Please or to access all these features

Baby names

Find baby name inspiration and advice on the Mumsnet Baby Names forum.

Baby # 4 name dilemma

55 replies

KatieBee25 · 31/10/2026 13:02

Hello! We are expecting baby number 4 and found out yesterday she's a girl.
In a bit of a dilemma on what to name baby girl...
My children are called George, Grace and Holly. Me and my husband love the name Alice for baby number 4.
However I've recently found out that my younger sister - (who isn't pregnant and probably isn't planning to be for the next few years as she still lives at home with my mum, she does have a boyfriend though who's she's been with for 10 years) also loves the name and is planning on calling her future daughter Alice. Obviously she may never have a daughter could end up with sons.
But am i being selfish if I call our baby girl Alice, my sister even said to me 'you've already got two girls leave the name Alice for me' but that's the only baby girl name that feels right for this baby?! I love how it sounds with Grace and Holly and I am in no way doing it to spite my sister. We also rarely see my sister as she lives 3 hours away from where I now live so would it be so bad if we both had baby girls called Alice?! My Alice would be years older anyway!!
any advice or other name suggestions that fit with my three welcome 🥰💖

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
SliceOfMammasPeachPie · 04/11/2026 07:12

I don't get the love for Alice, all I can see is
A Lice

Eliza is so much nicer. I also like the three syllable sound with your other names

AutumnOakTree · 04/11/2026 07:30

As she has specifically asked you, I’d not use it.

Lucy
Margot
Lily
Marnie
Lucinda
Maisie
Tegan
Rowena
Charlotte

GreenFritillary · 05/11/2026 15:26

I would find too many bad vibes around 'Alice' now in your situation, although I love the name. I like 'Lucy' in the same way, so I might go for that.

HappyViewer · 05/11/2026 15:29

Don’t do a Rachel, choose another name.

Calliopespa · 06/11/2026 18:15

KatieBee25 · 31/10/2026 18:54

Thanks ladies! I think I will mention it to her again and see what she says... it's so hard when I love the name Alice and no other name feels like the right one!! Or there's not another one me and my husband can agree on! But I've still got a little while to decide on names. I also do really like Olivia and Lucy! Xx

I prefer Lucy actually.

I think she is B a bit U, but I also think you are probably overstating the "only name that feels right" thing. After all, you are down to your third girl choice now, so it isn't as if it is your very favourite.

In those circumstances, I would probably go for my fourth choice, as in all honesty, whatever you choose will become the one you love, and your ideas about names change over the years. We had a couple on our list that I am now really pleased we didn't use - hovering around that third choice spot!

ETA if it helps, I don't really like the combination of Grace and Alice: too much hissing!🐍

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread