a tiny baby and that was a struggle for a while. There are two Rémi/Remys in his class, one boy and one girl. Whatever you decide, it will be perfect because it will become him!

Clafoutie · 04/11/2026 21:40

I like Frank ( and you can still then use Frankie as a nickname)

Firebird83 · 04/11/2026 21:33

You could call him Zac as a nickname? or Ike? That’s a commonly used nickname for Isaac in the US.

Ramblingaway · 04/11/2026 21:02

I have a 'hospital' name, arrived early, mum was unprepared. I don't like it and I don't think my mum does either but it would never have occured to her to change it. So I would say if you want to change it, go for it. Why be tied to something that was associated with a traumatic time when you don't need to be?

Aliencrispsandolives · 04/11/2026 20:57

Isaac is a great name but obviously not his name. Have you tried Ike as a nickname?

It’s ok to want to change it, you chose a name while under pressure and his name wasn’t ready.

I love Frank.

Mathair2 · 04/11/2026 20:52

@Lyndsey8880 I am a teacher and have come to realise Isaac is a great name. The Isaacs I teach are cheeky chappys, nice and hardworking but quick witted and cheerful - everything I would want in a son to be honest. I think you are subconsciously linking his name to a difficult time. It was a tough time but it was part of his story, as was the way you picked his name. I personally wouldnt change it but would work on how to change my perspective of the name if you can x

Freebliss · 04/11/2026 20:34

Jax.
Jazz.
Barr.
I like odd names.

hootingowls · 04/11/2026 20:24

I had name regret after my son was born and made up my mind I wanted to call him something else I thought would have suited him better but my husband didn’t like it and was adamant we had named him and that was his name.

I’m so glad he did though because he really grew into his name and it really does suit him now and he has shortened it so it’s one syllable which is so who he is and he really doesn’t look anything thing like the name I thought he would have suited which can’t be shortened.

Also he loves his name and when I told him what I nearly changed it to he looked horrified and thanked his dad for not letting me.

NiftyAmberHam · 04/11/2026 20:18

What about sticking with it as a middle name? Or nicknaming to Zak? It’s quite “bruiser” name?

MidlifeMiseryGuts · 04/11/2026 20:17

I agree with the NICU trauma playing a part. Stick with it, you will get to a part where this is just a minor chapter in your very long journey together. I think if you change it you might look back and wonder why you did it. Think hard about whether the reason you want to name him again is to kind of have a fresh start or second chance at the beginning? You don’t need a new name to mark the beginning of a better stage in some way

Diamond7272 · 04/11/2026 20:14

Lyndsey8880 · 04/11/2026 13:47

Hi all,
I had my baby in a whirlwind at 30+3 back in July.
Completely unexpected spontaneous labour and spent 6 long weeks in the NICU.
We had a few names, but for about a week he was 'boy'

Then it came to me being discharged...
I said to my partner that I'm not leaving him alone and nameless - but none of the names we picked seemed to work, so we randomly chose Isaac and that was that.

Fast forward to now, 16 weeks + 5 days actual age. Out of the NICU for 10 weeks.
I suddenly noticed i wasnt saying his name or calling him by his name, and then realised that actually... i dont think I like the name at all, i dont think I like the sound of the name, and it really doesnt suit him.

So now im in the dilemma of thinking up other names (he reminds of a rough and tumble type of kid!) Or whether im being silly and his name will grow to be him

But I feel this real disconnect with the name. I love my son with all my heart, he's a character, and a fighter, but the name just doesnt feel right.

Anyone ever had this and eventually loved the name and thought yes its the one?

Or anyone ever changed their child's name?

(I know its easy to do within the first year.. just keen to hear thoughts!)

I have some names i think suit him much more...
Remy
Frankie
Bobby

A bit old school bruiser type names.
But then a name is just a name!

Remy... The rat in ratatouille. Like the rat.

Frankie. Goes to Hollywood. Although, relax don't do it and a lot of sexualised balcony stuff in bondage gear may be an issue. Or dettori. Bankrupt but generally good guy.

Bobby. Brown. Largely responsible for Whitney's death and a bit of a saddo. Or davro. Always strikes me that Gemma Collins would have a child called Bobby....

Not really 'brit old bruiser names'... More hello sailor. I'd keep your options open...

MxCactus · 04/11/2026 20:11

I had a traumatic birth with one of my kids and had this with their name for ages. I ended up changing it late at 10 months because I just wasn't happy with it - but to a very similar name with the same nickname we used for baby - I do wonder if my birth trauma got a bit "attached" to the name, because it's quite an ordinary name, and I genuinely hated it.

I felt such relief when I changed it and haven't regretted it for a second.

Do it OP!

(FYI You can change it up until they turn 1 year old, then it's not so simple.)

Wheniswinenight · 04/11/2026 19:48

Change it if you want. He’s still really young. What about Charlie?

Namesy · 04/11/2026 19:36

I think Isaac is a nice name! I don’t like Remy (I think of the rat) and Frankie and Bobby are very popular names. Isaac is the best out of the four names.

abracadabra1111 · 04/11/2026 19:14

Lyndsey8880 · 04/11/2026 13:47

Hi all,
I had my baby in a whirlwind at 30+3 back in July.
Completely unexpected spontaneous labour and spent 6 long weeks in the NICU.
We had a few names, but for about a week he was 'boy'

Then it came to me being discharged...
I said to my partner that I'm not leaving him alone and nameless - but none of the names we picked seemed to work, so we randomly chose Isaac and that was that.

Fast forward to now, 16 weeks + 5 days actual age. Out of the NICU for 10 weeks.
I suddenly noticed i wasnt saying his name or calling him by his name, and then realised that actually... i dont think I like the name at all, i dont think I like the sound of the name, and it really doesnt suit him.

So now im in the dilemma of thinking up other names (he reminds of a rough and tumble type of kid!) Or whether im being silly and his name will grow to be him

But I feel this real disconnect with the name. I love my son with all my heart, he's a character, and a fighter, but the name just doesnt feel right.

Anyone ever had this and eventually loved the name and thought yes its the one?

Or anyone ever changed their child's name?

(I know its easy to do within the first year.. just keen to hear thoughts!)

I have some names i think suit him much more...
Remy
Frankie
Bobby

A bit old school bruiser type names.
But then a name is just a name!

Oh @Lyndsey8880 I remember you from the September Due Date Group - I was a lurker.. my September baby became a July baby also being born at 33+1 when I had a placenta abruption... Still wrapping my head around everything that happened.

Just wanted to say, the Consultant who was like a guardian angel the night my DD was born was called Isaac. I felt so blessed to have been looked after by him ❤