Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Waste of a name?! *(TW - miscarriage)

117 replies

SoVerySophie · 24/06/2023 11:51

Very sadly my sister lost her little boy at 15 weeks last year. He was called Milo, it's always been a favourite name for her.

I was chatting with a friend yesterday and she said the most awful thing (or at least I think so). She basically said that it's wasting a name to use it on a baby that you know isn't going to survive. WTAF??? I immediately said that I totally disagreed with her and a name is
special regardless of who you give it to. It didn't shift her opinion though, even when I made it clear that I thought it was a totally inappropriate thing to say. And I'm still upset about it today.

AIBU here or was she?

(Please note: the thread title has been edited by MNHQ - it originally said 'baby loss')

OP posts:
GoOnGoOnGoOnGoOnGoOn · 24/06/2023 13:06

I had a loss around the same time as your sister. We'd had a male name picked out already, so I chose to write this down in the hospital's book of remembrance. I also used the bump nick name on a necklace with a birth stone for the month they were due and planted a special tree. All the "well, it obviously wasn't meant to be" and dismissive comments were hurtful - I carried a little person for 3 months, who will always be my son or daughter. As the saying goes, I'll hold them in my heart until I can hold them in heaven. Please ignore the ignorant.

Chickychoccyegg · 24/06/2023 13:04

She shouldn't have shared her opinion with you, it wasn't appropriate to do so, even if others feel the same.
I've not heard of anyone naming a baby lost to miscarriage, and hadn't realised until this thread that sex could be determined so early on, or thst some hospitals give you option of a service and/or baptism.
It's a sad time for your family, I hope your sister takes good care of herself

UnsolicitedOpinions · 24/06/2023 13:03

ohfook · 24/06/2023 12:45

When you miscarry after the first trimester you are able to determine the baby's sex when it has been born and then name it. Some Hospitals also allow you to have the baby baptised and arrange a cremation service.

I fortunately don’t have any experience of this myself, but I realise that you would likely know or could find out the sex of a baby you had miscarried.

What I actually meant what that by 15 weeks of any pregnancy (without miscarrying) most people would not know the sex so it is not likely to be the case that the baby had been known to be definitely a boy called Milo for a number of weeks before he was miscarried. (And therefore keep the name).

As I said though, anyone unfortunate enough to be in that position can do whatever makes them feel best, and whatever I thought about it, I wouldn’t have commented on it myself.

SayHi · 24/06/2023 13:03

I agree with her but I wouldn’t have said it out loud.

Some people have their favourite names and once they’ve used that name they can’t really use it again.

I knew my DDs name since I was 10 years old so the second I got pregnant I knew if it was a girl she’d be called X so I understand how your sister had a babe picked out but she couldn’t have known whether it was male or female and it seems sad that she can’t use that name now.

continentallentil · 24/06/2023 12:57

She was being very tactless, but it’s unusual to name a 15 week pregnancy, and that I think is all she meant.

RosesAndHellebores · 24/06/2023 12:54

She needs a filter.

I lost a baby at 27 weeks. He was Alexander a friend I made later lost a boy who lived for 4 months rather than just hours. We both had girls: Alice (Alex), Olivia (Oliver). I have often wondered if there's a subconscious pattern among pare to like us or if it was just a coincidence.

I didn't name the babies we lost at 17 and 12 weeks but I have friends who did.

There aren't any rights or wrongs, hence the need for empathy.

atthebottomofthehill · 24/06/2023 12:53

It's not unreasonable to think it but it was totally unreasonable for your friend to say it out loud.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/06/2023 12:51

I would find it unusual to give a name to a baby that was lost at 15 weeks into the pregnancy, and I do kind of get where your friend was coming from. However, I would never be so insensitive as to express that thought out loud.

I'm sorry for your sister's loss. Dealing with loss and grief is such a personal thing and there is no right or wrong way of doing it. If it gives your dsis comfort to have named the baby that she lost, then that is really all that matters and nobody else really has a right to an opinion on the subject.Flowers

Kitcaterpillar · 24/06/2023 12:50

It's a poorly worded OP and I feel sorry for the posters sharing the loss of their babies.

The friend was unreasonable to say it, but it was a reasonable sentiment that many people would share.

willWillSmithsmith · 24/06/2023 12:48

People saying it’s unusual to name a baby when 15 weeks pregnant but surely lots of people have a name in mind very early on or even before pregnancy that they want to give their baby (or future baby). I wouldn’t say it’s that unusual.

