Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Waste of a name?! *(TW - miscarriage)

117 replies

SoVerySophie · 24/06/2023 11:51

Very sadly my sister lost her little boy at 15 weeks last year. He was called Milo, it's always been a favourite name for her.

I was chatting with a friend yesterday and she said the most awful thing (or at least I think so). She basically said that it's wasting a name to use it on a baby that you know isn't going to survive. WTAF??? I immediately said that I totally disagreed with her and a name is
special regardless of who you give it to. It didn't shift her opinion though, even when I made it clear that I thought it was a totally inappropriate thing to say. And I'm still upset about it today.

AIBU here or was she?

(Please note: the thread title has been edited by MNHQ - it originally said 'baby loss')

OP posts:
ChaToilLeam · 24/06/2023 14:46

ButImNotOldEnough · 24/06/2023 12:18

I think that anyone who has experienced a loss during pregnancy can call their baby whatever they want and anyone that thinks otherwise ought to keep their ignorant mouth shut.

This, all the way.

Clymene · 24/06/2023 14:45

I lost a pregnancy at 15 weeks. The baby had a name but I've never told anyone else because it was and is completely private.

SoVerySophie · 24/06/2023 14:43

Oh I'm sorry - I agree, I should have been clearer in the OP. I'll ask MNHQ to edit.

OP posts:
ThatsRoughBuddy · 24/06/2023 14:39

Imagine doubling down and not apologising when you were clearly upset. I don’t agree with her at all but it’s definitely something that splits opinion and is best not said aloud in some situations.

I miscarried at 14 weeks and chose a name for my baby. He came out in the pregnancy sac so I held him in my hands. This was definitely the loss of a baby despite some of the comments on here.

StarchySturgess1 · 24/06/2023 14:39

I've never put a name to a miscarriage, and I probably agree with your friend. I wouldn't have actually said it to you though.

RudsyFarmer · 24/06/2023 14:36

ohfook · 24/06/2023 14:31

I'm a bit sick of reading this to be honest. It may be usual to have a name ready when you're 15 weeks pregnant but it is not unusual to want to name your baby you have lost after carrying for months. Women that lose beyond the first trimester will see and probably hold their baby once it is born. I and many others certainly do give them names.

I think that’s right. They wanted me to labour my second trimester loss and I decided to fight against that and had a surgical procedure instead. If I had been forced to go into labour and see the child, I think I would have named the child.

RudsyFarmer · 24/06/2023 14:34

It’s certainly a bizarre thing to say!!! Everybody has their own way to deal with things. Personally I never named any of my losses, I also chose not to have funerals or memory boxes etc. it was just my way of dealing with it. I absolutely support those who choose to do the opposite. So no I would never say naming a lost child a waste of a name. It’s extremely thoughtless.

ohfook · 24/06/2023 14:31

continentallentil · 24/06/2023 12:57

She was being very tactless, but it’s unusual to name a 15 week pregnancy, and that I think is all she meant.

I'm a bit sick of reading this to be honest. It may be usual to have a name ready when you're 15 weeks pregnant but it is not unusual to want to name your baby you have lost after carrying for months. Women that lose beyond the first trimester will see and probably hold their baby once it is born. I and many others certainly do give them names.

OneCup · 24/06/2023 14:26

I would not have used a name I could use later but a) it doesn't mean I am right and b) I wouldn't have said this out loud!

Mariposista · 24/06/2023 14:24

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/06/2023 12:00

I agree with her. I just wouldn’t say it to a friend who’d suffered a bereavement because it’s not a helpful opinion to share. So yes, she was unreasonable for saying it out loud in an inappropriate context, but not for having an opinion which differs from yours.

This, it sounds like a very clumsy turn of phrase and definitely something that you think but don't say, as there is no way of saying it without sounding offensive!

PinkIcedCream · 24/06/2023 14:23

I think it’s just a different point of view, so she isn’t wrong to hold that opinion.

However, she’s wrong to voice it to you or suggest that you and your sister must adopt that position too. Your sister can choose to name a foetus whatever she wants to but most people tend to give them amusing non human names until birth, but there’s no specific etiquette around naming a pregnancy bump.

Some people are happy to re-use a name that was previously given to a stillborn baby or child that lived a very short life. This was much more common years ago when families were larger and you’d have maybe 3 boys called Tommy but the previous two had died either before or shortly after birth and so they named the third born male Tommy too. My Ex was given the name of his deceased older sibling who had died a couple of years before Ex was born.

Maybe tell your friend that your sister is following an old family tradition? She can hardly argue with that!

LaMaG · 24/06/2023 14:23

I would find it odd to name a 15wk foetus as I would see it as tempting fate but each to their own. In a way Milo will be forever with your sister because he had a name. I lost two and they are first miscarriage, second etc but to me they were my babies and I sort of regret that they weren't named. I know I've just contradicted myself but it's a confusing thing to consider.

Your pal was horribly insensitive to you, its not just your sisters loss, you lost a little nephew too. I get why she thought it but she should have kept her mouth shut. She needs to work on her filter

PriamFarrl · 24/06/2023 14:20

I agree with her. I lost a very wanted baby at 15 weeks. It never occurred to me to given them a name. But I know that everyone deals with things differently and if this name had already been given to this baby then it would feel wrong for her to use it for another.

Lwrenagain · 24/06/2023 14:13

I've named my babies before my pee on the stick dried, we're all different.

I've also had it said "waste of a name" for my last loss, when i didn't think I'd cope reusing the names chosen previously.

Big love to you and your sister, 15 weeks is a long time to love your baby, because whilst it's still cells for much of that, the potential to an excited person is huge.

Lots of people (and I applaud them and actually am quite jealous of them) are very logical with pregancy and don't make a fuss really until baby is here.
I'm someone who'd throw myself under the Kings horse to keep access to abortion and fully understand my raspberry seed sized teeny little cells aren't a baby, but I still call them that. To me, the second I'm pregnant I'm giving them names, imagining their interests, wondering what food they'll like etc.
I have Pinterest boards of how their rooms will not look anything like because I don't have a West Wing, but still, we're all so different, when it comes to pregnancy, so I think it wasn't reading the room what your friend said, but it's how she feels. Nobody is wrong to feel that way, but maybe voicing it was a bad judgement call.

Marylou62 · 24/06/2023 14:06

Bluestoat · 24/06/2023 12:48

I used up my favourite girl name on my first daughter who was still born unexpectedly at term. I’ve had two more daughters and a son since. I don’t regret giving my dead daughter the “best” name. I had nothing else I could give her.

What a beautiful legacy...you gave her something very special...the best name was a wonderful thing to give her💕.. I'm so sorry for your loss...

Lonevoiceasusual · 24/06/2023 13:58

Kitcaterpillar · 24/06/2023 12:50

It's a poorly worded OP and I feel sorry for the posters sharing the loss of their babies.

The friend was unreasonable to say it, but it was a reasonable sentiment that many people would share.

Nothing wrong with the wording at all. This was a wanted baby so 15 weeks pregnant or 15 weeks or 15 years since it’s not any different The only difference is the size . You wouldn’t say a 2 year old was any less of a person than an adult just because there is a size difference.

This was a wanted baby, a loss. The loss of a child .

Zezet · 24/06/2023 13:53

At 15 weeks I would also feel that it's a loss of a pregnancy, not a loss of a baby. So yes, I would use the name for a baby later. Not sure where the limit is for me - I think I would put it at fetal viability outside the womb, so about 22 weeks. After that I would not reuse the name.

I don't think a different opinion would be wrong either.

Mysleepisbroken · 24/06/2023 13:48

I get the sentiment but wouldn't express it unless asked.

Personally, I'd have used one of the names I loved but probably wouldn't have had the guts to actually use.

ObviouslyNameChanged99 · 24/06/2023 13:47

My DH's parents had a son before my DH and he died shortly after birth. They gave him DH's dad's name, and it's on his gravestone. They then had DH a year and a half later and gave him the same name! I think that's weird but it's never bothered my DH! So maybe the name could be re-used. I don't know. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Kalodin · 24/06/2023 13:46

We lost DS2 as a newborn, it was one of my favourite names and I did feel absolutely gutted that I'd never be calling out that name in public. It is odd, but I can understand it sort of, from angles. It's like losing two fold, losing the baby and then losing all the hopes on that name too.

It's a weird one to explain.

But still rather shocked anyone would air it out loud like she did.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 24/06/2023 13:40

I’d probably have thought the same, but I wouldn’t really see a 15 week fetus as a baby, I haven’t heard of anybody naming a miscarriage before and I didn’t even know you could know the sex of it at that point. But I absolutely wouldn’t have said what I was thinking out loud, your friend probably should have kept her thoughts to herself. This is a situation where it’s not unreasonable to think but probably unreasonable to voice.

grimmers44 · 24/06/2023 13:35

Was she just trying to say that if she had a favourite name, she wouldn't use it for a pregnancy lost at 15 weeks, but said it very clumsily? I can see where she's coming from but I wouldn't say it to someone in that situation.

georgarina · 24/06/2023 13:24

I think it's one of those things like mentioning an inheritance when someone dies. It's not horrible because it's illogical, it's because emotion and respect and tact are more important in the circumstances.

RecklessBlackberries · 24/06/2023 13:23

I think this wasn't the time, place or audience for those thoughts and I'm sorry she said it to you, OP.

I don't think the sentiment is unreasonable though. I think there's no right or wrong when it comes to whether you consider a miscarriage to be a baby or not. Personally, I wouldn't. Until viability, I don't consider a foetus to be a baby. It would be a tragic event that I'd think about sometimes rather than a child/sibling who died.

Other people feel differently though, and it is always wrong and rude to try and force them to feel how I do rather than empathise and support them.

FrillyGoatFluff · 24/06/2023 13:19

I lost my first daughter at 22 weeks, she was named one of our two favourite names, but the 'safer' of the two. She was named as soon as we found out she was a girl, at 16 weeks.

Our second daughter was named the name we wish we had been brave enough to use the first time. It is a real marmite name, but after the loss of our first baby girl, I don't give a monkeys. It's perfect, and it's absolutely her.

My business now incorporates my first daughters name, and as far as I'm concerned, I have two daughters, both of whom have a name that we love.

That said, I do sort of understand what your friend said... although it's not something that should ever be said out loud 🙄