Bluestoat · 24/06/2023 12:48

I used up my favourite girl name on my first daughter who was still born unexpectedly at term. I’ve had two more daughters and a son since. I don’t regret giving my dead daughter the “best” name. I had nothing else I could give her.

TheSnowyOwl · 24/06/2023 12:47

I’m really sorry.

My daughter is called one of my favourite names and I named her shortly after she was born when I already knew she wouldn’t live for very long. She’s still really special to me, even though she is dead so it’s not a waste of a favourite name because she is still my daughter.

People don’t know how to respond to a child dying. They say all kinds of well meaning or thoughtless things. This is quite tame compared to many I have heard and that your sister is likely to have to listen to.

storypushers · 24/06/2023 12:46

She was rude and insensitive. I agree with her thinking as I didn't use my favourite name on my stillborn as I wanted my dreamt of 'alive' baby with that name. Still chose a special name though. It is totally wrong of her to voice her opinions though!

ohfook · 24/06/2023 12:45

UnsolicitedOpinions · 24/06/2023 12:27

As others have said, I agree with what the friend said, but I wouldn’t have said it myself.

Most people wouldn’t even know the sex of the baby at 15 weeks, so it’s unlikely that it would have been the child’s definite name.

If you have one name that you really like, then yes it would be better to use that for a child that survived rather than one that was miscarried at 15 weeks.

But I would never say that to somebody - it’s your sister’s choice of course and everyone in that situation should just do what they think is right for them and their foetus/baby.

When you miscarry after the first trimester you are able to determine the baby's sex when it has been born and then name it. Some Hospitals also allow you to have the baby baptised and arrange a cremation service.

willWillSmithsmith · 24/06/2023 12:43

That’s horrible. If a name is important then that is what matters. Personally it would be very important to me, particularly if the name had already been chosen.

ohfook · 24/06/2023 12:42

To be fair I'm currently pregnant after some losses and can't think of a name I like - a similar thought has crossed my mind albeit very briefly about my own circumstances. I wouldn't say it aloud though.

Fancylike · 24/06/2023 12:41

That is a bit of a drip feed! It wouldn’t have occurred to me to name a miscarriage, and a stillbirth or live birth is quite, quite different.

It’s something people would think to themselves, but not say aloud though.

MenoRageisReal · 24/06/2023 12:39

I've never known anyone choose a name by 15 weeks pregnant either. Most don't even know the sex by then.

darkmodeon · 24/06/2023 12:39

My initial thought was what a horrible thing to say/think but now people have shared why they might think that it does make sense. I think however it is a very personal thing to name a child and your friend should have shown more respect

MenoRageisReal · 24/06/2023 12:38

Very, very misleading opening post. I think everyone will assume it was a post birth 15 week old child that was the loss not a pregnancy loss, which while still obviously very sad is not quite the same. The answers will be skewed especially if posters have not read the update that it was a pregnancy loss.

(And I've had a second trimester loss so I can sympathise with her totally).

I agree it was an unpleasant thing to say but I can also see her thought/logic behind it, brutal as that may seem to you as a loving sister.

SeaSaltAir · 24/06/2023 12:34

Your ‘friend’ is an idiot.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 24/06/2023 12:28

I think the OP was misleading- I read it as her little boy died at 15 weeks old and thought the friend was being really horrible, even if they had known he wouldn't survive for long, as he was their child that they loved and cared for through his short life. Other posters expressed sorrow for the OPs loss, because something like that would be distressing for the whole family.
I'm sorry but a miscarriage at 15 weeks, whilst upsetting for the parents, is not uncommon and does not compare at all. Even so, if the sister had decided on that name, I think it would be strange to think about saving it in case she had another son who survived and think of a different one this time.

UnsolicitedOpinions · 24/06/2023 12:27

As others have said, I agree with what the friend said, but I wouldn’t have said it myself.

Most people wouldn’t even know the sex of the baby at 15 weeks, so it’s unlikely that it would have been the child’s definite name.

If you have one name that you really like, then yes it would be better to use that for a child that survived rather than one that was miscarried at 15 weeks.

But I would never say that to somebody - it’s your sister’s choice of course and everyone in that situation should just do what they think is right for them and their foetus/baby.

TrueScrumptious · 24/06/2023 12:23

She was OK to think it, but she shouldn’t have said it. I agree with her thoughts, I suppose, in the sense that I would never think of naming a baby when I was only 15 weeks pregnant. But other people do think up names from the start.

SoVerySophie · 24/06/2023 12:23

Interesting! I really can't see how she isn't unreasonable in any way, BUT - this is my sister we're talking about so it's very close to home. Maybe that's distorting my view.

So sorry to hear of the losses 😞

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread